logo
Mexico election: Indigenous lawyer Hugo Aguilar leads race for chief justice

Mexico election: Indigenous lawyer Hugo Aguilar leads race for chief justice

BBC News04-06-2025
An indigenous lawyer, Hugo Aguilar, looks set to become Mexico's new chief justice following Sunday's ground-breaking judicial election.Mexicans were asked to choose the country's entire judiciary by direct ballot for the first time after a radical reform introduced by the governing Morena party.With almost all the votes for the Supreme Court counted, Mr Aguilar was in the lead for the top post.President Claudia Sheinbaum declared the elections a success, even though turnout was low at around 13%.
Electoral authorities said Mr Aguilar, who is a member of the Mixtec indigenous group, was ahead of Lenia Batres, the candidate who had the backing of the governing Morena party. Hugo Aguilar has long campaigned for the rights of Mexico's indigenous groups, which make up almost 20% of the population according to the 2020 census in which people were asked how the identified themselves. For the past seven years, the 51-year-old constitutional law expert has served as the rights co-ordinator for the National Institute of Indigenous Peoples (INPI).He was also a legal advisor to the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN) - an indigenous guerrilla group which staged a short-lived uprising in southern Chiapas state in 1994 - during the EZLN's negotiations with the government in 1996.During his campaign for the post of chief justice he had said that it was "the turn of the indigenous and Afro-Mexican peoples to take a seat in the Supreme Court", accusing the highest court of being stuck in the past and wedded to "principles which don't drive real change for the people".
Candidates with links to the governing Morena party look set to win the majority of the remaining eight posts on the Supreme Court, according to early results.Critics of the judicial reform which led to the direct election of all the country's judges say the dominance of the governing party is undermining the judiciary's independence.Those who backed the reform argued that it would make the judiciary more democratic and beholden to voters.However, the turnout was the lowest in any federal vote held in Mexico, suggesting that there was little enthusiasm among voters for choosing members of the judiciary directly.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Canadian PM Carney planning to visit Mexico in September, says source
Canadian PM Carney planning to visit Mexico in September, says source

Reuters

time2 days ago

  • Reuters

Canadian PM Carney planning to visit Mexico in September, says source

Aug 15 (Reuters) - Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney is planning to visit Mexico on September 18 to meet with President Claudia Sheinbaum and discuss closer ties amid U.S. tariffs, a person familiar with the matter said on Friday. The source said the exact date had yet to be formally confirmed. The news was first reported by Bloomberg. Reuters reported earlier this month that Carney was scrambling to save ties with Mexico after Canadian officials suggested last year that Ottawa would be better off negotiating a bilateral trade deal with the United States.

Mexico's Sheinbaum says former Pemex CEO arrested in US, to be deported
Mexico's Sheinbaum says former Pemex CEO arrested in US, to be deported

Reuters

time3 days ago

  • Reuters

Mexico's Sheinbaum says former Pemex CEO arrested in US, to be deported

MEXICO CITY, Aug 14 (Reuters) - Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum said on Thursday that Carlos Trevino, former CEO of state oil company Pemex, had been arrested in the United States and would be deported to stand trial in Mexico for corruption charges. Trevino served as CEO of Pemex from 2017 to 2018, stepping down after former President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador took office. Speaking at her daily press conference, Sheinbaum said Trevino would face prosecution for alleged acts of corruption during his tenure.

