SC refuses to reverse Bombay HC ban on pigeon feeding
A bench of justices JK Maheshwari and Vijay Bishnoi noted that proceedings in the matter remain pending before the Bombay High Court, which is expected to take up the case again on August 13.
'Parallel indulgence by this Court is not proper. Petitioner can move the High Court for modification of the order,' said the bench, refusing to interfere.
The Bombay High Court, hearing multiple petitions by animal lovers and rights activists challenging the BMC's demolition of decades-old kabutarkhanas, had initially stayed the demolition but barred feeding. On July 30, after noting continued feeding and obstruction of civic officials, the high court ordered criminal cases under relevant provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), calling the acts a 'public nuisance likely to spread diseases and endanger human life.'
Also Read: HC directs formation of 'expert committee 'to address pigeon feeding dispute in Pune
Earlier, on July 24, the high court had warned that pigeon breeding and large congregations at kabutarkhanas posed a 'grave social concern', stressing the decision was in the 'larger interest of societal health, from children to senior citizens.'
In court, BMC presented medical evidence that pigeon droppings and feathers can trigger asthma, hypersensitivity, pneumonitis, and lung fibrosis -- conditions with no cure once advanced. The civic body argued that many victims realise the damage only after irreversible harm to the lungs.
Petitioners in the Supreme Court, including Pallavi Sachin Patil, argued that pigeon feeding is a long-standing religious practice, particularly among Hindu devotees and the Jain community, with some 51 feeding spots in Mumbai operating for decades. They claimed health concerns were overstated and that asthma was more directly linked to pollution from vehicles and open burning. They proposed alternatives such as bird towers to allow human-pigeon coexistence.
The crackdown has sparked street protests. On August 6, hundreds clashed with police at Dadar 'kabutarkhana', tearing down tarpaulin sheets erected to block feeding. Two days earlier, over 1,000 community members protested after the site was barricaded with bamboo poles and covered.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
In Mumbai, 200 people protest against civic body hospital privatisation
Mumbai: Nearly 200 residents and activists protested in Cheetah Camp and Mankhurd on Monday against BMC's plan to privatise two peripheral hospitals and key health services in five others. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now A total of 20 participants also sat on a hunger strike near Maharashtra Nagar Maternity Home, demanding stronger public health infrastructure. The protest, the second in recent weeks under the coalition banner 'Aspatal Bachao, Nijikarn Hatao', brought together 25 civil society groups and political parties. Activists remembered residents who died because of poor hospital facilities and shortages. In a statement, the group alleged that more than half the women who visit smaller facilities like Shahji Nagar and Deonar maternity homes are sent directly to larger hospitals such as Sion hospital or Rajawadi Hospital in critical condition. "Several patients die during these referrals due to lack of timely treatment," the statement read, adding that the cost of travel, medicines, and tests pushes families into debt within days. On Saturday, TOI reported that the BMC plans to gradually privatise individual services, including blood banks, cardiology, and MRI at other peripheral hospitals, after a similar union faced protests when it tried to run entire hospitals on a public-private partnership. Protesters demanded the immediate recruitment at the Maharashtra Nagar Maternity Home, restoration of paediatric ICUs, scrapping of all public-private partnership projects in civic hospitals, and guarantees that no patient will be denied care for lack of identification. They also called for a citywide plan to improve govt hospitals and weekly meetings with the municipal health officer to address complaints. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Shubham Kothari of the Jan Haq Sangharsh Samiti said the demonstrators met chief medical superintendent of peripheral hospitals Chandrakant Pawar and were promised their concerns would be raised with senior authorities. Pawar was unavailable for comment.
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Kerala welcomes Supreme Court decision precluding local bodies from releasing captured dogs back on streets
The Supreme Court decision preventing civic authorities from releasing strays captured for sterilisation and rabies immunisation back on the streets had come as a fillip for the Left Democratic Front (LDF) government's bid to control the growing street dog menace in the State. Local Self-Governments Minister M.B. Rajesh said the court on Monday flagged the impracticality and absurdity of the Animal Birth Control (ABC) rules insisted by the Union government. The law required Corporations, municipalities and panchayats to release the strays into the neighbourhoods from which authorities captured them. Mr. Rajesh said the Central government has tied the hands of the State government to control the perilous stray dog menace by obstinately refusing to change the farcical rules. The abounding stray dog population in the State posed a major public health and safety issue for citizens, which local bodies struggled to mitigate, he said. He said opposition parties deliberately ignored the elephant in the room, the Centre's impossible ABC rules, and assailed the government whenever stray dogs attacked children, passersby, pedestrians and two-wheeler riders. Stray dogs have ambushed scores of pedestrians, including school students and menaced wheeled riders, resulting in dog bite injuries and road accidents. Free-roaming dogs were also a threat to early-morning walkers and cyclists. Packs of strays have taken over public parks, making it perilous for citizens to walk their pet dogs. 11 deaths this year Moreover, since January, at least 11 people have died after contracting rabies in the State, including three children. The deaths raised questions about the efficacy of the vaccine and the control of stray dogs in Kerala. According to Health department figures, 100,504 dog bite injuries were reported in the State until April 30, with Thiruvananthapuram topping the list with 15,718 cases. A 2001 Central law banned the culling of strays and emphasised the need for animal birth control programmes. Officials also pointed out that a dearth of kennels, dog pounds, dog catchers, and veterinarians in the State hampered the government's stray dog control measures. Moreover, the SC had precluded the government from releasing sterilised and immunised dogs back on the streets, entailing huge costs for local bodies to keep, feed and treat them in expansive pounds. Moreover, the State government has faced public resistance against setting up ABC centres in residential areas, including those in the less congested suburbs.
