Where do France, Britain and Canada stand on a Palestinian state?
If a week is a long time in politics, then a month is even longer in the Middle East, and what Israel, the West Bank and Gaza will look like by then is an open question.
France has decided to ignore all that, and make its recognition unconditional — at least in theory.
President Macron's statement said: 'True to its historic commitment to a just and lasting peace in the Middle East, I have decided that France will recognise the state of Palestine.
'We must also guarantee the demilitarisation of Hamas, and secure and rebuild Gaza.'
In other words, although he is — like most western states — demanding the disarming of Hamas and its removal as the governing force in Gaza, he would recognise Palestine anyway. He would argue that recognising Palestine in practice means recognising Hamas's rival, the Palestinian Authority, as its government, so this would not be 'rewarding Hamas'.
Britain tried a different tack, in keeping with Sir Keir Starmer's constant attempts to forge a middle way between his backbenchers and his desire to keep good relations with the pro-Israel Trump administration.
David Lammy, the foreign secretary, in a statement to the UN conference on the two-state solution, used similarly grandiose terms to Macron's.
He said: 'It is with the hand of history on our shoulders that His Majesty's government therefore intends to recognise the state of Palestine when the UN general assembly gathers in September here in New York.'
But unlike Macron, he gave Israel, which is deeply hostile to the idea, a way out. 'We will do it unless the Israeli government acts to end the appalling situation in Gaza, ends its military campaign and commits to a long-term sustainable peace based on a two-state solution,' he said.
In his speech, Lammy also made 'absolute and unwavering' demands on Hamas. 'It must immediately release the hostages, agree to an immediate ceasefire, accept it will have no role in governing Gaza and commit to disarmament,' he said.
• What will happen to the West Bank if Palestine becomes a state?
But there was 'no conditionality' attached and no statement that anything Hamas might do or not do would cause the British government to change its mind.
The main criticism raised by pro-Israel critics is that this gives Hamas an incentive to stall any ceasefire deal, since only Israel will be punished if one is not agreed. Lammy said: 'No one side will have a veto on recognition through their actions or inactions.' But only Israel would want to veto this development.
The critics are now demanding the government explicitly insert balancing conditions on the 'other side'.
Mark Carney, the Canadian prime minister, appears to have hewed more to the British path. His statement said that Canada 'intended' to recognise Palestine but also made the decision conditional.
His conditions, though, were aimed at the Palestinian Authority of President Abbas, rather than Israel.
He said: 'This intention is predicated on the Palestinian Authority's commitment to much-needed reforms, including the commitments by Palestinian Authority President Abbas to fundamentally reform its governance, to hold general elections in 2026 in which Hamas can play no part, and to demilitarise the Palestinian state.'
Many people have demanded reforms of the Palestinians — the West, the Gulf states, Palestinians themselves. Few have been forthcoming.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
26 minutes ago
- The Sun
Starmer's gesture politics on Palestine and why a vote for Corbyn's new party will put Nigel Farage in Downing Street
JEREMY Corbyn's party hasn't even launched yet and it is already calling the shots with this government – starting with the recognition of Palestine. Keir Starmer is terrified Jeremy and his band of pro-Gaza MPs will hoover up the Muslim vote and cost Labour the next election. 6 6 So in a jaw-dropping speech on Tuesday, he announced the UK will recognise an independent state of Palestine unless Israel signs up to a ceasefire and long-term peace process. It was an astonishing change in position from Keir, who just days earlier dismissed the stance as gesture politics. So what changed? The grim facts on the ground in the Middle East remained the same. Hamas is still refusing to release the Israeli hostages kidnapped on October 7 and held in cold, dank tunnels buried deep underneath Gaza. They have been there for more than 660 days. Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu still shows no signs of being willing to accept a two-state solution. And innocent civilians in Gaza are paying the price for Hamas' reign of terror. Appalling images of starving children desperately queuing for food have haunted our TV screens and newspaper pages. The only thing that has changed is the news Corbyn is launching a new party to challenge Labour. No10 denies Keir is tearing up 75 years of foreign policy because he is running scared of Jezza. Moved by appalling images of emaciated children, he is launching a last-ditch bid to get Netanyahu to re-engage with the peace process, they say. But recognising the state of Palestine will not put food into the belly of a single hungry child in Gaza. It will not release a single hostage snatched by Hamas as they slept in their beds or danced at a music festival. And it will not bring the Middle East a single step closer to peace. It is the very essence of gesture politics Keir Starmer claims to despise. Biggest danger There is no doubt the new Corbyn party poses a massive challenge for Keir. They plan to target seats with big Muslim populations. There are fears inside Labour that 'London could fall'. Wes Streeting and Angela Rayner are being targeted. Zarah Sultana — a former Labour MP who has switched to Corbyn's party — will run against Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood in Birmingham Ladywood. The loss of all three of these Cabinet big beasts would be a catastrophe for Labour. Sources close to Jeremy say the party could win around ten seats at the next election. Others reckon the number could be higher — more like 20. But the biggest danger to Labour is not the number of seats the party takes, but the number of votes. Pollsters More In Common say the new party could get ten per cent of the vote, mainly from current Labour and Green supporters. By nibbling at Labour's vote, Corbyn and his crew could hand Nigel Farage's Reform Party a seven-point lead — and a majority in Parliament. So vote Jeremy, get Nigel Farage in No10. Labour Party chiefs are expected to hammer this attack line on a Corbyn-led party. Keir Starmer was also under huge pressure from his own party and base to recognise Palestine. Over 100 Labour MPs had signed a letter demanding he do it. A large chunk of the Cabinet had urged him to do the same. But Keir has spent years painting himself as morally upright and principled standing loftily above the self-interest that motivates others. Now the Prime Minister looks like he is recognising Palestine to save his own political skin. As one party insider put it: 'Keir used to say country first, party second. Where does this decision leave that?' How Ozzy helped Jacob to rock up on reality TV AT first glance Jacob Rees-Mogg and Ozzy Osbourne do not have much in common. One is a pinstripe-suit-wearing former Tory MP best known for his love of Brexit and devout Catholicism. 6 The other was a heavy metal wildman famous for biting the head off a bat on stage and being so desperate for drugs he once snorted a line of ants off the roadside. So it was a bit surprising to see the Moggster dedicate a whole section of his GB News show to tributes to the late, great Prince of Darkness. But Jacob actually owes much of his success to Ozzy. The Osbournes was the original family reality TV show – featuring Ozzy, wife Sharon and children Kelly and Jack. Their lives were slightly bonkers, very loving – and made for intoxicating viewing. Twenty years later, Jacob followed in Ozzy's footsteps with Meet The Rees-Moggs, a reality TV show about his equally eccentric and loving family. Paying tribute to the Brummie rocker on telly, Mogg hailed him as 'a charismatic figure who had great charm and was at the top of his field'. He added: 'We will pray for his soul.' Judging by the rocker's hell-raising antics, I reckon that will take quite a few Hail Marys, Jacob. CUT OFF PHONE THEFTS STRICTLY dancer Michelle Tsiakkas has become the latest victim of mobile phone thieves to go public. The ballroom dancer was walking through London's Covent Garden in June when a thug on an e-bike snatched her phone. 6 When will this criminal scourge end? As a Londoner, I'm appalled to see how muggers are terrorising the capital on their green e-bikes. A phone is stolen in London every six minutes. That is a shameful statistic. When victims call the police they are just fobbed off and told officers are too busy to investigate – even when the phone has a tracker on it. Within days these mobiles are sold on by criminal gangs and end up around the world in places like China. Enough is enough. Police must take a zero-tolerance approach to these phone snatchers. I don't mind the rental e-bikes which have popped up all over the capital. But they are too easy for thugs to fiddle so they can ride them without paying – and to carry out their muggings. These businesses must step up and improve security. And if London Mayor Sadiq Khan wants a legacy he should hurry up and clean up the streets of our capital. Or his time in City Hall will go down in history as one of failure. MENUS JABBED HESTON BLUMENTHAL has revealed he is on the fat jab, and he's not the only one. The celebrity chef says so many Brits are on Ozempic and Wegovy it risks wrecking the restaurant trade. The days of charging diners through the nose for giant tasting menus might be over, he warns. It costs £395 per person to tuck into the 11-course tasting menu at Blumenthal's own restaurant, The Fat Duck. Looks like the fat jab will shrink Heston's bank balance as well as his waistline. POPE'S BLACK MAGIC Pope Leo XIV is said to have toasted St Patrick's Day this year with a pint of the black stuff. 