QuickCheck: Was Napoleon really short?
NAPOLEON Bonaparte, the legendary military leader and Emperor of France, is often remembered for his immense ambition, strategic genius and, curiously, his supposed diminutive stature.
His height and temper has inspired the term 'the Napoleon Complex', which later became a popular belief that short men tend to compensate for their lack of height through domineering behavior and aggression.
So, is it true? Was he really a tiny titan, or is this one of history's tallest tales?
Verdict:
FALSE
The notion of Napoleon being short may be one of history's most enduring misconceptions.
Part of the ongoing confusion seems to stem from the difference in the French and English measuring systems back in the day.
The French "pouce" is equal to 1.06 English inches, which meant that in France at the time, Napoleon was said to be five feet two inches tall.
More than one Napoleon observer, however, had said he was about five foot six inches tall, which is a little above average for a French man then.
This height was confirmed at his autopsy.
An engraving titled 'Armed Heroes' by James Gillray which was published in 1803 poking fun at Napoleon's alleged diminutive stature.
Historians also point out that Napoleon was often surrounded by his Imperial Guard, who were exceptionally tall. This made him appear shorter by comparison, further cementing the myth.
But one of the main reasons Napoleon was so relentlessly mocked might have come down to anxieties about his outsized ambitions, which prompted his enemies to try to cut him down to size.
The British, Napoleon's long-time adversaries, had a hand in promoting the image of Napoleon as a short man.
British cartoonists like James Gillray "manipulated size and dress to symbolically deflate a threatening military opponent."
The long-standing influence of Gillray's satire shows how mockery can be a powerful weapon against the powerful.
References:
1. https://www.thoughtco.com/was- napoleon-bonaparte-short- 1221108
2. https://www.history.com/ articles/napoleon-complex- short
3. https://www.britannica.com/ biography/Napoleon-I
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
41 minutes ago
- The Star
Hong Kong democrat Jimmy Lai given heart monitor for final stretch of marathon trial
FILE PHOTO: Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai pauses during an interview in Hong Kong on July 1, 2020. - AP HONG KONG: Hong Kong pro-democracy businessman Jimmy Lai was provided with medication and a heart monitor for the start of his final submissions in a landmark national security trial, following health concerns over heart palpitations. Lai, 77, who founded the Apple Daily newspaper that was forced to close after a police raid and asset freeze in June 2021, has pleaded not guilty to two charges of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces, and a charge of conspiracy to publish seditious material. Lai's lawyer Robert Pang told the court last Friday (Aug 15) that Lai had some episodes where he felt that he was collapsing and had heart "palpitations", prompting the court to adjourn proceedings and order that he be provided with a heart monitor and medication. Prosecutor Anthony Chau confirmed that Lai had been provided with these items on Friday and that he was now fit for court. Lai, noticeably thinner than when the trial began in late 2023, was dressed in a white jacket in the glass dock and pressed his palms together in a prayer gesture several times to his family and supporters. One of the judges, Esther Toh, said additional breaks could be provided for Lai if need be, while also acknowledging the opinion of a medical expert who examined Lai that he was "physically and mentally fit for court." "I'm worried for him. He's already in his 70s and has diabetes, and now palpitations," said Lucille, a supporter who queued for hours to get into the packed courtroom. Lai, a British citizen, has been held in solitary confinement for around 1,700 days. His son and some rights groups have expressed fear over his deteriorating health. Some Western governments have called for Lai's immediate release and raised concerns about the erosion of fundamental rights in the financial hub under China-imposed national security laws. Hong Kong and Chinese authorities have said Lai is being given a fair trial and have warned against such interference in the city's internal affairs. US President Donald Trump said in a media interview last week that he would "do everything I can to save him." An Australian foreign affairs spokesperson told Reuters on Monday that Canberra was "deeply concerned by Hong Kong's widespread application of national security laws to repress civil society and prosecute pro-democracy advocates... such as Jimmy Lai". - Reuters
New Straits Times
4 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Zelenskyy, EU leaders to meet Trump after failed Putin summit
BRUSSELS: European leaders said they would join Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in talks with US President Donald Trump on Monday, as they try to find a way to end Russia's offensive. Trump met Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska on Friday but the talks failed to yield any breakthrough on a ceasefire – though White House envoy Steve Witkoff said both leaders had agreed to provide "robust security guarantees" to Ukraine. European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen hailed the news, but Zelenskyy, speaking alongside her at a news conference in Brussels, rejected the idea of Russia offering his country security guarantees. "What President Trump said about security guarantees is much more important to me than Putin's thoughts, because Putin will not give any security guarantees," he said. Zelenskyy later said on social media that the US offer regarding security guarantees was "historic." French President