Patient gets Dhs1 million compensation for medical error at a Dubai hospital
The Court of First Instance had previously ruled to compensate the patient with Dhs7.5 million, but both the hospital and the patient's family appealed the verdict.
The details of the case date back to March 2023, when the patient underwent a surgical procedure using laser to remove a cervical disc and local injection of cortisone, under the supervision of a medical team consisting of a surgeon and an anesthesiologist.
After the operation, the patient allegedly experienced serious complications which resulted in a complete brain damage due to oxygen deprivation, causing him to fall into a permanent coma.
The patient's family filed a complaint with the Medical Liability Committee at the Dubai Health Authority (DHA) and then with the Higher Medical Liability Committee (HMLC).
Both committees affirmed in their reports that a severe medical error had occurred, along with negligence on the part of the anesthesiologist for leaving the operating room before the patient regained consciousness.
The report concluded that both the surgeon and the anesthesiologist were held responsible for the error, with a 50% share of responsibility for each.
The patient's family filed a compensation claim before the civil court, demanding a compensation of Dhs57 million for the material and moral damages they suffered due to the loss of their primary breadwinner.
After examining the case, the Court of First Instance issued a ruling obliging the hospital and the doctors to pay a compensation of Dhs7.5 million, with a legal interest of 5% annually from the date of the ruling until full payment.
Following the ruling, both parties filed appeals before the Appellate Court and the plaintiffs demanded an increase in the compensation amount to Dhs57 million, while the appellees challenged the ruling, requesting complete annulment.
After examining the appeals, the Appellate Court decided to modify the ruling of the Court of First Instance by reducing the compensation amount to Dhs1 million. The court also ordered the appellees to jointly pay the amount, along with bearing the legal fees.
Dr Alaa Nasr, the legal representative of the patient and his family, stated that determining the compensation amount is the court's responsibility, that assesses it based on its estimation of the material and moral damages incurred by the harmed party.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
4 days ago
- Zawya
Emirates Post issues commemorative stamp, marking Supreme Council for Motherhood and Childhood's 20th anniversary
United Arab Emirates: Emirates Post, in collaboration with the Supreme Council for Motherhood and Childhood, issued a commemorative stamp to celebrate the 20th anniversary of the Council's foundation, celebrating its profound contributions to UAE society. The stamp commemorates the Council's journey since its establishment in 2003 by the late Sheikh Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan, whose visionary leadership laid the foundation for the UAE's progress. It also underscores the Council's pivotal role over the past two decades in championing the rights and welfare of mothers and children, under the leadership of H.H. Sheikha Fatima bint Mubarak, Chairwoman of the General Women's Union, President of the Supreme Council for Motherhood and Childhood, and Supreme Chairwoman of the Family Development Foundation, Mother of the Nation. This commemorative issue highlights the Council's unwavering efforts to enhance maternal and child welfare across the UAE, reinforcing its role as the official national body entrusted with addressing issues related to motherhood and childhood. The Council remains a foundational institution within the UAE's social framework, dedicated to safeguarding the well-being of mothers and children. H.E. Rym Abdullah Al Falasy, Secretary-General of the Supreme Council for Motherhood & Childhood, emphasised that the Council's accomplishments over its 20-year journey are largely attributed to the steadfast support and vision of H.H. Sheikha Fatima bint Mubarak. Her Highness's leadership has significantly advanced the maternal and childhood sector, aligning it with the aspirations of UAE mothers and the hopes of their children. H.E. Al Falasy noted that Her Highness has been the Council's strongest advocate, closely overseeing its progress and cultivating a nurturing environment that has yielded substantial benefits for mothers and children nationwide. H.E. added: 'These efforts have translated into world-class opportunities, services, and capabilities, surpassing the standards of the most advanced nations. As a result, mothers and children have become central to the UAE's sustainable development and active contributors to its promising future.' H.E. further remarked that the commemorative stamp serves as a tribute to two decades of dedicated service and unwavering commitment to empowering two of the nation's most cherished segments. It also reflects the Council's initiatives that align with the UAE leadership's vision of placing people at the core of national priorities, enhancing well-being, ensuring happiness, and improving quality of life. Tariq Al Wahedi, Group CEO of 7X, said: 'This commemorative stamp reflects the dedication of Emirates Post to preserving the UAE's rich cultural legacy and honouring its outstanding achievements. Postal stamps have long served as faithful chronicles of the nation's evolution, capturing milestones, progress, and values for future generations. This collaboration with the Supreme Council for Motherhood and Childhood celebrates its vital role in empowering mothers and children, reinforcing the UAE's global reputation as a beacon of social welfare and sustainable development.' The stamp design features the date July 30, the day the official decree establishing the Supreme Council for Motherhood and Childhood was published in the UAE's Official Gazette in 2003, alongside an image of the Council's newly inaugurated headquarters bearing its official name. The headquarters' distinctive architecture stands as a symbol of the Council's progress and enduring legacy. It represents the Council's trailblazing initiatives to elevate social welfare for mothers and children, while fostering a culture of innovation and creativity that enables both to thrive and actively shape their communities, driven by a bold vision for a society rooted in well-being and happiness. -Ends-
