Committee asks BBC boss for view on ‘what went wrong' with Glastonbury coverage
They led chants of 'Death, death to the IDF (Israel Defence Forces)' during their set on the West Holts Stage on Saturday, with the broadcaster providing on-screen warnings about discriminatory language on its platform.
It later apologised on Monday and said the chants held 'antisemitic sentiments' that were 'unacceptable'.
Irish rap trio Kneecap, who are also facing an Avon and Somerset Police investigation, appeared on the same stage directly after Bob Vylan and led the Glastonbury audience in 'Free Palestine' chants.
It has since been revealed that Tim Davie was at Glastonbury when the pro-Palestine chants were broadcast.
In a letter sent to Mr Davie by the Culture, Media and Sport Committee on Tuesday, chairwoman Dame Caroline Dinenage asked the BBC boss 12 questions after saying its coverage had caused 'widespread concern'.
Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy previously said that 'several' editorial failures 'becomes a problem of leadership' during a statement on the BBC's coverage to the Commons.
It has since been revealed that Tim Davie, the BBC's director general, was at Glastonbury when Bob Vylan performed (Peter Byrne/PA)
Among the questions, Dame Caroline said: 'Before the festival started, did the BBC consider streaming all or part of its Glastonbury coverage with a short time delay, to allow room to respond to events if necessary?'
The Conservative MP went on to ask how many BBC staff and contractors were working at Glastonbury or on its coverage, if staff with the authority to cut Bob Vylan's live stream were present during their performance and whether ending the live stream was discussed mid-performance.
Dame Caroline then asked: 'At what level were the decisions made to not stream Kneecap live and to stream Bob Vylan live, but with a warning on screen?'
The letter asked if the BBC had a contingency plan for the event and who was responsible for forming and actioning the plan, before asking if the broadcaster would review its Editorial Guidelines and guidance for live output 'to ensure they are fit for live streaming'.
The Tory MP added: 'In summary, what is your personal assessment of what went wrong and what (are the) key lessons that the BBC will take away from the experience of live streaming Glastonbury 2025?'
Dame Caroline said she hoped for Mr Davie's response to the questions within two weeks.
Kneecap's performance at Glastonbury is also set to be investigated (Yui Mok/PA)
Avon and Somerset Police said it had launched a probe into both the Bob Vylan and Kneecap performances after reviewing video footage and audio recordings, with a senior detective appointed to lead the investigation.
A force spokesman said: 'This has been recorded as a public order incident at this time while our inquiries are at an early stage.
'The investigation will be evidence-led and will closely consider all appropriate legislation, including relating to hate crimes.'
In response to criticism of their performance on Tuesday, Bob Vylan said in a statement posted on Instagram that they were being 'targeted for speaking up' and that 'a good many people would have you believe a punk band is the number one threat to world peace.'
The statement said: 'We are not for the death of Jews, Arabs or any other race or group of people.
'We are for the dismantling of a violent military machine. A machine whose own soldiers were told to use 'unnecessary lethal force' against innocent civilians waiting for aid.
'A machine that has destroyed much of Gaza.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Statesman
38 minutes ago
- New Statesman
Stop taking Glastonbury so seriously
Illustration by André Carrilho Worthy Farm in Somerset, where Glastonbury Festival has been held 39 times, is 25 miles away from the sea. But once a year it is thronged by seagulls: this is an annual chips-in-styrofoam mecca for the scavenger birds – an event as unmissable for them as it is for the ageing-millennial liberals who populate the site, squatting on the fun that was once the preserve of the young. Parsing the 210,000-strong crowd at the festival is a process of subtle distinction, such as: who is 35 and who is 38? And, does this person live in Stoke Newington or Finsbury Park? Do they work at Deloitte or at a respectable grade in the civil service? Glastonbury in 2025 is where the professional class come to listen to Busta Rhymes (doyen of the 1990s) perform 'Break Ya Neck', with right-hand man, Spliff Star, and pretend the culture hasn't left them behind. Even though of course it has. It is not totally homogenous: there are the elites literally at the peripheries, their clean and catered camps looming from on-high over the grounds (metaphor alert!); and there are attendees on the more feral end of the spectrum (who would think, may I ask, to pitch their tent one metre downstream of the busiest bathrooms on the grounds?). But in its total average, the Glastonbury crowd leans towards the staid, stable and rote. When Richard Tice, the deputy leader of Reform, turned down a chance to debate a Green Party leadership hopeful he said his team feared that Glastonbury would not be safe for him. This is fair – if he is afraid of seagulls or management consultants. I was surprised, nonetheless, by the level of political noise the festival generated this year, from this most un-radical of crowds: a man with a straw boater and a collapsible camping chair – a friend for Tice, perhaps? – sat politely in front of me as Kneecap exploded on to the West Holts Stage on the Saturday afternoon. One member of the Belfast rap trio, Mo Chara, was charged with a terror offence in May, accused of brandishing a Hezbollah flag at a 2024 gig. There were questions about whether the festival