Concerns over R500 million spent on outsourcing matric exam paper printing
Image: Oupa Mokoena / Independent Newspapers
One provincial Education Department spending more than half a billion rand on printing matric exam question papers has shocked members of Parliament.
They accused some of the provincial Education departments of collapsing their printing facilities to outsource this duty to private companies.
The Select Committee on Education, Science and Creative Industries Chairperson, Makhi Feni, raised the concern after the committee heard this week that the Gauteng Education Department, which had a three-year contract to print exam papers for its North West counterpart, had since outsourced its exam paper printing.
After the end of its Gauteng contract, the North West Education Department signed a more than R500 million five-year contract with a private company, which was not named.
'I am not supporting that when you are having the service, you collapse the service and you run to the private service provider,' Feni said.
This would mean that the North West Education Department was now spending over R100 million a year on a private printing company.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad Loading
Gauteng Education Department spokesperson, Steve Mabona, declined to respond to questions sent to him regarding his province outsourcing its exam printing service.
The deputy director-general of the North West Education Department, responsible for exam papers, informed the committee that in 2009, the department secured printing machines from Bytes Solutions and Altron Solutions; however, their contracts were not renewed in 2019.
The province spent more than R69 million printing with the Government Printing Works (GPW) between 2019 and 2022, and also signed for R27 million to print with the Gauteng Education Department between 2023 and 2024.
The latest contract with a private company, which started at the beginning of the 2024/2025 financial year and would end in 2029, contained extra security, transport, and storage features for the papers, which were available in the previous contracts.
The Gauteng and North West departments had since joined the Eastern Cape in outsourcing the printing of their exam papers, while the Free State, KwaZulu-Natal, Mpumalanga, Northern Cape, and Western Cape departments still print in-house. Only Limpopo used the GPW facility.
Basic Education Chief Director, responsible for the National Assessment and Public Examinations, Rufus Poliah, told the committee in a virtual meeting held on Tuesday that the law allowed the provinces to handle the printing of their exams, but that should be transparent and cost-effective.
The exam papers were printed for the May/June examination for candidates who want to improve their results and adult candidates, and also for the main matric exams in October and November.
Poliah said departments have three options, which are for those who print in-house but do not have the facilities to hire printing machines, outsource, and use central government facilities.
He said those who insource use their staff for the printing job, while those who outsource are dependent on a private company to carry out the whole process, including providing the safety and distribution of the papers, while being monitored by Education officials.
He said the GPW was responsible for the printing of exam papers for the Department of Higher Education and Training's Technical Vocational Education and Training (TVET) colleges.
Feni expressed concern about the department spending money on private companies when the state has its printing facilities.
He said insourcing would bear no extra expenditure for the safety of the papers, as they would have to be protected by the police.
Feni stated that there were instances where learners would be out of transport because there was no money for that, while the money is being given away to private companies.
'They are giving away their responsibilities under the excuse that the facilities were not giving them satisfactory results. Why are you not enhancing your existing capacity to achieve your desired outcome?
'Why don't you buy your equipment? Are you telling me that the department is no longer having any technicians who can operate these particular works that you have been running, rather than going for private providers?' asked Feni.
'We must always take into cognisance the serious infrastructure backlog that provinces like the North West are confronted with.
'How does one balance the two, the infrastructure backlogs and the expenditure on this private company for printing?' said Feni.
He said there was nothing wrong with outsourcing the work if the government lacks the technical ability or skills, 'but outsourcing to private companies should be necessary and there ought to be plans for transfer of skills.'
'We will not tire of making the call to the enhancement of internal capacity within departments.