The National
5 days ago
- The National
Gaza mothers 20 times more likely to die in childbirth since conflict began
Gaza's mothers are 20 times more likely to die in childbirth 20 than before Israel 's war on the strip, UN health officials have revealed. Birth rates have also dropped by 40 per cent, and more than 5,000 recent newborns were underweight, premature or required intensive care, according to the UN's fund for reproductive and maternal health, UNFPA. The agency's director for the Arab world, Laila Baker, told The National that Israel's killing of mothers, the starvation of children and the attacking of an IVF hospital where thousands of embryos 'that were the lifelines' were destroyed, were all 'indicators of genocidal acts'. She said Israel has also blocked the entry of hygiene products to Gaza, claiming they are 'dual use items' that could have a military purpose. 'They say that sanitary pads which are included in our hygiene kits can be used to stop the bleeding of wounded people,' Ms Baker said. In place of sanitary pads, girls and women have had to use rags cut from filthy tents – causing infections to rise, she said. A UN report in March found that Israel's systematic destruction of sexual and reproductive healthcare centres checks two categories of genocidal acts in two war crimes treaties, the Rome Statute and the Genocide Convention. Little relief Amid massive international pressure over Gaza's starvation, Israel said it would start allowing aid into the enclave after more than 120 days of deprivation that has encompassed the most vital of products including flour, baby formula and sanitary pads. Following Israel 's announcement, what little aid entered on Sunday never made it to UN warehouses because desperate and hungry civilians took what they could from the lorries to secure something for their families, the World Food Programme (WFP) told The National. 'It does not take a genius to connect the dots that when you don't have proper nutrition for women who need twice the food and water while pregnant and nursing, that will have an immediate impact on them and their children if they even survive,' Ms Baker said. Additionally, women tend to prioritise others over themselves even when there's a scarcity in water, hygiene, space and food, which places an additional strain on those already suffering, she added. The World Health Organisation (WHO) on Sunday said that of the 74 recorded hunger-related deaths in 2025, 63 had occurred in July − including 24 children aged under five, one child older than five and 38 adults. On Tuesday, a report by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) said famine was unfolding in Gaza. 'Mounting evidence shows that widespread starvation, malnutrition and disease are driving a rise in hunger-related deaths,' the report said. The head of the International Rescue Committee, David Miliband, warned that thousands of Gaza's children will either be rescued or allowed to die depending on whether land crossings are opened and unfettered humanitarian access is granted to the people in Gaza. 'That is the choice before us,' he said.
The National
5 days ago
- The National
Gaza mothers die in childbirth 20 times more often due to Israel's war
Gaza's mothers are dying in childbirth 20 times more often than before Israel 's war on the strip, UN health officials have revealed. Birth rates have also dropped by 40 per cent, and more than 5,000 recent newborns were underweight, premature or required intensive care, according to the UN's fund for reproductive and maternal health, UNFPA. The agency's director for the Arab world, Laila Baker, told The National that Israel's killing of mothers, the starvation of children and the attacking of an IVF hospital where thousands of embryos 'that were the lifelines' were destroyed, were all 'indicators of genocidal acts'. She said Israel has also blocked the entry of hygiene products to Gaza, claiming they are 'dual use items' that could have a military purpose. 'They say that sanitary pads which are included in our hygiene kits can be used to stop the bleeding of wounded people,' Ms Baker said. In place of sanitary pads, girls and women have had to use rags cut from filthy tents – causing infections to rise, she said. A UN report in March found that Israel's systematic destruction of sexual and reproductive healthcare centres checks two categories of genocidal acts in two war crimes treaties, the Rome Statute and the Genocide Convention. Little relief Amid massive international pressure over Gaza's starvation, Israel said it would start allowing aid into the enclave after more than 120 days of deprivation that has encompassed the most vital of products including flour, baby formula and sanitary pads. Following Israel 's announcement, what little aid entered on Sunday never made it to UN warehouses because desperate and hungry civilians took what they could from the lorries to secure something for their families, the World Food Programme (WFP) told The National. 'It does not take a genius to connect the dots that when you don't have proper nutrition for women who need twice the food and water while pregnant and nursing, that will have an immediate impact on them and their children if they even survive,' Ms Baker said. Additionally, women tend to prioritise others over themselves even when there's a scarcity in water, hygiene, space and food, which places an additional strain on those already suffering, she added. The World Health Organisation (WHO) on Sunday said that of the 74 recorded hunger-related deaths in 2025, 63 had occurred in July − including 24 children aged under five, one child older than five and 38 adults. On Tuesday, a report by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) said famine was unfolding in Gaza. 'Mounting evidence shows that widespread starvation, malnutrition and disease are driving a rise in hunger-related deaths,' the report said. The head of the International Rescue Committee, David Miliband, warned that thousands of Gaza's children will either be rescued or allowed to die depending on whether land crossings are opened and unfettered humanitarian access is granted to the people in Gaza. 'That is the choice before us,' he said.
