logo
Traders can go bust even when they know the outcome; Zerodha cofounder Nithin Kamath explains how

Traders can go bust even when they know the outcome; Zerodha cofounder Nithin Kamath explains how

Time of India3 days ago
Zerodha
founder
Nithin Kamath
, in a post shared on X (formerly Twitter), discussed the findings of an
investment experiment
conducted by
ElmWealth
, which revealed that nearly half of the participating
finance students
lost money despite correctly predicting market movements more than half the time.
Kamath highlighted the experiment in a detailed thread, calling attention to the dangers of poor
position sizing
and
risk management
in trading.
Explore courses from Top Institutes in
Select a Course Category
CXO
Others
Cybersecurity
MBA
healthcare
Finance
Data Science
Product Management
Digital Marketing
Operations Management
Technology
Project Management
others
Management
Public Policy
Design Thinking
Leadership
MCA
PGDM
Skills you'll gain:
Digital Strategy Development Expertise
Emerging Technologies & Digital Trends
Data-driven Decision Making
Leadership in the Digital Age
Duration:
40 Weeks
Indian School of Business
ISB Chief Digital Officer
Starts on
Jun 30, 2024
Get Details
Skills you'll gain:
Technology Strategy & Innovation
Emerging Technologies & Digital Transformation
Leadership in Technology Management
Cybersecurity & Risk Management
Technology Strategy & Innovation
Emerging Technologies & Digital Transformation
Leadership in Technology Management
Cybersecurity & Risk Management
Duration:
24 Weeks
Indian School of Business
ISB Chief Technology Officer
Starts on
Jun 28, 2024
Get Details
Skills you'll gain:
Customer-Centricity & Brand Strategy
Product Marketing, Distribution, & Analytics
Digital Strategies & Innovation Skills
Leadership Insights & AI Integration Expertise
Duration:
10 Months
IIM Kozhikode
IIMK Chief Marketing and Growth Officer
Starts on
Apr 7, 2024
Get Details
Skills you'll gain:
Technology Strategy & Innovation
Emerging Technologies & Digital Transformation
Leadership in Technology Management
Cybersecurity & Risk Management
Duration:
24 Weeks
Indian School of Business
ISB Chief Technology Officer
Starts on
Jun 28, 2024
Get Details
Interesting experiment by
@ElmWealth
: 118 finance students were given tomorrow's WSJ front page 24 hours before the news broke. You'd expect easy profits. Instead, half lost money and 16% went completely bust.
It wasn't because their predictions were wrong. They called market…
pic.twitter.com/rdm1zNY8AE
— Nithin Kamath (@Nithin0dha)
July 21, 2025
According to Kamath's post, 118 finance students were given access to the Wall Street Journal's front page 24 hours in advance over a simulated 15-day period. While the information advantage should have logically led to profits, it was noted that half of these students lost money, and 16% went completely bust.
The students accurately predicted market direction 51.5% of the time, better than random chance, yet still failed to make gains.
Kamath explained that the core problem was not the quality of their predictions but their position sizing.
'Many students bet huge portions of their portfolio on a single trade. Some used 20x, even 60x leverage. When they were right, they made money. But when they were wrong, they blew up. All it took was a single misstep,' Kamath noted in his post.
In contrast, five experienced traders who ran the same simulation achieved dramatically different outcomes. Kamath said, 'Very different outcome: +130% average returns. Why? They knew how much to risk. They bet small when uncertain, and big only when the odds were clearly in their favor.'
He emphasized that this difference boiled down to understanding the art of position sizing.
Kamath pointed out a crucial takeaway: 'Even if you could predict the future, it wouldn't save you from poor risk management. Trading isn't just about being right. It's about surviving long enough to stay in the game.'
Quoting from the experiment, Kamath noted that most retail traders focus primarily on predicting market direction, but smart traders focus on how much to bet and how to manage risk even when they are correct.
He cited the wisdom of Ray Dalio: 'He who lives by the crystal ball will eat shattered glass.'
The experiment, which referenced a theory by Nassim Nicholas Taleb, supported the view that even with early access to market-moving news, traders could still fail without disciplined risk control.
Kamath concluded his post, stating, 'Because in the markets, being right means nothing if you go bust before you're proven right.'
In the end, the financial industry's pursuit of better predictive models should also focus on sensible investment sizing to fully realize the potential of their strategies.
(
Disclaimer
: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)
ETMarkets WhatsApp channel
)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

PM Modi's foreign visits cost India nearly Rs 295 crore since 2021; Rs 67 crore spent on 2025 trips to five countries
PM Modi's foreign visits cost India nearly Rs 295 crore since 2021; Rs 67 crore spent on 2025 trips to five countries

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

PM Modi's foreign visits cost India nearly Rs 295 crore since 2021; Rs 67 crore spent on 2025 trips to five countries

