Trump's firing of statistics chief sparks unease
Donald J. Trump
. The finance world was mainly interested in what host Joe Kernen might ask the president about what has quickly become one of the most disquieting federal dismissals since
he took office
.
Trump's decision to dismiss Bureau of Labour Statistics (BLS) chief Erika McEntarfer was taken on Friday afternoon, just hours after that body released a jobs report which included heavy revisionism of earlier data for jobs created in May and June.
The brusque dismissal, delivered on social media and accusing McEntarfer of having 'faked' the jobs report prior to last November's election to boost
Kamala Harris's
chances, left current and former employees at the bureau reeling. By Tuesday morning, it was reflected in the financial publications' reports of fresh jitteriness among investors.
Trump, though, was unrepentant, firing back a quick response to the suggestion that while the BLS methodology for collecting data-phone surveys and questionnaires has struggled to adapt to post-Covid work practices, it was always held as unimpeachably fair.
READ MORE
'It is antiquated but it is also very political. Just days before the election they put out numbers that the country was on fire, it was doing so well. Then two weeks later they put out a revision that was down by almost 900,000 jobs. They gave phoney numbers and then revised them a week-and-a-half later.'
Trump's logic was simple. McEntarfer was a Biden appointee, ergo the numbers were manipulated to reflect badly on the White House. As it turned out, his claim about the November numbers was inverse: the BLS pre-election report reflected badly on the Biden/Harris White House.
But Friday's report made for sombre reading. The July data reflected a modest total of 73,000 jobs created for the month. But the June data was revised from 147,000 to a dismal 14,000 and the May numbers were revised from 144,000 to 19,000. It was a combined reduction of 258,000, an erosion which directly refuted the official narrative of the unassailably strong Trump economy.
Worse, the report stated that manufacturing, and by association the industries which the Trump administration has promised to restore to former glories, lost 11,000 jobs in July. The numbers were unpalatable: it was the biggest BLS report revision since 1968. So, Trump decided to get rid of the messenger bearing the bad news. The response has been one of disquiet.
William Beach, the previous commissioner at the BLS and a Trump appointee, stated on social media that the firing was 'totally groundless' and that it sets 'a dangerous precedent and undermines the statistical mission of the bureau'.
In a statement, 'Friends of the BLS' pointed out that 'the president seeks to blame someone for unwelcome economic news. The commissioner does not determine what the numbers are but simply reports on what the data show. Every month, BLS revises the prior two months employment estimates to reflect slower arriving more accurate information. US official statistics are the gold standard globally.'
The data is collected by hundreds of staffers and then approved by a group of 40. The commissioner, in this case McEntarfer, does not typically even see the report until two days before it is presented to the White House.
On Sunday, the White House sent Kevin Hassett, its chief economic adviser and leading contender to succeed the under-siege Jerome Powell as chair of the Federal Reserve, on the morning talkshows to defend the sacking.
'The evidence is that there have been a bunch of revisions,' Hassett said.
'The revisions are hard evidence. There was an 818,000 revision making the Biden job record a lot worse after he withdrew from the election campaign. There have been a bunch of patterns that can make people wonder. The bottom line is that there were people involved in creating these numbers and if I were running the BLS and if I had a number that was a critically important revision, I would have a really long report explaining exactly what happened. And we didn't get that. And so right now people – Goldman Sachs, people on Wall Street – are wondering where these numbers came from.'
But this week, people on Wall Street are also wondering about the identity of the next BLS commissioner, and whether he or she will be expected to deliver only reports which flatter the performance of the Trump economy. Amar Reganti, a former treasury official turned bond strategist, told the Financial Times that the dismissal represented a 'long-term structural risk for the US securities market' and pointed out that the $29tn Treasuries market is reliant on the 'transparency and quality of US data'.
More broadly, the firing of McEntarfer, who has a long, distinguished reputation as a public service data specialist, has been interpreted as another small, vital elimination of a figurehead whose independence was held as sacrosanct to the normal functioning of the US democratic system. Trump's explicit accusation that the numbers are 'rigged' is a new version of what has been a constant undermining and weakening of federal institutions.
