logo
Woman's ‘nightmare began as she woke up', US prosecutor tells rape trial of Dublin firefighter

Woman's ‘nightmare began as she woke up', US prosecutor tells rape trial of Dublin firefighter

Irish Times09-06-2025
A US woman who has accused a Dublin firefighter of raping in her in a Boston hotel endured a 'nightmare' that began 'as she woke up', a US court was told.
Jurors in a Boston courthouse heard opening statements and testimony from the 29-year-old complainant in the case against
Dublin firefighter Terence Crosbie arrested on rape charges over St Patrick's Day weekend last year
.
Mr Crosbie (39) is charged with assaulting the woman in a shared hotel room while his colleague Liam O'Brien slept in the other bed.
He
denies the charges and has pleaded not guilty
in the trial, which started on Monday.
READ MORE
'Our nightmares belong in our sleep and our nightmares and are supposed to end when we wake up,' the prosecuting lawyer, Suffolk Assistant District Attorney Daniela Mendes, said in her opening statement to the jury.
'Her nightmare began as she woke up.'
Ms Mendes told jurors that the prosecution will present evidence 'that will prove beyond a reasonable doubt' that Mr Crosbie raped the woman as she slept and continued to do so after she woke up and tried to fight him off.
Mr Crosbie's defence attorney, Patrick Garrity, told the jury 'the evidence will show you that there is a lot of doubt'.
The woman claims she went with Mr O'Brien to room 610 of the Omni Parker House hotel on Thursday, March 14th, after meeting him at a nearby bar, The Black Rose.
The couple then had sex and fell asleep in separate beds. She then woke up to a different man with 'an Irish accent' raping her.
The key contention between the two sides presented to jurors was how the DNA evidence collected from the woman was interpreted.
Forensic experts found 'two distinct male profiles', Ms Mendes told the court.
Prosecutors claim the finding of two male profiles supports the complainant's allegation that she was assaulted by a second man after having consensual sex with Mr O'Brien.
But Ms Mendes added that there was an insufficient amount of DNA to match the second profile 'to a known person'.
Defence lawyers told the jury of eight men and six women that the only known male DNA profile belongs to Mr O'Brien.
'Not once did they find a trace of Terence Crosbie,' Mr Garrity told the court.
The prosecution case is that the encounter with Mr O'Brien was consensual, Ms Mendes told the court – that was the night she signed up for.
'She did not sign up to be raped in her sleep by that man's hotel roommate,' the prosecuting lawyer said.
Mr Crosbie met another woman at the bar, she said, but left the bar alone.
Although he initially waited outside the hotel room on a chair in the hallway to give his friend privacy, shortly before 2am he 'was done waiting'.
He saw that the complainant was 'defenceless' and asleep, and 'saw an opportunity', said the prosecutor.
According to the prosecution, the woman awoke to a man with an Irish accent having sex with her.
The man, later identified by the woman as Mr Crosbie, told the accuser that she 'wanted this', even as she struggled and told him to stop.
When she broke free, he then cornered her against a wall, all while Mr O'Brien slept, oblivious, still snoring, the prosecuting lawyer said.
Mr Garrity began opening statements with his hands on the defendant's shoulders, calling him 'Terry' as Mr Crosbie gazed directly at the jury.
Mr Crosbie is 'seated here because this is the only avenue he has to deny these allegations', he told the jury.
'We don't convict people on 'maybes' or 'what-ifs.' We don't convict people on emotion, and this is going to be an emotional case,' he said.
He told the jury they would hear 'how intoxicated' the woman was 'by the time she went back to the hotel room'.
He said they would hear how the woman's statements were inconsistent, with her story changing 'as recently as two weeks ago'.
The case, Mr Garrity said, 'boils down to the word of one person because Mr O'Brien was asleep and snoring through the alleged assault'.
Mr Crosbie attempted to flee the county on an early flight after being questioned by Boston police, but detectives had told him he was a 'free man, you can do whatever you please', his lawyer told the court.
Mr Crosbie was unfamiliar with American criminal and judicial customs, he said. This is 'not his world', added Mr Garrity, gesturing around the Boston courtroom.
In her testimony to the court, the complainant described the hours prior to the assault and reviewed video taken from The Black Rose, occasionally wiping away tears as she spoke.
She said she went with co-workers for drinks and met members of the Dublin Fire Brigade who had flown into Boston to march in the St Patrick's Day parade.
The woman identified herself as 'dancing very awkwardly' in the video and trying to get other people at the bar to get up and dance.
She described Mr O'Brien as 'about my height, maybe a little bit shorter, bald, white, Irish accent'.
Mr O'Brien and his colleagues were wearing T-shirts identifying themselves as members of the Dublin Fire Brigade, she said..
After dancing with Mr O'Brien for about two hours, she said they kissed, he gave her his sweatshirt and they left together.
The trial continues in Boston.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Brute who attacked female jogger shows Government and Gardaí 'not in control'
Brute who attacked female jogger shows Government and Gardaí 'not in control'