should cancel the set entirely; the BBC did not air it live for fear the group would say something on stage that contravened its guidelines and standards ('kill David Attenborough', perhaps). Before the festival had even started, Kneecap – with its anti-British posture and radical Irish republicanism – became the story. And then the trio were overtaken when the previously irrelevant rap duo Bob Vylan led the crowd in chants of 'death, death to the IDF'. Everyone – Wes Streeting, Glastonbury itself – was 'appalled', the BBC terribly sorry for broadcasting it; the world rather worried that these rappers had finally been the ones to radicalise the farmer's-market liberals around the festival. But as I watched Kneecap in the baking heat and saw exactly what I was expecting to (Palestine flags and Irish tricolours everywhere) and heard exactly what I was expecting to (Deloitte account managers joining in with 'Free Palestine' and 'Fuck Keir Starmer' chants) I was struck by the powerlessness of it all. Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe This is transient, ephemeral politics. In 2017 Jeremy Corbyn was the main character of Glastonbury, and when his electoral platform totally fell apart, all of a sudden no one at the festival was singing 'Oh, Jeremy Corbyn' anymore. Brexit was the great affront to the Glasto-class at the festival in 2016, and I spotted not one EU flag over the entire week in 2025; the very lonely Ukraine flag I saw looked almost out of date. There is no idée fixe of Glastonbury, but instead the politic du jour. It is hard to blame the millennial consultants and civil servants for rifling through a Rolodex of causes at such a clip. They came of age in the financial crisis and have been politically impotent since; things they don't like (the 2011 Liberal Democrat betrayal, Osborne austerity, Brexit, 'Boris Johnson') keep happening to them. In a country where politics itself is no longer very political and culture feels stuck – Rod Stewart (80) shared a stage on the Sunday with Ronnie Wood (78) and Lulu (76) – all that's left is these end-of-June howls of outrage from staffers at the Big 5. There was a time when liberal Britain could group together to stop the things it did not like, such as the slave trade or Mary Whitehouse. Or redirect the national trajectory: abolishing the death penalty and legalising abortion. They can't anymore. And so here they are with me in Somerset, eating cheese toasties, worrying about seagulls and raging against a non-specified, shapeshifting machine. The ambient Remainer-ism of the past decade of Glastonbury has been traded for this slightly edgier cause, with spikier standard bearers (Kneecap, Bob Vylan). But the sense of a non-committal, window-dressing politik is the same. To fly a Palestine flag in front of the Other Stage during Franz Ferdinand's set is to say: yes, I am a Glastonbury Goer. Just as was the case with open borders in 2018 (prime-time bullshit, by the way, in a camp that has border walls resembling Trump's). But to interrogate the hard politics or even the logic of it all is to misunderstand the project. There are too many drugs to do for that. The worst place to have an ear infection is 41,000 feet over the Atlantic in Delta economy class. The second worst place to have an ear infection is during country/hip-hop crossover event Shaboozey's performance of 'Bar Song (Tipsy)' on Sunday afternoon. It was – like the set by rock band Terrorvision, the crowd at the Information Stage when the independent MP Zarah Sultana appeared, and the 'sound bath' I suffered through at the, er, Healing Fields – extraordinarily loud. But not merely content with the audial invasion, Glastonbury Festival endeavours to assault you with wall of visual noise too: 'PASTA,' a sign screams at me; 'REDUCE, REUSE [and, plot twist], RESPECT' rolls across a TV screen; a posh woman with a hat like I have never seen before (steampunk meets pheasant massacre) walks past; the firework budget alone for the five days I suspect could feed a medium-sized Cambodian town for a year; the lights at the Levels Stage, designed for the ecstasy brain, are too frenetic for the sober one. I understand why these 'Sensory Calm' tents have cropped up everywhere: the one next door to the Kneecap performance got more use than usual. By Sunday the drugs had nearly run out; the politics – already predictable – were exhausting; the atmosphere was increasingly antsy. Deloitte awaited the revellers, they had just remembered. The site smelled like pickled sewage and everyone was taking the last of their ketamine. But, after a three-week cleanup job, the only evidence left of this, all the noise and all the mess, will be the famous Pyramid Stage. The rest – the pheasant-graveyard hat, the man in the boater, the PASTA vendors, the pair camping one metre downstream of the toilets, the elites at the top of the hill – will be gone from Worthy Farm for another year, almost as though nothing happened. And the seagulls will flee, like the ravens leaving the tower of London, to declare a new political lodestar for the Glastonbury class. All of it fair weather, all of it temporary. [See more: Jeff Bezos's Venetian wedding was a pageant of bad taste] Related
The Guardian
40 minutes ago
- The Guardian
TV tonight: Channel 4 airs the Gaza documentary the BBC wouldn't broadcast