'If we continue along this line, are we doing away with the functions of the state?' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
2 days ago
- Daily Maverick
Joburg is refurbishing its hostels for R500m — Residents say it's a waste of money
A number of Johannesburg hostels are undergoing R500-million renovations, but critics say the upgrades are cosmetic and represent a step away from plans to transform the overcrowded hostels into family units, once framed as a transformative step towards improving the living standards and the dignity of residents. Last week, Gauteng Human Settlements MEC Tasneem Motara and Johannesburg Human Settlements MMC Mlungisi Mabaso visited inner-city hostels to inspect a R500-million refurbishment programme. Johannesburg's hostels are dilapidated, overcrowded and often lack basic services. Siyamthanda Nkabinde, who has lived at the George Goch Hostel in Benrose for more than a decade, told Daily Maverick: 'Prisoners and hostel dwellers are equal inmates. One is physically incarcerated and the other mentally imprisoned.' Regarding the upgrades, he said: 'I don't think they know what they are doing.' The Gauteng government has earmarked R500-million to upgrade the six hostels under its control, focusing on fixing the most immediate problems such as plumbing and electricity, replacing flooring, repairing building cracks, waterproofing the buildings and replacing paving. According to some residents, however, no level of renovations can gloss over their long-lost dignity. They want the government to fulfil its longstanding commitment to transform the single-sex hostels into family units so they can live with their loved ones in a move away from the apartheid-era hostel system. George Goch resident Mdumiseni Miya said the renovations were being used to hoodwink residents into thinking that their housing problems were coming to an end. 'We want family units, which guarantee safety, dignity and comfort for families. There is no point in tiling, painting or filling buildings which are falling apart,' Miya said. 'We know they are wasting money on the collapsing buildings so that they can be seen to be doing something ahead of the upcoming elections.' Short-term plan Renovations are already under way in five of the six hostels in Johannesburg under the control of the Gauteng government. Renovations on the sixth hostel will begin within two months, and the process of appointing a contractor has just been concluded. The project is expected to take three years. Motara said the provincial government was undertaking the renovations to ensure that the hostels were habitable and had adequate living conditions. She said the long-term goal was to convert the hostels into family units, but that would be 'expensive as it involves redesign, demolitions and replanning'. 'Here, we didn't have to do redesigns. We have had to deal with the actual design as it is, and this will save the cost,' Motara said. The six hostels earmarked for renovation are George Goch, Jeppestown, Denver, MBA, Murray & Roberts, and LTA (Rethabile) hostels. Gauteng has a total of 65 hostels, but the other 59 are managed by municipalities. Motara told Daily Maverick this week: 'The overall strategy in relation to hostels is to redevelop them into family/housing units. But the six owned by the province are not currently approved for redevelopment [into family units]. 'Our current plan as the province is to renovate the six hostels we own as well as support the various cities across the province to at least renovate one per region that is owned by the municipalities,' Motara said. Professor Marie Huchzermeyer, from Wits University's School of Architecture and Planning, said: 'The frustration for those on the waiting list for a family unit is understandable, given past promises. However, renovation, if carried out with integrity, can lead to immediate improvements in people's lives.' Cost concerns The DA has expressed alarm over the cost and questioned what work is being done. 'Simply, to go along, visit the place, and then say R500-million is going to be spent — as far as we are concerned, that is meaningless,' said the DA's shadow human settlements MEC Mervyn Cirota, who has questioned why the province is refurbishing the hostels rather than converting them to family units. Cirota called on Motara to provide specific details for the R500-million plan. 'There has to be motivation, there has to be a plan, there has to be a timeline, there has to be a roll-out, and there has to be oversight so that we do not have the same scenario again. Promises keep being made, and no delivery.' 'Betrayal' At 88 years old, Shalaza Mbatha is no stranger to the corridors of Denver Hostel. He's not just one of its oldest and longest-serving indunas, he is also a living archive of the hostel's history. 'It's not just disappointing, it's a betrayal of a conversation that's been going on for years,' Mbatha said of the move to refurbish the hostels rather than upgrade them to family units. He did, however, note the challenges in building family units, saying that new structures should be built as converting the hostel in its current form could pose dangers to women and children. 