LTCG exemption: Key rulings that clarify grey areas in Sections 54 and 54F
Understanding the nuances of these provisions is essential, particularly in light of recent amendments and judicial rulings that continue to shape their interpretation.
The core difference: Section 54 vs Section 54F
Section 54 applies when the capital gain arises from the sale of a residential house, whereas Section 54F is available on the sale of any long-term capital asset ('LTCG") other than a residential house (e.g., shares, land, gold, etc.).
In both cases, the reinvestment must be made in residential house property situated in India to avail exemption. Sections 54 and 54F can also be claimed simultaneously, provided the respective conditions are fulfilled.
Also Read: How to calculate tax if capital gains are your sole income in FY25
From 2023-24, the maximum exemption is capped at ₹10 crore. This move aims to curb the misuse of exemptions by ultra-high-net-worth individuals.
Investment criteria and conditions:
Time limits
Purchase: Within one year before or two years from the date of transfer.
Construction: Within three years from the date of transfer.
Capital Gains Account Scheme (CGAS): If the amount is not immediately reinvested, it must be deposited in a CGAS before the due date for filing the income tax return.
Transfer of new assets: This exemption is maintained by requiring that the new asset not be transferred within three years of its acquisition or construction.
Exemption limits
Under Section 54: The exemption is the lesser of the capital gain or the amount invested.
Under Section 54F: The exemption is proportional, based on the net consideration reinvested:
Exemption = Capital Gain × (Amount Invested ÷ Net Sale Consideration)
Also Read: Capital gains on equities: Here's all you need to know when filing tax returns this year
Judicial rulings: Clarifying the grey areas
While the legal provisions appear straightforward, their implementation has often required judicial intervention. Key rulings include:
Purchase in spouse's name: Eligible for exemption.
In CIT v. Kamal Wahal, the Delhi high court held that the exemption cannot be denied merely because the legal title of the new residential property is in the spouse's name, as long as the funds belong to the assessee.
Investment in children's name: Exemption is not allowed.
In Prakash v. ITO, the Bombay high court denied the exemption as the beneficial ownership was considered to have passed to the children, defeating the legislative intent of the provision.
Property outside India: Exemption is not available if the new asset is located outside India.
Incomplete construction: Still eligible for exemption.
In CIT v. Sardarmal Kothari, the Madras high court clarified that completion of construction is not mandatory; timely investment is the critical requirement under Section 54F.
Multiple flats as one residential house: Allowed, if used as a single home.
In CIT v. Gita Duggal, the Delhi high court ruled that where multiple units are part of a common structure and serve a unified residential purpose, they qualify as 'a residential house" for the purpose of exemption.
Repayment of housing loan for new residential house: Treated as valid investment for exemption purposes.
Delay in registration: Exemption is allowed.
In Siva Jyothi Palam v. ACIT, the ITAT Visakhapatnam ruled that procedural delays in registration should not defeat substantive compliance with the law. Exemption cannot be denied if payment and possession are within time, even if registration is delayed.
Conclusion
Sections 54 and 54F continue to be vital planning avenues for taxpayers liquidating long-term assets. However, these provisions demand timely execution, accurate documentation, and sometimes even judicial guidance for interpretation.
Also Read: Who can avail the indexation benefit on property sale and is it even worth it?
The judiciary has repeatedly favoured substance over form, focusing on the taxpayer's intent and adherence to time limits rather than procedural lapses. However, caution is warranted. With increased scrutiny and potential litigation, aligning the declared sale consideration with the stamp duty value is critical to avoid tax litigation.
With growing litigation around capital gains exemptions, professional advice is strongly recommended.
Hitesh Kumar and Deepak Kapoor are chartered accountants.
The article reflects the authors' views based on current tax laws and judicial precedents as of the date of publication. Readers are advised to consult with tax professionals before taking any action.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
12 hours ago
- Mint
Understanding section 139(9): What to do when your income tax return is marked defective
The nation's Income Tax Department scrutinises every submitted return. Checks are done for completeness, clarity, and accuracy. When a tax return falls short of the required standards, it is highlighted and marked as a defective return. It becomes a defective return under Section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. This provision provides taxpayers with an opportunity to correct errors and mistakes while filing returns for FY 2024-25. It ensures that taxpayers are not directly subjected to penalties immediately in case they file a defective return. Missing essential information like PAN details. Errors in declared income and tax paid. Selection of incorrect ITR forms at the start. Failure to properly verify the return electronically. Non-submission of mandatory documentation. Incomplete details and data in annexures. Mistakes in presumptive taxation reporting. Mismatch of information and data in comparison with Form 26AS and Form 16. Once defects and mistakes are identified, the department issues a notice to the taxpayer highlighting the errors. Post the same 15 days are provided to the taxpayer to rectify these errors. The assessing officer (AO) may allow further time upon request. Immediate and prompt action in such cases ensures that the taxpayer avoids the consequence of an invalid return, which is treated simply as a non-filing. Furthermore, ignoring income tax notices or non-rectification can result in penalties, interest on unpaid taxes, loss of carry-forward benefits, and the possibility of legal action. Log in to the Income Tax e-filing portal and carefully check the notice details. Understand the exact mistakes in the notice. If in doubt, reach out to a tax professional. File a revised return using the correct form with complete and accurate information. Submit all necessary supporting documents and proof of tax payments. Verify the corrected return through Aadhaar OTP, digital signature, or electronic verification code. Providing the tax authorities with a credible and prompt response within the prescribed time protects the taxpayer's compliance status. It also protects the taxpayer against interest and penalties. Late rectifications may also be accepted if made before the assessment completion date. Still, in their interest, taxpayers are advised to act in a swift manner to maintain hassle-free and seamless tax records. For all personal finance updates, visit here. Disclaimer: Mint has a tie-up with fintechs for providing credit; you will need to share your information if you apply. These tie-ups do not influence our editorial content. This article only intends to educate and spread awareness about credit needs like loans, credit cards, and credit scores. Mint does not promote or encourage taking credit, as it comes with a set of risks, such as high interest rates, hidden charges, etc. We advise investors to discuss with certified experts before taking any credit.
