logo
Aggression not for everyone: Shubman Gill needs his own voice, not mimic Virat Kohli

Aggression not for everyone: Shubman Gill needs his own voice, not mimic Virat Kohli

India Today15-07-2025
It would not be far-fetched to suggest that Shubman Gill may be trying to mimic certain aspects of Virat Kohli. Since being appointed Test skipper, he has moved to the No. 4 slot where, notably, some of his best knocks in the ongoing England series have come.There have been moments when Gill has shown glimpses of Kohli-esque behaviour. One such instance was his celebration at Edgbaston the roar, the celebration strikingly similar to Kohli's century celebration at the same venue in 2018.advertisement
This may be a hot take, but the only reason to suggest Gill isn't actively trying to replicate Kohli is that his game might be suffering as a result. Yes, it's entertaining to be the one dishing it out, but when you're on the receiving end of verbal jabs, it's a different game altogether. That's what made Kohli so great: he thrived in the fire. But that style isn't for everyone, and perhaps not for Gill.Before his first Test as captain, Gill had stated that he didn't want to copy anyone's style, instead focusing on being his own man. But is that truly the case?Gill has certainly been more confrontational, a shift from the composed figure we've seen over most of his career. This change should serve as a wake-up call. Opposition players, as Ben Stokes demonstrated on the final day at Lord's, are more than happy to return the favour.Even the great Virender Sehwag, one of India's finest batters, initially struggled with trying to model himself after Sachin Tendulkar. But once he embraced his own identity, he flourished. The parallels for Gill are clear — and perhaps instructive.GILL'S HOSTILE TACTICS BACKFIRED? Former cricketers Sanjay Manjrekar and Mohammad Kaif, in hindsight, both suggested that Gill's approach — especially his verbal duel with Zak Crawley on Day 3 — might have worked against him.'Gill suddenly looking tentative last evening had a lot to do with the hostility he got at the crease from England. Virat performed better, the angrier he got. Dhoni is the exact opposite. Gill must decide what gets the best out of him as a batter — calmness or anger,' Manjrekar posted on X.'Shubman Gill's fight with Zak Crawley charged England. After Edgbaston, there were questions about their batting, bowling and captaincy. But that incident fired up Stokes, and he bowled an inspiring spell. It is wise to stick to the attitude that works for you. Gill will learn this the hard way,' Kaif echoed.'What would have fired him up in this game was the Indian team targeting Zak Crawley in that one over,' Broad said on Sky Sports Cricket. 'It was great fun, brilliant to watch, but he wouldn't have liked the fact that one of his players was out there alone, with just Ben Duckett for company, and the team going at him'. advertisementGill however, defended himself and suggested that those few minutes of play cannot determine an entire Test match. Instead he pointed out other moments that could have turned the result in their favour. 'No, five minutes can't define five days of hard work. If you ask me about key moments, that wouldn't even be in my top five. For us, Rishabh's run-out was more crucial. At one point, we felt we could get a 50–100 run lead, which would've been massive on Day 5 when batting gets tough. That was a big turning point," Gill said at the post-match press conference. Only time will tell if Gill can carve out his own identity as a Test captain. Since taking over, he has looked eager to take England head-on a trait that could either define or derail this early chapter of his leadership.With two Tests still to play, Gill has the chance to quiet his critics, including me. A series win would put many of these concerns to rest. One thing, however, is clear: this Indian Test team is full of fighters. The challenge for Gill is not to become someone else, but to channel that fight in a way that stays true to who he really is.- EndsTune InMust Watch
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Sai Sudharsan speaks on 'enjoyable' return to Test cricket, Rishabh Pant injury: 'You have to be ready for aggressive nature'
Sai Sudharsan speaks on 'enjoyable' return to Test cricket, Rishabh Pant injury: 'You have to be ready for aggressive nature'

First Post

time2 minutes ago

  • First Post

Sai Sudharsan speaks on 'enjoyable' return to Test cricket, Rishabh Pant injury: 'You have to be ready for aggressive nature'

Sai Sudharsan termed his return to Indian Test team and his innings as an 'enjoyable experience' as he made 61 on Day 1 of the fourth Test against England at Manchester. He also spoke on Rishabh Pant's injury. read more Sai Sudharsan relished his return to Test cricket and the challenge put forward by English bowlers. Image: Reuters Sai Sudharsan certainly enjoyed a successful comeback to the Indian Test team as he scored 61 on Day 1 of the fourth Test against England at Manchester on Wednesday. Sudharsan was picked in the team in place of Karun Nair after being dropped after the first Test following scores of 0 and 30. On his return, the 23-year-old Sudharsan was watchful and brought up a gritty fifty on a slow-moving day but eventually perished after a miscued pull shot off Ben Stokes. The catch was taken by Brydon Carse at short leg. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Sudharsan speaks on his return, Pant injury While Sudharsan would have wanted a three-figure score, he relished the innings, being proud of his fighting spirit. 'It was actually a really enjoyable experience, to be honest,' said Sudharsan. 'Because one of the best bowlers in the country is steaming in and trying to hit you hard. And you being there and giving your best for the team. That's one of the best feelings you can have. 'Playing against England on their home soil, you have to be ready for that aggressive nature. I enjoyed it.' The No.3 batter also opened up on after the wicketkeeper-batter was forced to retire hurt after being hit on his right foot by a Chris Woakes delivery. Pant missed the fuller ball while trying to play a reverse sweep, leading to a nasty right foot injury. He was later taken for scans, with BCCI yet to communicate the seriousness of the injury. 'He was in a lot of pain,' said Sudharsan, who was batting at the non-striker's end. 'They've gone for scans. We'll get to know overnight, probably get the information tomorrow.' England all-rounder Liam Dawson, who made a return to Test cricket after eight years and picked the wicket of Yashasvi Jaiswal, feels Pant is done for the game due to the injury. 'I hope he's all right,' Dawson said. 'He's obviously a very good player. I probably can't see him taking much more part in this game.' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Pant had missed the majority of wicket-keeping in the Lord's Test after suffering a finger injury while collecting a wide delivery on the leg side. He is the second-highest run-scorer in the series and the latest injury setback to Pant is a major blow to India.

