Khandallah trial: Court hears of 'unusual' actions by murder-accused
The trial before a judge and jury at the High Court in Wellington is set down for four to five weeks, and today entered its third day.
The Crown's case is that DeLuney violently attacked her mother on the evening of January 24 last year, possibly using a vase that was missing off one of the bedside tables, and staged it as a fall from the attic.
DeLuney dealt in cryptocurrency and appeared to be in some financial trouble.
However, the defence has asked the jury not to discount the possibility that there was a third person involved, with a neighbour reporting a mysterious knock on their door that same evening.
ADVERTISEMENT
The detective, Luke Hensley, under cross examination by defence lawyer Quentin Duff, said when he was called in the death wasn't being treated as suspicious.
But he said the blood around the house struck him as strange – as did the claim from DeLuney that, when she had left her mother on the floor of a bedroom to drive back to Kāpiti to pick up her husband to help, there had been no significant blood.
Hensley had eight years' experience at the time, but called a more senior officer to get advice, and they walked through the house on Facetime.
In his statement on the night, he wrote they agreed it was "likely some sort of accident, but where the blood was located around the house was strange".
They locked the scene down for an examination the next day.
Hensley also noted at the time he thought it was "unusual" that DeLuney had driven to Kāpiti to fetch her husband, instead of calling an ambulance.
The defence's case is that, while she was gone, a third person caused those fatal injuries to her mother.
ADVERTISEMENT
Duff asked Hensley on the witness stand: "Did it ever occur to you that perhaps someone else might have broken into the house and caused those injuries and spread that blood?"
Hensley replied: "At the time I believed that getting the statement from Ms DeLuney would cover off a lot of that" and "fill in those blanks".
On the night of the death, DeLuney was not yet being treated as a suspect.
She and her husband followed police officers in their own car to the Johnsonville police station in the early hours of the morning to give statements.
The court heard DeLuney's account for the first time today, in the form of her statement given in the early hours of that night in January 2024.
The statement
Police at the scene on Baroda St, Khandallah. (Source: 1News)
ADVERTISEMENT
Detective Elizabeth Lee, who worked in the Wellington Crime Squad based in Johnsonville, read out the written statement to the court.
She was one of the officers on the scene, but then took witness statements from the DeLuneys at the police station just after 2am.
The statement begins by detailing some recent falls her mother had had in the past two years, both times ending up in hospital. One fall resulted in a concussion and a skull fracture.
She said her mother often lost her balance, or felt that she might lose her balance around home.
That evening, Julia DeLuney's husband, Antonio DeLuney, had brought the car home from work, and she had driven it to her mother's house on Baroda St around 6pm.
It was her mother's birthday in May, and she and her daughters had thought tickets to the ballet would be a nice present.
They sat down at computer and picked out seats.
ADVERTISEMENT
"She was in a good mood," she said in her statement.
But her mother was "kind of obsessed" with a shirt she had misplaced and asked for help finding it, going into cupboards and wardrobes.
At one point, DeLuney went up into the attic to store some watches.
The rungs of the ladder to the attic were built into the wall.
"Even I struggle to get up there," DeLuney said.
About 8.30pm, Gregory went into a cupboard to search for the shirt again, and knocked over some toilet paper, which she said she wanted to put into the attic.
DeLuney said at this point, she was in the kitchen.
ADVERTISEMENT
"All of a sudden, I heard a big crash, and I went over to find that she had fallen."
Her mother was "sore everywhere" and holding the top of her head, "crumpled and tangled" against some objects at the base of the attic entrance.
She moved her to one of the bedrooms, with her mum saying things like, "I'll be alright".
She had a little bit of blood on her hand from holding her head. DeLuney said she couldn't see any open wounds, but it looked like the blood – "not a lot" – was coming from the top of her head.
She told her mother she was going to get her husband Antonio to help.
"At this stage, I didn't think there was anything major going on, and I knew she hated hospitals," she said.
She left Gregory lying on the floor, with her feet facing the window. She was "agitated" and trying to get up, but she told her to stay put.
ADVERTISEMENT
Then, she drove 40 minutes home, and found Antonio in bed. She told him her mother had fallen and she needed him to come with her to check on her.
It took another 40 minutes to get back to the house, and when they entered, they ran into the bedroom and "freaked out" because "it looked like a warzone" with blood in lots of different places.
She said none of that blood was there when she left, "so I got a hell of a shock".
