Instead of overcomplicating COE system, Govt has ensured affordable transport for all: SM Lee to Jamus Lim
SINGAPORE - Complicating the certificate of entitlement (COE) system by having it account for the needs and circumstances of different groups may render it unworkable, said Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong on July 16.
Instead, the Government has ensured that everyone has access to affordable and efficient transport, even if they do not own a car, he added.
And those who need more help, such as families with young children, are helped directly such as through grants which can go towards paying for a COE, he said.
SM Lee was responding to a Facebook post by Workers' Party Sengkang GRC MP Jamus Lim, who said that the COE bidding system does not account for those who may genuinely need to own a car.
Associate Professor Lim added in his July 16 post that relying on market forces may not be the best way to adjudicate between the competing needs of different groups.
He was commenting on what SM Lee had said at a dialogue on July 15
at the Economic Society of Singapore's (ESS) annual dinner .
ESS president Euston Quah, who was moderating the dialogue, had asked SM Lee about calls to let some groups pay less for COEs.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore Over 600 Telegram groups in Singapore selling, advertising vapes removed by HSA
Singapore 2 weeks' jail for man caught smuggling over 1,800 vapes and pods into Singapore
Singapore Jail for man who fatally hit his own daughter, 2, while driving van without licence
Singapore Primary 1 registration: 38 primary schools to conduct ballot in Phase 2A
Singapore ComfortDelGro to introduce new taxi cancellation, waiting fee policy
Singapore Here comes the sun: Less rain, more warm days in second half of July
Singapore Strong argument for cockpit video recording, says Iata chief in wake of Air India crash report
Singapore Baby died after mum took abortion pills and gave birth in toilet; coroner records an open verdict
Responding, SM Lee said there were many 'good arguments' for why certain groups are more deserving of a car.
However, it would be very difficult for the Government to design a COE system which takes into account how many children people have, if they have a disabled family member or old folks at home, and whether their jobs require them to move around, among other things, he added.
'I think if you want to design a scheme which worries about all those things, it will fail,' he said at the dialogue.
There is no fair and easy way to distribute something valuable like road space while making it very cheap, he added.
What the COE system does is to act as a proxy for road space, price this scarce resource at fair market value, then allocate it using economic principles, he noted.
Referring to these comments, Prof Lim, who was also at the ESS dinner, said what was 'sorely missing' in such a system was how those with genuine needs may not be able to afford a car, even if their needs have more merit.
He added that having 'every aspect of their lives determined in a transactional way' was not how humans wished to live.
'Society has values—about compassion, equity, respect, and loyalty - that are poorly valued by impersonal markets. It's why we teach our children to share, why we don't charge an hourly rate to time we spend with our kids, why we don't think twice in breaking the bank when our parents fall in, and why we devote so much of our energies to causes that we believe in,' he said.
'That's why, for all our economic successes, there are ways that Singapore, Inc. operates that rubs many people the wrong way.'
At the dialogue, SM Lee said that the Government can guarantee every Singaporean affordable, convenient transportation, but cannot guarantee that everyone can have an affordable car.
He added that for those who have a special need, it was better for the Government to help directly rather than giving them cheaper COEs. For instance, families with young kids get bigger baby bonuses, which they can use to defray the cost of a car.
'Directly help the group you need to help in cash, rather than make complicated schemes, which then end up with all kinds of contradictions and wrong incentives,' added SM Lee.
Prof Lim, who teaches economics at the Essec Business School, said in his post that the bottom line for him was that people are 'not mindless slaves to the prevailing structures and institutions' and can actively shape the future they want.
'If we want to head in a different direction, toward a more empathetic and just economy and society, then it is on us to seize that vision and make it real,' he added.
