Chris Minns warns of $2bn budget hole if bill curtailing psychological injury claims fails
In parliament, the premier said if the changes to curtail psychological injury claims did not go through, an additional $2bn would be required from NSW taxpayers to fund the public service portion of the scheme.
He also warned that businesses would see premiums rise by 36% over three years to fund the scheme for the private sector.
Sources have told Guardian Australia that there was intensive lobbying of upper house MPs from the Shooters and Fishers party and other right-leaning MPs, including former One Nation MPs Mark Latham and Rod Roberts, Legalise Cannabis MP Jeremy Buckingham and Libertarian MP John Ruddick.
The opposition will move on Thursday to send the complex bill to an inquiry. Opposition leader Mark Speakman described it as 'unconscionable' and 'cruel'.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
The opposition wants the status quo of 15% impairment to qualify for compensation, instead of the 30% that the government is proposing.
He said the opposition had offered amendments that would yield some savings, such as tightening definitions of psychological injury due to bullying, or 'unworkable' claims due to 'excessive work demands', but the Coalition would not budge on the impairment threshold.
A 15% impairment means a person struggles with daily tasks and requires reminders about their hygiene needs. Experts have said that a 30% impairment was so high that it would make it virtually impossible for people to ever claim for psychological injury.
The high-stakes game will play out on Thursday.
The shadow treasurer, Damien Tudehope, warned that the government was seeking to cajole the crossbench with offerings in other policy areas that were important to them.
The public had strong views about the ethics of this approach, he said.
Two days before the government released its workers compensation legislation, Minns surprised many by indicating support for a bounty scheme proposed by the Shooters party in its conservation hunting bill to control feral animals.
The bill would create a new conservation hunting authority and proposes a raft of changes, including enshrining a 'right to hunt' and recognition of hunting as a conservation management tool.
Minns has previously denied there was any deal with the Shooters for support of other legislation.
Conservation groups and scientists have condemned the hunting proposal as ineffective and a waste of taxpayer dollars.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
As debate on the bill began in the upper house on Wednesday, the scientist-led Biodiversity Council wrote to MPs warning that the legislation, if passed in its current form, would 'undermine invasive species management across the state, leading to poorer outcomes for the environment and agriculture'.
Conservationists are concerned the bill will become a vehicle for promoting the interests of recreational hunting and management of invasive species as game rather than driving down feral animal numbers with control programs.
The Invasive Species Council and other groups have also expressed concern that the proposed authority bears similarities to the defunct Game Council, which was abolished in 2013, and that hunting interests would dominate the authority's proposed voting structure.
'Recreational hunting is not conservation. It rarely delivers environmental benefits, and in many cases actively obstructs professional control programs,' the council's chief executive, Jack Gough, said.
There also appear to be moves afoot to provide an exception for motorists who test positive when using medical marijuana, a policy that both Buckingham and the Greens have pushed.
Unions, legal and medical experts have strongly criticised the government's attempts to curtail claims for psychological injury, warning that a 30% threshold would make it virtually impossible for people to make claims.
They have urged the government to first focus on prevention and educating employers about handling psychosocial injuries, rather than cutting off compensation.
The Unions NSW secretary, Mark Morey, said the result would be simply to cost shift on to the welfare and health systems.
Compensation for injured public servants comes out of the Treasury Managed Fund (TMF), which is already under enormous pressure due to natural disaster funding in the last year.
