Sixteen states sue White House over healthcare access for transgender youth
The Democratic attorneys general of California, New York, Massachusetts, Illinois and Connecticut are leading the lawsuit, announced on Friday, which challenges the president's efforts to eradicate vital medical treatments for trans youth.
The complaint targets one of the president's first executive orders issued in January, which described puberty blockers and hormone therapy as 'chemical and surgical mutilation', called for federal funds to be withheld from hospitals that provide the treatments and suggested the US Department of Justice could investigate doctors. Those gender-affirming treatments, which are accessed by a small fraction of youth in the US, have for years been the standard of care endorsed by major US medical associations.
Under intensifying threats that hospitals could lose federal funding, and growing fears that providers could be criminally prosecuted, a number of major institutions have abruptly ended gender-affirming care for trans youth.
The crackdown has sent families scrambling for alternatives, including in blue states long considered sanctuaries for LGBTQ+ rights, where clinics and lawmakers had previously assured youth they would be shielded from Donald Trump's agenda.
Last month, Children's Hospital Los Angeles, one of the nation's largest and most prominent institutions to serve trans kids, shuttered its gender-affirming care center for youth after three decades, citing funding threats from across the federal government.
Other institutions that have recently pulled back gender-affirming care services for trans youth include Phoenix Children's Hospital in Arizona, Stanford Medicine, Denver Health, the University of Chicago, the University of Pennsylvania and Children's National Hospital in Washington DC. Some have ceased surgeries for patients under age 19, which are rare, while others have also ended hormone therapy and puberty blockers.
The justice department in July also announced that it had sent subpoenas to more than 20 doctors and clinics that provide gender-affirming care to youth, a move that sent shock waves among providers and raised alarms that patients' information could be shared with the federal government.
The suit notes the administration has already launched criminal investigations and explicitly threatened providers in California, Colorado and Massachusetts and that officials have 'demanded extensive data, including patient medical records'.
The blue states are also challenging a June memo from Brett Shumate, assistant US attorney general, which directed the justice department's civil division to 'use all available resources to prioritize investigations of doctors, hospitals, pharmaceutical companies and other appropriate entities' that provide gender-affirming care.
Republican lawmakers in more than 25 states have moved to restrict trans youth healthcare in recent years. But the treatments remain legal in other parts of the country, and states such as California have anti-discrimination laws that explicitly protect the services.
The plaintiffs argue that Trump's actions should be declared unlawful, alleging his order exceeds federal authority. California's attorney general, Rob Bonta, also challenged Trump's definition of children as people under the age of 19, affecting 18-year-old adults' access to care, saying the administration's directives force hospitals to violate state laws.
Bonta said denying this care has been shown to worsen mental health outcomes, including increased rates of depression, anxiety and suicidal ideation. 'Trump and Bondi are not trained medical professionals. They aren't at all qualified to give anyone medical advice. What's worse, they refuse to listen to the actual experts,' he said at a press conference.
Sign up to This Week in Trumpland
A deep dive into the policies, controversies and oddities surrounding the Trump administration
after newsletter promotion
Citing comments from one parent of a trans child treated at a center that is shutting down, Bonta said: 'This closure will be life and death for trans youth who can no longer get the care they need.'
'What would you do if your child was diagnosed with gender dysphoria? I would fight for my kid every single day,' added William Tong, the Connecticut attorney general. 'We're fighting for … parents who just want to do the best for their kids, as we all do, to help them live their best and truest lives.'
Joining the lawsuit are the attorneys general of Delaware, Hawaii, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, Rhode Island and Wisconsin, along with the District of Columbia and the Pennsylvania governor.
The White House and justice department have been contacted for comment.
The suit comes after the US supreme court upheld Tennessee's ban on trans youth healthcare.