In his Facebook comment, SM Lee said: 'Therefore where we disagree is not over who cares more for our fellow Singaporeans, but what is the best way to meet people's needs and take care of them.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Cambodia's Hun Sen at the helm in border conflict with Thailand
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: Hun Sen speaks at a press conference at the National Assembly in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, August 22, 2023. REUTERS/Cindy Liu/File Photo When weeks of tensions escalated into a major border conflict with Thailand last week, former Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen appeared to take charge of his country's response. Photographs showed him at the end of a long table, speaking with military officers and poring over detailed maps, radio set in hand and a cup of Starbucks coffee within arms reach. The former guerrilla fighter is no longer Cambodia's leader, having passed on the premiership to his eldest son in 2023 after nearly four decades in power, and has taken over as the president of the Southeast Asian nation's Senate. But Hun Sen played an outsized role in events leading up to the deadliest fighting between Thailand and Cambodia in over a decade and - according to three diplomatic sources - showed his continuing influence during the five-day conflict. On Friday, after artillery fired from Cambodia landed in civilian areas in Thailand's border provinces, the Thai army took direct aim at him. "Based on available evidence, it is believed that the Cambodian government, led by Samdech Akka Moha Sena Padei Techo Hun Sen, is behind these appalling attacks," it said in a statement, using honorifics for the veteran politician. Within hours of the clashes breaking out, Hun Sen, 72, was sharing a flurry of posts on Facebook, his favoured social media platform, to rally his people and criticise Thailand. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore SMRT's finances hit by 2024 EWL disruption; profit after tax for trains division dips 8% Asia US-Malaysia tariff deal set for Aug 1 after Trump-Anwar phone call Asia Malaysia PM Anwar says Trump to attend Asean Summit in October Multimedia 60 years, 60 items: A National Day game challenge Singapore Underground pipe leak likely reason for water supply issues during Toa Payoh fire: Town council Singapore Driver in 2024 Tampines crash that killed 2 set to plead guilty in October Singapore Jail for SCDF officer who had sexual relationship with 15-year-old girl he met as her CCA instructor Singapore 'Switching careers just as I became a dad was risky, but I had to do it for my family' In one photograph he posted, Hun Sen is seen in a video conference call with a dozen people, including several soldiers. In another post, he shared a photo of himself in combat fatigues. "On the border clashes, what strikes me is the extent to which he goes to create the optics of being in charge - wearing the uniform, being seen as directing the troop movements, intervening on Facebook," a Cambodia-based diplomat told Reuters. Like all the other diplomats interviewed for this story, he asked not to be named because of the sensitivity of the issue. Lim Menghour, a Cambodia government official working on foreign policy, said Hun Sen acted as the main logistics commander for troops on the frontline. "He has always monitored and kept observing the situation all the time," he told Reuters. LEAKED CALL AND CRISIS In contrast to his father, Cambodia's incumbent premier Hun Manet, a four-star general and graduate of the West Point military academy in the United States, remained more muted on social media in the early days of the conflict, changing tack as he readied to travel to Malaysia for negotiations that yielded a ceasefire. Chhay Sophal, a Phnom Penh-based author of books on Hun Sen and his family, said the former premier can direct the government in his capacity as the president of the ruling Cambodian People's Party. "So, the prime minister must respect and follow the party's policy and president," he said. A Cambodia government spokesman did not respond to questions from Reuters. Thailand and Cambodia have bickered for decades over undemarcated sections of their 817 km (508 miles) land border, which has also led to fighting in the past. The recent tensions began rising in May, following the killing of a Cambodian soldier during a skirmish, and have steadily escalated since - a situation that Thai premier Paetongtarn Shinawatra sought to diffuse when she spoke directly with Hun Sen on June 15. A partial recording of the call was initially leaked, where Paetongtarn, 38, can be heard criticising a Thai general and kowtowing to Hun Sen, who later released the full audio of their conversation, triggering a political crisis in Thailand. In a rambling three-hour televised