Why was a superinjunction put on the Afghan evacuation story and what did it do?
The term 'superinjunction' may be familiar to people who paid attention to the news in the 2010s, thanks to their deployment by several high-profile figures who wanted to stop people reading about their private lives.
It is a court order a step above an injunction, which is used to stop details of the case being published in public.
In a case with a superinjunction, not even the existence of the injunction can be made public.
These orders are powerful enough when used by an individual. The use of one by the government to keep the entire UK in the dark is unprecedented.
Hundreds of thousands of pounds of taxpayers' money was spent without the public's knowledge, to bring a large number of individuals to the UK from Afghanistan without anyone being allowed to learn why.
Craig Munro breaks down Westminster chaos into easy to follow insight, walking you through what the latest policies mean to you. Sent every Wednesday. Sign up here.
It all stemmed from an accidental data breach in February 2022, which exposed the personal details of more than 18,000 Afghans who had assisted British forces in their fight against the Taliban.
When the government learned about this breach 18 months after it happened, then-Defence Secretary Ben Wallace requested an injunction in the courts.
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
The reason for this, according to court documents, was to 'preserve the confidentiality of the personal information for as long as possible in order that His Majesty's Government may do everything it reasonably can to help those who might have been put at further risk by the data compromise'.
But when the time came for the injunction to be placed, Judge Robin Knowles decided to go a step further. More Trending
He wrote: 'I conclude that it is an environment of no publication that best protects lives, although again the matter must and will be kept under constant review.'
This decision was made for eight reasons listed in the judgement: 'The risk in question is to the lives of many individuals and their families, and of torture.'
The confidentiality of the data was not completely lost, though it had been breached.
The order would create a period of time where the data compromise is 'not known or widely known'.
It would be less likely for the information to fall into the wrong hands during that period.
The period would provide an opportunity for the government to do 'everything it reasonably can' to help those at risk.
The impact on freedom of expression was 'justified in the particular and exceptional circumstances of this case'.
The fact the injunction would probably no longer be needed at some point and be lifted would limit that impact.
The operation and duration of the injunction would be kept under close review.
This order was so stringent, then-shadow Defence Secretary John Healey did not tell his party leader about the situation when he was briefed before last year's election.
Instead, Sir Keir Starmer learned about it after he became Prime Minister.
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: What changes in ISAs could mean for you and where you should invest
MORE: Middle class parties hit by lumpy skin disease
MORE: What changes to mortgages for first-time buyers means for you
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
42 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Brit 'tried to drown' daughter-in-law on family holiday after row over will
Jasmine Wyld, 33, is said to have been locked in a violent row with father-in-law Mark Gibbon, 62, about his will during a luxury holiday near Disney World in Florida This is the first picture of the young British hairdresser whose father-in-law allegedly attempted to drown her in a swimming pool near Disney World in Florida. Jasmine Wyld, 33, reportedly feared for her life after it is said she became involved in a furious argument with Mark Gibbon, 62, regarding his will during a luxury holiday break. It is alleged Gibbon, who operates a film and television lighting business Ultralight in Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, shoved and forced Ms Wyld's head beneath the water in the pool on multiple occasions. Local law enforcement said in a statement: "Because Mr Gibbon couldn't control his anger, he may find himself spending a lot more time in Florida than he had anticipated." He has now been charged with attempted second-degree murder and battery by police in the US, where the family had been residing at a rental property at the Solterra Resort in Davenport, Florida. The grandfather is being detained at Polk County Jail. Ms Wyld has two children with Gibbon's son, Alex, who had previously been employed alongside his father at the film and television lighting business. He stepped down as director in April 2023, reports the Mirror. Gibbon Snr has subsequently rebranded the company as MRG Lighting. He is registered as the sole director. Facebook photographs show Ms Wyld, a hairdresser from Buckinghamshire, beaming alongside Alex and their two children. Companies House records reveal she was formerly a director of Jasmine Elizabeth Hair, but the business was dissolved "via a voluntary strike off" in April 2024. When approached by the Daily Mail on Wednesday, Ms Wyld reportedly refused to comment about her father-in-law's arrest. Police had rushed to reports of a disturbance in a back-garden swimming pool at approximately 5.20pm local time at the Solterra Resort on Sunday. According to the Polk County Sheriff's Office, Gibbon had become embroiled in a row with Ms Wyld regarding the "stipulations of his will". Deputies recorded: "She advised that she could not breathe and believed that she was going to drown. [The victim] advised that she had to fight Mark in order to get away from him and from under the water but he kept pushing her back under." MRG Lighting, which belongs to Gibbon, has previously carried out work on television and film productions, as well as on music videos for artists including Paloma Faith. The father, from Beaconsfield, is also registered as the sole director of Sage Hairdressing. Gibbon and his daughter-in-law had been consuming alcohol prior to the confrontation, reports Law and Crime. Ms Wyld's nine year old daughter leapt into the pool in an attempt to halt the incident, police revealed. Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd commented: "It's great that Polk County draws visitors from all across the world, but we expect vacationers to behave while they visit with us, just as we expect our lifelong residents to do the same. Because Mr Gibbon couldn't control his anger, he may find himself spending a lot more time in Florida than he had anticipated."
