GEC alumni team counters ‘misleading reports' on collapsed building
Against the backdrop of the recent collapse of a commercial building in the city, a group of alumni from the Government Engineering College (GEC), Thrissur, has come forward with a fact-finding report to counter what it termed as 'misleading and damaging' information that wrongly implicated the college's structural engineering experts.
Several reports had suggested that the collapsed building had received a structural safety certificate from the GEC's Civil Engineering department, but documents and inspection records reviewed by the alumni reveal this claim as incorrect.
According to the team, the building had in fact been declared unsafe by a faculty member from the GEC on August 17, 2024 following a site inspection conducted in response to a request from the Thrissur Corporation.
The inspection was triggered by an incident the previous day, when glass panels from the first floor of the building shattered and fell, prompting the corporation to issue a formal letter requesting an urgent assessment.
The inspection report clearly stated that the building was not structurally sound, with supporting technical reasoning. Furthermore, on September 28, during a visit by a court-appointed advocate commission— based on a Kerala High Court order dated September 12 —the same GEC faculty member reiterated in person that the building was unsafe.
The team said the reports mistakenly referred to a safety certificate issued for the adjacent building that had been certified as safe on November 11. It was this certificate that had been misrepresented in public discourse.
The Government Engineering College, Thrissur, has long been authorised under the Kerala Building Rules to carry out structural assessments. Faculty members from the Civil Engineering department, especially those with postgraduate specialisation in structural engineering, have regularly served on expert panels formed by municipal bodies and even the Kerala High Court, the report says.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
8 hours ago
- The Hindu
HC orders arrest of vessel owned by MSC on admiralty suit filed by five exporters
The Kerala High Court has ordered the arrest of Liberian-flagged vessel MV MSC Manasa F, along with among others, its paraphernalia, furniture, etc., at present anchored in the Vizhinjam Port, on an admiralty suit filed by five exporters who lost their consignment following the sinking of Liberian-flagged container vessel MSC Elsa 3 off the Kochi coast on May 25. This order will remain in effect until the owner firm of the vessels deposited ₹6 crore in the High Court. The counsel for the petitioners submitted that each one of them had lost containers in which they had sent their cargo, when the vessel sank. The warrant of arrest would be withdrawn, and the conditional order of arrest would automatically be vacated once the amount was deposited or security was furnished by the company in the court, without (waiting for) any further order, the court said. The shipping company does not have any movable or immovable properties within the territory of India, and hence, the petitioners were entitled to invoke the admiralty jurisdiction of the court for the arrest and detention of the vessel, their counsel said.
India Today
11 hours ago
- India Today
Sister vessel of sunken Liberian ship to be held for deposit: Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court has directed state port authorities not to release a sister vessel of the Liberian ship MSC Elsa 3 unless a deposit of Rs 6 crore is furnished. The court passed this order on a petition filed by six cashew importers, who claimed that their consignments were on board MSC Elsa 3, the ship that sank off the state's coast on May 25. The court stated that the vessel may be released if proof of the deposit is Joy Thattil, counsel for the petitioners, told the court that the matter will be considered again at 1.45 pm today, during which the company is expected to provide evidence of the Kerala police have registered a case of rash navigation against the owner, master and crew of MSC Elsa 3, which was flagged in Liberia. The container vessel sank near Alappuzha district while reportedly carrying hazardous and combustible cargo. A First Information Report was filed at the Fort Kochi Coastal police station on June 11 under multiple sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, including those related to rash navigation, negligence with hazardous substances, and causing obstruction in a public navigational route. According to the FIR, the ship's owners and crew are accused of handling the vessel negligently, leading to its sinking and a subsequent environmental impact. The complaint alleges that hazardous materials were not managed properly, and that drifting containers have caused significant damage to the marine environment and affected the livelihoods of the fishing community, resulting in financial losses running into lakhs of rupees. The case was filed based on a complaint by C Shamji, a resident of Alappuzha Ministry of Defence has stated that MSC Elsa 3 was carrying 640 containers, including 13 with hazardous material and 12 containing calcium carbide. It was also loaded with 84.44 metric tonnes of diesel and 367.1 metric tonnes of furnace May 29, the Kerala government declared the wreckage of MSC Elsa 3 a state-specific disaster, given its potential environmental, social and economic implications. The Liberian-flagged ship had capsized and sunk in the Arabian Sea, 14.6 nautical miles off the Kerala coast. Since the sinking, containers have been found drifting ashore at various points along the coast in Alappuzha, Kollam and Ernakulam to a government order, the incident raised serious environmental concerns, particularly the risk of oil spills and the spread of hazardous cargo debris. IN THIS STORY#Kerala
The Hindu
12 hours ago
- The Hindu
Kerala shipwreck: State to file admiralty suit in High Court
The Secretary of Kerala's Disaster Management department has written to the Advocate General, to initiate action to file an admiralty suit before the Kerala High Court, regarding the sinking of container ship MSC Elsa 3 off the Alappuzha coast on May 25. The AG's advice has also been sought on action to be taken to 'arrest' any vessel of Elsa 3 Maritime Inc., MCM SA, or MSC Geneva within Kerala's waters, and the possibility of engaging a legal firm which has the expertise in maritime laws to defend the case on behalf of the State government. Furthermore, the Secretary has in a communication to the AG, sought the furnishing of documents/reports on the estimated loss (due to the sinking), as assessed by the committees constituted by the State government.
