
Charles Darwin's contribution to Patagonia's grim history
It was a journey Bruce Chatwin hankered to make: to Southampton and the grave of General Juan Manuel de Rosas, the exiled Argentine dictator described in the Southampton Times after his funeral in 1877 as 'one of the most cruel, remorseless and sanguinary tyrants who ever existed on Earth'. Chatwin died before I could accompany him to the Hill Lane Cemetery, but four years later I stood with his widow in front of Rosas's ornamented tomb in Buenos Aires as we prepared to meander south on a 2,000-mile car journey in his footsteps.
In 1989, the year of Chatwin's death, President Menem decided to have Rosas's remains repatriated as a gesture of national reconciliation. Their arrival was greeted by mounted lancers wearing Rosas's signature red uniform. But his bones were still contentious. W.H. Hudson's great-niece told us that the original grave in Southampton – Rosas ended his days as a dairy farmer in nearby Swaythling – had been destroyed by bombing in the second world war that had killed some stray cattle. The returned relics were unlikely to be Rosas's. 'People say they are the bones of a cow.'
To read Matthew Carr's 'grim history' of Patagonia is to realise how much of our understanding of this evocative region has been based on a succession of monstrous misidentifications and misconceptions. As the author does not flinch from reminding us, the vast territory which Rosas had sought to subjugate in his Desert Campaign (1833-4) – and which Chatwin's 1977 travel book In Patagonia resuscitated as a mysterious, exotic wilderness – was misunderstood by outsiders from the start.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Spectator
5 days ago
- Spectator
Charles Darwin's contribution to Patagonia's grim history
It was a journey Bruce Chatwin hankered to make: to Southampton and the grave of General Juan Manuel de Rosas, the exiled Argentine dictator described in the Southampton Times after his funeral in 1877 as 'one of the most cruel, remorseless and sanguinary tyrants who ever existed on Earth'. Chatwin died before I could accompany him to the Hill Lane Cemetery, but four years later I stood with his widow in front of Rosas's ornamented tomb in Buenos Aires as we prepared to meander south on a 2,000-mile car journey in his footsteps. In 1989, the year of Chatwin's death, President Menem decided to have Rosas's remains repatriated as a gesture of national reconciliation. Their arrival was greeted by mounted lancers wearing Rosas's signature red uniform. But his bones were still contentious. W.H. Hudson's great-niece told us that the original grave in Southampton – Rosas ended his days as a dairy farmer in nearby Swaythling – had been destroyed by bombing in the second world war that had killed some stray cattle. The returned relics were unlikely to be Rosas's. 'People say they are the bones of a cow.' To read Matthew Carr's 'grim history' of Patagonia is to realise how much of our understanding of this evocative region has been based on a succession of monstrous misidentifications and misconceptions. As the author does not flinch from reminding us, the vast territory which Rosas had sought to subjugate in his Desert Campaign (1833-4) – and which Chatwin's 1977 travel book In Patagonia resuscitated as a mysterious, exotic wilderness – was misunderstood by outsiders from the start.


Metro
5 days ago
- Metro
Lisandro Martinez makes Man Utd transfer decision after surprise Napoli links
Lisandro Martinez has no intention of leaving Manchester United despite becoming the subject of interest from Serie A champions Napoli, according to reports. Martinez is still working his way back from a cruciate ligament injury he suffered in February and may not feature again until 2026. Despite that, reports in Italy suggested that the Argentine international was attracting interest from Napoli as they look to bolster their defensive options. The Italian giants enjoyed great success buying from United last summer, recruiting Scott McTominay for a cut-price fee of £25million. McTominay then went on to play a guiding role for Antonio Conte's side, scoring 12 times as Napoli saw off Inter Milan to win the title. Wake up to find news on your club in your inbox every morning with Metro's Football Newsletter. Sign up to our newsletter and then select your team in the link so we can send you football news tailored to you. However, Napoli are unlikely to be able to repeat the trick this time around, with the Daily Mail reporting Martinez is more than happy at Old Trafford and has no desire to move. Prior to his injury, the 27-year-old had established himself as a key part of Ruben Amorim's defence and is seen as one of the experienced leaders within the United squad. While Martinez may not join, however, Napoli could have more success trying to sign Alejandro Garnacho who has fallen out of favour with Amorim. The Serie A side were interested in signing Garnacho in January but were unable to reach an agreement with United at the time. The Red Devils have since lowered their asking price to £60m, but Garnacho appears to have his heart set on staying in the Premier League amid interest from Chelsea. More Trending Garnachp is one of several players that could leave Old Trafford this summer as United look to raise funds for another costly rebuild. Antony, Jadon Sancho and Marcus Rashford are all set to leave the club when they return from their respective loans. The club will also reportedly entertain offers for Kobbie Mainoo, while Rasmus Hojlund could be set for a move to Italy, after Inter were credited with an interest in the young striker. For more stories like this, check our sport page. Follow Metro Sport for the latest news on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. MORE: Sweden boss rubbishes Viktor Gyokeres transfer claim amid Arsenal talks MORE: Ange Postecoglou speaks out on message to Spurs fans during Europa League parade MORE: Steven Gerrard names five teams that can rival Liverpool for the Premier League title next season


Daily Mirror
5 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Alexis Mac Allister gives away No.10 shirt after Florian Wirtz's angry response
Florian Wirtz has hit out at claims that he wants to take the Liverpool No.10 shirt from Alexis Mac Allister should he complete his transfer to Liverpool this summer Liverpool's Alexis Mac Allister has generously gifted his Reds No. 10 shirt - but not to Florian Wirtz. Germany international Wirtz continues to be strongly linked with a club record breaking move to the Reds this summer, with all parties hopeful the move can be signed off in the coming days. Both Mac Allister and Wirtz currently don the No. 10 for their respective teams, sparking rumours that Wirtz might fancy the same number at Liverpool should he make the switch to Anfield. the man himself has dismissed the suggestions outright. An irritated Wirtz took to Instagram on Tuesday to address the chatter, subtly suggesting a transfer might be in the pipeline while also dismissing claims about his shirt number preference: "Who says I want the 10, I respect players," Wirtz posted. "Don't believe everything what's written [clown emoji]." Shortly afterwards, professional Argentine Padel player Alex Chozas expressed his gratitude to Mac Allister for receiving a signed Liverpool shirt from him, Posting on Instagram, he wrote: "Thank you [Mac Allister] for this unforgettable afternoon. You now have a Padel to play with, I hope you like it! "Thanks for your Liverpool shirt, you're a star on and off the pitch, my friend. Get well soon, CHAMPION." With their shirts held up high for the camera, Mac Allister and Chozas shared a snapshot on social media, showcasing their mutual appreciation. The Liverpool midfielder chimed in with encouragement for his mate: "Great, crazy! Keep up the good work," penned Mac Allister. After playing a key role in Liverpool's triumphant Premier League campaign, Mac Allister is now soaking up the summer sun. He is currently absent from the Argentina squad as he recuperates from an injury that prevented him from starting any of the four matches Liverpool played after they secured the Premier League title, missing the last two entirely.