Indian Express
6 hours ago
- Indian Express
Why, to tackle the stray dog problem, it is important to make pet owners accountable, too
The Supreme Court on Monday (August 11) directed the Delhi government, civic bodies, and authorities of Noida, Gurgaon, and Ghaziabad to round up and move stray dogs to shelters, underlining the urgency in tackling the 'grim situation'. A Bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and R Mahadevan said: 'Infants and young children, at any cost, should not fall prey to rabies. The action should inspire confidence that they can move freely without fear of being bitten by stray dogs. No sentiments should be involved.' For many, the intervention of the top court has come as a major relief. But the intervention may not produce the desired effect without also making pet owners accountable. This is because the plight and the menace of stray dogs in India are a direct consequence of irresponsible pet rearing. There are more than 60 million stray dogs in India. Very few of them survive disease and vehicular accidents to die natural deaths. Also, someone is bitten by a dog in India every 10 seconds. This works out to more than 3 million bites a year, of which around 5,000 turn out to be fatal. Dogs spread more than 60 diseases to people. Rabies alone claims at least two human lives every three hours. More than 15,000 tonnes of dog poop and 8 million gallons of dog pee – a major health and environmental hazard – is discharged on Indian roads and fields daily. India's pet dog population was estimated at 30 million in 2024. The population of pet dogs, along with India's dog food market, has grown at 10-15% per year over the last five years. The size of the Indian pet dog industry, currently worth Rs 300 crore, is projected to double by 2030. There are upscale dog hotels such as Critterati in Gurgaon, and dog grooming parlours such as Scoopy Scrub in Delhi, Fuzzy Wuzzy in Bengaluru, and Tailwaggers in Mumbai. Companies such as Bajaj Allianz and Future Generali offer dog health insurance. While cherishing their 'best friends' at home, Indians have been far less kind to them on the street. Historically, there have been efforts to eliminate the stray dog problem by means including electrocution, poisoning, shooting, or just clubbing them to death. But long before the killing of dogs became an animal rights issue, it had become evident that short of elimination en masse, this would not have a lasting effect on the population of strays. As food becomes increasingly abundant (garbage dumps, and individual and organised feeders), the partial elimination of the stray population reduces the competition for resources and boosts breeding. Thus came the idea of sterilisation. Since 1992, NGOs such as Chennai-based Blue Cross of India, and various governments have carried out Animal Birth Control (ABC) programmes in several cities. In 2001, the Animal Birth Control (Dogs) Rules were notified under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960. However, unless at least two-thirds of a canine population is sterilised within a small (typically 6-12 months) window, ABC drives fail to have any stabilising effect. With the job left to a few NGOs, every Indian city has struggled to achieve the target that requires neutering hundreds of stray dogs every day for months. But even if that mark is hit, stray dog populations may still continue to increase. There is no national law in India that requires dog owners to register their pets. A few cities have such rules, but enforcement remains shoddy. It is not mandatory to get pets sterilised or vaccinated either. Since owners are not accountable for their dogs or their dogs' pups, hundreds of unwanted pet dogs and pups are abandoned on the street daily. Also, thousands of pet dogs are allowed to roam or break free and breed with street strays. In consequence, even as governments and NGOs continue to neuter a few dogs on the street, pet dogs, thanks to callous owners, add to the stray population. This is also why the so-called 'Indian street dog' is mostly mongrels of various crossbreeds. The solution, experts say, is to have ABC drives target pedigreed pets with high breeding frequency. The government could offer incentives to owners to get their pets registered and sterilised. A steep tax may be levied on breeding pets. The problem with petting without owning Equally irresponsible is the trend of petting dogs outside the home. In all cities, neighbourhood good samaritans feed stray dogs on the streets outside their homes or workplaces. This has the same effect as petting, and turns stray dogs territorial and aggressive. Such feeding has also created monsters of monkeys in many parts of India. Over the decades, governments cutting across party lines have sponsored the feeding of stray dogs by various organisations. In The Ecology of Stray Dogs: A Study of Free-ranging Urban Animals (1973), possibly the most authoritative work on the subject, Alan Beck wrote: 'Loose or straying pets and stray (feral) dogs are different. True stray dogs form somewhat stable packs… are more active at night and cautious about people. In general, straying pets have smaller home ranges and [are] active when people are.' This is why abandoned or proxy pet dogs on the street are more likely to be aggressive towards people who do not pet (or feed) them. Thus, not only do some pet owners contribute to the growing population of strays, they also bear responsibility for many dog attacks on people. Anticipating resistance from some quarters, the Supreme Court warned on Monday that any individual or organisation coming in the way of implementing its order would face legal action. It may widen its gaze to make pet owners and proxy pet feeders accountable when it hears the matter again after six weeks. Jay Mazoomdaar is an investigative reporter focused on offshore finance, equitable growth, natural resources management and biodiversity conservation. Over two decades, his work has been recognised by the International Press Institute, the Ramnath Goenka Foundation, the Commonwealth Press Union, the Prem Bhatia Memorial Trust, the Asian College of Journalism etc. Mazoomdaar's major investigations include the extirpation of tigers in Sariska, global offshore probes such as Panama Papers, Robert Vadra's land deals in Rajasthan, India's dubious forest cover data, Vyapam deaths in Madhya Pradesh, mega projects flouting clearance conditions, Nitin Gadkari's link to e-rickshaws, India shifting stand on ivory ban to fly in African cheetahs, the loss of indigenous cow breeds, the hydel rush in Arunachal Pradesh, land mafias inside Corbett, the JDY financial inclusion scheme, an iron ore heist in Odisha, highways expansion through the Kanha-Pench landscape etc. ... Read More