6 Perhaps the pontiff's love of Irish stout should come as no surprise. He is a Yank after all – and they are known to be huge fans of the Irish tipple. We were always big fans of Guinness in my family. My grandad, Jim O'Sullivan (no awards for guessing where he came from), swore by the medicinal qualities of a pint of Guinness. Whenever me or my brother were feeling sick when we were kids he would suggest taking a long glug of Guinness. It is packed full of iron and would get our strength up, he said in his thick Cork accent. It sounds like The Pope agrees. Drinking Guinness is God for you! The mega-rich Brits are said to be part of a consortium trying to take over the controversial porn site. The property tycoons are considering pumping hundreds of millions of pounds in the project. Well, no one ever became poor overestimating our interest in sex. CHEAP AS LIPS CLOBBERED by the cost-of-living crisis, us girls are turning to small treats like lipstick to give ourselves a little lift. Britain's 'prestige lip market' has grown by 16 per cent in the past six months, according to the market research company Circana. I never leave my flat without a full face of make-up. But last time I bought a lippy it set me back £30, which isn't exactly cheap as chips. Although I guess it's cheaper than a week in Marbella.
The Sun
26 minutes ago
- The Sun
Lionesses' victory showed strong & proud England at its finest… the return of unapologetic patriotism was long overdue
IF you were attempting to fly off on your family holiday this Wednesday just as all outbound flights from the UK were grounded due to a technical failure, then you would have had a vivid close-up of broken Britain. You know the place. The land where 'nothing works'. The country where taxes are at an all-time high and yet public services are at an all-time low. Where a deeply unpopular government presides over unfettered immigration, industrial unrest, porous borders, NHS queues, rising violent crime and economic paralysis. If I had been one of 577,000 Brits decked by the latest air traffic chaos, you bet your life I would have been screaming: 'Why does nothing work in this bloody country?' Most feel that a raft of crimes are on the rise, from sex offences to knife crime to street mugging. Yet police stations are closed. Coppers are rarely seen on our lawless streets. Burglars, shoplifters and phone-snatchers get away with their crimes. Our capital has become Dodge City with a mayor who frets more about the American President than he does the anarchic streets of London. But it is always worth remembering that there is another country — an unbroken Britain. And it is just as real as the land of striking doctors, online haters, small boats, e-bikes dumped in disabled bays, brazen shoplifters, phone snatchers, knife crime, and all the rest of our litany of misery. What my old mucker Ian Dury called reasons to be cheerful. That unbroken Britain — strong and proud, stoic and resilient — was rampant when England's women won the Euros. England's Lionesses return home to heroes' welcome with EURO 2025 trophy 'This team shows exactly what it means to be English,' said Lioness Chloe Kelly. 'I am so proud to be English. This team is made of magic and made of steel.' 'We've shown during this tournament that we can come back when we go a goal down,' said hero goalkeeper Hannah Hampton. 'We have that grit. We have English blood in us.' The return of unapologetic, unabashed patriotism is long overdue. Remembering who we are — and why it should make us happy — can never be wrong. Those patriotic Lionesses spoke of something real. This country has faced and fought tyrants for centuries. It has not been invaded for 1,000 years. It is home to a tough, tolerant, quietly courageous, freedom-loving people with an instinct for good manners and gentle humour. Fashionable self-loathing Doesn't that remind you of your family and your friends and everyone you grew up with? We have so many reasons to be proud of our country. Eleven years ago, Labour's Emily Thornberry took a photo of a working-class home with a St George flag on display outside — because Emily clearly thought it was hilarious, darling. But for all that ails our nation — and yes, there is plenty — I believe in my blood and bones that Emily Thornberry's brand of fashionable self-loathing has had its day. Enough. I am always proud of this country. Our history. Our people. The freedom we revere. The creativity that has poured from these shores. The grit we show when our backs are against the wall. Parts of Britain undeniably feel shattered. But there is a national soul that is made of unbreakable material. It was there in the smiling faces of all those different generations on the Mall, as they waved their Union Jacks and their flags of St George, responding to what George Orwell called, 'The spiritual need for patriotism for which, however little the boiled rabbits of the Left may like it, no substitute has yet been found.' Never forget that our unbroken, unbreakable Britain is real too, and we are right to feel an unapologetic love for it. There are no small boats trying to get into France, are there? MARIAH A TIME KILLER MARIAH Carey insists that ageing is optional. Asked how she deals with getting older, Mariah flounces: 'I don't allow it – it just doesn't happen. 