Safety fears over lack of harbour lighting
A 2023 assessment, undertaken as part of the Holmes Wharf Refurbishment project, identified that the overhead power lines, poles and streetlights around the harbour had failed.
Consequently, and in view of the public safety risk, the pre-1960 poles were removed and the power disconnected. The height of some of the poles was reduced to be repurposed as bollards along the northern side.
Two years later, a report to Waitaki District Council's (WDC) harbour area sub-committee says there are now three options to restore lighting.
"Network Waitaki has assessed overhead power as an option and have indicated underground power would be the preferred option moving forward. A shared trench system for multiple services would provide best value for money and flexibility of use in the future.
"The current situation at Holmes Wharf is undesirable, in that commercial fishermen and boat owners operate without light when tying up or unloading. Without sufficient area lighting, there is also a greater risk to both the public using the wharf and waterborne traffic."
Otago Regional Council's (ORC) Harbourmaster had already raised safety concerns regarding the lack of area lighting.
Harbourmaster Steve Rushbrook said, while he had no issues personally as the navigational lights at the harbour entrance were working, he had had two discussions around the high-level flood light on the end of the wharf.
"It has been there a long time and, when functional, it helps show the rocks at the end of the wharf during the hours of darkness. To the best of my knowledge, it has been a good aid when entering and departing Oamaru Harbour, as the channel is all to one side at this location.
"The rest of the wharf is in darkness with no current lighting. While this is not an ORC area, I have spoken with WDC to identify this issue."
People exercising and jogging around the harbour area, particularly the Sumpter Wharf side, in the evenings said they had also raised safety concerns due to being in darkness.
The new WDC report said a resource consent was approved last September and would remain in place for five years to allow for entrenching of the power supply for staged delivery of electrical and utility services via underground ducting, in partnership with Network Waitaki.
Doing so would resolve the health and safety concerns, but the report points out replacement lighting was not part of the original refurbishment project and there is no funding set aside in the council's 2025-34 Long-term Plan for such works.
Works are estimated to cost between $213,000 to just install a high-voltage power supply and street lighting and up to $428,000 to also provide reticulated power to harbour berths and install services at Holmes Wharf sheds.
The harbour sub-committee will discuss the report on Tuesday.
andrew.ashton@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
12 hours ago
- Scoop
ORC Modifying Its Shotover Testing Regime
Otago Regional Council is modifying its testing programme at the Queenstown Lakes District Council owned and operated Shotover Wastewater Treatment Plant near Queenstown with water testing and plant site visits moving from weekly to monthly. This decision balances the need to ensure a robust monitoring programme which provides assurance to the people of Queenstown and downstream from the discharge, with the need to ensure prudent financial management, where appropriate monitoring and oversight is already in place. There will still be weekly water testing of the Kawarau River downstream of the treatment plant site and monthly on-site visits and auditing of the plant. Test results will continue to be made public, says ORC's General Manager Environmental Delivery, Joanna Gilroy. 'Monitoring of compliance on site with the Enforcement Order and consents remains a high priority for ORC.' 'We have confidence in the combination of the sampling required under the Enforcement Order, our continued weekly sampling of the Kawarau at our Chard Road monitoring site plus our continued monthly full site sampling and audits at the plant.' 'This monitoring regime will maintain the high standard expected,' she says. All the results from the independent lab will continue to be made public and ORC will maintain on-site visits once a month and respond to any complaints, Ms Gilroy says. Staff will continue to audit sample results and information supplied to Council to ensure compliance. Monthly sampling, or sampling after any incident, will continue from the established sites; below. Upstream entirely of the Shotover WWTP and ponds (before the SH6 bridge) Final discharge post-UV treatment Discharge to the river (at the last realistic and safe point) Approximately 200 metres downstream Upstream of Kawarau River Downstream of Kawarau River (past Shotover river) ORC will also continue to monitor the Kawarau River at Chard Road site once a week. 'These sites have been chosen so that any impacts on the Shotover and Kawarau can be monitored. Samples will be taken by ORC staff in line with previous sampling processes and the results will still be analysed at an independent laboratory,' she says. Once results have been returned to ORC from the lab and checked by staff, they will continue to be uploaded to ORC's Shotover web site. Ms Gilroy notes the results may not be uploaded on the web site until 10 or more days after the sample is taken, due to lab processing times and the need to consider whether the results may be required to be used as evidence in the future. Any results and data shown will not give any indication of compliance status, any environmental effect or any potential compliance action, she says. Background What monitoring has ORC been doing of the site since before April 2025? ORC has been regularly undertaking testing to monitor compliance with consented limits and conditions. This occurred at a standard series of locations to enable trend data to be collected. Testing included investigation of E. coli – Escherichia coli, TBOD – Total Biochemical Oxygen Demand, TN – Total Nitrogen, and TSS – Total Suspended Solids. The samples were analysed based on consents parameters, and, where appropriate, other parameters used to detect wastewater. Sampling is completed by ORC staff in line with sampling procedures and analysed in an independent lab. From 7 April 2025 a new set of standardised sampling locations were set up to specifically monitor the discharge on site. These sites will be sampled weekly until 18 August, and will then move to monthly, along with a monthly site inspection. What monitoring is happening at the Shotover site from August ? After 18 August, ORC will be doing monthly testing on site to monitor compliance with consented limits and conditions and the Enforcement Order rather than weekly. This will happen at the standard series of locations to enable trend data to continue to be collected. Testing will include investigation of E. coli – Escherichia coli, TBOD – Total Biochemical Oxygen Demand, TN – Total Nitrogen, and TSS – Total Suspended Solids. Will ORC continue the current monitoring of the site under the Enforcement Order ? Yes. Under the Enforcement Order, QLDC is required to undertake monitoring on site. ORC will audit this monitoring and the results regularly to ensure that they are compliant and to check for any impacts on waterways. These results will continue to be supplied on this webpage. ORC will continue to monitor the Kawarau River at Chard Road State of the Environment Monitoring site once a week to ensure the community has access to frequent monitoring results and to continue to provide information to downstream water users. What information did ORC base its decision on to change the monitoring approach? With the Enforcement Order in place, as well as the monitoring required under the resource consent, QLDC are now required to undertake a wide range of monitoring and supply these results to ORC. ORC staff have reviewed what QLDC are required to do under their Enforcement Order; what the results of ORC's monitoring programme to date have shown and balanced this against the continued need to provide information and confidence to the public. With this in the mind the monitoring for the site has changed to monthly compliance sampling on site and the continuation of weekly monitoring of the Kawarau River at Chard Road will continue. Will the monitoring approach change again? Potentially. The approach to monitoring will be reconsidered once any decision is reached on the consent, or if there are impacts on the environment or when upgrades are made at the site.