The trial continues, and is set down for four to five weeks.
rnz.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Dogs that fatally mauled Neville Thomson also allegedly turned on owner Abel Wira
By Shannon Pitman, Open Justice Journalist of Abel Wira is on trial in the High Court at Whangārei, accused of the manslaughter of Neville Thomson. (File photo) Photo: RNZ / Peter de Graaf A pack of dogs that mauled a man to death had a reputation for lunging at visitors, attacking livestock and even allegedly turned on their owner - resulting in him needing a trip to the emergency department. Despite their history, Abel Wira kept at least 21 dogs confined to a caravan on Neville Thomson's property - until the morning they allegedly broke free and fatally mauled the man he called his brother. Now the 61-year-old is on trial in the High Court at Whangārei on charges of manslaughter and owning a dog that caused injury or death. On day two of the trial the jury heard from Wira's friend Daniel Knopp, who said he'd come across the pack at least six times. "They were vicious-looking dogs. " had to wind the window up so they didn't jump in the window 'cause they were bailing up the truck." Knopp said the dogs were often in the caravan fighting with each other and he noticed the door was only secured by a log. "It wasn't that secure, I don't think it was, just leaning up against it, dogs could probably push it open," Knopp said. Knopp also recalled a story Wira had allegedly told of his own dangerous encounter with the dogs. "One time he told me his own dogs attacked him. He was saying it was on the beach and he had to go in the water to try and drown them to get them off him." The jury heard on Monday that Wira had been staying at Thomson's Puketawa Rd property in Panguru in a caravan with his dogs. Neville Thomson was killed by the dogs on his property in Panguru. (File photo) Photo: Supplied At least six of the dogs were adults and the rest were at varying stages of puppy life. On August 4, 2022, Wira went out to retrieve a car he had crashed weeks beforehand and then went to Broadwood to pick up items, including dog food. Thomson was home alone and on the phone to his partner when the pack of dogs, which were allegedly barricaded in the caravan, got out and mauled him to death. Wira arrived home to discover Thomson's body, which he dragged into the house and covered with a blanket before sending a friend a Facebook message. "I need help bro please my dogs have attacked my bro and hes gone please bro," he said. He then locked the dogs in a truck, closed the gate and drove Thomson's truck an hour away to Ahipara, where he was able to wave down police officers. Emergency services arrived on the scene more than three hours after the incident and pronounced Thomson dead. Thomson's partner Shirley Orchard gave evidence about their 17-year relationship, which was mostly long-distance. Orchard lived in Auckland and would speak to Thomson on the phone every morning when he had his morning coffee. She said on that morning, about 10am, he was chatting about his garden and she could hear that he was outside. With her knowledge of the property, she believes Thomson was walking along the gravel towards the back of the house and the dogs, which were locked in the caravan, caught sight of him. "They started off barking, as soon as he walked into sight of the caravan, they thought he was a stranger because he had shaved off his beard," Orchard said in evidence. "The barking all started up and got louder and that was when I heard him shout out 'get out, get the f*** out' then the noise escalated from the dogs and I never heard not another sound out of him." During cross-examination, defence lawyer Connor Taylor suggested to Orchard that Thomson himself may have released the dogs from the caravan. "I'm not a stupid woman, as soon as he walked into sight of those dogs they busted out of the caravan and attacked him," Orchard responded. "You're just guessing, aren't you?" Connor questioned. "The evidence is he was attacked by dogs, whether he was by the fish pond or I'm making it all up the fact was, he was out in the garden and he was hurt by dogs," Orchard said. Orchard then gave evidence she spent the next hour trying to contact Thomson and asked a neighbour, Lucy Burkhardt, to check on his house. When Burkhardt texted her saying the gate was closed, Thomson felt a slight relief as it was his normal habit to close the gate if he had left the property. "That's a good sign, he's out and not lying in a pool of blood maybe he's in Rawene getting stitched up," she texted back to Burkhardt. Orchard assumed Thomson was okay but made a call to 111 as a safety check. The call was played to the jury. "The dogs are going off for quite a while and I couldn't hear him then the dogs have settled down. "Those dogs have actually attacked me and I know they haven't been fed for two days. I thought 'my God have they attacked him?' I've got no way of knowing," Orchard told the operator. When asked what kind of dogs they were, Orchard responded "mongrels". Burkhart gave evidence the dogs had mauled her pig's ears on one occasion. The trial continues before Justice Andrew Becroft. * This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald .
NZ Herald
15 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Comancheros retribution: Elijah Meyer, Patrick Langi targeted departing gang member's family
Langi, who became a patched member after his deportation from Australia, and Meyer, who was partially raised in Australia but voluntarily left, were initially charged with attempted murder. They were set to go to trial earlier this year but it was cancelled after both agreed to instead plead guilty to lesser charges of discharging a weapon with reckless disregard and arson. Prison search, surveillance Court documents state Langi and Meyer carried out the shootings in August 2023 after high-ranking patched member Khalid Slaimankhel said he wanted out. Slaimankhel is serving a six-year sentence in Whanganui prison for his part in a Comanchero's methamphetamine distribution scheme. Khalid Naser Slaimankhel appears in the High Court at Auckland on an unrelated charge in 2015. Photo / Jason Oxenham On August 10, 2023 – just over two weeks before the shootings – the Department of Corrections searched Unit 8 of Rimutaka Prison, where gang president Pasilika Naufahu and fellow patched member Jalal Safi were housed. Officers seized notebooks from Safi's cell, as well as a mobile phone he was using when the search began. Authorities would later realise the phone had been used to search Google Maps for the same streets where the shootings would later occur. The notebooks also contained addresses on those streets, with notations such as 'mum' and 'brother older'. Jailed Comancheros president Pasilika Naufahu was investigated but not charged with participating in the retribution plan. Photo / Brett Phibbs Neither of the imprisoned gang members were charged. On August 15, 10 days before the shootings, Langi used his phone to screenshot maps of the same addresses. That same day, co-defendant Meyer was 'directed by unknown parties to conduct surveillance' on the addresses. He took notes and photos that were later recovered from his phone. Timeline of violence Langi and Meyer showed up at the first property, in Epsom, about 7pm on August 25, 2023. Meyer fired at least three shots while another unidentified man was armed but his gun appears to have jammed, documents state. 'One of the fired projectiles went through the wooden window frame of the master bedroom at the front of the house, causing the interior of the window frame to chip off,' court documents state. 'At the time of the shooting there were eight occupants within the house, including three young children playing in the master bedroom that was shot at.' Comancheros prospect Elijah Meyer appears in the High Court at Auckland for sentencing. Photo / Michael Craig Thirteen minutes later, after fleeing the scene, the stolen car used by the duo was torched. Meyer and Langi arrived at the next home, in Hillsborough, at 7.31pm in a second stolen vehicle. Meyer got out of the vehicle and began knocking on the door aggressively. Langi did not go up to the door with him, but he was charged with the same offence for having aided or encouraged the crime. Those inside the home had been eating upstairs, and a man yelled that he was coming down. Meyer opened fire as the man opened the door, with the bullets lodging in the door as the victim attempted to shut it. 'Mr Meyer placed his foot in the door to attempt to keep it open but [the victim] managed to push the door closed, and locked it, before attempting to run up the stairs away from the defendant,' police noted in the summaries of facts for both men. Meyer then walked to the front entrance window and aimed three more shots at the fleeing man – one of them grazing him in the back. Less than 15 minutes later, the second stolen vehicle was set alight at nearby Nash Rd Reserve. Patched Comancheros member Patrick Langi appears in the High Court at Auckland for sentencing. Photo / Michael Craig Police caught up to Meyer and Langi at 8.07pm that day after spotting them in a third stolen vehicle near the reserve. Gunshot residue was found in the vehicle and on both men's clothing, authorities said. 'The defendant Langi declined to comment to most questions, [but] when confronted with the gunshot residue evidence he stated that it was 'bullshit' and police must have made that up,' court documents state. Victim impact statements were provided to the court but Slaimankhel's family declined to read them aloud. They had come to New Zealand from Afghanistan seeking a 'safer foundation' but now their children are traumatised and suffer nightmares, the court was told. Raised in Australia Langi and Meyer both faced up to 14 years' imprisonment today for arson and up to seven years for discharging a firearm with reckless disregard. Defence lawyers disagreed the plot was as uncommon as the prosecution had suggested. Family homes are unfortunately shot at often in gang culture, said Jasper Rhodes, who represented Langi. Defence lawyer Jasper Rhodes. Photo / Michael Craig He noted that Langi was sentenced to prison at age 18 for an aggravated assault, after which he was deported to New Zealand without support despite having lived in Australia since he was 5. The defendant had developed cocaine, MDMA and cannabis habits as a young teen and began using methamphetamine and heroin on a near-daily basis while in prison, he told authorities. But since his arrest, he had engaged in rehabilitation and had written a letter of apology, Rhodes said. 