'Some people are happy that the hostels are being renovated, but they are looking to continue staying with their families, which is why the family units are a necessity. 'The people must be built these family units after all these years of complete neglect of the hostels by the government,' he said. 'This way, everybody's dignity would be fully restored.' Jeppestown Hostel resident Khulekani Sibiya asked Daily Maverick: 'Have you ever seen a hostel as rotten as the Jeppestown Hostel? 'When I am sleeping at night, I can see the sky because there is no roof above. We are living like pigs; even pigs live a better life. Hostel dwellers are on their own in this country.'' Municipal facilities The bulk of hostels in Gauteng are managed by municipalities, with at least 13 falling under the City of Johannesburg. In March 2025, Johannesburg housing MMC Mabaso said the City had earmarked R10-billion to fix its hostels. When asked what would happen to the 59 hostels currently under the control of municipalities, Motara said the province was helping municipalities conduct assessments on the conditions at each facility. 'This provides the municipalities with an accurate state of the property. We are encouraging the municipalities to now budget for the work that needs to be done, or use the information to go to the next steps of addressing the current state of the properties,' Motara said. 'It is now the responsibility of the individual municipalities to action and implement the same. We will support the municipalities in so far as we are able to.' The City of Johannesburg is conducting a detailed social survey of its hostels, which Huchzermeyer said was necessary to tailor redevelopment to the needs of residents. 'A tailored approach must be welcomed as more appropriate than the one-size-fits-all hostel-to-homes plans of the past, which also envisaged home ownership. These assumed every hostel dweller has a family and qualifies for a capital subsidy. 'A far more nuanced approach is needed that considers needs and affordability, and actively avoids displacing residents. From what I can gather, the City of Johannesburg is adopting this approach, whereas Gauteng's six hostels will be renovated until such time as budgets are available for redevelopment,' said Huchzermeyer. The DA, meanwhile, has questioned whether Gauteng municipalities are able to implement hostel upgrades, given that plans have been derailed in the past. It is calling for the control of all of the province's hostels to be centralised under the provincial government. 'We are of the view that all hostels in Gauteng must fall under the [provincial] Hostel Redevelopment Plan,' Cirota told Daily Maverick. 'The municipalities are unable, unwilling and just do not have the capacity to fix the hostels. It's been many years.' DM
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Parliament slams Operation Dudula's ‘vigilante tactics'
Parliament emphasised that it must operate within established legal frameworks rather than extrajudicial means. The chairperson of parliament's Select Committee on Education, Science and the Creative Industries has condemned Operation Dudula's campaign to disrupt services at healthcare centres and schools. Makhi Feni expressed his disapproval of the organisation's actions, which have prevented foreign nationals from accessing healthcare facilities in recent months. Three arrested members of Operation Dudula were released on Monday on a warning after appearing in the Orlando Magistrate's Court. They were arrested for denying foreign nationals access to healthcare at the Lilian Ngoyi Clinic in Diepkloof. Police allege the women stormed the maternity ward at the clinic and tried to remove a pregnant woman. ALSO READ: 'We've not broken any laws': Operation Dudula to press on with ID checks after members freed on warning The arrests did not deter them. Shortly after their release, they marched straight back to the clinic to remove undocumented migrants. Operation Dudula announced last week that it plans to carry out similar disruptions at schools when they reopen in 2026. Operation Dudula's vigilante approach condemned The organisation's tactics have drawn sharp criticism from some in parliament. 'Operation Dudula's actions have the potential to misrepresent our country and our democracy. South Africa is a country of law and order, and these should be strictly adhered to,' said Feni on Tuesday. The parliamentary chairperson described the organisation's actions as problematic and counterproductive to government efforts addressing immigration challenges. 'The actions of Operation Dudula are objectionable and are an unnecessary distraction to the work the government is doing around immigration challenges. People do not just come to South Africa out of free will but for refuge and from hunger,' he added. ALSO READ: Gauteng health MEC warns against denying foreign nationals health care access Feni emphasised that the government must operate within established legal frameworks rather than extrajudicial means. 