'Hormone therapy truly saves lives,' said Eli, a trans 16-year-old who lost his healthcare in Los Angeles, in a recent Guardian interview. 'I wish people understood they're doing so much more harm than they could possibly imagine – that so many lives will be hurt and lost and so many people torn apart.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
2 minutes ago
- The Independent
Trump administration wants to end abortion coverage through Veterans Affairs
President Donald Trump 's administration is calling to remove abortion coverage from the list of medical benefits for veterans and their families, saying it's not needed. The Department of Veterans Affairs posted the proposed rule change on Monday and opened a public comment period on it that runs through Sept. 3. The department said in its proposal that it wants to ensure it 'provides only needed medical services to our nation's heroes and their families.' The department says it would still provide abortion in life-threatening circumstances — something state laws allow, even in places where bans are in place. But critics of the change note that abortion would not be provided when pregnancies are the result of rape or incest. Amy Friedrich-Karnik, director of federal policy at the Guttmacher Institute, said in a statement that the change would cut off millions of veterans and their families from services. 'Veterans have historically faced significant barriers to reproductive health care, and with the current patchwork of abortion bans and restrictions across the country, these barriers are even steeper today," she said. Veterans Affairs, which provides health coverage for veterans and their dependents, did not include abortion in its coverage until 2022. President Joe Biden 's administration added it months after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade and state abortion bans began kicking in. The Biden changed allowed the VA to provide abortion even in states where it was banned. The VA says in its proposal that allowing abortion is legally questionable because Congress has not specifically allowed it. The policy change would also bring the VA's coverage into line with other federal health care plans — including Medicaid and the TriCare coverage for active military members and their families — which exclude abortion in most cases. The VA said in its filings that about 100 veterans and 40 dependents obtain abortions using the benefits each year — far below the projection the department made in 2022 of a total of 1,000 a year. The conservative law firm Alliance Defending Freedom called on the VA to drop abortion coverage in a letter last month, saying the cost or providing abortion takes other health resources away from veterans.
Telegraph
3 minutes ago
- Telegraph
How to get skin like Martha Stewart at 84
It's no secret that Martha Stewart is something of a perfectionist. So is it any surprise that the veteran hostess with the mostess has aged so beautifully, her taut, glowing skin especially noteworthy? Thankfully, she's never been a gatekeeper when it comes to sharing her tips and tricks, and now she's revealed her first ever skincare range, Elm Biosciences, available from September. Announcing the news on Instagram, she wrote: 'After five years of working behind the scenes, hundreds of prototypes, and endless hours of research – we can't wait to finally share with you all.' Created alongside her long-time dermatologist, Dr Dhaval Bhanusali (the same doctor who helped to develop Hailey Bieber's $1bn beauty brand, Rhode), the new launch will consist of just two products to begin with: The A3O Elemental Serum ($135), a patent-pending antioxidant serum that targets visible signs of ageing, including UV damage, pigmentation, dehydration and irritation, and the Inner Dose Daily Skin Supplement ($50), a dermatologist-formulated capsule that addresses internal triggers of ageing, including inflammation, oxidative stress and hormonal imbalance. Celebrity and influencer-backed beauty brands are enjoying something of a vogue at the moment, with Rhode being just the most recent success story. Yet with the founders often being women in their 20s and 30s, there's been a glaring gap in the beauty space for a skincare line specifically for elderly skin needs. In this way, it's certainly an astute move for Stewart to be launching her own niche beauty brand, which will no doubt stand out from the crowd. 'From as early as your mid 20s onwards you are losing collagen,' shares skin expert Dr Christine Hall. 'Some studies estimate as much as 1 per cent per year. Production rates decrease and what you have is broken down more quickly. By the time you reach your mid 40s it becomes noticeable, and by your 80s you will have lost a significant amount – but you will also be losing elastin and hyaluronic acid. 'Skin cell turnover, sebum production and blood flow to your skin will be reduced, and post-menopausal oestrogen levels will drop. Together, these are the main drivers in the ageing process, and by your 80s skin can be more sensitive, it may appear dry, thin and pale, and the visible signs of ageing will be apparent – think lines and wrinkles, volume loss, patches of pigmentation and loss of elasticity.' Here, we reveal the skincare wisdom Martha Stewart has offered over the years. Skip to: Daily face masks Stewart has been a long term fan of the hydrating benefits of a great face mask, telling Into The Gloss in 2015 that she would apply one as soon as she woke up in the morning before her shower (her favourites included the Yon-Ka Gommage 305, the Mario Badescu Super Collagen Mask and the Mario Badescu Azulene Calming Mask). Mario Badescu Super Collagen Mask, £20, Space NK Mario Badescu Azulene Calming Mask, £20, Speaking to Vogue earlier this year, Dr Bhanusali revealed that he has created custom-made special formula sheet masks for his client too. Never forget your SPF According to Dr Bhanusali, Stewart mixes her SPF (she is a fan of the Alastin HydraTint Pro Mineral Broad Spectrum Sunscreen SPF 36) in with her moisturiser, and applies it liberally to not only her face but also her neck, décolleté, body and even her ear lobes. She also revealed to Into The Gloss that she is a fan of La Roche-Posay Anthelios: 'I found it one time in St. Barth's many, many years ago, and I've been using it ever since because it's French.' Alastin HydraTint Pro Mineral Broad Spectrum Sunscreen SPF 36, $79 (£60), La Roche-Posay Anthelios, £16, Boots Stewart has also always been a champion of wide-brimmed hats to protect her skin from sun damage. 