Irish Daily Mirror

time2 hours ago

  • Irish Daily Mirror

Brute who attacked female jogger shows Government and Gardaí 'not in control'

A brute who sexually assaulted a woman in the UK before coming to Ireland and attacking a female jogger shows 'the Government and Gardai are simply not in control', it's been claimed. Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín made the stark admission after the Irish Mirror unmasked 'Hoyda Hamad' as a pervert with 27 aliases and 20 convictions earlier this week. The 'non-binary' barber was sentenced on August 6 for kicking the jogger near Fairview Park on the East Wall Road in Dublin on July 26. It then transpired last Wednesday before Cloverhill District Court, the 'genderfluid' deviant had multiple identities and had a rake of offences including theft, burglary and a sexual assault conviction from the UK. This emerged while they were being sentenced for breaching the Sexual Offenders Act. Garda Patrick Watson from Clontarf Garda Station, who gave evidence last Wednesday, said: 'I don't think anybody knows who he is'. Garda Watson said extensive inquiries had taken place at national and international level along with Interpol. He said once his fingerprints were run through the system - 27 aliases popped up. Some of these listed the accused as being from Syria, Libya and Algeria. The court also heard that the Garda National Immigration Bureau had no record of the accused and the accused never sought International Protection - but presented to TUSLA as a minor. Tests later proved he was an adult. Hoyda Hamad being arrested by gardai Speaking yesterday, Mr Tóibín said: 'This particular case makes a mockery of the Criminal Justice System in Ireland. It shows you both that the Criminal Justice System and the immigration system is highly porous. It feeds into the narrative that the Government and the Gardaí are simply not in control of this issue.' The accused will likely be released in the coming weeks but it was said in court, the Gardaí wouldn't even know what country to deport him to. Mr Tóibín stressed he would be raising this particular case with Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan and said the accused needs to be booted out. He continued: 'No one such as this should have been allowed into Ireland and no one such as this should be allowed to remain in Ireland. 'And yet it's quite clear the Government does not have the systems to prevent the entry of such individuals or to remove them. It's quite clear that the Minister for Justice must get on top of this issue. 'I believe it should be the case that people apply for asylum at the ports of entry and I believe there should be an Irish Sea border to make sure we can control the people coming onto the island of Ireland cause we simply can't control the border between the north and south in terms of the movement of people.' Aontu leader Peadar Toibin The TD for Meath West also stressed Ireland has no responsibility to provide refuge to criminals such as Hamad. He explained: 'It is quite incredible and I've seen this before where the Government is simply not using the legal rights that they have to deport people that have committed criminal acts. 'We have absolutely no moral responsibility to provide refuge for anybody who criminally breaks the law. There is a contract here that people who we bring into this country must abide by the laws of this country. 'The immigration system and the criminal justice system are completely incapable of dealing with situations such as this. This case proves that they are porous. This case proves neither are in control of these situations.' The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Mr Tóibín added: 'It's an incredible situation that a person who is a criminal isn't being tracked and isn't identifiable. My worry would be here - we have just one example of an individual who is flouting the law, who is completely immune it seems to the justice system and can act with impunity. 'Anybody who is involved in a criminal act who is not a citizen of this country is removed from this country and anybody who comes into this country with a verifiable criminal conviction should not be allowed into this country. We have a responsibility to help those fleeing war and violence, we have no responsibility to help those who are criminals.' Peadar Toibin (Image: Gareth Chaney Collins) It's understood Hamad came to Ireland where was convicted of a number of offences including burglary in Cork and put behind bars in the Midlands Prison for 11 months in January 2024. The accused was convicted of these offences under the name Youssouf Angelina. After his release from the Midlands, he went on to commit theft in Wexford. In July, the accused was given a three month suspended sentence for this under the name Hoyda Hamad. Following on from this conviction, the accused was then arrested for assaulting a female jogger on the East Wall Road. The sexual assault conviction from the UK and the conviction for breaching the Sex Offenders Act was under the name Youssouf Chergui. A spokesman for the Department of Justice said they don't comment on individual cases. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.

