TV director accuses UK culture secretary of ‘bullying' BBC over Gaza coverage
In a strongly worded letter, Kosminsky — known for the BBC historical drama 'Wolf Hall' — likened the government's actions to those of a 'tinpot dictatorship' and warned against sustained pressure on BBC Director General Tim Davie.
'Could I respectfully suggest that you stop trying to bully the BBC, the nation's primary public service broadcaster, over its coverage of the war in Gaza,' wrote Kosminsky in the letter, reported by The Guardian.
He argued that politicians should not 'police the individual editorial decisions of the BBC,' stressing the broadcaster must, above all, maintain public trust. His letter echoed warnings from veteran BBC figure Richard Ayre, who described Nandy's direct intervention as 'outrageous.'
Nandy has been a vocal critic of the BBC, pressuring the broadcaster to withdraw its Gaza documentary 'How To Survive a Warzone' after it emerged the young narrator was the son of a Hamas official. She also criticized the broadcasting of a Glastonbury Festival segment featuring the punk-rap duo Bob Vylan chanting anti-IDF slogans.
'For its part, the BBC must ensure that its output is balanced. But this means balanced across the totality of its output,' said Kosminsky, cautioning that past conflicts between government and BBC had ended tragically and citing the death of weapons expert Dr David Kelly in 2003.
Meanwhile, the Department for Culture, Media and Sport has acknowledged recent 'serious failures' at the BBC but framed Nandy's criticism as justified accountability on behalf of license-fee payers. A spokesperson reiterated that editorial independence remained paramount.
The controversy comes amid crucial discussions over the BBC's future funding and charter renewal, adding further pressure on its leadership — particularly Davie, who faces mounting scrutiny and internal dissatisfaction over perceived lapses in impartiality and editorial oversight.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
2 hours ago
- Arab News
Former diplomats urge UK prime minister to recognize Palestinian state
LONDON: More than 30 former UK ambassadors and 20 former senior diplomats at the UN have urged Prime Minister Keir Starmer to recognize a Palestinian state, as international outrage grows over the distressing scenes in Gaza. The former diplomats have represented the UK in Afghanistan, Bahrain, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Morocco, Pakistan, Qatar, Syria and Turkiye, as well as the UN. Their statement adds to the growing pressure on Starmer from ministers and senior figures in the ruling Labour Party, including the mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, to address the question of Palestine. Starvation has affected the 2 million residents of the Gaza Strip amid Israeli attacks and aid restrictions. Khan said on Wednesday that the scenes in Gaza were harrowing and that 'nothing justifies the actions of the Israeli government.' He asserted that there 'can be no two-state solution if there is no viable state left to call Palestine.' The former diplomats warned that 'the risks of inaction have profound, historic and catastrophic implications,' and called on Starmer to seize the 'moment to recognise Palestinian statehood unconditionally. '(Israel) cannot be secure from threats in the future if the question of Palestine is not taken forward to a political settlement,' they said. The statement added: 'In the face of the current horror and impunity, words are not enough … a partial suspension of arms sales, delays on trade talks and limited sanctions are far from the full extent of the pressure the UK can bring to bear on Israel.' Recognising a Palestinian state would be a 'foundational first step toward breaking the deadly status quo,' the letter said. The UK has consistently stated it would recognize Palestine in conjunction with allies 'at the point of maximum impact.' A rescheduled international conference will be held in New York City from July 28-29, sponsored by Saudi Arabia and France, to gather support for the recognition of Palestinian statehood. The organizers postponed the gathering planned for June due to the sudden conflict between Israel and Iran that occurred in the same month. Former diplomats urged Starmer to use the event to create a constructive plan that includes statehood for both Palestinians and Israelis. On Wednesday, Stephen Cottrell, the de facto leader of the Church of England, said Israel's 'war of aggression' in Gaza was a 'grave sin.' He said: 'With each passing day in Gaza, the violence, starvation and dehumanization being inflicted on the civilian population by the government of Israel becomes more depraved and unconscionable. 'In the name of God, I cry out against this barbaric assault on human life and dignity. It is a stain on the conscience of the international community and a flagrant breach of international humanitarian law.' Cottrell called for an immediate ceasefire, the release of all hostages and the rebuilding of the Palestinian coastal territory.