'I don't know time. I don't know numbers. I do not acknowledge time.' David Bowie once told me exactly the opposite. 'The years seem to go faster,' Bowie told me just before his 50th birthday in January 1997. 'And that's because the years really are going faster.' The David Bowie theory of time was that it accelerates as we get older because one year is always becoming a smaller percentage of your life span. For Bowie, at 50, a year was just two per cent of his life – a fleeting fragment. But when David was a ten-year-old boy at Burnt Ash Junior School in Bromley, a year was ten per cent of his life. Mariah Carey, that admirably defiant diva, 56, says that we can ignore the passing of time. But David Bowie insisted that time is forever slipping through our fingers. I wonder who is right? LISTEN TO NEV, RACHEL GARY Neville is that great rarity – a Labour supporter who is also a successful businessman. We think of Gary as an acid-tongued football pundit. But – as his website proudly states – he has been a property developer since he was 21 years old, he is the co-founder of the production company Buzz 16 and his investment business, Relentless, is now ten years old. So when Gary Neville talks about this Labour Government's relationship to business, they should listen. Gary points out the intolerable burden that has been placed on British business by Chancellor Rachel Reeves hiking employers' National Insurance contributions. 'I honestly don't believe that companies and small businesses should be deterred from employing people,' he told Sky News. Neville is right – hammering employers is the dumbest move of a Government that claims to crave economic growth. Our Government is stuffed full of people who have worked as a lawyer (Keir Starmer, David Lammy), economist (Rachel Reeves) and trade union representative (Angela Rayner). Incredibly, there is not one entrepreneur among them. Can't they find a seat for Gary Neville around the Cabinet table? LIAM AND PAMELA HAVE GUN AND DONE IT 5 AGAINST all expectations, film critics are hailing the Liam Neeson-Pamela Anderson reboot of clasic cop caper The Naked Gun as a comic masterpiece. 'This is one of the funniest films I have seen in years,' said my colleague Grant Rollings in The Sun. 'So funny it made me physically crumble in my seat on multiple occasions,' gasped the Telegraph. There are two reasons this is weird. One – in recent years, comedy has gone out of fashion in Hollywood. And two – although the sequel, reboot and film franchise are all the rage in Tinsel Town, they are usually never as good as the original. Until Liam Neeson flashed his lurid underpants and got out his indecently large Glock. Until Pamela Anderson, above with Liam, brilliantly reinvented herself as a comic femme fatale. Until now. I suggest that no film this year has received rave reviews like this remake of The Naked Gun. And I hear you cry – surely you can't be serious? But I am dead serious. And don't call me Shirley! THUGS ON RISE MOHAMMED Fahir Amaaz has been convicted on three counts of assault at Manchester airport, including attacks on two female officers, PC Lydia Ward and PC Ellie Cook. The CCTV footage of Amaaz using what was described in court as 'a high level of violence' is truly sickening. PC Cook had her nose broken by this violent thug. Once upon a time – how long ago it seems! – men in this country did not think it was acceptable to hit women. And now, God help us, some of them do. PROVING that our footballers have far more money than they know what to do with, Erling Haaland's partner Isabel Haugseng Johansen poses with a £330,000 diamond-encrusted crocodile-skin Hermes handbag. Now that's what I call a sick bag. Are we meant to be impressed? Frankly, the notion that some beautiful crocodile was skinned to provide some narcissistic rich person with clicks on Instagram turns my stomach. A crocodile is a wild animal. Never a handbag. ON a golfing trip to Scotland, Donald Trump took time out to knock Net Zero for fore. While Sir Keir Starmer sat mutely by his side, the POTUS pointed out that there was a 'vast fortune to be made for the UK' if the Government reversed its self-harming policy of denying new licences for gas and oil extraction from the North Sea. Trump also railed against wind turbines and the madness of ignoring shale reserves. Starmer said nowt. Perhaps he knows that the Orange King is right. And that green goon Ed Miliband, the swivel-eyed major nutjob of Net Zero, is wrong, wrong, wrong. AS JK Rowling turns sixty, she is rightly hailed as a fearless women's campaigner. Joanne also deserves the thanks of a nation for her achievement as a writer. Nobody ever did more to give generations of children a love of reading that will stay with them for a lifetime.