Indian community celebrates independence day in Dublin
Indian community celebrates independence day in Dublin

Irish Examiner

time15 hours ago

  • Irish Examiner

Indian community celebrates independence day in Dublin

Hundreds of people have participated in an event marking India Day in Dublin, as gardai and the Government sought to assure the community it was taking action against racially motivated crime. The free event at Merrion Square came despite a separate celebration being called off following concern over recent attacks on the Indian community. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has expressed concern over 'totally unacceptable' attacks on the Indian community, adding that the majority appear to have been carried out by young people. Mr O'Callaghan said he engaged extensively with the Garda commissioner on the matter, and senior investigating officers had been assigned to investigate all reported incidents. Event organizer Sanjeeb Barik with a statue of the Indian deity Jagannath as people attend the India Day Festival at Merrion Square Park, Dublin (Niall Carson/PA) Sunday's celebration, organised for India's 79th independence day, featured music, dance, food stalls, exhibition stands and a range of cultural activities. Sanjeeb Barik, the secretary of organising group the Federation of Indian Communities in Ireland, said the event had gone well amid 'fantastic and beautiful weather'. 'Lots of people are here, there's food and dancing and lots of fun.' Asked about the engagement with Government and gardai, Mr Barik said the event had received 'good support'. It has been a challenging time but the main thing is to come together as a community and celebrate our heritage Speaking to the PA news agency, he said: 'Naturally, because there has been so many incidents there was some concern. 'We have been actively discussing with ministers, junior ministers and the Minister of Justice and they have all assured us that appropriate safety measures would be in place – and they are. 'We're working very closely to make sure everyone would be safe and, importantly, that it would be enjoyable for everyone.' Mr Barik said they wanted to go ahead with the celebrations to send a message about the importance of standing together. 'It has been a challenging time but the main thing is to come together as a community and celebrate our heritage 'There are people from all backgrounds here – Indian, Irish and others – from all over the the island. 'It is about the strength of bonding and sowing the richness of India and Ireland's multicultural spirit.' From left, Areet Kaur Chandi, seven, Japleen Kaur, 10, and Preety Singh, eight, join the festivities for India Day in Dublin (Niall Carson/PA) He added: 'We are saying come together, stand together. Celebrate unity and diversity – and I hope that will continue.' Inspector Ciaran Nunan from the Garda diversity unit said hate crimes are attacks on the whole community. 'The mission statement of An Garda Siochana is keeping people safe, and this refers to individuals, families, communities and society as a whole. 'It also now includes hate crime. Hate crime is not just an attack on a person, it's an attack on the community. 'An Garda Siochana is very aware of the impact that hate crime has upon individuals and communities, and we take it very, very seriously. 'Since our last India Day celebration last year, we now have hate crime legislation in force and we're applying that legislation at every opportunity – but we need people to report incidents of hate crime to us so that we can then take them on board and react to those.' Entertainment was part of the festivities in Merrion Square Park (Niall Carson/PA) He added: 'So I would encourage everybody or anybody that perceives to be a victim of a hate crime to please report it to An Garda Siochana, and allow us to continue what we're doing and work with our communities to keep people safe.'The Dublin event was attended by Akhilesh Mishra, ambassador of India to Ireland, and Minister of State Emer Higgins. The Ireland India Council, a separate group, said there had been an organised social media campaign against the Indian community in the country and the number of violent attacks has intensified since January. Last week, it said it took the 'difficult' decision to postpone its planned event at Farmleigh House over concerns for the safety of the community.