'At this stage of life, routine dermatological screening is just as important as a good skincare routine,' shares Dr Mariana Noy. 'Skin cancers often present subtly in older adults, and early detection can make a critical difference.' Modest use of tweakments Stewart defers to her aesthetics doctor, Dr Belkin, when it comes to tweakments, relying on his expertise to know what's best. According to Vogue, this includes the use of non-ablative fractionated lasers, which stimulate skin-cell turnover and reduce signs of sun damage. She's also tried energy-based therapies, including Ulthera and SofWave, to help lift, firm and tighten the skin. 'Non-invasive treatments like radiofrequency can help stimulate collagen in older skin without the downtime or risk associated with more invasive procedures,' explains Dr Noy. 'These are ideal options for patients seeking subtle, safe improvements.' And while she doesn't have Botox on her forehead after disliking how it makes her eyebrows look, she does have it on her jawline and neck, as she revealed during an episode of her podcast last year. According to Dr Belkin, Botox here reduces the banding on the neck and the downward pull on the face. The duo also do a little conservative filler on Stewart, mostly in the jaw and cheeks, to add plumpness where the skin typically looks hollow as we age. Invest in bespoke skincare As someone who spends the majority of her time outside in her garden and on her farm, sun damage is a key concern for Stewart. Dr. Bhanusali mixes a custom-made serum for Stewart, after consulting with the Visia-CR skin analysis machine to check photodamage and wrinkles. It seems likely that the new Elm Biosciences serum is a variation on this. 'Older skin is often more fragile, and tolerance to active ingredients like retinoids or exfoliants varies widely,' explains Dr Noy. 'Bespoke formulations, such as those offered by dermatology-led services and compounded specifically for the patient, are especially useful for tailoring care to individual needs.' At the Montrose clinic in Belgravia, Dr Noy offers this bespoke service via the dermatologist-founded skincare brand Klira. Keep everything clean Stewart likes to apply her skincare and make-up with her fingers ('sponges soak up all the product!' she told Allure in 2021), ensuring that they are thoroughly clean beforehand. She also transports everything in a small Muji travel toiletry bag, so that all her products are as uncontaminated as possible from the elements. She's also a firm adherent to the rule that you must remove your make-up before bed, telling Into The Gloss that she uses Johnson's Baby Oil and a warm wash cloth to do so. Muji travel toiletry bag, £6.95, Muji Johnson's Baby Oil, £1.50, Boots Beautiful skin starts from within With organic fruit and vegetables grown on her farm, Stewart has undoubtedly got a pretty faultless diet. Her other non-negotiable? A daily green juice, which always includes ingredients such as celery, cucumber, parsley, spinach, mint, ginger, pear and orange (including the rind).
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Covid cases rising in US as officials plan to restrict booster vaccines
Covid is on the rise again in the US, as children begin returning to school and as officials plan to restrict booster shots. While cases are increasing less quickly than at the start of other surges, it is too soon to tell how big the current late-summer wave could get – and with highly varied immune responses from prior infections and vaccinations, it is difficult to know how severe illness could be, experts said. The risks of a wave are compounded by new vaccine restrictions from the Trump administration. 'If you're vaccinated against Covid-19, you're less likely to get infected,' said Andrew Pekosz, a virologist at Johns Hopkins University. 'But we haven't gotten a lot of people vaccinated for the past few years, and with the current recommendations changing, it's even less likely.' Future waves could become more severe as vaccination lags and immunity drops, Pekosz said. Several key measurements – including wastewater data, test positivity and emergency room visits – indicate a new rise in infections. In the past, Covid has surged about twice a year, usually in the summer and the winter. But the pattern can change, as it does with other respiratory viruses – with late or early starts to the season and curveballs like double peaks. 'Each year has been different, so in some ways, this is more of the same,' said Sam Scarpino, a professor of health sciences at Northeastern University. Cases are increasing or probably increasing in 26 US states, especially in the south and midwest, according to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). 'In the snapshot that we're seeing right now, increases are happening at a relatively low rate, and that would indicate that we probably aren't going to peak at a very high level. But again, this is early in this summer surge, so we really have to keep monitoring the data and paying attention to what it's telling us,' Pekosz said. The variants currently spreading around the globe have known immune-evasion properties, Scarpino said. 