BBC News
26 minutes ago
- BBC News
Evyatar David's family condemns Hamas video of emaciated Israeli hostage
The family of Israeli hostage Evyatar David held by Hamas in Gaza has accused the group of deliberately starving him as part of a "propaganda campaign"."He is being starved purely to serve Hamas's propaganda," the family said on Saturday, a day after Hamas released a video showing an emaciated David in a narrow concrete 24, has been in captivity since his seizure by Hamas at a music festival in southern Israel on 7 October 2023."We are forced to witness our beloved son and brother, Evyatar David, deliberately and cynically starved in Hamas's tunnels in Gaza - a living skeleton, buried alive," the family statement added. The hostage's family also urged the Israeli government and the world community to do "everything possible to save Evyatar".In the video released by Hamas, Evyatar David is heard saying "I haven't eaten for days... I barely got drinking water" and is seen digging what he says will be his own its attack on Israel nearly two years ago, Hamas seized 251 hostages. David is one of 49 hostages who Israel says are still being held in Gaza. This includes 27 hostages who are believed to be dead. Israel has been accused by aid agencies of pushing Gaza towards famine by weaponising food in its war against Hamas - an allegation it has said there is "no starvation" and it is not imposing restrictions on aid entering Gaza - claims rejected by its close allies in Europe, the UN and other agencies active in the Saturday, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said it was "continuing the series of actions aimed at improving the humanitarian response in the Gaza Strip".It said that 90 aid packages containing food for residents in southern and northern Gaza had been airdropped in the past few hours as part of co-operation between Israel, the United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Egypt, France and the Hamas-run Gaza health ministry said seven more people, including a child, died of malnutrition in the territory on health ministry said the total number of malnutrition deaths since the start of the war has reached 169, including 93 on Saturday in Gaza, the health ministry said at least 83 had been killed and 1,079 injured as a result of Israel's military offensive in the past 24 Hospital in Nuseirat told the BBC it had received the bodies of three people killed by Israeli forces near an aid distribution point on Salah al-Din street, south of the Wadi Gaza area in central Gaza, run by the US and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). The hospital said at least 36 people were IDF said its troops "fired warning shots" hundreds of metres away from the aid distribution site, and not during its operating hours, after a crowd did not comply with their calls not to advance towards them "in a manner that posed a threat"."The IDF is not aware of any casualties as a result of the warning shots, and the details of the incident are still being examined," it said there was "nothing at or near our sites today". It understood that UN/World Food Programme (WFP) aid convoys were in the area of the incident, which have been drawing large crowds that have overrun and taken food off BBC has asked WFP for journalists, including the BBC, are blocked by Israel from entering Gaza independently, making it difficult to verify claims. Israel imposed a total blockade of aid deliveries to Gaza at the start of March and resumed its military offensive against Hamas two weeks later, collapsing a two-month ceasefire. It said it wanted to put pressure on the group to release its remaining Israeli blockade was partially eased after 11 weeks amid warnings of a looming famine from global experts, but shortages of food, medicine and fuel remain, aid agencies have launched its offensive in Gaza in response to the Hamas-led attack on 7 October 2023, in which about 1,200 people were killed. The Hamas-run health authorities say 60,430 people have been killed as a result of the Israeli military campaign.