The dismal numbers may very well prompt Trump's nemesis at the Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, to implement the interest rate cut that Trump has demanded for months. And the final irony is that Erika McEntarfer's final act as commissioner might have been to deliver a report that signals approaching tariff storms for a US economy that the White House has been showcasing as evidence of the new golden age.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
6 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Cambodia and Thailand to hammer out permanent ceasefire in Malaysia meeting
Cambodia and Thailand's top defence officials have begun a meeting in Malaysia to finalise a permanent end to hostilities following a violent five-day border conflict that ended in an unconditional ceasefire late in July. The Southeast Asian neighbours saw the worst fighting in over a decade last month, including exchanges of artillery fire and jetfighter bombing runs that claimed at least 43 lives and left over 300,000 people displaced on both sides of the border. Fighting continued despite diplomatic interventions from China and Malaysia, chair of the regional bloc ASEAN, calling for restraint. The leaders of Cambodia and Thailand only came to the negotiation table when US President Donald Trump told them that tariff negotiations would not continue unless there was peace. Cambodian Defence Minister Tea Seiha and Thailand's acting defence minister Nattaphon Narkphanit are due to meet at Malaysia's Armed Forces headquarters in Kuala Lumpur. The two countries will establish guidelines to resolve border disputes, restore trust between their military forces and agree to a ceasefire with measures to minimise tensions and protect civilians, Mr Nattaphon said in a statement before the talks. The conditions were formulated during three days of talks between senior officials in Kuala Lumpur and are to be finalised on the fourth day in the presence of observers from China and the United States. Thailand and Cambodia have quarrelled for decades over undemarcated parts of their 817 km land border, which was first mapped by France in 1907 when the latter was its colony.
Irish Times
6 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Trump should use influence with Netanyahu to stop war in Gaza, says Taoiseach
US president Donald Trump should use all his influence with Israel to get prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu to stop the war in Gaza and end the starvation of Palestinians to prevent thousands of more deaths in the enclave, Taoiseach Micheál Martin has said. Mr Martin said that while there was now broad agreement within the European Union that the war in Gaza should end, the country with the most influence over Israel was clearly the United States and he believed Mr Trump should use that influence to end the conflict. 'Well, I believe he ( Mr Trump) should use his influence, and he's a man of peace, he's a man who hates war, and I believe the US can put pressure on Israel to stop this terrible war – too many innocent people are losing their lives, too many children are losing their lives. 'The European Union also has to collectively continue to put pressure on Israel. There's no argument within the European Union now in terms of the catastrophe that is unfolding for so many people ….. it's clear the people of Gaza are suffering terribly,' he said. READ MORE Speaking at a State Commemoration to mark the 250th anniversary of Daniel O'Connell in his native Caherdaniel in Kerry, Mr Martin said that he had no doubt, but that O'Connell would be horrified by what is happening in Gaza and Ukraine given his belief in democracy and freedom. 'I believe he would have been appalled by it, the injustice that's been meted out. I believe he would have called for the release of all hostages, for all the violence and the war to stop, and for a huge distribution and surge of humanitarian aid properly into Gaza. 'We are all appalled, as I said in my speech, in many ways, the legacy of O'Connell is that we do stand up and speak out for those who are suffering in Ukraine, in Gaza, in Sudan and other places of conflict,' he said. 'But what's happening within Gaza now is beyond any moral compass. There is a moral obligation on Israel to stop the killing, stop the killing of innocent people who are queuing for food, stop the killing of children, stop the starvation. 'It offends everyone across the world, and Israel itself has to stop, and I believe forces within Israel, that opinion within Israel is strengthened against the behaviour and activities of prime minister Netanyahu and his colleagues.' Mr Martin defended Ireland's actions in relation to what is happening in Gaza, saying that Ireland had adopted one of the strongest and most supportive positions in relation to the Palestinian people and their right to self-determination. 'Our stand on Gaza is one of the strongest in the world and in Europe we are working with other countries to put more pressure on Israel – everyone is now looking for a ceasefire because what is happening there is terrible (but) there is a pathway, in my view, to stopping this war.' Some 50 or so pro-Palestine supporters mounted a protest outside the grounds of Derrynane House during the O'Connell 250th commemoration, calling on the government to immediately enact the Occupied Territories Bill to outlaw trade with illegal Israeli settlements.
