‘The Sopranos' Creator David Chase Worried James Gandolfini ‘Wasn't Threatening Enough' Before Casting Him in Iconic Lead Role: ‘I Have One Concern'
In an excerpt from Jason Bailey's book 'Gandolfini: Jim, Tony, and the Life of a Legend' (via Vulture), Chase worried that Gandolfini wasn't 'threatening enough,' before ultimately casting him in the career-defining role.
More from Variety
'Industry' Producer Jane Tranter on How Late James Gandolfini Friendship Changed Her Career: 'First Time I Had Someone Who Was on My Side'
'Sopranos' Star Drea de Matteo on Joining OnlyFans, Coming Out as a MAGA Supporter and Why She Believes 'Half of Hollywood Is Voting for Trump'
'Sopranos' Star Lorraine Bracco Thought Divisive Ending Was 'Bad and Wrong': 'How Do You Invest 5 Years Into Someone's Life and Just Walk Away?'
During the show's development, Gandolfini's manager, Nancy Sanders, told Chase, 'I think I have Tony Soprano.' Chase wasn't immediately convinced.
Sanders stood up for her client, quickly quieting Chase's concerns, 'If you said to me, 'He's a little chubby,' or 'He's losing his hair,' I could understand. But he's threatening enough. This is your guy.'
'The Sopranos' casting directors, Sheila Jaffe and Georgianne Walken, echoed Sanders' enthusiasm. They remembered that Gandolfini 'was really our favorite idea from the beginning.'
Gandolfini himself wasn't confident that he would land the role of Tony Soprano. He recalled in the excerpt, 'I think my exact words were, 'I could kick this guy right in the ass, but I'll never get cast. They'll hire some fucking pretty boy.' I thought they'd hire, you know, one of these Irish-looking guys who are all over TV now.'
He also worried that Chase would be 'a pain in the ass' to work with. However, after the pair met for breakfast, all concerns melted away.
'When he finally settled down and really did a reading, it was just obvious,' Chase said.
'The Sopranos' is currently streaming on Max.
Best of Variety
New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week
What's Coming to Disney+ in May 2025
The Best Celebrity Memoirs to Read This Year: From Chelsea Handler to Anthony Hopkins
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
24 minutes ago
- New York Post
Darren Criss returning to Broadway's ‘Maybe Happy Ending' after casting backlash
Maybe it is a happy ending for this Broadway musical after all. 'Maybe Happy Ending' writers Will Aronson and Hue Park have announced that the show's original star, Darren Criss, will return to the lead robot role of Oliver this fall. 'This Model 3 is anything but retired,' the Tony-winning musical posted via Instagram on Wednesday. 'Darren Criss returns to Maybe Happy Ending on Broadway as Oliver beginning November 5th.' Advertisement 10 Helen J. Shen and Darren Criss in 'Maybe Happy Ending.' YouTube / Maybe Happy Ending the Musical 10 Helen J. Shen and Darren Criss bow on stage during the 'Maybe Happy Ending' Gala celebration at Belasco Theatre in New York City, November 11, 2024. Getty Images The news that Criss, 38, will return to 'Maybe Happy Ending' comes after the show's creators faced serious backlash for recasting the half-Filipino actor with Andrew Barth Feldman, who is not of Asian descent, last month. Advertisement Although Broadway insiders tell The Post that Criss was always scheduled to take a two-month leave of absence from the musical, and that Feldman was only cast to fill in for Criss for a nine-week limited engagement, there was still public outcry about the decision. Feldman is also married to Helen J. Shen, who plays the female lead Claire in 'Maybe Happy Ending.' 10 Helen J. Shen and Andrew Barth Feldman attend the 2025 Town Hall Spring Shout Benefit Concert at Town Hall in New York City on May 19, 2025. Getty Images 10 Andrew Barth Feldman and Helen J. Shen pose at the 2024 Tony Awards After Party hosted by Rick Miramontez and John Gore at the Carlyle Hotel in New York City on June 9, 2025. Bruce Giikas/WireImage Advertisement Playwright and actor BD Wong penned an open letter criticizing Aronson and Park's choice to temporarily replace Criss with a non-Asian actor, and the lengthy essay garnered more than 2,400 signatures. 'This deserves attention,' the 'M. Butterfly' star charged. 'To put it simply: Asian Actors and the Asian Theatergoing Community are fiercely wrestling over a non-Asian actor replacing the Asian male lead in the Broadway musical 'Maybe Happy Ending.'' 'Please google this responsibly,' Wong added. 'It's a real, eternal outcry about race and representation, not an irrational rant about robots.' 10 BD Wong attends 'Call Me Izzy' Broadway opening night at Studio 54 in New York City on June 12, 2025. Getty Images Advertisement Aronson and Park, who later responded to the backlash on Instagram, said that they were 'extremely saddened' that their show 'could ever become a source of confusion, anger or pain.' 