Otago Daily Times
20 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
New book-a-seat bus service ‘unreliable': residents
Mosgiel residents and frequent bus-users (from left) Becky Campbell, Vicki Clinch, Theo Campbell, 3, Arthur Guthrie, 2, Kate Guthrie and 9-week-old Maeve Guthrie in the pram pause on their way to catch the Orbus On Demand service home. PHOTO: GREGOR RICHARDSON Mosgiel residents are being left high and dry thanks to the botched rollout of a new on-demand bus system, a regular user of the service says. At the end of June, the Orbus on-demand service was rolled out where users book a spot on the bus to request a ride. It replaced the previous loop service, which ran once every 40 minutes on weekdays. But Mosgiel resident and frequent bus user Becky Campbell said the rollout of the new service had been botched, leaving people frustrated by faults and cancellations. The Otago Regional Council acknowledged the rollout had come with challenges, but said the system was new to the council as well and it was working hard to iron out the teething issues. Mrs Campbell said the new service had led to many people giving up on using the service altogether. "One woman said it's just too unreliable. Another man has had to buy a mobility scooter because it's just impossible for him to organise getting on to the service." Mrs Campbell said complications with the system had made her morning kindergarten drop-offs a challenge. "We are always panicked, because we don't know if we're going to make it on time to pick the kids up after kindergarten." Mrs Campbell's friend, Kate Guthrie, said there had been cases of both of them attempting to book the bus, but one of them receiving the message it was booked out. "When you order the bus, it only picks one person at a time — 22 seats just for you." They said they would like to see a return to the regular loop circuit, as it was more reliable, and easier for Mosgiel's elderly residents to use. ORC implementation lead for transport Julian Phillips said there were operational challenges and the system was new to everyone. "We appreciate the change is a big one and we are currently planning further community engagement and looking at ways we can assist all Mosgiel residents to use the service." He said one adjustment for the service had already been made on July 21, which had led to a reduction in cancelled bookings. There was room for further tweaks to the system and he was keen to hear feedback. "We want all Mosgiel residents to feel enabled to use the service. We would love anyone who hasn't tried the service to give it a go by downloading the app, signing up and making a booking, or booking over the phone."
Otago Daily Times
6 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Safety fears over lack of harbour lighting
After two years in the dark, moves are being made to address the safety concerns of boaties and people using Oamaru Harbour at night. A 2023 assessment, undertaken as part of the Holmes Wharf Refurbishment project, identified that the overhead power lines, poles and streetlights around the harbour had failed. Consequently, and in view of the public safety risk, the pre-1960 poles were removed and the power disconnected. The height of some of the poles was reduced to be repurposed as bollards along the northern side. Two years later, a report to Waitaki District Council's (WDC) harbour area sub-committee says there are now three options to restore lighting. "Network Waitaki has assessed overhead power as an option and have indicated underground power would be the preferred option moving forward. A shared trench system for multiple services would provide best value for money and flexibility of use in the future. "The current situation at Holmes Wharf is undesirable, in that commercial fishermen and boat owners operate without light when tying up or unloading. Without sufficient area lighting, there is also a greater risk to both the public using the wharf and waterborne traffic." Otago Regional Council's (ORC) Harbourmaster had already raised safety concerns regarding the lack of area lighting. Harbourmaster Steve Rushbrook said, while he had no issues personally as the navigational lights at the harbour entrance were working, he had had two discussions around the high-level flood light on the end of the wharf. "It has been there a long time and, when functional, it helps show the rocks at the end of the wharf during the hours of darkness. To the best of my knowledge, it has been a good aid when entering and departing Oamaru Harbour, as the channel is all to one side at this location. "The rest of the wharf is in darkness with no current lighting. While this is not an ORC area, I have spoken with WDC to identify this issue." People exercising and jogging around the harbour area, particularly the Sumpter Wharf side, in the evenings said they had also raised safety concerns due to being in darkness. The new WDC report said a resource consent was approved last September and would remain in place for five years to allow for entrenching of the power supply for staged delivery of electrical and utility services via underground ducting, in partnership with Network Waitaki. Doing so would resolve the health and safety concerns, but the report points out replacement lighting was not part of the original refurbishment project and there is no funding set aside in the council's 2025-34 Long-term Plan for such works. Works are estimated to cost between $213,000 to just install a high-voltage power supply and street lighting and up to $428,000 to also provide reticulated power to harbour berths and install services at Holmes Wharf sheds. The harbour sub-committee will discuss the report on Tuesday.