Sheinbaum's expulsion of criminals is more about placating Trump than keeping Mexico safe
Sheinbaum's expulsion of criminals is more about placating Trump than keeping Mexico safe

The Guardian

time3 days ago

  • The Guardian

Sheinbaum's expulsion of criminals is more about placating Trump than keeping Mexico safe

Mexico's president, Claudia Sheinbaum, has denied that the transfer of 26 alleged cartel members to the United States was part of any kind of deal with Washington and was instead about her country's own security priorities. This week's expulsion marked the second time Mexico had sent top criminals to the US this year: in February, Mexican authorities handed over 29 cartel members, including druglord Rafael Caro Quintero, who was responsible for the murder of a DEA agent in 1985. The latest transfers took place after US authorities vowed that prosecutors would not seek the death penalty in any of the cases. But despite the claims from Sheinbaum and others in her government, analysts say these transfers are less about Mexico's national security and more about appeasing Donald Trump, who has made going after drug cartels a hallmark policy of his administration – even going so far as to designate several Mexican criminal groups as foreign terrorist organizations. 'I think [Sheinbaum] believes she can depressurize by sending a bunch of narcs that are already in custody … as an offering to placate Washington's thirst for Mexican criminals,' said Tony Payan, a Mexico expert at Rice University's Baker Institute for Public Policy. 'They're simply being put on a plane and offered on a silver platter.' Sheinbaum said that the expulsion of 26 criminals from organized crime groups including the Jalisco New Generation and Sinaloa cartels was unrelated to efforts to reach a new security agreement with the United States. Among those handed over to US authorities were Abigael González Valencia, a leader of 'Los Cuinis', a criminal group closely allied with the Jalisco cartel, as well as Roberto Salazar, wanted in connection with the slaying of a Los Angeles county sheriff's deputy in 2008. 'In all of these cases, the extradition or the transfer of these members of organized crime, the decision is for the safety of our country,' she said during a news conference on Wednesday. 'Nor do they have anything to do with the security agreement; they are sovereign decisions taken for the security of our country.' Security minister Omar García Harfuch echoed her comments, saying the move had been taken to stop convicted criminals from continuing to run their organizations from behind bars. 'This action was taken to prevent the continued ordering of kidnappings, extortion, homicides, and other crimes from prison,' he said. Sheinbaum has taken numerous other actions to crack down on drug trafficking in an effort to appease the Trump administration, including deploying thousands of troops to the state of Sinaloa, a cartel stronghold, arresting dozens of top-level narcos and seizing large quantities of fentanyl. But, Sheinbaum still faces increasing pressure from the Trump administration in terms of economic tariffs which would hobble the Mexican economy. Perhaps not coincidentally, the timing of tariff discussions have been closely followed by the transfer of wanted criminals from Mexico to the US. The transfers in February came as officials in Mexico were attempting to put off the Trump administration's imposition of tariffs on Mexican imports. This latest round of 26 criminal transfers comes just a few weeks after Trump spoke with Sheinbaum and agreed to delay the threatened 30% tariffs for another 90 days. 'At the end of the day Mexico hasn't faced the levels of tariffs that were supposed to take effect because of fentanyl trafficking on February 1st,' said Cecilia Farfán-Méndez, a security analyst at the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime. 'These types of transfers which for the Mexican government are not necessarily costly are a way of making progress in DC.' Sheinbaum 'is trying to show Washington that she's pliable, she's cooperative, she is responsive, and she's willing to talk and she's willing to concede', Payan added. Still, according to Ilan Katz, head of the criminal law commission at the Mexican Bar Association, the claim by security minister Harfuch that these criminals continue to present a threat in Mexico even behind bars is not without merit. 'Narcos in Mexico have had a lot of operational capacity even while in confinement,' he said. 'One of the solutions is to effectively remove any drug trafficker from the country who might have communication with their criminal groups from prison.' The two mass transfers are also significant in that they are not technically extraditions, but rather the Mexican government simply acting unilaterally without the due process normally required by the justice system to complete an extradition. 'Drug traffickers in Mexico have been able to evade extraditions to the United States through a series of injunctions and suspensions,' said Katz. 'It's the lesser of two evils to send this guy right now and comply with the extradition order rather than to continue keeping him here because of those suspensions.' But this too is problematic, says Farfán-Méndez, if Mexico is simply exporting its criminals without due process to be dealt with elsewhere. 'It creates questions about whether this represents justice in Mexico,' she said. 'What does it say about our criminal justice system?'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store