speech in late June, Hun Sen openly rebuked Paetongtarn for her handling of the border row and attacked her father, former premier Thaksin Shinawatra, long seen as his ally. "At least before the flare-up, he was very much right there in your face," said a regional diplomat who closely tracks Cambodia. "I mean, he was the one who was mostly visible, who was making all the pronouncements." RICE FIELDS TO POWER Hun Sen is a wily survivor of Cambodian politics and the wider tumult across Southeast Asia over the last half-a-century. Born to rice farmers in a province heavily bombed during the secret U.S. war in Cambodia and Laos, he became a soldier for the Khmer Rouge, whose murderous regime from 1975 to 1979 killed about a quarter of the population. But he defected to Vietnam in 1977 and, when they overthrew the Khmer Rouge, Hun Sen returned as foreign minister and then rose to become prime minister. The self-styled strongman presided over an economic boom in Cambodia, with per capita income almost quadrupling from $240 to $1,000 in the decade from 1993 to 2013. But much of the new-found wealth came to be concentrated in the hands of the country's ruling elite, even as political rivals were jailed or exiled, critical media outlets shuttered and civil dissent crushed, paving the way for Hun Manet to take over. In recent months, even domestic administrative policy decisions were being brought to Hun Sen for approval, according to the regional diplomat who interacts with Cambodian officials. Now, the border conflict has made his clout more apparent, and there has been an outpouring of support for the government on social media amid a wave of nationalism. "It hasn't surprised anyone that he's taken the lead which tells you everyone knew he was in charge," another Cambodia-based diplomat said. "If the goal is to strengthen nationalism, he has succeeded." REUTERS
AsiaOne
7 hours ago
- AsiaOne
3-room and bigger Tampines, Toa Payoh BTO flats most popular with first-timers in July HDB launch, Singapore News
Three-room and bigger Built-To-Order (BTO) flats in Tampines and Toa Payoh were the most popular among first-time home buyers in the July 2025 sales exercise which closed on Wednesday evening (July 30). According to information on HDB's service portal at 5pm, more than 22,000 BTO applications were received. This was higher than the 13,200 applications received in the February sales exercise, said National Development Minister Chee Hong Tat in a Facebook post on Thursday. Simei Symphony in Tampines saw nearly 2,400 first-and second-timer families applying for the 240 units of four-and five-room standard flats available. The project - within walking distance to the Downtown Line's Upper Changi MRT station and the Singapore University of Technology and Design - had more than six first-timer families applying for each of the 140 four-room units, and almost eight first-timer families applying for each of the 100 five-room units. The last HDB project in the area was Parc Lumiere, a Design, Build and Sell Scheme (DBSS) development which was completed in 2011. Over in Toa Payoh, the 741-unit Toa Payoh Ascent received more than 5,800 applications from first-and second-timer families. In particular, there were more than six applications for each of the 468 four-room units. Located at the junction of Toa Payoh Rise and Braddell Rise, the BTO project is within walking distance to Caldecott MRT station which serves as an interchange for the Circle Line and Thomson-East Coast Line. Both BTO projects are also popular with first-timer singles with almost 42 applications for each of the 140 units of two-room flexi flats in Tampines, and more than 18 applications for each of the 195 flexi flats in Toa Payoh. At the Sembawang Beacon project, the first in Sembawang North, there were 905 applications for the 607 units of three-room and bigger BTO flats available. In his Facebook post, Chee Hong Tat said that the median application rate of 1.4 for three-room and bigger BTO flats among first-timer families was slightly higher than the application rate of 1.1 in February's exercise. He added that this was lower than that of the three sales launches in 2024, which ranged from 1.6 to 2.6. The July exercise is also the first since the Housing Board announced that singles applying for new flats can join married couples in getting priority access when they buy a home near or with their parents. The new Family Care Scheme (Proximity) streamlines three priority schemes and allows both parents and children to have priority access if they are applying for a new flat to live with or near each other, regardless of marital status. A second component of the scheme, which grants singles priority if they jointly apply for two units in the same BTO project with their parents, will kick in from the October sales exercise. Continued demand for