4th Test: Rahul and Jaiswal showed excellent defensive technique, says Manjrekar
4th Test: Rahul and Jaiswal showed excellent defensive technique, says Manjrekar

Hans India

time2 minutes ago

  • Hans India

4th Test: Rahul and Jaiswal showed excellent defensive technique, says Manjrekar

Mumbai: Former India batter Sanjay Manjrekar has said that openers KL Rahul and Yashasvi Jaiswal showed excellent defensive technique and strong minds as they went unseparated in the morning session on the opening day of the fourth Test of the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy at Old Trafford in Manchester. The K.L. Rahul–Yashasvi Jaiswal opening partnership fetched India 94 runs and laid the foundation for India's strong start in the crucial match that India needs to win to maintain their chances of taking the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy home. 'The morning session clearly went in India's favour — thanks to these two. They carried their form with excellent defensive technique and strong minds. India have always struggled to find a consistent opening pair in overseas conditions, but they now seem to have one. A left-right combination that scores hundreds and looks dependable — that's rare. You can expect consistency from this pair, and that's significant,' said Manjrekar, speaking on 'Match Centre Live' after the conclusion of Day 1 of the fourth Test. Already trailing 1-2 in the five-match series, India made a superb start after being asked to bat first by England skipper Ben Stokes, with Yashasvi Jaiswal and KL Rahul seeing through the first session. But England fought back after lunch by dismissing both the openers and India skipper Shubman Gill in quick succession to make it 140/3. However, it was Sudharsan who kept Indian hopes afloat in this crucial match, which India had to win to keep the series alive. Manjrekar also noted Jaiswal's rapid growth as a Test batter. 'In the past, you'd say some Indian batters flattered to deceive because of flat home pitches. But now, when a young batter puts together a strong Test run, you know Jaiswal has done it across tough conditions. South Africa was his first overseas tour — arguably the hardest. He'll do better next time. What stands out is how late he plays the ball, how decisively he moves on the front and back foot, and his hunger for Test success.' Yashasvi Jaiswal hit a gritty 58 while sharing a 94-run opening stand with KL Rahul, who hit 46. Meanwhile, JioHotstar expert Jonathan Trott shared his analysis on England's strategy, saying the real test will be with the new ball. 'I think England laid the groundwork, but the real test will be with the new ball on Day 2. If it doesn't behave the way they hope, they might regret the decision to bowl first. Batting last at Old Trafford rarely gets easier. That said, we've had 16 days of fantastic cricket, and we're still no closer to knowing which side is better. That's the beauty of this series,' he added.

India vs England 4th Test, Manchester Weather On Day 2: Rain Likely To Arrive At...
India vs England 4th Test, Manchester Weather On Day 2: Rain Likely To Arrive At...

NDTV

time2 minutes ago

  • NDTV

India vs England 4th Test, Manchester Weather On Day 2: Rain Likely To Arrive At...

Half-centuries from Yashasvi Jaiswal and Sai Sudharsan guided India to 264/4 at the close of play against England on Day 1 of the 4th Test in Manchester. Barring the injury to Rishabh Pant, who was later taken for scans, it was a decent day for the Indian team after skipper Shubman Gill lost the toss for a fourth consecutive time in this tour. It was a real treat for the fans as well especially after the build up was largely dominated by concerns surrounding the weather. While it was cloudy throughout the day, fans at Old Trafford got to witness 83 overs of action-packed cricket, that too without any rain delay. As per Accuweather, the sun is likely to be out for the majority of Thursday, with some light showers around 4 PM local time (8:30 PM IST). Let's take a look at the hourly weather report for Day 2: On a day when conditions weren't entirely in favour of the batters, young Sai Sudharsan showed immense patience and composure to notch up a hard-fought half-century. The left-hander scored a valuable 61 off 151 deliveries, an innings that included seven boundaries and a lot of resilience Speaking at the post-day press conference, Sai opened up about the challenges he faced while batting on a tricky surface against a quality England pace attack. "I mean, there's a bit of variable bounce and two pace wicket as well and overcast was also there," Sai said. "So, throughout the day, it was cloud-covered. Throughout the day, the ball was moving, doing something or the other from the wicket...I thought I played a bit tighter and took some time in the wicket," he added. Despite the testing conditions with the seamers getting assistance both in the air and off the surface, Sai showed remarkable temperament. He left balls well, waited for loose deliveries, and looked increasingly assured as his innings progressed. His knock came at a time when India needed stability.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store