More than Rs 67 crore was spent on Prime Minister Narendra Modi 's visits to five countries in 2025, with France being the most expensive destination, according to information shared by the government in Parliament. The total cost of Modi's foreign trips between 2021 and 2024 stood at nearly Rs 295 crore. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category CXO MBA Design Thinking Product Management Operations Management healthcare others Artificial Intelligence Degree MCA Cybersecurity Leadership Data Science PGDM Technology Project Management Public Policy Data Analytics Healthcare Digital Marketing Management Data Science Finance Others Skills you'll gain: Operations Strategy for Business Excellence Organizational Transformation Corporate Communication & Crisis Management Capstone Project Presentation Duration: 11 Months IIM Lucknow Chief Operations Officer Programme Starts on Jun 30, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Technology Strategy & Innovation Emerging Technologies & Digital Transformation Leadership in Technology Management Cybersecurity & Risk Management Duration: 24 Weeks Indian School of Business ISB Chief Technology Officer Starts on Jun 28, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Customer-Centricity & Brand Strategy Product Marketing, Distribution, & Analytics Digital Strategies & Innovation Skills Leadership Insights & AI Integration Expertise Duration: 10 Months IIM Kozhikode IIMK Chief Marketing and Growth Officer Starts on Apr 7, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Digital Strategy Development Expertise Emerging Technologies & Digital Trends Data-driven Decision Making Leadership in the Digital Age Duration: 40 Weeks Indian School of Business ISB Chief Digital Officer Starts on Jun 30, 2024 Get Details Where Did Modi Travel in 2025? In 2025, Modi visited France, the US, Thailand, Sri Lanka, and Saudi Arabia. Here's how much each trip cost: France: Rs 25.59 crore US: Rs 16.54 crore Saudi Arabia: Rs 15.54 crore Thailand: Rs 4.92 crore Sri Lanka: Rs 4.46 crore The France visit was the most expensive among these. Some Bills Still Being Settled Country-wise costs for Modi's other visits in 2025, including trips to Mauritius, Cyprus, Canada, Croatia, Ghana, Trinidad & Tobago, Argentina, Brazil, and Namibia, were not available. The External Affairs Ministry said those bills are still being settled. Live Events How Much Was Spent in Previous Years? According to Minister of State for External Affairs Kirti Vardhan Singh, who gave the written reply in Rajya Sabha, here's how much India spent on Modi's foreign trips in the last few years: 2024: Around Rs 109 crore (16 countries) 2023: Nearly Rs 93 crore 2022: Rs 55.82 crore 2021: About Rs 36 crore What Did Modi Do on These Visits? In February 2025, Modi travelled to France and the US. In Paris, he held bilateral talks with President Emmanuel Macron and took part in an AI Summit. In the US, he met former President Donald Trump and attended various high-level meetings. The government also revealed data about public events, advertising, and broadcast costs. For example, during Modi's 2023 visit to Egypt, India spent around Rs 11.90 lakh just on advertising and broadcasting. Inputs from PTI

Is Yahoo mail down? Thousands of users report temporary error 15 and email access issues
Is Yahoo mail down? Thousands of users report temporary error 15 and email access issues

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

Is Yahoo mail down? Thousands of users report temporary error 15 and email access issues