The full extent of the fund's deterioration will be revealed in the budget on 24 June.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
41 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Sydney restaurant faces human rights complaint after temporarily denying entry to people wearing keffiyehs
The Racial Justice Centre is preparing to file a group complaint with the Australian Human Rights Commission after a Sydney restaurant denied dine-in service to people wearing Palestinian keffiyehs during a 20-minute period last weekend. The legal centre will file the complaint to Australia's national anti-discrimination body on behalf of six Palestinian complainants, regarding an incident that took place on 3 August at Merivale-owned Jimmy's Falafel in the Sydney CBD after the Sydney Harbour Bridge march, first reported by the Sydney Morning Herald. Guardian Australia has spoken to four people, not part of the complaint, who report being told they would be barred from eating inside at Jimmy's Falafel unless they removed their keffiyehs. A man who wishes to be identified as Amir – not his real name – travelled from Queensland to Sydney to attend the pro-Palestine protest. Afterwards, Amir and his friend Hasan, who were both wearing Palestinian keffiyehs, went searching for food and stumbled across Jimmy's Falafel on George Street. Sign up: AU Breaking News email Amir said while they were asking a restaurant employee if a table was vacant, a security guard approached the pair and said their scarves could not be worn inside the venue and had to be removed if they wanted to dine in. The security guard said the directive came from the restaurant manager, Amir said. 'We were quite shocked that this is happening to us, right in the centre of Sydney,' he said. Amir, who said he saw other people also being turned away due to wearing keffiyehs, said the pair calmly left the venue. Keffiyehs, traditional scarves worn across the Middle East, are often worn by people expressing support for Palestine. A Merivale spokesperson said in a written statement that Jimmy's Falafel was patronised by many who participated in the Harbour Bridge protest march on 3 August, including 'many, many people wearing keffiyehs and hijabs'. The statement said that a management decision was made at about 3.55pm 'that people carrying large flags and placards should not carry or display them within the Jimmy's Falafel venue', after instances of members of the public 'yelling obscenities and violent rhetoric' at Merivale venues on George Street, including comments such as 'death to the IDF', 'death to all Zionist pigs' and 'f***ing Zionist pigs and scum'. 'Jimmy's staff understood that decision as providing that persons wearing political garb and/or carrying flags and placards should be kindly asked to remove those items (place them in their bags) before entering,' the spokesperson said. 'This meant that for the period 3.55pm to 4.15pm, people wearing political items of clothing were politely asked to remove those items and place them in their bags before entering.' Merivale CCTV footage, viewed by Guardian Australia, shows that during that 20-minute window, some patrons wearing keffiyehs left the venue or were turned away, while others removed them before entering or ordering takeaway. The footage shows other diners wearing keffiyehs inside the venue during that period, as well as at other points during the day. On the footage, which did not include audio, just before the start of the 20-minute period, protesters appear to yell into the venue. 'To be clear, at no time was anyone refused entry or discriminated against due to their political or religious affiliations. As you can imagine, it was a day of thousands of people attending the city. It was a challenging time for venue staff, and we of course have an obligation to their safety and comfort. Merivale is politically neutral and has no interest whatsoever in disabusing any patron of their religious or political views,' the spokesperson said. 'No Merivale venues including Jimmy's Falafel have policies on customers wearing keffiyehs or other scarves.' Sharfah Mohamed, a lawyer at the Racial Justice Centre, said: 'Our position is that Merivale's conduct breaches the federal Racial Discrimination Act. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion In a written statement, Mohamed said that security personnel 'in all types of venues are required to respond to threats to safety on a case-by-case basis based on actual conduct'. 'As to neutrality, there is nothing neutral about banning the cultural garment of a specific racial or ethnic group,' Mohamed said. Hasan, who requested his last name be withheld, said the security guard did not say why they were not allowed to wear the keffiyehs inside the venue. 'We were humiliated. I felt humiliated,' he said. Hasan, who is Lebanese, said the keffiyeh resonates with Palestinians and is a symbol of 'hope and freedom'. 'We just wanted to become one with the Palestinian people and show solidarity with them,' he said. Amir said he now fears wearing a keffiyeh in public or expressing his opinion about the conflict in the Middle East. 'I feel quite shocked, traumatised and humiliated,' he said. Qamar Albashir said he was wearing a Moroccan scarf when his group of six people approached Jimmy's Falafel . He said the security guard told the group, which included three people wearing keffiyehs, they could not enter the venue wearing the scarves and would have to remove them to go inside. 