Supreme Court revives FBI 'wrong house' raid lawsuit
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Thursday revived a lawsuit against the FBI in a damages claim arising from an incident in which agents raided the wrong house in Atlanta.
The ruling marks a narrow win for Toi Cliatt, his former girlfriend Trina Martina and her son Gabe Watson, who were all present in the house during the October 2017 encounter.
The unanimous decision written by Justice Neil Gorsuch means they can continue to press claims alleging assault, battery and false imprisonment under a law called the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA), one of the few avenues to hold federal officials accountable. Litigation will now continue in the Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
"We look forward to continuing this fight with the Martins in the Eleventh Circuit and making it easier for everyday people to hold the government accountable for its mistaken and intentional violations of individual rights," Patrick Jaicomo, a lawyer at the libertarian Institute for Justice who represents the plaintiffs, said in a statement.
The case highlights the problem of law enforcement raiding the wrong house, which has happened in several high-profile cases.
A district court judge and the appeals court ruled for the government.
The legal question touched upon on whether a particular provision of the law, which allows claims concerning the actions of federal law enforcement officers, is trumped in this instance by another provision called 'the discretionary function exception,' which protects certain judgment calls from liability.
The court did not resolve that question, but did remove a barrier to the plaintiffs being able to argue it in lower courts.
"We readily acknowledge that different lower courts have taken different views of the discretionary function exception," Gorsuch wrote. "We acknowledge, too, that important questions surround whether and under what circumstances that exception may ever foreclose a suit like this one."
In a separate concurring opinion, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that "there is a reason to think" that the discretionary function exception should not bar the plaintiffs' claims. Her opinion was joined by Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson.
During the raid in question the agents had guns drawn and used flash-bang grenades as they entered the house.
Cliatt was handcuffed and thrown on the floor. Martin wanted to rush to her son but wasn't allowed to move. Watson, then 7, woke up to see agents with guns in his bedroom.
The agents quickly left the house upon realizing their error and a supervisor returned later to apologize.
The Justice Department in court papers said that a Garmin GPS device that FBI agent Lawrence Guerra used to lead the team to the house had indicated the agents had arrived at the correct location.
The FBI was seeking to arrest a man named Joseph Riley, who lived nearby. After they left the wrong house, the agents raided the correct home. Riley was arrested and later convicted.
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
44 minutes ago
- Miami Herald
Trump approves Nippon Steel purchase of U.S. Steel
June 14 (UPI) -- President Donald Trump issued an executive order on Friday officially giving the green light to Nippon Steel Corporation's multi-billion-dollar purchase of U.S. Steel Corporation. Trump's executive order rescinds a directive issued by former President Joe Biden that blocked the Tokyo-based steel producer's $14.9 billion purchase on national security grounds. The president had been signaling he would approve such a move, stating in May that the two steel giants would form a "planned partnership." Trump previously ordered a review of the transaction by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States. "Based on the recommendation of and my review of the materials provided by CFIUS, including re-review of the prior assessment of risk, I additionally find that the threatened impairment to the national security of the United States arising as a result of the Proposed Transaction can be adequately mitigated if the conditions set forth in section 3 of this order are met," Trump wrote in the executive order. "President Trump has approved the Companies' historic partnership that will unleash unprecedented investments in steelmaking in the United States, protecting and creating more than 100,000 jobs," Pennsylvania-based U.S. Steel said in a release jointly issued with Nippon Steel. "We thank President Trump and his Administration for their bold leadership and strong support for our historic partnership. This partnership will bring a massive investment that will support our communities and families for generations to come. We look forward to putting our commitments into action to make American steelmaking and manufacturing great again." Trump's executive order requires both companies to enter into a National Security Agreement, which stipulates $11 billion in new investments must be made in the United States by 2028. That includes an already-underway project not scheduled for completion until after 2028. The United States government will also be issued a golden share as part of the NSA, giving it unique voting rights. "President Trump promised to protect American Steel and American Jobs -- and he has delivered on that promise," White House spokesperson Kush Desai told CNN in a statement. "Today's executive order ensures US Steel will remain in the great Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, and be safeguarded as a critical element of America's national and economic security." Confirmation of the deal comes just over a week after 50% tariffs took effect on metals imported into the United States from nearly all countries. The tariffs were enacted a day after Trump signed an executive order doubling the duties on almost all imported aluminum and steel. Copyright 2025 UPI News Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
Boston Globe
44 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Russia's summer offensive in Ukraine gains ground with new tactics
