Calls to change State of Origin 18th man rule as Reece Walsh, Bulldogs dudded
The highly controversial 18th man rule in State of Origin has once more cost the Bulldogs a star for this week's important Round 18 clash against the Brisbane Broncos this Friday.
FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer.
The side have been constantly burned by the problem, losing key players like Matt Burton and Kurt Mann previously without them even getting a run of rep footy.
Mann was the Maroons Reserve in Game 1, while Burton was the same for NSW in Game 2 and other occasions in past years.
This time, its metre-eating winger Jacob Kiraz whose selection by coach Laurie Daley as a precautionary back-up for Brian To'o will cost the Dogs significant yardage carries and a pair of safe hands.
The Penrith winger played through a knee injury in his sides tight win over Canterbury last week, but scan results have cleared To'o of any concern, meaning it is highly unlikely Kiraz will take to the field come Wednesday.
Brisbane find themselves in a similar problem, running out against the Bulldogs without superstar Reece Walsh who fills the Maroons 18th man slot and has been in great form since returning from injury.
'It's ridiculous...Jacob Kiraz and Reece Walsh, they should be allowed to play in their club teams,' Mark Geyer said on 2GB.
'We don't play (Origin) until next Wednesday. In fact, I think it's time in Origin for us to bring in an 18th and 19th man to sit on the bench — a forward and a back.
'Come on, we've outgrown that '18th man can't play' thing.
'It's just a bit of a bug bear of mine. The 18th man should be allowed to play for his club team.
Coach Billy Slater's decision to shift Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow to fullback to replace the injured Kalyn Ponga leaves Michael Maguire with their own equally devastating Origin casualty list.
In Game 2 it was Ezra Mam.
'It's interesting the 18th man rule, I don't think anyone agrees with the way it is,' Daley said on the Sky Sports radio on Monday.
'Matt (Burton) I think has been selected as 18th man five times, missed club games and hasn't played a part in the Origin games themselves.
'The reason why I picked Jacob, we've got one bloke who is in a bit of doubt and that's Brian To'o.
'We want to give him every chance to play and because the Bulldogs are playing on the Friday night we want to make sure if Brian is ruled out than Jacob has had a full 11 days preparation with us.'
Team performance manager Frank Ponissi on Triple M weighed in on the topic, suggesting on Wednesday that picking an 18th man solely from a team with the bye isn't solution for picking the optimal player.
'What makes it difficult is the draw is unbalanced, so you don't know who's going to play. Some weeks that situation … it may favour NSW more than QLD because there's more NSW players not playing that weekend compared to QLD,' he said.
'We've got to get the draw right before we get this particular issue correct.
'Origin has to be played in the middle of the season, it's so big and massive for our game. It's what we do with the NRL around the Origin period, we've got to get that right. So when we can sort that out, I think the 18th man and everything else will fall in line.'
Whether the NRL makes any changes to the 18th man rule following the series is yet to be seen as the discussion grows.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Courier-Mail
39 minutes ago
- Courier-Mail
West Indies v Australia, second Test day two live: Scoreboard, latest news from Grenada
Don't miss out on the headlines from Cricket. Followed categories will be added to My News. Australia is hoping to cash in on variable bounce in the Grenada pitch which reared its head on day one of the second Test against the West Indies. Pat Cummins has dismissed by a delivery which kept low, the most significant sign of demons in the pitch on the opening day of play. FOLLOW THE KEY MOMENTS FROM DAY TWO WITH DANIEL CHERNY BELOW 'I think there was probably opportunity there for a few more runs. But we're in the game with 280-plus. I think there was enough variable (bounce) there on day one,' Aussie keeper Alex Carey told SEN. 'Potentially that will come into play tomorrow, three and four. I guess prefer to have 280 than anything less and we're in the game.' On Pat Cummins' dismissal — when the ball kept alarmingly low — Carey said: 'We saw Pat Cummins' dismissal today. That's 50 overs in and it stays low. There was enough movement there early for sure.' Carey said Australia's top-three played encouragingly to help set up a total of 286 which was spearheaded by the gloveman and Beau Webster. 'I thought the openers started really well today … I thought Usman and especially Sam Konstas, his intent was fantastic. I thought he really looked the part out there today. Then Cam Green came in and did the same thing. Had great intent. Played good shots. He looked really solid. They are promising signs,' he said. X SUBSCRIBER ONLY Originally published as West Indies v Australia, second Test day two live: Scoreboard, latest news from Grenada
Daily Telegraph
an hour ago
- Daily Telegraph
Rosehill Turf Talk: Best bet gets key gear change, plus a $71 tip
