MUN student protester wins against university in Supreme Court decision
Years after being sanctioned, a student who was punished over protesting at Memorial University has won his say in the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador.
Matt Barter, who was accused by the university of bullying and intimidation after silently protesting the university's tuition hikes in late 2021, says he is relieved.
"For the Supreme Court to intervene, the decision has to be really, really bad," Barter told CBC Radio's On The Go.
His protest involved holding a sign that read "Stop Vianne" while silently standing next to now-former university president Vianne Timmons at a media briefing on Dec. 2, 2021.
The university later claimed Barter violated the student's code of conduct, and its lawyer said his protest was a form of bullying. As a result, Barter was banned from campus, except to attend classes, for three months while an investigation was launched into his actions.
The following investigation imposed sanctions on Barter for two offences: bullying and causing a disturbance. He was given a letter of reprimand, ordered to attend a bullying seminar and was placed on non-academic probation for one year.
Barter appealed the investigation's findings, but lost. He then decided to take legal action against the university to review the administration's decision.
His case was heard in court in March 2023 and the decision was released on Sunday.
Justice Rosalie McGrath found that the university's sanctions against Barter were unreasonable, and sent it back to the university for reconsideration.
She also awarded legal costs to Barter.
In a statement, MUN spokesperson Chad Pelley says the university will reconsider its decision to punish Barter.
Pelley says McGrath found that MUN followed due process, adding she also agreed with MUN's claim that Barter conducted bullying and harassment.
"While I may not have necessarily have come to the same finding based on the evidence I have referred to above, I cannot say that the conclusion reached was not within a range of reasonable outcomes," wrote McGarth in her decision.
"It's not my role on judicial review to interfere with factual findings or re-evaluate the evidence."
Barter's lawyer, Kyle Rees, says he's happy with the outcome.
It's not typical for the court to make a judicial review of an administrative decision, says Rees, as the process to apply for one is not easy.
Rees says the university's decision to punish Barter didn't consider provisions that address the right to peaceful protest.
"Something needs to be truly disruptive to create a disturbance beyond what should be expected of sort of free speech and free protest at the university in order for it to be sanctionable under the code," said Rees.
As a result, he says the judge sent the decision back to the university with instructions of what to consider next.
Barter says he has been involved in protest against the university's tuition increase and spending decisions since he began as a student in 2015.
Barter has continued protesting and looking into information about the university. He has issued more than 400 access-to-information requests from the university, and publishes them on his personal blog.
He says MUN is trying to stop him from doing his investigative work.
"They've pretty much conducted a targeted campaign against me," said Barter.
As for what happens next, Pelley said that will be communicated with Barter's lawyer.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
03-06-2025
- Winnipeg Free Press
Newfoundland voters concerned after apparent voter mistakes void hundreds of ballots
ST. JOHN'S – Two voters in Newfoundland say they hope Elections Canada can learn from a dramatic judicial recount that revealed hundreds of people in their riding may have marked their ballots in the wrong spot. Jennifer Barnett says she didn't receive instructions about how to mark her ballot when she voted for Conservative candidate Jonathan Rowe in an advance poll ahead of the April 28 federal election. The rural Newfoundland riding of Terra Nova-The Peninsulas is home to many seniors and others who may have needed more instruction than she received to properly fill in a ballot, Barnett said. 'Being able to vote is such a privilege, and if your vote is spoiled because of a simple error, I think it's very sad,' the 43-year-old said in a recent interview. 'I think it's very important, going forward, that we take a page from this.' Elections Canada said it has several measures in place to ensure voters have the correct instructions for filling in their ballot, including visual instructions posted on the back of voting screens. 'As we do after each election, we will look back at what went well and where we could improve things so that we can adjust our efforts to better serve electors, including the ways we communicate about how to properly mark ballots,' spokesperson Matthew McKenna said in an email. A judicial recount in the eastern Newfoundland riding last month resulted in an 'unprecedented' 1,041 disputed ballots, according to a report last week from provincial Supreme Court Justice Garrett Handrigan, who oversaw the process. On many of the disputed ballots — 'maybe as many as half,' Handrigan's report said — the voter had placed their mark in the rectangular boxes containing a candidate's name. In some of those so-called 'rectangle votes,' the elector had also made a mark in the circle to the right of the candidate's name. The Canada Elections Act is clear: any ballot 'that has not been marked in a circle at the right of the candidates' names' should be rejected. Accordingly, the judge rejected the 'rectangle votes,' his report said. In all, 819 ballots were rejected in the recount. Rowe was declared the winner, defeating Liberal Anthony Germain by 12 votes. The Liberal party said last week that it accepts the results. The average age in Terra Nova-The Peninsulas is 50, the highest among the seven ridings in the province — though not by much. In the ridings of Central Newfoundland and Long Range Mountains, the average is age 49, according to Elections Canada. There were fewer rejected ballots in both ridings — 492 and 452, respectively. Amanda Bittner, a political science professor at Memorial University in St. John's, said anything Elections Canada can do to decrease the confusion around voting is good. 