'He's insightful as to how he got here,' he said of his client. Justin Harder noted that Meyer, his client, was only 21 at the time of the offending and as a prospect was quite low in the Comancheros hierarchy. Defence lawyer Justin Harder. Photo / Michael Craig 'He's not the architect,' he said of the retribution plot, describing a 'power imbalance' in which his role was to follow orders. Meyer was born in Australia but was sent to New Zealand by his mother as a young teen in hopes of getting him away from anti-social influences. His father had died when he was 11 and his major male influences after that were his gang-connected older brothers, the lawyer said. The change of scenery didn't appear to work, and Meyer picked up a Youth Court notation for firearms offending. 'The reality was it didn't matter what side of the Tasman he was on - he wasn't able to escape that,' Harder said. Meyer returned to Australia, then made a final return to New Zealand about 18 months before the shootings. Justice Ian Gault presides over a hearing in the High Court at Auckland. Photo / Michael Craig The judge ordered Meyer to serve a sentence of four years and four months' imprisonment. Langi was sentenced to four years and seven months' imprisonment. He allowed some discounts for guilty pleas, background and remorse but said the reductions had to be weighed against their continued involvement in the gang. Good family, tragic past Slaimankhel, formerly a Dunedin bodybuilder, was also found guilty in 2015 of kidnapping a fellow bodybuilder and perverting the course of justice. He came from a good family, his lawyer said at his 2022 Auckland District Court sentencing on drug trafficking charges. Lawyer Mark Ryan said at the time his client turned to drugs and gangs after his father was killed by a suicide bomber in Afghanistan. The family of jailed former Comancheros member Khalid Naser Slaimankhel was targeted for retribution. Photo / Supplied Dr Hashem Slaimankhel had been a physician in Afghanistan and Pakistan before arriving in New Zealand in 1998 and taking on a role as a refugee health worker. His advocacy made enough of an impact in New Zealand that police publicly praised the 'dedicated and deeply respected community leader' after his death in January 2018. The elder Slaimankhel was among the nearly 100 people killed when an ambulance with a bomb inside detonated at a police checkpoint in Kabul. The Taliban claimed responsibility for the massacre. At his 2022 sentencing, the younger Slaimankhel told Judge Evangelos Thomas he wanted to leave gang life behind him. Prosecutors voiced some scepticism but acknowledged the goal was a worthy one if genuine. 'It's going to take an awful amount of work to make sure that is carried through,' Crown prosecutor Jacob Barry said. The judge agreed, turning to Slaimankhel's family and supporters, who filled the courtroom gallery, after the defendant was led away to begin serving his sentence. He encouraged them to continue supporting him. 'If people aren't working hard around him, he's going to be straight into that [gang] environment,' the judge said. 'This work is really only beginning now.' Craig Kapitan is an Auckland-based journalist covering courts and justice. He joined the Herald in 2021 and has reported on courts since 2002 in three newsrooms in the US and New Zealand. Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
1News
15 hours ago
- 1News
Auckland woman sentenced on numerous tax fraud charges
An Auckland woman has been jailed for two years on numerous tax fraud charges. Caitlin Briar Ashby appeared in the Manukau District Court on August 14, where she faced 18 charges of using documents with intent to obtain a pecuniary advantage from income tax returns, GST returns and applications to two Covid-19 support schemes. She had previously admitted the charges. Ashby had set up three bank accounts using false identities and filed 64 false income tax returns for 14 different taxpayers. She also made two false GST returns, two false Small Business Cashflow scheme loan (SBCS) applications - of which one was paid out while the other was declined - and one false Resurgence Support Payment (RSP) application. ADVERTISEMENT Between May and August of 2019, Ashby had the bank account details changed for 19 taxpayers, so income tax refunds for those people would be paid into accounts she controlled. The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including Zelensky's suit becomes hot topic at peace summit, a cold blast on the way, and Auckland FC lures new signing back home. (Source: 1News) Between July and August 2019, she applied for 61 tax refunds for 14 people for whom she had updated details. The money was paid into bank accounts she had control of. Ashby also tried to get two GST returns paid into her accounts, but it was not. Nearly $37,000 was deposited into bank accounts under Ashby's control from the Covid-19 relief schemes. Inland Revenue said Ashby attempted to obtain a total of $222,822.44 from the department and successfully received $36,629.64. She was sentenced to two years in prison for her fraudulent behaviour. She was given leave to apply for home detention if she could find a suitable address to live. ADVERTISEMENT No reparation was ordered, and six months' special and standard release conditions were included in her sentence.