Emmanuel Macron, who will take part in the Washington meeting along with von der Leyen and others, said European leaders would ask about the extent of the security guarantees offered to Ukraine in any peace agreement. Of Moscow's position, he said: "There is only one state proposing a peace that would be a capitulation: Russia." Russian foreign ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova called that an "abject lie" in a statement on Telegram later Sunday. Moscow had been proposing a "peaceful resolution" of the conflict for seven years under the terms of the Minsk Accords, she said. Macron, she added, was trying to convince Ukraine that it could win on the battlefield even when he knew that that was "impossible." Trump, who pivoted after the Alaska meeting to say he was now seeking a peace deal rather than a ceasefire, on Sunday posted "BIG PROGRESS ON RUSSIA. STAY TUNED!" on his Truth Social platform, without elaborating. Trump's sudden focus on a peace deal aligns with the stance long taken by Putin, one which Ukraine and its European allies have criticised as Putin's way to buy time while trying to make battlefield gains. Zelenskyy also said he saw "no sign" the Kremlin leader was prepared to meet him and Trump for a three-way summit, as had been floated by the US president. The leaders heading to Washington on Monday to appear alongside Zelenskyy call themselves the "coalition of the willing." As well as von der Leyen and Macron, they include British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Nato Secretary-General Mark Rutte. Also heading to Washington will be Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and Finnish President Alexander Stubb, who get on well with Trump. On Sunday, they all held a video meeting to prepare their joint position. Speaking to US broadcaster CNN, Witkoff said: "I'm hopeful that we have a productive meeting on Monday, we get to real consensus, we're able to come back to the Russians and push this peace deal forward and get it done." US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, speaking to NBC on Sunday, warned of "consequences" – including the potential imposition of new sanctions on Russia – if no peace deal was reached on Ukraine. European leaders have expressed unease from the outset over Trump's outreach to Putin, who has demanded Ukraine abandon its ambitions to join the EU or Nato. They were excluded from Trump's summit with Putin. Witkoff, in his CNN interview, said the process of offering "game-changing" security guarantees would involve territorial "concessions." According to an official briefed on a call Trump held with Zelenskyy and European leaders as he flew back from Alaska, the US leader supported a Putin proposal that Russia take full control of two eastern Ukrainian regions in exchange for freezing the frontline in two others. Putin "de facto demands that Ukraine leave Donbas", an area consisting of the Donetsk and Lugansk regions in eastern Ukraine, which Russia currently only partly controls, the source said. In exchange, Russian forces would halt their offensive in the Black Sea port region of Kherson and Zaporizhzhia in southern Ukraine, where the main cities are still under Ukrainian control. Several months into its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Russia in September 2022 claimed to have annexed all four Ukrainian regions even though its troops still do not fully control any of them. "The Ukrainian president refused to leave Donbas," the source said. On the ground in Ukraine, the conflict rages on, with both Kyiv and Moscow launching attack drones.
The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
QuickCheck: Was Napoleon really short?
Napoleon Bonaparte was born in 1769. He was a French general and statesman who literally redrew the map of Europe after leading a series of military campaigns from 1796 to 1815. NAPOLEON Bonaparte, the legendary military leader and Emperor of France, is often remembered for his immense ambition, strategic genius and, curiously, his supposed diminutive stature. His height and temper has inspired the term 'the Napoleon Complex', which later became a popular belief that short men tend to compensate for their lack of height through domineering behavior and aggression. So, is it true? Was he really a tiny titan, or is this one of history's tallest tales? Verdict: FALSE The notion of Napoleon being short may be one of history's most enduring misconceptions. Part of the ongoing confusion seems to stem from the difference in the French and English measuring systems back in the day. The French "pouce" is equal to 1.06 English inches, which meant that in France at the time, Napoleon was said to be five feet two inches tall. More than one Napoleon observer, however, had said he was about five foot six inches tall, which is a little above average for a French man then. This height was confirmed at his autopsy. An engraving titled 'Armed Heroes' by James Gillray which was published in 1803 poking fun at Napoleon's alleged diminutive stature. Historians also point out that Napoleon was often surrounded by his Imperial Guard, who were exceptionally tall. This made him appear shorter by comparison, further cementing the myth. But one of the main reasons Napoleon was so relentlessly mocked might have come down to anxieties about his outsized ambitions, which prompted his enemies to try to cut him down to size. The British, Napoleon's long-time adversaries, had a hand in promoting the image of Napoleon as a short man. British cartoonists like James Gillray "manipulated size and dress to symbolically deflate a threatening military opponent." The long-standing influence of Gillray's satire shows how mockery can be a powerful weapon against the powerful. References: 1. napoleon-bonaparte-short- 1221108 2. articles/napoleon-complex- short 3. biography/Napoleon-I