Irish Examiner
36 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Trump's broad tariffs go into effect
President Donald Trump was set to officially begin levying higher import taxes on dozens of countries on Thursday, just as the economic fallout of his months-long tariff threats has begun to create visible damage for the US economy. The White House said that starting just after midnight, goods from more than 60 countries and the European Union (EU) would face tariff rates of 10% or higher. Products from the EU, Japan and South Korea will be taxed at 15%, while imports from Taiwan, Vietnam and Bangladesh will be taxed at 20%. President Donald Trump in the Oval Office in Washington (Alex Brandon/AP) For places such as the EU, Japan and South Korea, Mr Trump also expects them to invest hundreds of billions of dollars in the US. 'I think the growth is going to be unprecedented,' Mr Trump said on Wednesday afternoon. He added that the US was 'taking in hundreds of billions of dollars in tariffs', but he could not provide a specific figure for revenues because 'we don't even know what the final number is' regarding tariff rates. Despite the uncertainty, the Trump White House is confident that the onset of his broad tariffs will provide clarity about the path of the world's largest economy. Now that companies understand the direction the US is headed, the administration believes it can ramp up new investments and jump-start hiring in ways that can rebalance the US economy as a manufacturing power. But so far, there are signs of self-inflicted wounds to America as companies and consumers alike brace for the impact of new taxes. What the data has shown is a US economy that changed in April with Mr Trump's initial rollout of tariffs, an event that led to market drama, a negotiating period and Mr Trump's ultimate decision to start his universal tariffs on Thursday. A customer shops in a grain isle at New India Bazar in Fremont, California, where most merchandise is imported from India and Canada (Noah Berger/AP) After April, economic reports show that hiring began to stall, inflationary pressures crept upward and home values in key markets started to decline, said John Silvia, chief executive of Dynamic Economic Strategy. 'A less productive economy requires fewer workers,' Mr Silvia said in an analysis note. 'But there is more, the higher tariff prices lower workers' real wages. The economy has become less productive, and firms cannot pay the same real wages as before. Actions have consequences.' Even then, the ultimate transformations of the tariffs are unknown and could play out over months, if not years. Many economists say the risk is that the American economy is steadily eroded rather than collapsing instantly. 'We all want it to be made for television where it's this explosion – it's not like that,' said Brad Jensen, a professor at Georgetown University. 'It's going to be fine sand in the gears and slow things down.' The Statue of Liberty is seen near Port Liberty Terminals in New York (Frank Franklin II/AP) Mr Trump has promoted the tariffs as a way to reduce the persistent trade deficit. But importers sought to avoid the taxes by importing more goods before the taxes went into effect. As a result, the 582.7 billion dollar trade imbalance for the first half of the year was 38% higher than in 2024. Total construction spending has dropped 2.9% over the past year. The lead-up to Thursday fit the slapdash nature of Mr Trump's tariffs, which have been variously rolled out, walked back, delayed, increased, imposed by letter and frantically renegotiated. The process has been so muddled that officials for key trade partners were unclear at the start of the week whether the tariffs would begin on Thursday or Friday. An employee counts US dollar notes at a money changer in Jakarta, Indonesia (Tatan Syuflana/AP) The language of the July 31 order to delay the start of tariffs from August 1 said the higher tax rates would start in seven days. On Wednesday morning, Kevin Hassett, director of the White House National Economic Council, was asked if the new tariffs began at midnight on Thursday, and he said reporters should check with the US Trade Representative's Office. Mr Trump on Wednesday announced additional 25% tariffs to be imposed on India for its buying of Russian oil, bringing its total import taxes to 50%. He has said that import taxes are still coming on pharmaceutical drugs and announced 100% tariffs on computer chips, meaning the US economy could remain in a place of suspended animation as it awaits the impact. The president's use of a 1977 law to declare an economic emergency to impose the tariffs is also under challenge. The impending ruling from last week's hearing before a US appeals court could cause Mr Trump to find other legal justifications if judges say he exceeded his authority. Even people who worked with Mr Trump during his first term are sceptical that things will go smoothly for the economy, such as Paul Ryan, the former Republican House of Representatives speaker, who has emerged as a Trump critic. Tropical spices are displayed for sale at a Presidente Supermarket in North Miami, Florida (Marta Lavandier/AP) 'There's no sort of rationale for this other than the president wanting to raise tariffs based upon his whims, his opinions,' Mr Ryan told CNBC on Wednesday. 'I think choppy waters are ahead because I think they're going to have some legal challenges.' Still, the stock market has been solid during the recent tariff drama, with the S&P 500 index climbing more than 25% from its April low. The market's rebound and the income tax cuts in Mr Trump's tax and spending measures signed into law on July 4 have given the White House confidence that economic growth is bound to accelerate in the coming months. As of now, Mr Trump still foresees an economic boom while the rest of the world and American voters wait nervously. 'There's one person who can afford to be cavalier about the uncertainty that he's creating, and that's Donald Trump,' said Rachel West, a senior fellow at The Century Foundation who worked in the Biden White House on labour policy. 'The rest of Americans are already paying the price for that uncertainty.'