'We would like to share some thoughts on the collective casting decision of Andrew Barth Feldman in Maybe Happy Ending,' the pair began. 'Our dream at the outset was that our allegorical robot show could one day miraculously become part of the American musical theater canon – a modern Fantasticks, able to be comfortably performed by anyone, anywhere – yet distinctly set in Korea,' they added. 'This went against prevailing wisdom that we needed to set our show in America.' 10 Darren Criss attends Macy's 4th of July fireworks at the Rooftop at Pier 17 in New York City on July 4, 2025. Getty Images for Macy's, Inc. 10 Darren Criss and the cast of 'Maybe Happy Ending' perform at the 2025 Tony Awards at Radio City Music Hall in New York City on June 8, 2025. CBS via Getty Images 'We're so grateful for the artists and audiences who've embraced this story, and we will continue our conversations as Maybe Happy Ending continues its journey onstage,' Aronson and Park concluded. But while countless Broadway fans were happy to learn that Criss will return to 'Maybe Happy Ending' later this year, some questioned whether it was only because of the ongoing casting backlash. 'So like… was this the plan all along?' one person asked. Advertisement 10 Darren Criss as Oliver in 'Maybe Happy Ending.' YouTube / Maybe Happy Ending the Musical 10 Darren Criss as Oliver in 'Maybe Happy Ending.' YouTube / Maybe Happy Ending the Musical 'So are you going to fire [Andrew Barth Feldman] or not?' commented another. 'I see y'all finally read the room,' wrote a third 'Maybe Happy Ending' fan, while yet another user added, 'Well, they learned their lesson.' Advertisement 'Maybe Happy Ending,' which premiered in Korea in 2016 before coming to Broadway last year, follows robots Oliver and Claire (Helen J. Shen) as they develop a connection in Seoul in the year 2060. 10 Darren Criss accepts the Best Actor in a Musical award for 'Maybe Happy Ending' during the 2025 Tony Awards at Radio City Music Hall in New York City on June 8, 2025. Getty Images for Tony Awards Productions Criss, who will have starred as Oliver from the beginning of the musical's Broadway run until his brief leave of absence starting Sept. 2, became the first Asian American to win a Tony for Best Actor in a Musical earlier this year. Advertisement 'What a night!' he began his acceptance speech on June 8. 'I have such immense pride to get to be part of this notably diverse and exquisite Broadway season this year.' 'Maybe Happy Ending' also went on to win Best Musical at the 2025 Tony Awards.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Horse Racing as a Metaphor for Life Explored in Sanfic Industria Title ‘The Curve'
Set in Montevideo, Uruguay, documentary 'The Curve' ('La curva') follows legendary horse trainer, 74-year-old Jorge Firpo, on the cusp of retirement as its director, Agustín Flores, reckons with the suicide of his father. What starts as an exploration of legacy turns into a moving treatise on emotional fragility, resilience and the drive we need to keep pushing on. More from Variety 'Puan' Co-Helmer Benjamín Nashtat, Composer Santiago Dolan Board Sanfic Industria WIP Title 'Bagman' The Dominican Republic Targets a Co-Production Axis With Chile Record Number of Submissions for Sanfic's Santiago Lab, as Chilean Project Market Builds International Profile 'We live in a system that constantly forces us to compete. When we are no longer functional, the same machinery discards us,' mused Flores, adding: ' 'The Curve' is a documentary about the cycle of life in a unique, highly competitive context where animals are the center and people trade illusions. Leaving the track is inevitable; it will happen to all of us. The question is: in what way is life worth living before that happens? Life without passion has no meaning.' Project participating in Sanfic Industria's WIP section has an impressive development trajectory. It was a Spotlighted Project at the Marché du Film 2025, won the Cannes Docs Award at Ventana Sur 2024, the DocsBarcelona Industry Award at VS 2024 and the DocCo Award at VS 2024, among others. It also received an official mention in the WIP Documentaries in Progress section at Atlantidoc 2024. This is Flores' second feature documentary. He admits that he barely got any distribution for his debut doc, 'The Forgotten' ('Los Olvidados') in 2018. 'But I was inexperienced. I'm working to internationalize 'The Curve' before it's ready to be screened and I expect to get better results,' he said, adding that he hopes to work with streaming services, whether global, regional or local. According to Flores, 'The Curve' refers to a very specific area in Montevideo around the racetrack. 'For me, 'The Curve' is a metaphor for life. The machine is ruthless and discards us when we are no longer functional parts. We are all running this race,' he said. 