'It's a kind of renaissance of the cavalry, but with internal combustion engines,' said Col. Viktor Kevliuk, a Ukrainian army reservist and an analyst at Ukraine's Center for Defense Strategies, a think tank. The fighting is intensifying even as ceasefire talks have mostly stalled. The most recent round of negotiations, held this month in Istanbul, yielded little result beyond an agreement to exchange prisoners and the bodies of fallen soldiers. The exchange continued Saturday, with Ukraine saying that it had received 1,200 bodies and that more prisoners had been returned. Advertisement Here are the areas where the front is moving. Sumy In recent months, Russian troops have captured at least a dozen villages in the Sumy region. The advance is tiny but in frequent steps, with small assault groups, often just two or three Russian soldiers, who probe Ukrainian positions in waves. Advertisement 'Where the last surviving infantry is holding out, the next assault group arrives to build on any success,' Kevliuk said. Ukraine has one defensive advantage. The terrain is full of ravines, so movement is only possible on roads, according to Andrii, an intelligence officer with an air assault brigade operating near the city of Sumy, who asked to be identified only by his first name in keeping with military protocol. The city is home to more than 200,000 civilians, including many displaced from fighting along the border, and is now under growing threat as Russia advances. Russian forces overran it in their initial invasion in 2022, but Ukraine recaptured it later that year. Pasi Paroinen, a military analyst with Finland-based Black Bird Group, said Russian forces were seizing high ground north of Sumy and pushing toward dense forests that dominate the city's northern and northeastern approaches. If Russia captures four villages -- Khotyn, Yunakivka, Pysarivka and Kyyanytsia -- that would threaten the city itself. If the battles shift into the forests, commanders warn, it could require additional infantry reinforcements from Ukraine, as drone surveillance becomes less effective through the leaves. Kostyantynivka Kostyantynivka, a Ukrainian operations hub, will likely become Russia's main effort in the coming months, with other fronts serving the supporting role of preventing Ukraine from sending reinforcements to this fight, Paroinen said. The first step is to try to isolate Kostyantynivka from multiple directions, in a 'semi-encirclement,' he said, isolating Ukrainian units while maintaining a narrow, hazardous corridor for retreat. The idea would be to advance eastward across the T-0504 road; northward from Toretsk; and westward from the hilltop town of Chasiv Yar. Advertisement This would not be easy. Russian forces have been trying to capture Chasiv Yar for two years, since the nearby city of Bakhmut fell in the spring of 2023. So long as Chasiv Yar remains contested, Russia's advance to Kostyantynivka will be slowed. Also, to the south, Russian forces are bogged down in urban fighting in Toretsk. In some areas near Kostyantynivka, Russia has a manpower advantage of up to 20-to-1, Ukrainian commanders in the area say. 'Our task is to block their actions,' said Capt. Filatov, a commander deployed along the line. His soldiers regularly engage in close-range combat while slowly retreating, he said. A unit of a few dozen hundred typically repels 10 to 15 assaults per week, with as many as four in a single day, he said. At the same time, front-line airstrikes have intensified, even after Ukraine's destruction of at least a dozen Russian strategic bombers. At the start of May, Russia was carrying out 11 airstrikes a day. That pace has picked up to 17 in June, said Lt. Col. Dmytro Zaporizhets, spokesperson for Ukraine's Luhansk Operational Tactical Group. Throughout the Donbas -- parts of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions -- Russian has concentrated drone units and is targeting roads, threatening supply lines. Analysts say Russian advances in the Donbas follow a systematic pattern. The troops first isolate Ukrainian positions, targeting logistics and reinforcements with drones; then pound them with artillery and aerial bombs; then attack in small units, often on motorcycles. Then they repeat the process farther down the line. Pokrovsk West of Kostyantynivka lies Pokrovsk, also in the Donetsk region, where Russian forces are also pressing forward with superior manpower, said Sr. Lt. Vasyl Yemelianov, an artillery commander in the area. Advertisement Russian forces are closing in on Pokrovsk from several directions, similar to their semi-encirclement strategy around Kostyantynivka. Still, the city remains in Ukrainian hands, while Russian efforts have recently shifted farther west, with some troops crossing the administrative border between the Donetsk and Dnipropetrovsk regions. But the front, here and elsewhere, remains fluid, with Russian forces looking for weaknesses and Ukrainian troops scrambling to hold defensive lines. This article originally appeared in
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
La Quinta man arrested for allegedly threatening shooting at Palm Springs 'No Kings' rally
A La Quinta man threatening violence at a "No Kings" rally has been arrested, the Palm Springs Police Department announced Saturday morning. Edward Miranda, 28, allegedly threatened to commit a shooting at the Palm Springs "No Kings" rally scheduled for 6 p.m. Saturday, June 14, police said on social media. Police became aware of the threat, which was posted online, at around 2:12 p.m., Friday, June 12. Live: California to see 200 anti-Trump 'No Kings Day' protests across state PSPD worked with the FBI to identify Miranda and locate him at his residence in La Quinta. He was taken into custody without incident and is expected to be charged with one felony count of criminal threats and a misdemeanor count of threatening to interfere with civil rights. Law enforcement executed search warrants at two residences, one in Riverside County and another in San Bernardino County, locating a firearm belonging to Miranda, PSPD said. Police did not say in their post if Miranda remained in custody. "We take all threats to public safety seriously and will vigorously pursue those intent on committing violence in our community," Chief Andy Mills said in a statement. "Thanks to the vigilance of a community member who saw something and said something, along with the tireless efforts of our PSPD detectives and FBI partners, we were able to identify and apprehend the suspect, ensuring the safety of tonight's event." A heavy police presence is expected at the "No Kings" rally in Palm Springs to ensure public safety. The investigation remains ongoing. Anyone with additional information is urged to contact PSPD at 760-327-1441 or submit anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers at 760-341-7867. This is a developing story. Sam Morgen covers the city of Palm Springs for The Desert Sun. Reach him at smorgen@ This article originally appeared on Palm Springs Desert Sun: Police: man arrested for threat to shooting at Palm Springs rally