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Angela Rayner calls on China to explain redacted images in super-embassy plans
The Deputy Prime Minister, who as Housing Secretary is responsible for overseeing planning matters, has given Beijing two weeks to explain why areas of its plans for the sprawling new embassy site in central London are blacked out. China hawks in Westminster have raised alarm that the embassy site could be used to conduct surveillance from British soil. Pro-democracy campaigners from Hong Kong, as well as Uighurs and Tibetans, meanwhile, fear that intimidation and reprisals from the Chinese state could result from the embassy going ahead. This follows reports that bounties have been issued by China for dissident Hong Kongers now living in the UK. Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner is also Housing Secretary (Peter Byrne/PA) In a letter seen by the PA news agency, Ms Rayner's Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government asks planning consultants representing the Chinese embassy to explain why drawings of the planned site are blacked out. The letter gives two weeks, until August 20, for an explanation to be provided. It also suggests that a final planning decision on the embassy site, at Royal Mint Court, just east of London's financial district, will be made by September 9. Copies of the letter were also sent to the Home Office and the Foreign Office by email. It notes that the Home Office requested a new 'hard perimeter' be placed around the embassy site, to prevent 'unregulated public access', and acknowledges this could require a further planning application. Plans for the super-embassy were previously rejected by Tower Hamlets Council in 2022, with the Chinese opting not to appeal. However, Beijing resubmitted the application a fortnight after Sir Keir Starmer's election victory last year, believing Labour may be more receptive to the application. Since entering office Sir Keir's Government has sought closer links with Beijing after a cooling during the final years of Conservative Party rule. The final decision will be made by Mr Rayner in her role as Housing Secretary. Alicia Kearns, the shadow national security minister, said: 'No surprises here – Labour's rush to appease Xi Jinping's demands for a new embassy demonstrated a complacency when it came to keeping our people safe. Having deluded themselves for so long, they've recognised we were right to be vigilant. 'The disturbing bounty notes urging British citizens to kidnap and deliver their Hong Kong neighbours to the current CCP embassy laid bare the risks – yet the Foreign Secretary didn't even summon the Chinese ambassador in the face of direct threats to those seeking refuge in our country. 'CCP ambitions for a larger embassy would only amplify opportunities for espionage and transnational repression.'
Powys County Times
an hour ago
- Powys County Times
British man charged with attempted drowning of daughter-in-law on US holiday
A British man has been charged by US police with the attempted murder of his daughter-in-law after allegedly trying to drown her in a swimming pool while on holiday, local authorities said. Mark Raymond Gibbon, 62, of Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, allegedly tried to drown the 33-year-old woman after they argued about his grandchildren in their rental home at the Solterra Resort in Davenport, Florida, on Sunday, Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd said on X. Officers had responded to reports of a disturbance in a back-yard swimming pool at around 5.20pm local time. Gibbon allegedly pushed and held the victim's head under water multiple times which prevented her from breathing, Mr Judd said. He allegedly only stopped after holidaymakers next door said they had called the sheriff's office, while the victim's nine-year-old daughter jumped into the pool to try to stop the incident, the sheriff said. Gibbon was arrested and taken to Polk County Jail before he was charged with attempted second-degree murder and battery, Mr Judd said. The sheriff said in a statement: 'It's great that Polk County draws visitors from all across the world, but we expect vacationers to behave while they visit with us, just as we expect our lifelong residents to do the same. 'Because Mr Gibbon couldn't control his anger, he may find himself spending a lot more time in Florida than he had anticipated.'
