Affront to Bengal's dignity: CM on NITI's map goof-up
summary report on Bengal, showing a map of Bihar instead of the state on the cover page, prompted CM
on Wednesday to write a strongly worded letter to its vice-chairman, Suman K Bery, demanding an immediate "clarification and apology".
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
"I am writing with deep concern and unequivocal disapproval that in the 'Summary Report for the State of West Bengal', published by NITI Aayog and available on its website... the map intended to represent the state of West Bengal has depicted the territory of Bihar in its place," the CM wrote.
Later in the day, the page was no longer available.
Banerjee said in her letter: "Such a grave lapse in an official document of a premier national institution is not merely a technical error but an affront to the identity and dignity of the state of West Bengal.
Such a blunder in an official publication of NITI Aayog reflects an alarming lack of diligence and respect towards the States of the Union."
Such representations "raise legitimate concerns about the rigour and reliability of the institution's work, which policymakers and citizens alike depend upon for accurate and informed decision-making, and cast significant doubt on the quality, authenticity, and credibility of reports and publications of NITI Aayog," she wrote.
"The govt of West Bengal strongly condemns this inaccuracy and calls upon NITI Aayog to issue a clarification and apology and take immediate corrective action to rectify the document and to institute robust mechanisms to prevent such lapses in future," Banerjee added.
Trinamool spokesperson Saket Gokhale also took to X to say it was "pathetic" that the Centre couldn't even place Bengal on an India map. Gokhale pointed out that BJP had 12 Lok Sabha MPs from Bengal, including two junior Union ministers, but "shamelessly" showed Bihar as Bengal on a map.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Linking this with the issues, including NRC, that have pitted Trinamool govt against the Centre, Gokhale said: "BJP has been targeting and harassing Bengalis in every state ruled by them. CM Mamata Banerjee has also exposed how the Modi govt wants to impose NRC in Bengal out of fear of losing elections."
posted on X: "We demand that NITI Aayog issue a formal clarification, offer an unconditional apology, take immediate corrective steps to rectify the document, and establish strong quality control mechanisms to prevent such egregious lapses in the future."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
26 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Mamata slams Delhi police for calling Bengali a Bangladeshi language
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Sunday accused the Delhi Police of describing Bengali as a "Bangladeshi language", calling it scandalous, anti-national and unconstitutional. Sharing a letter by Delhi Police on X, Banerjee said, "See now how Delhi police under the direct control of the Ministry of Home, Government of India, is describing Bengali as 'Bangladeshi' language! Bengali, our mother tongue, the language of Rabindranath Tagore and Swami Vivekananda, the language in which our National Anthem and the National Song (the latter by Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay) are written, the language in which crores of Indians speak and write, the language which is sanctified and recognised by the Constitution of India, is now described as a Bangladeshi language!!" She called the act 'scandalous' and urged everyone to strongly protest against the government for disrespecting Bengali-speaking people. "Scandalous, insulting, anti-national, unconstitutional!! This insults all Bengali-speaking people of India. They cannot use this kind of language which degrades and debases us all. We urge immediate strongest possible protests from all against the anti-Bengali Government of India who are using such anti-Constitutional language to insult and humiliate the Bengali-speaking people of India," the post reads. On July 28, Banerjee said she is not against any language or community and supports unity in diversity. Addressing the Bhasha Andolan in Birbhum, Mamata Banerjee said, "I am not against any language or divisive policy. We want unity in diversity. Have I told Hindi-speaking people to leave Bengal? I never said that. You are also my are 1.5 crore migrant workers in Bengal, and 22 lakh people from Bengal work in other states. You should stop your oppression." A row over the Bengali language surfaced after Banerjee and the Trinamool Congress raised the issue during the 'Shahid Dibas' (Martyrs' Day) celebrations on July 21.