Al Arabiya
6 hours ago
- Al Arabiya
Birmingham mourns the death of native son Ozzy Osbourne
Ozzy Osbourne's fans had sensed the end was near. At his final show just a few weeks ago, admirers watched the heavy metal icon perform while seated on a black throne and knew it would likely be the last time they saw the lead singer of Black Sabbath. He died Tuesday at age 76. So there was little surprise Wednesday as they made pilgrimages to sites around Birmingham, the city in central England where Osbourne grew up and the band was formed. Outside the Crown Pub, where Black Sabbath played its first gig, Daria DeBuono, 59, and Stephen Voland, 32, both from New York, described the bond the rockstar had with his fans during that farewell show at the city's Villa Park stadium. Even though he stayed seated throughout, the man nicknamed the Prince of Darkness reveled in the embrace of the crowd, they said. 'It's like that is what he was living for, that is what he was keeping himself alive for, was to have that final glorious moment of love,' DeBuono said. 'And being in the crowd, you can just feel the love in the arena that day. It was just very emotional,' Voland completed her thought. 'When I was watching the show, I told her, 'This is like a living memorial that he gets to enjoy,'' he said. 'All this hard work and everyone is here for him. I just felt like it was a cool thing not knowing that this was happening very soon after.' The original members of Black Sabbath reunited for the first time in 20 years on July 5 for what Osbourne said would be his final concert. Osbourne had been diagnosed with Parkinson's disease in 2019. 'Let the madness begin!' he told the 42,000 fans packed into Villa Park as the show got underway. On Wednesday, Birmingham sites linked to Black Sabbath became magnets for fans of the band's front man, who built a second career as a star of the reality TV show 'The Osbournes.' They gathered around the bull in Birmingham New Street station, which was created for the 2022 Commonwealth Games and is known as 'Ozzy.' And they trooped to a mural on Navigation Street that was painted in honor of Black Sabbath's farewell concert. 'He's one of us,' West Midlands region Mayor Richard Parker said at the mural. 'There is an enormous amount of pride – he was forged by this place and he put this place on the map and everyone could relate to him.' But the biggest draw was the Black Sabbath bench, where fans can take selfies alongside life-size images of the four band members. The bench, which was unveiled on the Broad Street canal bridge in 2019, has been surrounded by tributes to Osbourne. 'I think it is so beautiful that he got to finish and do his wish before he finally passed,' said Matthew Caldwell, 36, of Stourbridge, just west of Birmingham. 'Very sad but incredible.'
Arab News
6 hours ago
- Arab News
Mayor of London urges UK government to recognize Palestinian state
LONDON: The Mayor of London Sadiq Khan has urged the UK government to recognize a Palestinian state as pressure mounts from the ruling Labour Party on Prime Minister Keir Starmer ahead of a UN conference addressing the Palestinian question. Khan said on Wednesday that the UK government should 'immediately recognize Palestinian statehood' and asserted that there 'can be no two-state solution if there is no viable state left to call Palestine.' Senior Labour figures, including Wes Streeting, Shabana Mahmood, and Hilary Benn, have called on the UK government to bring forward its recognition of Palestine. The UK has consistently stated it would recognize Palestine in conjunction with allies 'at the point of maximum impact.' A rescheduled international conference will be held in New York from July 28-29, sponsored by Saudi Arabia and France, to gather support for the recognition of Palestinian statehood. The organizers postponed the gathering planned for June due to the sudden conflict between Israel and Iran that occurred in the same month. Khan's statement comes against the backdrop of starvation impacting the 2 million residents of the Gaza Strip amid ongoing Israeli attacks and aid restrictions. Khan said that 'the absolutely harrowing scenes of suffering in Gaza are being made worse by the day, with no sign of the crisis abating.' He added: 'Starving children searching hopelessly for food in the rubble; family members shot dead by Israeli soldiers as they search for aid. In heartbreaking scenes, innocent lives are being torn apart before the eyes of the world. 'The international community — including our own government – must do far more to pressure the Israeli government to stop this horrific, senseless killing and let vital lifesaving aid in. Nothing justifies the actions of the Israeli government. 'The UK must immediately recognize Palestinian statehood. There can be no two-state solution if there is no viable state left to call Palestine.' Khan's remarks echoed a rare intervention on foreign policy by Streeting, the health minister, during a parliamentary session on Tuesday. Streeting said: 'I sincerely hope that the international community can come together, as the foreign secretary has been driving towards, to make sure that we see an end of this war, but also that we recognize the state of Palestine while there is a state of Palestine left to recognize.'