'The grief over my father's suicide becomes an invisible engine driving this story. As the camera explores Jorge's life and legacy, it also reveals my internal struggle to find meaning amid the pain. Both stories intertwine in a shared quest: how to face the frustrations that throw us off course and find the strength to keep moving forward, even when everything seems lost,' he explained. 'The Curve' is produced by Raquel Ferreiro of Trapecista Prods., founded in Montevideo in 2018, which has produced documentary features and experimental videos. It produced 'The Forgotten,' which premiered in cinemas and is now available online at The documentary is co-produced by Spain's Zona Cielo Films and Insumisa Films. Madrid-based Zona Cielo Films, founded by Guzmán Infanzón y Valentina Ferreira, has produced documentaries, music videos and collaborates with art musuems and galleries, among others. Insumisa Films, based in Barcelona, has co-produced 'La fabula de la tortuga y la flor' with Uruguay's Monarca Films and 'Criollos' with Argentina's Dim Films and has several others in development. Best of Variety New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week 'Harry Potter' TV Show Cast Guide: Who's Who in Hogwarts? What's Coming to Disney+ in August 2025
Business Insider
2 hours ago
- Business Insider
Helen Mirren went from criticizing Netflix to starring in one of the streamer's new movies
Standing in front of thousands of movie theater owners and executives at CinemaCon in Las Vegas in 2019, Dame Helen Mirren uttered two words that were met with thunderous applause. "Fuck Netflix!" Six years later, weeks away from starring in the Netflix original movie, " The Thursday Murder Club," the 80-year-old actor emits a wry laugh when reminded of her explosive proclamation. "Before saying that I did say, 'I love Netflix,'" Mirren told Business Insider over the phone. (She's right: her full comment was, "I love Netflix, but fuck Netflix!") That quote, she added, was specifically about how the rise of streaming has threatened the existence of the communal moviegoing experience. "Many generations of people enjoy the process of going to the cinema and crying or laughing around strangers. That is a special experience. So my words, it was really related to that." Mirren said. "And I have to say, Ted Sarandos was understanding in what I meant." The Oscar, Tony, and Emmy winner didn't have to be dragged kicking and screaming into a project on the streamer, either. As a fan of the Richard Osman book series of the same name, which follows a group of amateur detectives solving cold cases in an English retirement home, Mirren thought she would be a good fit to play the Thursday Murder Club's no-nonsense ex-spy Elizabeth Best, who's one of the club's founders. "In the back of my mind while reading, I did wonder, 'Will they ever make these into a movie? Because I would love to play this role,'" Mirren said. Mirren got her chance. The resulting film is an entertaining whodunit in which Mirren leads an ensemble cast stacked with talented actors, from Pierce Brosnan, Ben Kingsley, and Celia Imrie to Jonathan Pryce, David Tennant, Richard E. Grant, and Naomi Ackie. Being a fan of the source material came with its own pressure to embody the character right. "With a book that's so popular, there is a responsibility because you don't want to disappoint people who love it," Mirren said. "I don't want people watching the movie and going, 'I loved it, but I didn't think Helen Mirren was great as Elizabeth.'" If the pressure from fans seems minor compared to the responsibility of playing the Queen of England — Mirren won an Oscar playing Queen Elizabeth in the 2006 drama "The Queen" — well, Mirren disagrees. "In a weird way, it's harder to play the imaginary character, especially if it's a character from a beloved book. With the Queen, you just have to sound like the Queen, walk like her, dress like her," she said. "With Elizabeth, from costuming forward, everything you do, you have to engage in other people's imagination of what they think she would look and act like. That was a challenge to get that right. " That said, Mirren is happy with her performance and experience on the film, and is open to doing another "Thursday Murder Club" installment if the ensemble returns. She also is setting her sights on returning to another medium: the stage. "I didn't want to about a year ago, but now, I love going to the theater. Every time I go, I have a yearning to be back on stage," Mirren said. So what changed? "This goes back to what I said about Netflix — the communal experience of theater is a very special experience," she continued. "If it's a great play and brilliantly performed, there's nothing quite like that experience as an audience." In the meantime, you can enjoy "The Thursday Murder Club" from your couch.