India Today
26 minutes ago
- India Today
Trinamool claims Delhi Police called Bengali a Bangladeshi language, BJP retorts
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and her party, the Trinamool Congress (TMC), on Sunday went ballistic against the Delhi Police for allegedly addressing Bangla as a "Bangladeshi" language. She also accused the Centre of using "anti-Constitutional language to insult and humiliate Bengali- speaking people".The Trinamool chief shared a letter purportedly written by the Lodhi Colony Police Station and was addressed to the Banga Bhawan in Delhi with the subject line reading "Translation of documents containing text written in Bangladeshi language-regarding".advertisementThe purported letter was written by the police to apprise the Banga Bhawan about the arrest of eight suspected Bangladeshi nationals illegally living in India without any valid documents. India Today TV could not verify the authenticity of the purported letter."See now how Delhi police under the direct control of Ministry of Home, Government of India is describing Bengali as " Bangladeshi" language! Bengali, our mother tongue, the language of Rabindranath Tagore and Swami Vivekananda, the language in which our National Anthem and the National Song (the latter by Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay) are written, the language in which crores of Indians speak and write, the language which is sanctified and recognised by the Constitution of India, is now described as a Bangladeshi language!!" the West Bengal Chief Minister sent out a scathing the Delhi Police's alleged reference "scandalous, insulting, anti- national, unconstitutional", the Trinamool Congress Supremo added, "This insults all Bengali-speaking people of India. They cannot use this kind of language which degrades and debases us all. We urge immediate strongest possible protests from all against the anti-Bengali Government of India who are using such anti-Constitutional language to insult and humiliate the Bengali- speaking people of India".The picture of the letter shared by Mamata Banerjee also had another part of it highlighted in yellow, which read, "The identification document contains texts written in Bangladeshi and are needed to be translated to Hindi and English. Now for the investigation to proceed further, it is requested that an official translator/interpreter proficient in Bangladeshi national language may kindly be provided for the aforesaid purpose".Calling the purported letter an attempt to "defame Bengal", Trinamool MP Abhishek Banerjee also attacked the Centre, saying, "For months now, Bengali-speaking people have been targeted, harassed and detained across BJP-ruled states. Now, in a shocking escalation, @DelhiPolice has officially referred to Bangla, as a "Bangladeshi language" in an official letter".He accused the government of trying to undermine the Bangla cultural identity and equate West Bengal with Bangladesh for "narrow political propaganda".advertisementEchoeing her senior party leaders, Trinamool MP Mahua Moitra lashed out at the BJP government in the Centre, demanded an apology by the Delhi Police and sought strict action against the officer concerned. She also attacked the Central and Delhi governments over the crackdown against illegal said it was not a clerical mistake but a calculated action by the BJP and the Centre to delegitimise Bengali and Bengal's linguistic REBUTS TRINAMOOL'S CLAIMSThe BJP reacted strongly to the Trinamool Congress's claims and accused Mamata Banerjee of fanning enmity between people of different cultures by "weaponising language"."It is beyond shameful that West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee is defending a lawful police action against illegal Bangladeshi infiltrators by weaponising language and stoking sentiment. Let us be absolutely clear: all illegal Bangladeshi infiltrators and Rohingyas will be dealt with strictly, as per the law of the land," BJP IT cell chief Amit Malviya tweeted."No political grandstanding or vote-bank politics will come in the way of protecting India's sovereignty and national security. Of all people, Mamata Banerjee should know this," he added.- Ends
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Amid 'Bangladeshi' Row, Bengal SIR Buzz Amit Shah To Meet State BJP MPs Tomorrow
Last Updated: The meeting between Union Home Minister Amit Shah and the BJP's Bengal MPs is scheduled for the same day the TMC is holding a virtual huddle Union Home Minister Amit Shah is set to hold a crucial meeting with BJP MPs from West Bengal in the national capital on Monday. This comes as political tension escalates over the 'Bangladeshi" row in New Delhi. The controversy has attracted a barrage of criticism from Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and the Trinamool Congress, who have accused the Centre of targeting Bengalis and their language via police verification drive in BJP-ruled states against illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. Although there has been no official statement from the BJP, party insiders indicate that the meeting will focus on addressing these allegations. During a rally at Durgapur in July, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had made it clear that the BJP will not be defensive on this issue. 'This is why infiltration is being encouraged, their fake documents are being created. An entire ecosystem has been developed here. This is a threat to West Bengal, the country, and Bengali culture," he had said. He added: 'They (TMC) want to challenge the Constitution and constitutional institutions. The TMC is now speaking openly in their favour. Let me make it clear, those who are not citizens of India, those who have infiltrated illegally, will face action under the Constitution. The BJP will not allow any conspiracy against Bengal's pride to be successful. This is Modi's guarantee." The TMC has since labelled this stance as BJP's 'audacity" and intensified efforts to portray the saffron party as 'Bangla birodhi" (opposed to Bengali speakers), a label the BJP MPs are eager to dismiss. In another development, sources have suggested that a special intensive revision (SIR) for West Bengal is also likely to be part of the meeting's agenda. This voter list revision, akin to the one in poll-bound Bihar, reportedly includes sensitive assessment on demographic shifts and cross-border dynamics, which could impact both electoral strategy and security planning in the region. The SIR in Bihar has sparked protests from opposition parties. Earlier on Sunday, TMC leader Derek O'Brien termed the exercise as 'silent invisible rigging". The anticipated meeting between Shah and the Bengal MPs is scheduled for the same day the TMC is holding a virtual huddle. Mamata Banerjee is expected to address all her party MPs, many of whom are in Delhi for the ongoing monsoon session of Parliament. This meeting comes at a time when the BJP is reassessing its approach in West Bengal following a mixed performance in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections. Several MPs from the state have expressed concerns about internal coordination, grassroots support, and ideological messaging. While there is no official confirmation yet of the meeting's agenda, political observers believe it could shape the BJP's future strategy in Bengal ahead of the 2026 assembly polls. view comments Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