Mint
13 hours ago
- Mint
No taxable income? You may still have to file a return in these scenarios.
One question that always comes up during tax season is: 'Do I need to file a return if my income is below the basic exemption limit?" At first glance the answer seems obvious. No taxable income, no return. But India's Income tax Act doesn't look at things through the 'income earned" lens alone. And frankly, that makes sense. Think about that one friend on Instagram whose weekdays are a blur of exotic vacations. When you meet them in person, they complain: 'Buddy, I'm broke." Yet they're somehow sipping sangria in Spain and Seychelles every other week. Wondering how the math works? So is the taxman. Not having taxable income doesn't automatically mean you're off the hook. The law looks at how you live, spend, and save—not just how you earn. That's why it says: even if there's no taxable income, certain people must still file a return. It's the government's way of keeping track of big financial moves, opulent lifestyles, and transactions that would otherwise have slipped through the cracks. The basic rule Companies, limited liability partnerships (LLPs) and partnership firms have no escape—they must file returns every year, even if they have zero income or losses. For individuals and others, Section 139(1) of the Act requires you to file a return if your gross total income (before deductions under sections 80C, 80D, etc) exceeds the 'maximum amount not chargeable to tax". This the part that trips people up: is that ₹2.5 lakh (old regime) or ₹3 lakh (new regime)? Earlier, the limit was ₹2.5 lakh ( ₹3 lakh for senior citizens, ₹5 lakh for super-seniors). But now the new regime under Section 115BAC has become the default, with a basic exemption of ₹3 lakh. So the trigger can be said to be ₹3 lakh, not ₹2.5 lakh. And it doesn't matter which regime you eventually pick—the law looks at the 'maximum amount not chargeable to tax" under the Finance Act, which is ₹3 lakh. That said, many professionals still advise filing a return if your income crosses ₹2.5 lakh to avoid disputes and build a clean record. That's the simple part. Now let's get into some lesser-known but equally important triggers. Hidden triggers Even if your income is below taxable limits, you are required to file a return if you cross certain thresholds or perform certain transactions. You must file a return if in these situations: Why does the government do this? This may all sound cumbersome, but it's not about troubling the small guy. It's about gathering data and keeping tabs on large money flows. If someone deposits crores in current accounts or spends lakhs abroad, the tax department wants a paper trail, even if the person technically owes no tax. Why you should consider filing voluntarily Even if you are not required to file a tax return, doing so can strengthen your financial profile, speed up loan and visa approvals, ensure refunds are processed smoothly, and act as a shield in case the taxman comes knocking later. Think of it as your annual financial report card. Vijaykumar Puri is a chartered accountant and partner at VPRP & Co LLP, Chartered Accountants.
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
ITR filing: What is updated income tax return and ITR-U? Who can file & what you can't change - top points to know
ITR filing: Taxpayers who miss the regular deadline for filing their income tax return get an additional chance through the updated income tax return (ITR-U) facility, introduced under Section 139(8A) of the Income Tax Act. This option allows individuals to correct errors, add omitted income, or rectify misreporting even after the due dates for belated or revised returns have passed. Time limit for filing ITR-U An updated return can be filed within four years from the end of the relevant assessment year, according to an ET report. For example, if a taxpayer misses the original filing deadline of July 31 (extended to September 15 this year) and also the belated or revised return deadline of December 31, they can still file an updated return for the assessment year 2025-26 until March 31, 2030. Additional tax liability While ITR-U offers the flexibility to correct past mistakes, it comes with an added cost. Taxpayers filing an updated return are required to pay additional tax, with the quantum depending on how late the filing is within the four-year window. When you cannot file ITR-U Certain changes are not permitted through an updated return. Taxpayers cannot use ITR-U if they are: Claiming or increasing a refund amount Declaring reduced tax liability Reporting or carrying forward losses Facing an assessment, reassessment, or revision proceeding Subject to a survey under Section 133(A) or search under Section 132 In cases where accounts, assets, or documents have been seized under Section 132A If an updated return has already been filed once for the relevant year ITR-U thus provides a safeguard for taxpayers to correct past omissions but with clear restrictions and an additional tax cost. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays , public holidays , current gold rate and silver price .