Don't miss out on the headlines from Horse Racing. Followed categories will be added to My News. Form experts Mitch Cohen and Shayne O'Cass debate all the key chances at Rosehill Gardens on Saturday, including a recently-gelded Godolphin sprinter and a Kris Lees runner that will go around at a massive price. • PUNT LIKE A PRO: Become a Racenet iQ member and get expert tips – with fully transparent return on investment statistics – from Racenet's team of professional punters at our Pro Tips section. SUBSCRIBE NOW! ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Shayno: Hello Mitchy. I can't help myself; can never walk past an honour roll. Past Winter Stakes winners that stood out – San Domenico, Nebo Road, All Our Mob. You can go first Mitchy, who will join that list after Saturday? Mitch: Word is you're on the honour roll at a certain Thai restaurant in Haymarket, Shayno. As for the Winter Stakes, tipping it will be Welwal. He went enormous in that Civic Stakes behind Headley Grange and can go one better here. Wet track has to be a huge plus! • Darby tons up as the winners keep rolling Shayno: I am pretty keen on Ruby Flyer. In fact I made him my best bet. I hope it stays nice and wet, heavy would do more without being a bog. He got some very good form at a mile, so 1400m fresh is right up the alley. Mitch: Good to see a two-year-old race back on the program after a couple of weeks without, albeit there nearly all three now Shayno. I reckon we are going to see a very serious horse step out again – that's Raging Force. Tipping he makes a statement and we see him making his presence felt in races like the Rosebud soon. Shayno: This is a 'before scratchings' statement; but wow, what a line-up. I should have learned by now that race experience is gold in two-year-old racing, more so on a heavy track but I fancy one of Waller's bluebloods to run well here, namely the Gerry Harvey-bred Portofino. Mitch: Could we see a Kerry Parker quinella in the Midway? Close Encounter and Equilibrist look to be great chances and they're both double figure odds. • Pride has eyes on weather for Winter Stakes top seed Shayno: I feel like you should be writing this one Mitchy. but I have a Kembla quinella for this Midway too. Kerry Parker's Equilibrist is so close to a win and so far as I see it, Noble Soldier's 'best' beats them all. Mitch: All Kembla content welcome here mate. If we are looking elsewhere, I am really keen on Tarpaulin first run back a gelding. This is a horse that finished a length off the winner in Group 2 company last prep and finds himself in a Benchmark 78 here. The wet track should be no worries for him. • Sistina's a special but still plenty of intrigue for horse of the year gongs Shayno: Whatever happens I hope it is no better than a Soft 7 by the last so my longshot of the day, Valimi, wins. Mitch: As soon as I saw that name in the form guide, I knew you'd be finding it. $71 for the punters. The value for me is Cormac T, race 7. Reckon he bounces back in a big way. Originally published as Rosehill Turf Talk: Key gear change for Mitch Cohen's best bet on Saturday as Shayne O'Cass takes swing at $71 pop
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
AFL round 17 Carlton v Collingwood: Scores, news from MCG
Collingwood has kicked clear of a struggling Carlton as the Blues' season continues to spiral. Captain Patrick Cripps could be seen pointing in an animated discussion with Zac Williams as the Blues trod off the field at half-time, carrying a 24-point deficit. It only got worse after the major break as the Magpies put the foot down on their arch rivals. After a bright start for Carlton, a glaring skill gap between the two sides opened up as an efficient Collingwood took over, with Nick Daicos heading into the shed with 15 disposals and a goal to his name. Daicos was brilliant in the first half despite plenty of attention from George Hewett. While the Blues have found the ball often, continuous errors from the likes of Adam Cerra and Blake Acres put a stop to potential attacks. Amid a quiet season, Blues forward Jesse Motlop had one notable moment in the first term, when he converted a goal and then sat down to recreate the celebration of Liverpool soccer player Diogo Jota, who tragically died this week in a car crash at the age of 28. Motlop sat down cross-legged and pretended to play with a gaming console, reminiscent of a trademark Jota celebration. Motlop hits the Diogo Jota celebration 🎮 â�¤ï¸� ðŸ'° Watch #AFLBluesPies LIVE on ch. 504 or stream on Kayo: âœ�ï¸� BLOG ðŸ'¢ MATCH CENTRE — Fox Footy (@FOXFOOTY) July 4, 2025 SELWOOD RETURNS Collingwood assistant coach Scott Selwood has made a welcome return to Craig McRae's coaching box, back at a Magpies game for the first time since the tragic passing of his older brother Adam. The forwards coach of the Pies, Selwood has taken time away from the club and hasn't been at a match since Adam's death on May 17, the same day Collingwood faced Adelaide in round 10. Adam's twin Troy passed away earlier this year. A beloved figure at the Pies, Selwood was given as much time away as he needed but he returned to the club in other duties last month. Great to see Scott Selwood back at the club and in the coaches box tonight for the Pies after such a tough year. Collingwood has rejigged its coaches box in recent weeks but so happy to have their forwards coach back at the club as he grieves the loss of his brothers @foxfooty — Jon Ralph (@RalphyHeraldSun) July 4, 2025 Selwood ran a marathon around Albert Park in Melbourne on June 14, honouring a commitment to take on the hard yards as part of Carrie Bickmore's Beanies 4 Brain Cancer charity. He described the effort as a 'meaningful way to make a difference' and was proud to honour his brothers by going through the run.