'You can look at the rise that we're seeing, the fact that we know it's an immune-escape variant, and I think we can be pretty confident that there's some kind of wave coming,' Scarpino said. 'Whether it's going to be large or small, I don't think we could really say one way or the other.' But 'the vaccines are still providing some protection,' he said. 'It's never too late to get the booster.' Yet officials softened the recommendation for children on Covid vaccines, and they removed the suggestion entirely for pregnant people, despite the clear benefits of the shot in reducing the risk of severe illness and death during pregnancy. A new, more effective Covid shot from Moderna and the Covid shot from Novavax were approved only for people over 65 or people over the age of 12 with health conditions. The independent advisers to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recommended that vaccine manufacturers once again update booster shots this fall to a more recent variant. Covid boosters are usually recommended for all adults. But this fall, the boosters may be limited to older people and those with health conditions, FDA officials wrote in May. 'So it's a big question mark, going into the fall, is who it's going to be approved for,' Scarpino said. 'If it's not approved, can you still pay out of pocket for it? How much is it going to cost? And then are there going to be supply chain issues?' Health officials have also called for placebo trials for the boosters to judge their benefit to people without pre-existing conditions – but such trials would be unethical and extremely difficult to conduct, experts say. 'Clearly, the guidelines right now are focused on the populations that are more prone to have severe disease and severe outcomes. It's always been good to vaccinate that population,' Pekosz said. But the Trump administration is moving away from the approach of immunizing broad swaths of the population – especially those most likely to get and pass the virus on, like children, he said. 'If you vaccinate broadly, you can reduce the spread of Covid-19 in the population,' Pekosz said. 'The benefit, to me, is very clearly on the side of getting vaccinated.' Some of the pre-existing conditions proposed by FDA officials include asthma, diabetes, depression and physical inactivity. According to that list, 'basically everybody's eligible for one of the vaccines,' Scarpino said. And doctors, including pediatricians, may also prescribe vaccines for off-label use. Yet the more restrictions are placed on vaccination, the harder it is to reach even the people who need it most, Pekosz noted. Antivirals like Paxlovid could also see wider use, the experts said. 'We shouldn't forget about the antivirals,' Pekosz said. 'Those don't seem to be the target of more restrictive use by the CDC or the FDA, so those will be available for people if they do get infected.' A program to make Paxlovid more affordable to those who need it is slated to end in December. 'The benefits of antiviral treatment are very clear with respect to hospitalization and mortality decreases,' Pekosz said. Paxlovid is still highly effective against current variants, Scarpino said. 'There's a whole bunch of good reasons to get it.' Rates of hospitalizations and deaths in recent waves have dropped among adults compared with earlier Covid waves, but the virus remains deadly. An estimated 35,000 to 54,000 people in the US have died of Covid since October. Children continue to see hospitalizations rates from Covid similar to previous years. Covid cases can be less severe because of immunity – from prior infection or from vaccination. 'It's not so much that the virus has become less dangerous, it's that we have immunity, so we fight off the virus more efficiently than we did early in the pandemic,' Pekosz said. That's why vaccinations remain a key part of controlling Covid, he said. Without boosters, people become more susceptible to severe illness and death. About 23% of adults had received updated Covid boosters as of April. About 5.6% of children aged six months to four years are vaccinated against Covid, and about 15% of children aged five to 17 are vaccinated, according to the CDC. 'Children's cases are always surging, because children don't have much immunity to Covid,' Pekosz said. 'Covid cases are really occurring in children at a very high level right now. It's not nearly as dangerous in children as it is in adults, but it still causes a lot of hospitalizations in children.' Hospitalizations and deaths are not the only ways to measure the damage and disruption wrought by Covid. While the Trump administration has not released updated data on long Covid, an estimated 5.3% of all adults in the US said they were currently experiencing long-term Covid symptoms as of September. Even in times of lower transmission, Covid still circulates, with 149 deaths in the week ending 28 June, the last week for which the CDC shares full mortality data. 'It's still a little surprising that it's around all year,' said Pekosz. During lull times, 'we're not seeing it disappear completely, like we do with other respiratory viruses.' When it comes to keeping rates of Covid low, 'it's all the same stuff we usually go over,' Pekosz said – getting vaccinated, taking precautions like masking and using air purifiers, and staying home if you're sick. 'But it's just a very different environment these days. When the government doesn't use the science to drive their decision making, you can see the confusion that it puts into the general public.'