two-room flexi flats Demand for two-room flexi BTO flats remained strong among single and seniors with over 7,000 applications for the 1,321 two-room flexi flats available. Across the seven projects offering two-room flexi flats, the median application rate was 2.5 for seniors and 8.4 for singles. Meanwhile, the median application rate for first-timer families for Sale of Balance Flats (SBF) dropped to 1.8, from 2.6 in February 2025. Three-room SBF flats in Ang Mo Kio, Choa Chu Kang, Geylang, Jurong East/West, Kallang Whompoa, Queenstown, Toa Payoh and Woodlands were least chosen by first-timer families, with less than one application per unit. HDB will offer about 9,100 flats in Ang Mo Kio, Bedok, Bishan, Bukit Merah, Jurong East, Sengkang, Toa Payoh and Yishun for the next sales exercise in October. [[nid:720412]] editor@
Business Times
9 hours ago
- Business Times
Meta beats expectations sending share price soaring
[SAN FRANCISCO] Meta reported robust second-quarter financial results on Wednesday, with revenue jumping 22 per cent year-over-year to US$47.5 billion as the social media giant continues investing heavily in artificial intelligence. The Facebook and Instagram owner's share price soared as much as 12 per cent in after-hours trading, with investors buoyed by the company's growing advertising business and a rise in users across its family of platforms. 'We've had a strong quarter both in terms of our business and community,' said CEO Mark Zuckerberg. 'I'm excited to build personal superintelligence for everyone in the world.' Meta posted a net profit of US$18.3 billion, compared with US$13.5 billion in the same period last year. The results exceeded Wall Street expectations as advertising revenue climbed a stellar 21 per cent to US$46.6 billion. Meta's Family of Apps segment, which includes Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp and Messenger, saw daily active users reach 3.48 billion in June, up 6 per cent from a year earlier. The company significantly increased its capital expenditures to US$17 billion in the quarter, primarily for AI infrastructure investments. Meta projects total 2025 capital spending between US$66 billion and US$72 billion. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Zuckerberg has embarked on a major AI spending spree, poaching top researchers with expensive pay packages from rivals like OpenAI and Apple as he builds a team to pursue what he calls AI superintelligence. 'To win the superintelligence race requires the best of the best talent and Meta's been on a roll when it comes to recruiting top AI talent. Money talks and Meta has plenty of it,' said Forrester research director Mike Proulx. The big question is whether Wall Street will continue backing the expensive strategy. Meta is locked in a bitter rivalry with other tech behemoths as they invest heavily in AI, aiming to ensure the technology benefits society and generates profits in the not-so-distant future. Most analysts believe Meta will make the investment pay off by improving its advertising efficiency and creating new opportunities, such as with its smart glasses through a partnership with Ray-Ban maker EssilorLuxottica. 'Capital expenditures are still shockingly high, but with these strong results, Meta has bought itself more time with investors,' said Debra Aho Williamson, chief analyst at Sonata Insights. However, others signal that Meta's AI spending spree needs a clearer sense of direction. A strong quarter 'won't shield Meta from questions concerning the company's future as it breathlessly tries to keep up in the AI race,' said Emarketer analyst Minda Smiley. Another reason that Zuckerberg's spending bonanza may raise eyebrows is because it echoes his previous leap into spending vast amounts on virtual reality and entering the metaverse, with the CEO even changing the company's name from Facebook to Meta to reflect the strategy change. The bleeding continued in that segment, with the Reality Labs division, Meta's virtual and augmented reality unit, posting significant losses. The unit lost US$4.5 billion in the quarter on revenue of just US$370 million, highlighting ongoing challenges in the metaverse business. 'Undeniable' Zuckerberg's AI team is headed by Alexandr Wang, the former CEO of Scale AI, a startup in which Meta invested US$14.3 billion at the beginning of the company's spending blitz in June. Hours before the earnings report, Zuckerberg insisted that the attainment of superintelligence is now 'in sight.' In a post outlining Meta's AI strategy, Zuckerberg signalled that the remainder of the decade would be a transformative period for artificial intelligence development and that the company's priority was to bring AI to its users. 'There's no other company that is as good as us at taking something getting it in front of billions of people,' he told analysts. AFP
