Piardi call in Australia-Lions test should be accepted, Erasmus says
The Lions won the test with a try from Hugo Keenan in the final seconds but Australia believe a ruling from referee Andrea Piardi at a ruck immediately beforehand was incorrect.
Australia coach Joe Schmidt said the call was an error in his post-match press conference, suggesting Jac Morgan's clear-out of Carlo Tizzano was dangerous, and Rugby Australia chief executive Phil Waugh said he would seekg "accountability" from World Rugby over it.
But Erasmus, who received a two-month ban from World Rugby for a 62-minute video that was critical of Australian referee Nic Berry after the first Lions test in South Africa in 2021, said he could see both sides of the argument.
"I had Australia (winning) by four points in the game, so I lost our internal (coach's competition) on that one," Erasmus told reporters with a smile on Tuesday.
"It's such a tough decision. World Rugby has come out to say it was the right decision. It was a very tough call for the referee to make.
"If I was Joe, I would be really disappointed, and if I was (Lions coach) Andy (Farrell), I would be really happy. I think it was touch-and-go, so I can understand both sides of what each coach sees.
"But World Rugby has ruled on it and that is what everybody has to accept."
World Rugby chief Alan Gilpin backed the call from Piardi earlier on Tuesday.
"We do share with Joe and the coaching team why the match officials made that decision," he said.
"Joe's got a view about what was wrong with that decision and there'll be a debate so that Joe and his players can go into the next test understanding how that game's going to be officiated."
South Africa will host Australia in two Rugby Championship tests in Johannesburg and Cape Town next month.
Italian Piardi will officiate the defending champion Springboks' final match in the competition against Argentina in London in October.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
12 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Ben Cousins announces stunning footy comeback and reveals the star who convinced him to return to the field
Controversial AFL legend Ben Cousins has announced he'll be returning to the field in a high–profile match – with the chance to star alongside a fellow great of the game proving too much to resist. The 47–year–old revealed he'll be playing in the AFL Legends game at Melbourne's Marvel Stadium on August 28, joking, 'How hard can it be?' after last playing first grade 15 years ago. 'I think it might be time to dust them [the footy boots] off. One game, hey? I can get myself up for one! It should be a bit of fun… I'm looking forward to it,' Cousins said on Mix94.5's Pete & Kymba with Ben Cousins radio show on Monday. The West Coast Eagles premiership–winner will take to the field with a host of big names, but the one that sticks out for him is former Hawks superstar Cyril Rioli. 'Shane Crawford is the coach; Nick Riewoldt is the captain. I only decided [to play] over the weekend. But, for me, the chance to play alongside Cyril, you know? I'm excited about that,' he said. 'It's a big thing; he was just such a great player. The 47–year–old has kept himself in great shape – and joked 'how hard can it be?' when he was asked about having just over three weeks to prepare for the match 'Everyone's situation is different but because he was 28 when he stopped playing, we all felt he had so much good footy left in him. 'To see him run around and have a kick is so exciting and I'm looking forward to handpassing to him or getting one off him!' Last month, Rioli stunned footy fans by announcing he'll run out for the All Stars side against their Victorian opposition in the match, which will raise funds for the Australian Prostate Cancer Centre. Rioli's bombshell exit from the game came after he accused Hawthorn of having a shocking relationship with its Indigenous players, and later penned an open letter about his experiences. When Cousins was reminded that the Legends game is only just over three weeks away, he replied, 'It's supposed to be like riding a bike, isn't it? 'It's a young man's game but I can get myself up for one, surely. How hard can it be?' Cousins – who is also working for Channel Seven in Perth – has kept himself in great shape since he was released from jail in 2019 after several stints behind bars. He recently looked super–fit as he took the rare step of publicly posting photos with his children after they enjoyed a family holiday in Western Australia. Cousins was also joined on a cruise by a host of other A–list Australian celebrities, including radio presenter Fifi Box, former host of The Project Carrie Bickmore, and former West Coast Eagles teammate Chris Judd and his wife Bec Judd. Cousins' battles with addiction have been well documented since they became public in 2007 after a series of off–field incidents, including arrests and suspensions. He was suspended from the AFL in 2007 and returned in 2009 to play two seasons with Richmond before retiring.