'Clearly, there were a lot of voters who wanted to have their voice heard in this election, if there were that many 'confused but clear' ballots,' Bittner said in an email. 'That speaks to a gap between voter understanding of what to do and Elections Canada processes.' 'Fortunately, Elections Canada takes voter turnout very seriously, and I am sure they have already made note of this issue and are working on tweaking their processes for next time,' she added. Liberal volunteer Sheilagh Crombie-Brown said she didn't receive instructions when she cast a ballot at an advance poll in Bonavista, a community in the Terra Nova-The Peninsulas riding. She believes her 83-year-old husband would have mistakenly spoiled his ballot if she hadn't have been there to help him. The 62-year-old also hopes Elections Canada will try to figure out why so many ballots were cast incorrectly. The federal elections agency does provide instructions, she acknowledged, but if people can't read or understand them, they won't be of much use. Meanwhile, Barnett is pleased that Rowe won and she doesn't question the results of the recount. However, she hopes Elections Canada will take note of what happened and ensure it won't happen again. 'I think if they don't, they'd be doing an injustice to the whole system,' she said. 'Because when you see something of this magnitude happen, to not talk about it is just wrong.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 3, 2025.
CBC
20-05-2025
- CBC
Student advocates outraged as MUN uses money set for tuition reduction elsewhere
Memorial University says it will continue increasing the cost of tuition despite budget cuts being put on hold — which two student advocates say shows a continued lack of financial responsibility. Rana Abuidris, the executive director of campaigns for MUN's student union, says the decision comes as students face heavy financial anxiety. "Students are skipping meals. I know students are currently working three jobs to be able to afford the tuition costs right now," Abuidris told CBC Radio's On the Go. In a post on Memorial's Gazette on Tuesday, president Jennifer Lokash outlined parts of the 2025-26 budget approved by the board of regents. Part of the budget includes a one-time pause in a tuition reduction grant given to the school by the provincial government totalling $13.68-million. The province has cut the fund yearly since 2022, when it was giving $68.4 million to the school to keep a tuition freeze in place. A cut of about $14-million per year led to the end of the tuition freeze. Costs skyrocketed from $2,550 to $6,000 per year for Canadians and reached $20,000 for international students, along with an annual four per cent increase until 2026. Lokash wrote that the $13.68-million aimed at tuition reduction was instead directed to "drive Memorial University's transformation to a more learner-centric, sustainable and efficient institution." The school will use $3.9-million to contract teachers, while using the rest to enhance efforts on student recruitment and retention, business transformation efforts and critical technological improvements among other items, Lokash wrote. Nicolas Keough, chair of the Canadian Federation of Students in Newfoundland and Labrador, said he had hoped the money would be used for its intended purpose. "The grant that is made to offset tuition, the money should be going toward that," he said. "This is not 'The money had to come from somewhere.' … That's what the operating grant is for." Tuition should be as low as possible: Education Minister Both Keough and Abuidris believe there was some support among the board of regents to move the freeze forward, but not enough. It's the latest example of financial mismanagement from the university, Abuidris added, highlighted by a scathing report from the auditor general in January that showed years of infrastructure neglect and overspending. "This was an opportunity for MUN to rebuild a relationship with the provincial government and rebuild their trust. And again, Memorial again have shown that they cannot be trusted with, like, money. Student's money. They're clearly not putting students as their main priority," Abuidris said. Asked about the decision on Tuesday afternoon, Education Minister Bernard Davis said MUN is an autonomous organization that can do what it wants with the money it receives from government. The province supports the school, Newfoundland and Labrador's only university, through more than $400 million, and accounts for about 70 per cent of the school's total operating grant. However, Davis added he knows the financial struggles students are facing and tuition costs are challenging. "I always would like to see as low a tuition as you possibly can for our students," Davis said. "The decision about tuition sits with the university and the administration of the university. We give them a very high level of support. We've looked at some of the cost pressures ... and we gave them more money. But as I've said many, many times, it is up to the university to determine where and how they spend that money."