On Thursday morning, July 24, many Yahoo Mail users started facing issues with logging in and accessing their emails. The issue began just after 9 a.m. EST, and reports suddenly spiked from almost zero to over 9,000 complaints, as per Down Detector. The real number of people affected is likely much higher than what was reported. Another website, Down for Everyone or Just Me, also confirmed that Yahoo Mail was down. Users trying to check their mail online saw a message saying: "We are experiencing some technical difficulties. Temporary Error: 15", as per the report by Men's Journal. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category CXO Finance MCA Operations Management Digital Marketing Leadership Product Management Data Analytics Public Policy Data Science Management Artificial Intelligence MBA Healthcare Degree Design Thinking Data Science PGDM healthcare Project Management Cybersecurity others Others Technology Skills you'll gain: Digital Strategy Development Expertise Emerging Technologies & Digital Trends Data-driven Decision Making Leadership in the Digital Age Duration: 40 Weeks Indian School of Business ISB Chief Digital Officer Starts on Jun 30, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Operations Strategy for Business Excellence Organizational Transformation Corporate Communication & Crisis Management Capstone Project Presentation Duration: 11 Months IIM Lucknow Chief Operations Officer Programme Starts on Jun 30, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Technology Strategy & Innovation Emerging Technologies & Digital Transformation Leadership in Technology Management Cybersecurity & Risk Management Duration: 24 Weeks Indian School of Business ISB Chief Technology Officer Starts on Jun 28, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Customer-Centricity & Brand Strategy Product Marketing, Distribution, & Analytics Digital Strategies & Innovation Skills Leadership Insights & AI Integration Expertise Duration: 10 Months IIM Kozhikode IIMK Chief Marketing and Growth Officer Starts on Apr 7, 2024 Get Details ALSO READ: AEye stock skyrockets 255% after game-changing Nvidia deal stuns Wall Street What message are users seeing? A clickable 'learn more' option showed a follow-up note saying, 'Sometimes, issues in Yahoo Mail can cause a temporary error. 'Temporary error 15' usually fixes itself in a few minutes to a few hours. Here are possible causes and tips to fix it', as per Yahoo support page. Yahoo released an official update, saying, 'We are aware some users are experiencing issues accessing their Yahoo Mail. We are working to resolve this as quickly as possible', as per official Yahoo statement. Live Events What are users saying online? Many users shared their personal issues on Down Detector. One said: "Same problem here, web-based version shows 'Temporary Error: 15' with no access. My phone works but subfolders show 'no messages'." ASLO READ: Oklo stock rockets 12% to record $75 — is this just the beginning for the nuclear energy disruptor? Another shared: "I thought my account got deactivated. It says 'Your mail is temporarily unavailable. Please wait a moment and reload the page. Learn more.'" A third user said: "I can log in again, but emails still won't load. It says, 'An error occurred while trying to fetch the items in this list.'' Right now, users are waiting for Yahoo to fix things, hoping the issue ends soon because not having access to email is super frustrating, according to the report by Men's Journal. FAQs Q1. Why is Yahoo Mail not working today ? Yahoo Mail is down for many users due to a technical error called "Temporary Error 15", which Yahoo is working to fix. Q2. What is Temporary Error 15 on Yahoo Mail? Temporary Error 15 is a common Yahoo Mail issue that usually fixes itself in a few minutes to a few hours.

Duty concessions to UK only on large petrol, diesel vehicles, high-priced EVs: Official
Duty concessions to UK only on large petrol, diesel vehicles, high-priced EVs: Official

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

Duty concessions to UK only on large petrol, diesel vehicles, high-priced EVs: Official

New Delhi : India has provided duty concessions to the UK auto exporters only on large petrol and diesel vehicles and high-priced EVs, while protecting sensitive segments of the domestic automotive industry especially mid and small cars and low-priced EVs under the trade pact, an official said. No concessions are given to electric, hybrid, and hydrogen-powered vehicles in the first five years of the agreement. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Healthcare others Cybersecurity Others Public Policy Product Management Leadership Artificial Intelligence Data Science Data Science Project Management CXO MBA Design Thinking Digital Marketing MCA Management Technology Data Analytics Finance healthcare PGDM Skills you'll gain: Financial Analysis in Healthcare Financial Management & Investing Strategic Management in Healthcare Process Design & Analysis Duration: 12 Weeks Indian School of Business Certificate Program in Healthcare Management Starts on Jun 13, 2024 Get Details The pact, officially called Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), was signed in London on Thursday in the presence of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his British counterpart Keir Starmer. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Treatment That Might Help You Against Knee Pain Knee pain | search ads Find Now Undo As per the pact, tariffs on automotive imports will go from about 110 per cent at present to 10 per cent under quotas on both sides. The offered quota and duty reduction is more on the large engine capacity categories (above 3,000 cc petrol / 2,500 cc diesel). Live Events "It ensures the domestic sector sufficient time to expand, innovate, and enhance global competitiveness in our area of strength in small (up to 1,500 cc) and mid segment (1,500-3,000 cc petrol / up to 2,500 cc diesel," the official said adding the duty reduction to 10 per cent will be done in over five years with quota. Out of quota duty reduction is 50 per cent in over 10 years. "The concession framework is designed to provide market access to UK exporters mostly on large engine size ICE (internal combustion engine) vehicles and high price range EVs while simultaneously protecting sensitive segments of India's automotive industry (mid and small size engine capacity ICE vehicles and mid and low price range EVs)," the official said. As per the details of the agreement, the number of vehicles from ICE engines shall get deducted by the number of EV vehicles getting concessions in sixth year onwards to maintain the total quota volume of 37,000 units at the end of 15 years of duty concession. For vehicles priced below British Pound 40,000 (CIF), no market access is provided, ensuring complete protection for the mass-market EV segment in which India seeks global leadership. Market access in EV is given mostly in high-priced vehicles priced above British Pound 80,000 (CIF). "India has secured market access to the tune of four times of its concession given to UK on EV in UK market," the government official said adding India has extended a structured and balanced market access offer to the UK in the automobile sector under the trade agreement. India's commitment is calibrated, phased, and development-oriented quota based liberalization strategy. This offer pertains exclusively to Completely Built Units (CBUs) of passenger vehicles encompassing Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) vehicles as well as electric, hybrid, and hydrogen-powered vehicles.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store