S.F. Police Commission sheds another police critic as potential successors line up

San Francisco Chronicle​

03-05-2025

Jesus Yáñez only days ago finished his term on the powerful San Francisco Police Commission, and already a host of potential successors are lining up for his job.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors has fielded five applications to the commission, including from a Tenderloin community advocate and several prominent local attorneys.
The commission, which sets police policy and imposes discipline against officers, is one of the most influential bodies at City Hall. The seven-member panel was until recently controlled by Yáñez and other progressive-aligned members who emphasized the commission's role as an independent check on the police department.
But as the pandemic gave way to concerns about crime and street conditions, the commission became a lightning rod for critics who accused it of putting reform over public safety. Voters curtailed its power last March, approving a measure that requires more time and public input for changes to police policy. Then this year, Mayor Daniel Lurie ousted its most prominent adversarial voice, attorney Max Carter-Oberstone, a mayoral appointee who broke off from Mayor London Breed.
The board's upcoming decision on Yáñez's successor, which has yet to be scheduled, could give Lurie and his police-friendly allies another reliable vote on the commission. The body is already stacked in favor of the mayor's office, which gets to appoint four of its members. Lurie himself has appointed two members, Mattie Scott and Wilson Leung. Adding another moderate-aligned voice to the commission would only shore up their majority.
The balance of power on the commission is especially consequential at a time when the city has a new mayor and its longest serving police chief in decades, Bill Scott. If Scott departs for any reason, the commission will play a key role in choosing his successor.
The candidates who applied as of Thursday included Pratibha Tekkey, a community organizer with the Tenderloin Housing Clinic, and Hasib Emran, a California deputy state controller and longtime aide to State Controller Malia Cohen, who previously led the police commission.
In her application, Tekkey said she would build trust between police and the community, while Emran, a Bay Area-born son of Afghan refugees, told the Chronicle he wanted to be a 'community ambassador' for the commission.
The other applicants so far were Meredith Osborn, a white-collar defense attorney and former chief trial deputy for the city attorney's office, Neil Hallinan, a criminal defense attorney, and Albert Mayer, an artificial intelligence consultant and former senior trial counsel with the U.S. Department of Justice.
Osborn wrote in her application that she would be an ally for immigrants and LGBTQ+ people as well as a representative for working families, while Hallinan noted that he had represented many people arrested by San Francisco police, sometimes wrongfully.
'I understand the proper balance between acknowledging the difficulty of being an effective and honorable police officer versus the need to hold police to the high standard,' Hallinan wrote.
Mayer told the Chronicle he had successfully prosecuted opioid companies and wanted to help the police department fight to end the 'open-air drug markets and theft rings.'
At least one other potential candidate is also considering applying: Marjan Philhour, who was endorsed by the police union in her unsuccessful race for District 1 supervisor last year.
'I have been approached by numerous neighborhood, small business and public safety leaders urging me to apply,' Philhour said.
Another rumored candidate, community advocate Betty Louie, said she applied for the role, but withdrew her name from consideration after learning about the other applicants.
Yáñez, a juvenile justice advocate and commissioner since early 2022, held one of three seats on the panel appointed by the Board of Supervisors. The other two are currently filled by Cindy Elias and Kevin Benedicto. He said Thursday that he decided not to seek reappointment because he became disillusioned with the commission and what he saw as its lack of urgency for reform and embrace of 'copaganda.'
'I was left being one of the few voices that was not willing to bite my tongue,' Yáñez said.
Yáñez said he had struggled to get the commission to hold hearings on issues he viewed as important, including on a police pursuit that led to a stolen vehicle crashing into a parklet in the Mission and injuring multiple people in February. Yáñez was also upset that the San Francisco Police Officers Association had publicly accused him and his wife, a deputy public defender, of obstructing a police investigation — a claim he denied.
'The way that people perceive me has completely shifted,' Yáñez said. 'Why am I going to continue to expose myself to this?'
It's unclear that Yáñez would have had the support to remain on the commission, even if he wanted to. To oust Carter-Oberstone, Lurie secured a 9-2 vote at the Board of Supervisors. Yáñez would have had to garner the support of the board to retain his seat.
Any applicant for the commission has to appear first before the board's rules committee.
Rafael Mandelman, president of the board and a member of the rules committee, said he probably wouldn't have supported Yáñez had he chosen to reapply.
Mandelman said it was time for a 'new day' at the police commission and that he wanted the next appointee to signal the board's 'commitment to safety.'
"There's an abundance of excellent candidates for this spot,' Mandelman said. 'It's going to be a hard choice to make.'
Supervisor Stephen Sherill, another rules committee member, also emphasized the need for candidates focused on public safety.
'Public safety is my number one priority and I want police commissioners who share that priority,' Sherill said.
Supervisor Shamann Walton gets to decide when to schedule a hearing to vote on the applicants as chair of the rules committee.
He has not set a date yet and did not respond to a request for comment.