Daily Mail
44 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The NRL drops a bombshell after footy stars were busted delivering a hidden insult to Middle Eastern fans
The NRL Integrity Unit is investigating after Wests Tigers players appeared to make obscene gestures at Canterbury supporters during the boilover at CommBank Stadium. After the final try of their side's shock 28-14 win, a number of Tigers players appeared to taunt Bulldogs fans with the 'khod' gesture, known as an equivalent to 'flipping the bird' in the Arabic community. Tigers players Samuela Fainu, Sunia Turuva, Brent Naden and Latu Fainu all made the hand gesture towards the southern grandstand, where a large contingent of Bulldogs fans were sitting. On Sunday night, Tigers centre and former Bulldogs player Naden appeared in a since-deleted TikTok video in which he made the gesture and yelled 'f***ing dogs'. The video was reportedly sent by Naden to a friend and then leaked publicly. The Bulldogs have a passionate Middle Eastern fan base and reached out to the NRL integrity unit, which is now investigating the matter after the club was inundated with complaints from their fans. A footy supporter took to Reddit to post a video of the celebrations, captioning the clip: 'Naden giving the Dogs the Khod', with other commenters also referencing the gesture in their posts. The phrase 'Khod' has several meanings. In Arabic, its literal translation is 'take', but the symbol can also be used as an insult in some cultures. Fainu and Naden's gesture divided footy fans online, with some branding it disgraceful. 'This is disrespectful and completely worth being looked at by the NRL. If they flipped the bird, which is what this action actually means, they'd be getting smashed for it. There is no difference. Pull your players' heads in @WestsTigers,' one wrote on X. However, many fans saw the lighter side of the incident and said the Tigers players should be allowed to celebrate wildly after winning the game. 'Let the joint venture have their day, one finals appearance since 2011,' one wrote on Facebook. 'But the fans were doing it to the players ? I was literally there seen it with my own eyes. So they can but players cant give it back ? Give and take in life mate,' another said. It came after star Bulldogs signing Lachlan Galvin was verbally abused by a fan on-field before kick-off of Sunday's game. Tigers members and fans formed a long guard of honour for their players on the field before kick-off, with the large crowd taking time to disperse. Australian Associated Press has been told that in the commotion, one fan stood only metres from former Tiger Galvin and yelled at the star, who controversially left the club to join the Bulldogs mid-season. The Bulldogs are privately questioning why security was not on hand, particularly given tensions were always expected to run high with Galvin facing his old side for the first time. Galvin was booed with every touch of the ball on Sunday afternoon, but coach Cameron Ciraldo said at full-time that the 20-year-old had taken the jeering in his stride. 'Nothing much flusters him. I thought he went out there, he did his job today. I don't think it rattled him that much. It's just we got beaten as a team,' Ciraldo said.
Telegraph
44 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Lions failed to reach their full potential in Australia
There has been no stranger end to a British and Irish Lions tour than that of last Saturday in Sydney. After a break for potentially dangerous storm weather, the Lions ended the series well beaten in a game that showed what Australia might have achieved had they had the full services of Noah Lolesio, Will Skelton and Rob Valetini. If you doubt the influence of just those three players, imagine the Lions without Finn Russell, Maro Itoje and player of the series Tadhg Beirne. Andy Farrell and his cohorts deserve much praise for achieving what is still a rare goal in winning a Lions series, but the residual feeling for the tour is one of falling short. The heights that might have been achieved had the Lions played to their full potential were not reached. There will always be questions – what would have happened had Blair Kinghorn been available from the start of the tour? Should Ellis Genge have started all the Tests? Would he have put the Lions on the front foot and denied Australia the 'go forward' possession that enabled them to take leads in the second and third Tests? In the end, the thing that counts for the Lions' brand is that the tour again captured the attention of their fans who travelled in their tens of thousands. They were matched by the supporters of their hosts and together they produced a record-breaking attendance for a Lions' Test match in Melbourne. Commercially the tour has been a success, and in the end, this is the defining factor. From an England point of view, the Lions and the Argentina tour have thrown up a headache for their head coach, Steve Borthwick. And it is not a new one. What does he do about the No 10 jersey and, by extension how does he solve the 22-year-old conundrum of settling a centre partnership? This question has featured regularly over the years in this column but that is only because it has not been solved satisfactorily. The next World Cup will be imminent in less time than imagined. Where are England in this regard? Owen Farrell has returned to top-flight Test rugby and George Ford has just led an England squad to an away series victory in Argentina. Marcus Smith featured for the Lions but as a dual-capacity replacement covering fly-half and full-back. Unfortunately, Fin Smith's rise to top of the No 10 tree halted on a tour that never really fired for him. If all those possible fly-half selections are available and on form, what will Borthwick do? To start with he must make a difficult call regarding Farrell and Ford. Without reliable evidence he has to judge whether both, one, or neither will be at their best in two years' time. There is no doubting their quality and experience but those will only count if they are fit and firing. You could say that he should wait to see how they perform over the next two years, but what does he then do if they wane nearer to the tournament? This is one of the most difficult selection decisions; when do you say: 'Thanks for all you have done, but goodbye?' If you look at nearly all the past World Cup-winning teams and finalists, almost all of them have gone into the tournament with clarity on these questions. From two years out they have had in mind their preferred combinations at 10, 12 and 13 and have finessed this issue through occasional experimentation, but working from a settled combination. A fully fit Ollie Lawrence looks the most likely first-choice pick in the centre, but England are still to settle on whether he will be a 12 or 13. Henry Slade is still in the frame but Borthwick must, at some point, decide whether he is Lawrence's preferred partner and then let that combination develop. They have recently been given an extended run, but the results have not been conclusive. This situation is set to reignite a problem that has bedevilled England selection for something approaching a decade: whether to choose Farrell for his overall contribution to the England team. His leadership skills and his Test-match credentials have been apparent for years, but so has the problem of choosing him in the centre as an adjunct to his best role at fly-half. This comes back to the claim that two playmakers at 10 and 12 is a winning idea. If so, why do virtually no international coaches do this and why did Andy Farrell not start any of his Test teams in Australia with this sort of combination? I confess, I do not have the answers, beyond knowing that doing what England have done repeatedly and expecting different results is a form of madness.