CBC
14-05-2025
- CBC
MUN student representatives call for tuition freeze and 'a break'
Memorial University student representatives are once again calling on the board of regents to pause tuition increases, as the provincial government hits pause on its reduction of the tuition offset grant. A handful of university students, and staff from the Canadian Federation of Students (CFS), showed up at MUN's Signal Hill campus on Wednesday to have their message heard. Longtime student activist and current chairperson for CFS Newfoundland and Labrador, Nicolas Keough, wants the board to include a tuition freeze in its 2025-26 university budget. MUN has been implementing a four per cent increase to tuition rates every year since 2022, which ended a previous 22-year freeze. "We need to see it this week, and we need to see some relief to students who are really struggling under the current cost of living and housing crisis," Keough told reporters. WATCH | Students say high cost of living is behind drop in enrollment at Memorial University: A funding cut to Memorial University is on hold. Students say a tuition hike should be too 24 minutes ago Duration 1:40 A student protest greeted Memorial University's board of regents on Wednesday morning. The students want a planned tuition increase cancelled, in response to the provincial government pausing a funding cut to the university. But the CBC's Mark Quinn says Memorial is holding firm. This year's provincial budget included $312 million for the university's core operating grant and $7.8 million for the campus renewal fee, which will save full-time students $500 a year. Further, $13.7 million is tabled to support the university's budget, $4.7 million for the Faculty of Nursing's satellite sites and $2 million for the Doctor of Psychology program. The demand comes just months before Janet Morrison is scheduled to begin her new role as the university's new president. Morrison cut dozens of programs in her previous post as the president of Sheridan College in Ontario. Despite that, Keough is optimistic. "I think the president has made it clear that she wants to meet with the students, that she wants to have a good relationship with the students," he said. Outgoing president Jennifer Lokash posted a budget update to the MUN Gazette on April 23, which says the university anticipates the reductions to continue for the next two fiscal years. "Given this is a one-year pause, rather than a forgiveness, care must be taken to invest the money in pressing priorities that will help Memorial become more sustainable," Lokash wrote. CFS staffer Ashlinn Pennell said MUN needs to "make the right decision" in light of the relief. She said the cost of tuition is detrimental to both domestic and international students. "We need to be giving young people here opportunities, and that starts with giving them a break," said Pennell. A written statement sent to CBC News by Memorial University said the institution isn't required to use the money any certain way. "The provincial government provided direct investment to address student affordability through the funding of the Campus Renewal Fee," wrote spokesperson Chad Pelley. "The pause in the reduction of the tuition offset grant did not include directives on how the money should be spent." In a later statement, Pelley wrote that MUN is facing the same budget problems as other universities across the country. That's coupled with lower enrolment and increased inflationary pressure, Pelley continued. "University leaders, including the board of regents, must determine the best path forward to ensure financial sustainability and protection of the university mission, including priority on the student experience and academic quality. The board is considering the request from students within the context of the overall university budget," the statement reads. "The tuition offset grant from government has been, and continues to be, an investment that funds the university's core operations, including teaching and learning, student services and the overall supports required to ensure the academic mission of the university is maintained."