Opposition must be wary of slating Trump's Washington DC crackdown
Opposition must be wary of slating Trump's Washington DC crackdown

Irish Times

time16 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Opposition must be wary of slating Trump's Washington DC crackdown

My sister is having a bad summer. Even as I'm typing this, Peggy is at [Washington] DC police headquarters. We had dinner in Georgetown recently and when we came back to my house, where her car was parked, she was short a Buick. Two polite officers who responded to our call said they could do little, amid a rash of brazen car thefts by teenagers. READ MORE One officer said that even if they saw the perp driving her car, they could not chase him because of laws passed by the DC council. Kids – some too young to drive legally – can just hot-wire cars to go home. Two 15-year-olds are charged in a carjacking attack on a former DOGE [department of government efficiency] employee who helped set off US president Donald Trump 's crusade on crime in the district. The council has been notoriously lax toward juvenile offenders. Peggy had always loved that Buick, which she bought because Peyton Manning was the pitchman. We figured we'd never see it again. The next morning, though, an officer from Prince George's County, a working-class Maryland suburb, banged on her door. Her car was found in a park, running and nearly out of gas. When she collected it, after paying a $215 (€214) towing charge, she found an odoriferous collection: half-eaten pizza, soda cans, fast-food wrappers, a used condom and a couple of debit cards. She called police to tell them about the debit cards, thinking they could help trace the thieves. (Our dad, after all, was a DC cop.) But officers said to throw them away, noting that the cardholders had probably already gotten new ones. Peggy got the car detailed and celebrated its return by going shopping at Bloomingdale's. When she got back to her parking space, someone had T-boned the poor Buick [collided with the car]. [ Genteel streets of Washington's Georgetown meet national guard in Trump's crime crackdown Opens in new window ] Then, icing on the cake, she got more than $1,800 worth of speed-camera tickets that the car thieves had racked up going 70 in 25mph (40km/h) zones, and some for running red lights. One ticket revealed that the car was stolen just after she got out of it, at 7pm, still light outside. For all we know, the thieves watched her get out. She had to go down to headquarters on Friday to get the police report so she could appeal the tickets. It's hardly the most heinous crime, but you hear a lot about Washingtonians and their personal experiences of being preyed upon. City officials and many liberal residents are outraged about Trump's painting the district as a hellscape and flooding the zone with law enforcement and troops. Protesters around town held up signs reading 'Fascists' and a department of justice employee (now fired) threw a Subway sandwich at an officer and was charged with assault. It's ridiculous to drag FBI agents from their desks to be cops on the beat. And the tableau of national guard troops – even unarmed – raises the spectre of martial law being normalised and weaponised. (Armed and masked border patrol agents showing up at a Gavin Newsom gerrymandering speech in Los Angeles was disturbing.) It is also true that many district residents are secretly glad to see more uniforms. No matter what statistics say, they don't feel safe. I've always been hypervigilant. My mom, the wife of a policeman, passed down a healthy paranoia. She drove me to move into my dorm at Catholic University with a butcher knife on the seat between us. She gave me a Chinese letter opener with written instructions on how to find the jugular. At Christmas, there was always a can of pepper spray or a whistle among the presents. I find myself packing pepper spray again. I feel more wary walking around the city. It's disturbing to ask someone to unlock the Claritin at CVS because the police don't lock up the smash-and-grabbers. Drugstores, as Bill Maher said, have become a 'zoo for teeth-whitening strips'. Trump is playing the saviour on crime when he's the biggest scofflaw [law breaker] in town – first inciting the mob on January 6th and then pardoning felons who broke into the Capitol and beat up police officers. Elie Honig, a CNN legal analyst and author of the forthcoming book, When You Come at the King: Inside DOJ's Pursuit of the President, From Nixon to Trump, summed up the dilemma. 'Yes, Trump is hypocritical and scattershot on public safety,' he told me. 'And yes, he's likely doing this as a flex. But he happens to be within the law here and he happens to be right.' [ Trump sends troops into Washington DC: distraction tactic or part of wider policy? Opens in new window ] While the district's homicide rate has fallen, it's almost as high as New York City's at its most dangerous, in 1990. In the Atlantic, Michael Powell noted that the reality of crime is grimmest in Wards 7 and 8, the disadvantaged, majority-Black neighbourhoods where more than half of the district's homicides occurred last year. 'I have no doubt that Trump enjoys targeting Democratic-controlled cities for embarrassment,' Powell writes. 'I also have little doubt that a mother in Ward 8 might draw comfort from a National Guard soldier standing watch near her child's school.' The diva of distraction is putting on a show. ( They're eating the cats and the dogs!) But progressives should not fall into Trump's trap and downplay crime, once more getting on the wrong side of an inflammatory issue. As with inflation, they should remember that personal experiences can count more than sanguine statistics. Even if Trump is being diabolical, Democrats should not pretend that everything is fine here. Because it's not. This article originally appeared in The New York Times .

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store