'We were kind of dumbfounded. When [they] said we couldn't go in we ask why not, and the security guard said it was a private establishment. We were lost for words.' 'It felt really horrible. We felt further anguished because our kids were there with us.' A fourth man, who requested anonymity, said he was also denied entry to Jimmy's Falafel on the afternoon of the march while wearing a Jordanian keffiyeh. 'We were told by the security guard that we wouldn't be allowed in because we were wearing scarves,' he said. 'We were in shock at first.' The man said he was accompanied by his wife, who was wearing a Palestinian keffiyeh, and his friend, who was not wearing a scarf. He said the group observed two other groups, where some members were wearing Palestinian keffiyehs, who were denied entry on the same basis. The man said his friend ordered takeaway food from the venue from the street for the group.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Donald Trump's 'disgust' at Albanese's move to recognise a Palestinian state
Donald Trump has slammed the Australian government's decision to recognise a Palestinian state, with a US official warning the White House is 'disgusted'. US Ambassador to Israel and former Arkansas Governor, Mike Huckabee met with the President and discussed Prime Minister Anthony Albanese 's controversial move. He said Trump, and senior members of his administration, had shared their confusion with Australia's foreign policy. 'There's an enormous level of disappointment and some disgust,' the ambassador told ABC's 7.30 on Thursday. 'I don't know that the president used that word, [but] I would say that is a characterisation of a sentiment. 'I think it does express the emotional sentiment, a sense of, "You've got to be kidding... why would they be doing this?".' The ambassador branded the timing 'terrible' and claimed it was a 'gift' to Hamas as it would negatively impact any negotiations of a settlement in Gaza. He said the decision to recognise a Palestinian state would also directly impact Hamas' remaining Israeli hostages and that it has endangered the hope of a peaceful resolution. Albanese revealed on Monday that Australia would recognise Palestinian statehood, following similar commitments by Western allies including the UK, France and Canada. 'Today I can confirm that at the 80th session of the United Nations General Assembly in September, Australia will recognise the state of Palestine,' he told reporters. 'Australia will recognise the right of the Palestinian people to a state of their own predicated on the commitments Australia has received from the Palestinian Authority.' The Prime Minister said his government's backing of Palestinian statehood was contingent on the promise Hamas would play no future role in the state. The commitments also include free elections being held in Palestine and demilitarisation of the region. Ambassador Huckabee criticised Albanese for not notifying the US of his government's decision to recognise Palestine. 'As Israel's closest partner, we would have expected that there would have been some heads up,' he said. However, Foreign Minister Penny Wong has said she personally spoke to US Secretary of State Marco Rubio about the decision as a 'matter of courtesy'. Ambassador Huckabee was also asked whether the Trump administration had tried to influence Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's conduct in the war in Gaza. He said the US respected the fact they were attacked on October 7 and that he was tired of people blaming Israel for defending itself. The ambassador's comments come after Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu slammed Australia's recognition of Palestinian statehood as 'shameful'. During a rare press conference for international media, Netanyahu said it was an 'absurdity' to recognise Palestine and singled out Australia - before the country had announced its stance. 'It defies imagination or understanding how intelligent people around the world, including seasoned diplomats, government leaders, and respected journalists, fall for this absurdity,' he said. 'To have European countries and Australia march into that rabbit hole just like that is disappointing, and I think it's actually shameful.' Netanyahu also vehemently denied the accusations Israel has led a 'starvation policy', denying Palestinians access to food and humanitarian aid. Evidence from international human rights groups suggests aid restrictions have led to the dire situation currently playing out in Gaza. According to the Gaza Health Ministry, as of Wednesday, 235 people, including 106 children, had died from hunger-related deaths since the war began in October 2023. Gaza Health officials also reported that 20 Palestinian civilians were shot dead last week while trying to seek aid outside humanitarian depots.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Morning Mail: Coalition's ‘Willy Wonka' summit complaint, property investor splurge, Trump hopes for Putin deal
