Florida bill would shift responsibility when a tree falls on a neighbor's home
But if your neighbor's tree falls on your house, you could be responsible for the damage.
It's called the Massachusetts rule, and State Senator Jonathan Martin (R-Fort Myers) believes it's outlived its usefulness.
'This Massachusetts Rule is hundreds of years old, and it was put in place back when everyone lived on farms. Nobody had houses on their property lines and if a tree fell on your property, that was free wood,' said Martin during a committee hearing in early April.
Martin is sponsoring legislation that would make homeowners responsible for damage caused by trees on their property.
Mark Friedlander with the Insurance Information Institute argues the 'Fallen Tree Act' would more or less codify what courts have already held in litigation involving trees falling on neighbors' homes.
'Courts in Florida have typically ruled in favor of the impacted homeowner. Meaning, they have ruled that the party responsible for the tree must pay the damages,' said Friedlander.
But the idea got some pushback in its first committee stop.
Read: Florida democrats fear new legislation would set the stage for 'fetal personhood' ruling
George Feijoo with the Florida Insurance Council expressed concern over the lack of distinction between healthy and unhealthy trees.
'We're particularly concerned that the bill will lead to increased litigation specifically between neighbors, which is not sound public policy to incentivize, in our opinion,' said Feijoo.
But Martin argued neighbors are already suing each other, and clarifying who is liable would only stand to reduce litigation.
'This is a solution to a problem that will bring down insurance costs and it'll keep our communities safer during hurricanes and shortly after hurricanes,' said Martin.
The bill still has two more committee stops in both chambers.
With only three weeks left in session, it seems the Fallen Tree Act may be falling on deaf ears.
[DOWNLOAD: Free Action News Jax app for alerts as news breaks]
[SIGN UP: Action News Jax Daily Headlines Newsletter]
Click here to download the free Action News Jax news and weather apps, click here to download the Action News Jax Now app for your smart TV and click here to stream Action News Jax live.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
10 hours ago
- New York Post
Trump weaponization czar teases ‘more' developments with Schiff, warns J6 Committee alums to ‘keep an eye on their mailbox'
President Trump's weaponization czar Ed Martin dropped hints that his team may soon take additional investigative actions against Sen. Adam Schiff and members of the since-defunct House Select Jan. 6 Committee who weren't pardoned by former president Joe Biden. Martin, who helms the Justice Department's Weaponization Working Group, took note of the criminal probe of Schiff (D-Calif.) over allegations of mortgage fraud and strongly implied something else is in the works. 'There's a referral from Bill Pulte about mortgage fraud about Adam Schiff. That's publicly discussed. His own lawyers have been out there,' Martin told Fox News' Sunday Morning Futures.' Advertisement 'Now there's more on Adam Schiff.' Martin did not specify what else could be coming down the pike. 3 Ed Martin teased that his weaponization working group has additional investigations into Adam Schiff and the since-defunct Jan. 6 Committee in the works. AP Advertisement 3 Sen. Adam Schiff was one of President Trump's top Democratic adversaries in the House during his first term. REUTERS Back in May, Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) Director William Pulte referred Schiff to the Justice Department for 'multiple instances' between 2003 and 2019 when the senator allegedly 'falsified bank documents and property records to acquire more favorable loan terms.' This includes accusations that he listed his Maryland home as a primary residence in multiple mortgage refinancing filings despite being an elected member of Congress from California at the time. Some lawmakers have homes in both their states and in the Washington, DC, Maryland and Virginia area during their time in Congress. But Pulte alleged that Schiff also sought a similar exemption on a Burbank, Calif., condo that he also dubbed his primary residence. Advertisement In a separate matter, Schiff recently faced surfaced accusations from a former Democratic House Intelligence Committee aide who alleged the then-congressman approved leaks of classified information to harm President Trump during the height of Russiagate. It is unclear if those allegations are what Martin was referencing. DOJ officials concluded Schiff may have had liability protections for those leaks under the speech and debate clause of the Constitution, according to an FBI memo on the accusations obtained by The Post. 'All we're going to do, again, is get to the facts of this and use all the tools that we have in our system,' Martin stressed. 3 Ed Martin inspected Letita James' Brooklyn home last Friday. New York Post Advertisement Last week, Martin was seen in Brooklyn checking out New York Attorney General Letitia James' multi-family residential property that is subject to a mortgage fraud inquiry. Pulte alleged that the AG may have 'falsified bank documents and property records to acquire government-backed assistance and loans and more favorable loan terms.' Similar to the Schiff accusations, Pulte alleged that James declared a Norfolk, Virginia, property purchased in 2023 her 'principal residence' while calling her Brooklyn brownstone she's owned since 2001 her second residence. Beyond Schiff and James, Martin also teased that he is reviewing members of the since-defunct House Select Jan. 6 Committee, despite Biden's sweeping 11th-hour pardon for the panel. 'We're all in that too,' Martin said. 'A lot of people did not get a pardon that were involved in the select committee, and they ought to be keeping an eye on their mailbox, because there's a lot to be asked about.' Martin didn't specify names, but noted that US Attorney General Pam Bondi 'let us loose on' issues of alleged government weaponization.
Newsweek
2 days ago
- Newsweek
Florida Voters Urged To Check Driver's License Issue
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Florida voters are being urged to verify their driver's license information ahead of upcoming elections as mismatched or outdated records could prevent some residents from casting ballots. Newsweek has contacted the Florida Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) and the office of the supervisor of elections for comment via email. Why It Matters Several U.S. House districts in Florida are expected to be competitive in the 2026 midterm elections. Districts such as the 10th, 15th and 16th have drawn attention because of shifting demographics and political dynamics. Both major parties are preparing for intense campaigns in these areas, and any elections in the state could affect the balance of power in Congress. A highway near Raleigh, North Carolina, on May 13, 2018. A highway near Raleigh, North Carolina, on May 13, 2018. Getty Images What To Know According to WPTV, any licenses issued from July 31, 2024, onward will include updated combination numbers, and this change could have significant implications for future voters. The change means that those attempting to request a vote-by-mail ballot online will encounter error messages if their driver's license information is out of sync with their voter registration. In-person voting is not affected by the new license changes. But Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland told Action News Jax that petitions could also be affected. "If you don't update your registration info and use your new license number on a petition, it can't be counted. So that's where you do want that update prior to putting your new number on a petition form," he said. The Florida DMV said the update was designed to make driver's licenses more secure. The new licenses feature an updated two-digit number within the license number that corresponds to the holder's birth year. The Supervisor of Elections Office, which has been sharing guidance about the change through newsletters and press releases, plans to send postcards as Election Day approaches to remind residents to verify and update their voter registration details. When updating a driver's license, voters should check the box indicating "yes" to update their voter information, even if no other changes are being made. This simple step can prevent problems on Election Day. Brad Ashwell of All Voting Is Local told Action News Jax that a new license number wouldn't "automatically update with your local supervisor of elections." He added that the update came into play especially for voters "who want to vote by mail, which is, you know, hugely popular all over the state with both parties." Voters can also contact the Supervisor of Elections Office directly or visit to confirm their registration. Holland said he had asked the state whether it would eventually automatically advise election supervisors when a voter's driver's license number changed and that he expected an answer by Monday. Vote-by-mail requests must be submitted to the supervisor of elections at least 12 days before an election. What Happens Next In Palm Beach County, there's a special election for the Republican Party in House District 90 on September 30, followed by the special general election on December 9. The midterm elections follow in November 2026, with the primaries taking place in August.
Newsweek
2 days ago
- Newsweek
Democrat Says Texas 'Gerrymandering War' Shows Party's New Fiery Path
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A Texas congressional candidate told Newsweek that Democrats need to use every weapon in their arsenal to counter Republicans' efforts in a "gerrymandering war." "I believe it's imperative at this moment to use every tool that we have to fight back," said Isaiah Martin, a 27-year-old Democratic candidate running in a November special election in Texas's 18th congressional district, which includes much of Houston. "I think the only thing Republicans understand is being thrown out of power without mercy … that's why blue states have got to go and fight fire with fire." Isaiah Martin, a congressional candidate in Texas, told Newsweek that Democrats need to "fight fire with fire" to counter Republican redistricting efforts. Isaiah Martin, a congressional candidate in Texas, told Newsweek that Democrats need to "fight fire with fire" to counter Republican redistricting efforts. Courtesy of Isaiah Martin for Congress' Martin's comments come as the fight over redistricting in Texas has sparked a scramble to redraw congressional maps in other states. Texas Democrats fled their state on August 3, heading to Illinois, New York and Massachusetts, in order to stop Republicans from approving the redrawn House maps sought by President Donald Trump that would give the GOP five more winnable seats before next year's midterm elections. California Governor Gavin Newsom said there will be a special election in November seeking approval of redrawn districts that would allow Democrats to gain five more seats, offsetting any GOP gains in Texas, and other Democrat-led states could follow suit. Martin said other Democrat-led states need to follow suit. "What the Republicans are doing is coming for the jugular for us on every single front and we've got to respond back appropriately," he said, pointing to Vice President JD Vance visiting Indiana this week to discuss redistricting with leaders in that state. "I think it's time to teach these guys a math lesson about the blue state population advantage," he added. "Let them find out the hard way that California and New York are a heck of a lot bigger than states like Indiana, and personally, it's unfortunate that it has to come to this, but we have to make sure we can fight back." 'I Spoke Unapologetically' Martin was forcibly removed from the Texas State Capitol and arrested last month after he refused to yield while speaking at a hearing on redistricting. "What I saw was Republican lawmakers doing everything they can to not listen to folks that have driven hours to go and testify," he said. "So I spoke unapologetically, and ended up with Republicans getting me tossed out of there and thrown in jail." He was charged with disrupting a meeting, resisting arrest and criminal trespassing, CBS Austin reported. The charges were later dropped, and Martin was released after spending 30 hours in jail. "I went right back to Houston … to tell those lawmakers that they weren't stopping anything," he said. "The result has been millions of people talking about this gerrymandering war that Trump started and the response that needs to be levied." On Thursday, the Texas Democrats who fled Texas said they would return, provided Texas Republicans end a special session and California releases its own redrawn maps. However, Texas Governor Greg Abbott is expected to call another special session to push through new maps. Newsweek has contacted Abbott's office for comment via email. "As Democrats across the nation join our fight to cause these maps to fail their political purpose, we're prepared to bring this battle back to Texas under the right conditions and to take this fight to the courts," Gene Wu, Chair of the Texas House Democratic Caucus, said. Martin said it was up to the Texas Democrats who left the state to determine how long they stay away, but he encouraged them to stay away "as long as possible to give blue states time to respond appropriately." He added that those opposed to the idea of Democrats retaliating by redrawing their maps should ask themselves if they are willing to lose their health care. If Republicans retain power, they "can go and push more cuts to things like Medicare, Medicaid, and the long term goal of cutting Social Security," he said. Martin said that going forward, he wants to talk about "making America more affordable." He said: "Trump's very stupid policies has resulted in people losing jobs and having their grocery bills go up with reckless abandon, and so we need people that can unapologetically call that out, but then also provide a vision for the Democratic Party to help people have more of their own money. "I believe that's where we've got to be moving forward. We've got to be bold. We've got to be audacious, because that's what this moment demands in history."