'We cannot all adopt vigilante tactics when dealing with a challenge everyone accepts as massive and worthy of resolution. Legislative amendments and means are being proposed to resolve this challenge,' he said. Government initiatives underway The chairperson highlighted several government initiatives already in motion to address immigration concerns. In 2024, authorities established the Border Management Agency to manage border-related issues more effectively. 'On the labour front, something is being done with the Labour Migration Policy. Home Affairs is deporting those it can, who have been found to have been in the country illegally,' Feni explained. He called on Operation Dudula to collaborate constructively with the government rather than targeting vulnerable populations. Operation Dudula leader defiant Operation Dudula leader Zandile Dabula remained defiant when speaking to the media, criticising the legal process her organisation faces. 'There's no way that you will keep people in jail for five days and give them free bail and take them out on a warning. We have been treated like this is a Schedule 6 offence,' she said. Dabula drew comparisons between current government actions and historical oppression. 'The government of the ANC and the GNU together. They're taking us back to the apartheid days. They're using the system. It's just coming in a different colour now. They're using the police to work against us,' she stated. Escalation threats and continued operations Dabula indicated her organisation would intensify its activities despite government opposition. 'Now we're going to do what the ANC did to the apartheid government. Now we're going to do it to the ANC government, together with the GNU, whatever they call themselves. We're not going to stop,' Dabula declared. She stopped short of explicitly calling for violence but suggested confrontation is possible. 'I'm not inciting violence, but if we have to fight. If this country has to be ungovernable, then let it be. We're going to operate,' she said. Dabula maintained that her organisation operates within legal boundaries while the government fails to enforce existing laws. 'There is nothing wrong that we have done. We have not broken any laws. Instead, we are implementing and enforcing the laws that the government is failing to enforce,' she claimed. READ NEXT: Operation Dudula wants to know why organisations prioritise foreign nationals
The South African
08-08-2025
- The South African
Growing calls for SASSA grant recipients to be exempt from TAX
A latest deep dive into South Africa's tax revenue methodology makes a sound argument for SASSA grant beneficiaries being exempt from tax. By the same rationale, government employees should be exempt from tax, too. But why exactly? According to the latest tax revenue figures from the South African Revenue Service (SARS), the country generated R1.1 trillion in 2024/2025. Of that, R267 billion was generated through personal income tax (PIT) and value-added tax (VAT) of SASSA grant recipients and government employees. The argument against tax exemption is that too many residents (45%) receive a SASSA grant of some sort. Image: File There is a perfectly sound argument that this amount going to SASSA beneficiaries and government employees should be exempt from tax. Roughly one quarter of South Africa's tax revenue is money the government pays out as it sees fit and then re-appropriates back to itself, reports Daily Investor . Therefore, economists and financial experts believe that government employees and SASSA grant recipients could just as well be exempt from tax. The argument being it's 'inefficient and wasteful' to pay SASSA grants using tax collections, only to tax a portion of the funds back into the fiscus. As of 2025, roughly 45% of the country's population receives a government grant of some sort. This accounts for the second highest spend of national budget, after debt servicing. The current tax approach merely moves 25% of the fiscus around 'wastefully' with no real benefit. Image: File However, the complexity and potential for fraud is ultimately what experts say makes this approach largely unfeasible. While SARS collected R1.1 trillion total revenue in 2024/2025, R762 billion was shelled out to SASSA grant recipients and government employees. At a personal income tax rate of 21.3%, government employees were responsible for R162 billion income generation. This is roughly 25% of all revenue received. Combined with VAT, the amount payable is more than R100 billion. This means government employees and social grant recipients are responsible for around 23% of all VAT receipts. While private consumption accounts for 77%. Total Personal Income Tax in 2024/2025 – R651 400 000 000 (100%) (100%) Private Employee Personal Income Tax – R488 988 565 000 (75%) (75%) Government Employee/SASSA Personal Income Tax – R162 411 435 000 (25%) Total VAT Receipts 2024/2025 – R447 600 000 000 (100%) (100%) VAT Receipts on Private Consumption – R342 576 718 725 (77%) (77%) VAT Receipts on Government Employees – R81 011 281 275 (18%) (18%) VAT Receipts on SASSA beneficiaries – R24 012 000 000 (5%) Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