10pm, Channel 4 Last month, the BBC said it was no longer airing a documentary about Israeli military attacks on hospitals in Gaza because it risked creating 'a perception of partiality' over the broadcaster's coverage of the conflict. Channel 4 is now showing it instead. Ramita Navai investigates the allegations of the targeting of doctors and healthcare workers in Gaza's 36 main hospitals – which the film says have all now been attacked by Israel. Hollie Richardson 8pm, Channel 4'Oh God, they've got the Live, Laugh, Love wallpaper – that needs to go.' In a slightly more bearable new property series, expert siblings Stuart and Scarlette Douglas help couples who are struggling to sell their properties. First up, a seriously cluttered cottage in Wales and a terrace with too much pink personality in Liverpool. HR 9pm, ITV1Long Lost Family often reveals the devastating impact of last-century attitudes to things like out-of-wedlock pregnancy, but this week tells the story of Sarah, the show's youngest-ever foundling, who was left in a Surrey car park in 2001. Also featured is Chris, who was dropped off at a childminder's 62 years ago and never collected. Ellen E Jones 9pm, Channel 4Llwynhelig House in the Vale of Glamorgan is a Grade II-listed manor with a log cabin and shepherd's hut in case the house itself isn't big enough – but can agents Sorcha and Jemma flog it for £2.2m? More than seven times that price will secure Sunningdale Manor in Jersey for one lucky buyer. Down in Flushing in Cornwall, meanwhile, big local noise Ian spots the chance to trouser more commission on a house he has sold twice before. Jack Seale 9pm, U&WThis small business competition from Reese Witherspoon's production studio continues, and a woman who works a food stall with her ex is the first to pitch her future dreams to potential investor Emma Grede. Then, Ashley Graham is excited to meet the woman behind Bonks emergency thongs ('Yes! Yes! I want panties in a bag!'). HR 10.45pm, BBC OneThere might be a tear of pride in your eye while watching one of the best goalkeepers in the world tell her story – from 'being in pieces on the kitchen floor' after not making the England squad to a meeting with Sarina Wiegman that would lead to her helping the Lionesses become the 2022 European champions. It hits even harder given that she retired from international football in May. Jill Scott, Alessia Russo and Ella Toone chip in, too. HR Heads of State (Ilya Naishuller, 2025), Prime Video Strongly in the running for the most gleefully preposterous film of the decade, Heads of State is a movie about the American president and the British prime minister. What's preposterous is that they are respectively played by John Cena and Idris Elba. Even more preposterously, it's an action buddy comedy by Ilya Naishuller, the director of Nobody. Did the world need a film where the leaders of the western world are stranded in the middle of nowhere and have to machine-gun their way out in a whirlwind of quips? Absolutely not. But the most preposterous thing of all is that it somehow works. Stuart Heritage Football: Uefa Women's Euro 2025, Switzerland v Norway, 7pm, BBC One The opening match at St Jakob-Park in Basel, Switzerland.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Lions star owns up to bedroom blunder after arriving late to camp in Australia
Blair Kinghorn was the last member of the British and Irish Lions squad to arrive and as soon as he checked into the team hotel waltzed into his room and accidentally woke up Maro Itoje Blair Kinghorn got off the wrong foot when he arrived on the Lions tour by disrupting skipper Maro Itoje's beauty sleep in Brisbane. The Scotland full-back joined up with party late because was playing in Toulouse's epic 39-33 extra-time Top 14 final win over Bordeaux-Begles in Paris on Saturday night. Kinghorn partied all night with his teammates and families, then jumped on a midday flight to Dubai on Sunday, stopping there before flying on to Queensland. The new arrival got into Brisbane just before midnight and thought he had a single room as he blundered through the door only to find captain Itoje trying to sleep in bed. Kinghorn explained: 'I got in about quarter to 12. I was thinking 'surely there won't be anyone in the room'. I go in, chuck the bags down and up he pops. I was like 'uh, sorry'. He'd been sleeping and I woke him up. It was funny, he woke up, shook my hand and went straight back to sleep. I went straight from Paris because we went from Toulouse for the final on Thursday, so I had to make sure all my stuff was ready. 'Luckily my mum and my wife were there to help me take everything up because packing for two separate things is a bit stressful. I think I've got everything. All you need is your boots and your passport, so that's fine. 'It's good to finally be here and it feels a bit more real for me now. I'm actually here, I've got all the kit, I'm with the boys, it feels great.' Kinghorn might have been an unwelcome disturbance for Itoje but he is aiming to be a big noise on tour now he has finally arrived down under. The Scotsman's career has taken off since a mid-season switch to Toulouse from Edinburgh in December 2023 and he has won two Top 14 titles and a Champions Cup since the move. At Toulouse he rubs shoulders with French superstars like Antoine Dupont, Thomas Ramos, Romain Ntamack and Thibaud Flament. So, joining up with the best of British with the Lions is not hard for the 28-year-old who is used to training with the top players in the game. And he insists a two-month lay-off with a knee injury this season will work in his favour now he is on tour having peaked for the French final last weekend. He added: 'I was injured for eight weeks so this is fine. Getting injured is never good. You're sitting on the sidelines, not really involved in the rugby stuff but it is kind of refreshing for the brain. If you are not motivated to be here, then you shouldn't be here. It is not tough at all. 'Everyone's here to do their best and to win the Test series. Every training session is going to be competitive. Everyone's motivated and that brings the best out of people. At Toulouse, the squad is so deep and so talented that you've got to be on top of your game. It is high pressure.'