Morning everyone. Jim Chalmers has given us the big buildup for his economic summit next week but the Coalition is now comparing him to Willy Wonka giving away golden tickets for a 'privileged talk-fest' (with economic reform, presumably, as the chocolate). Back in the real economy, new figures show property investors are borrowing more than ever and edging first-time buyers out of contention. Donald Trump thinks Vladimir Putin is ready to make a deal in Alaska, while the AFLW season is up and running with a win for Carlton over Collingwood. Koala threat | Habitat for threatened koalas that are part of a population described by one expert as nationally significant would be bulldozed under plans to extend a Queensland coalmine. 'Candy man' | The Coalition has likened the treasurer's much-anticipated economic summit next week to Charlie and Chocolate Factory and dubbed Jim Chalmers 'Australia's candy man' as it challenges Labor proposals it says would increase taxes and pass debt to future generations. NSW | The Minns government will establish a $1m program to combat anti-Muslim hate, including establishing a support hotline for victims and a program to build awareness of Islamophobia. Investor record | Property investors borrowed a record sum, nearly $130bn, to buy homes over the year to June, supported by interest rate cuts but squeezing out first-time buyers, according to figures out today. Stratton tributes | Legendary film critic David Stratton has been remembered for his 'incredible insight', 'humility' and 'deep love of cinema' in tributes after his death at age 85. Catch up with Luke Buckmaster's personal tribute here, and our obituary of the revered cinephile. Deal or no deal? | Donald Trump believes Vladimir Putin is ready to make a deal on the war in Ukraine as the two leaders prepare for their summit in Alaska, but his suggestion the Russian leader and Volodymyr Zelenskyy could 'divvy things up' may alarm some in Kyiv. The Russian president is expected to tempt his US counterpart with financial incentives from Russia's 'untapped' economic potential in exchange for siding with him. Keir Starmer and Zelenskyy met in Downing Street (pictured) and hailed 'a visible chance for peace' – so long as Putin takes steps to prove he is serious. And our American politics podcast asks if Trump is too weak to be a strongman. Settler split | Israel appears set to give formal planning approval to a highly controversial settlement project for more than 3,400 new homes – which has been frozen for decades – which critics say would split the occupied West Bank in half. Cholera outbreak | The 'worst cholera outbreak in years' has killed at least 40 people in the past week in Sudan, according to the medical charity Médecins Sans Frontières. India floods | At least 37 people have died and more than 200 are missing after a sudden rainstorm in Indian Kashmir, the second such disaster in the Himalayas in a little over a week. Aztec gold | Nearly five centuries after Spanish conquistador Hernán Cortés signed it and decades after someone swiped it from national archives, a priceless manuscript page has been returned by the FBI to Mexico. Newsroom edition: can Labor jumpstart the economy? Bridie Jabour talks to the head of newsroom, Mike Ticher, and our economics editor, Patrick Commins, about whether the Albanese government has the ambition for big reform. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ The Greens have urged Labor to stop allowing manufacturers of F-35 fighter jet parts to sell to global suppliers that can then pass them on to Israel – but the government says such claims are 'misinformation'. So who's telling the truth? Henry Belot investigates. After an opening volume called Young Hawke: The Making of a Larrikin, the second part of David Day's biography of Bob Hawke is The Making of a Legend and explores how he quit drinking to help become prime minister. Paul Daley writes that 'those of us voted for him … won't regret it when they read this book. But they will understand a lot more about the man's fabric.' Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion AFLW | A slick Carlton performance saw off Collingwood in the AFLW's opening match in Melbourne last night and there were enough flashes of brilliance from the league's newest faces to show the competition has a future. Rugby union | The Wallabies' promising backs will come up against the formidable South African forwards in Johannesburg this weekend, but veteran James O'Connor will lead the playmaking duties after being recalled for the start of the Rugby Championship. Swimming | Michael Phelps has launched a scathing attack on USA Swimming's leadership with the 23-times Olympic gold medallist branding the body weak and demanding sweeping reforms after what he sees as years of decline. The University of Technology has suspended enrolments for more than 100 courses next year amid financial problems and plans to axe about 400 jobs, the Sydney Morning Herald reports. Transurban says it will refund drivers for incorrect toll charges, which it blames on an increase in number plate duplicates, the Canberra Times says. Changes to Western Australia's gun laws have been backed by parliament despite an attempt to stop them, WAtoday reports. Economy | CommBank data release on household spending. New South Wales | Committal at Parkes courthouse for the man accused of the domestic violence murder of Molly Ticehurst. Arts | Children's book of the year award winners announced at the National Library in Canberra. If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword
