Medics objecting to Sandie Peggie's return warned of culpability, tribunal told
Sandie Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton at Victoria Hospital, Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023.
She was placed on special leave after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about 'patient care'.
Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation.
The tribunal resumed in Dundee on July 16 after an initial set of hearings in February.
On Monday, service manager Charlotte Myles, who made a decision to lift the suspension on March 7, told the tribunal that two senior consultants and two senior nurses 'weren't happy' at her decision to allow Ms Peggie to return to work.
Ms Myles said that Dr Kate Searle and Dr Maggie Currer both objected to her decision, while senior nurse managers Esther Davidson and Louise Curran 'similarly expressed' objections, but were not able to give an 'accurate response' regarding alleged patient safety concerns.
She said she told Ms Peggie verbally on March 7 and in writing on March 12 that the suspension would be lifted. However, it was later reinstated due to issues with looking after the nurse's dog, and she returned to work around April 12 2024.
Ms Myles said that 'usually we don't like to suspend' and she believed there were no patient safety issues, the tribunal heard.
However she said that she 'wasn't impressed' by allegations made by senior medics and warned them to comply with correct protocols and policies.
Ms Myles said: 'When I explained to staff members they weren't particularly happy with my decision initially.'
She said she visited Dr Searle's office to co-ordinate a rota and was met with further objections, but warned the consultant she was 'culpable' if allegations were not reported correctly, the tribunal heard.
Ms Myles said: 'Kate Searle expressed unhappiness that we were taking Ms Peggie back into the workplace and made a comment saying there had been patient safety issues, there had been other behaviours towards a doctor. I asked if this had been investigated and reported appropriately, and she said no.
'I said that if these events had happened and they had not been reported, you were culpable.'
She added: 'They weren't happy but it was my sole responsibility to review the suspension. My primary concern is to make sure patients are getting seen.'
The witness said she did not know 'what the indicators were… to be suspended in the first place' and felt there 'was no risk', the tribunal heard.
Ms Myles said: 'I wasn't impressed; if someone wants to raise patient safety concern it should go through correct process and be escalated at the time the incident happened. My stance was: 'If you have not followed correct protocol and policy you are culpable'.'
She said that Ms Davidson alleged that a doctor had been subject to a racist slur by Ms Peggie, and branded allegations by Ms Curran that the nurse shared Donald Trump's views on gender 'tittle-tattle', the tribunal heard.
Ms Myles said: 'It was very similar, tittle-tattle of being a supporter of Donald Trump and sharing his views on gender. That's somebody's personal view and as long as it doesn't impact on workforce or patients or cause harm, people are entitled to have their private views.'
She said she perceived Dr Upton to be 'a female colleague', but said: 'I do believe we should make alterations to support everybody, but how we do it is completely out of my remit.'
During re-examination by Jane Russell KC, representing NHS Fife and Dr Upton, the witness was asked about the alleged comments.
Ms Myles said: 'I was told Sandie Peggie had called a member of the medical team a P**i but that was not reported formally; when I asked Esther which member of the team it was directed at, it took a while to get a response. I believe the person who was supposed to have had the comment directed at them doesn't recall the comment being directed at them.'
Judge Alexander Kemp asked if she had seen a previous risk assessment for suspending Ms Peggie, and the witness said she had not, despite asking for previous documentation prior to March 7.
The tribunal continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
30 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
JK Rowling slams ‘hapless' NHS bosses who suspended nurse for complaining about trans doc using female changing rooms
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) AUTHOR JK Rowling has slammed "hapless" NHS bosses for suspending a nurse who challenged a trans doctor in the female changing rooms. Sandie Peggie was suspended after she objected to sharing a changing room with Dr Beth Upton - a biological male - at the NHS Fife hospital where they both worked in Scotland. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 JK Rowling has slammed NHS bosses for their 'hapless and unprofessional' behaviour Credit: twitter/jkrowling 4 Sandie was suspended from work in January 2024 Credit: Iain Masterton 4 Dr Upton - a biological male - made an allegation of bullying and harassment Credit: Alamy Sandie was suspended from work at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, in January last year after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment. But she was cleared of allegations of misconduct, failures of patient care and misgendering the doctor in an internal disciplinary hearing. The Harry Potter writer, 59, also took aim at former Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, suggesting the "unprofessional" behaviour of NHS Fife was a direct result of her legacy. Writing on social media, Rowling fumed: "This is Nicola Sturgeon's legacy. "... a government that publicly backs the hapless, unprofessional, ideologically captured health board that's persecuting a nurse for asserting her legal right to a single-sex changing room." Ms Peggie's solicitor Margaret Gribbon said that the nurse - who has worked at the health board for 30 years - was "relieved and delighted" after being cleared of the allegations. In a statement, Ms Gribbon said: "On Tuesday 14 July, the evening before the resuming of her tribunal, Sandie Peggie received confirmation from Fife Health Board that following a disciplinary hearing, none of the gross misconduct allegations against her were upheld. "This follows a disciplinary hearing on 25 June, which considered four gross misconduct allegations: two relating to patient care failures, one of 'misgendering' Dr Upton, and one relating to her encounter with Dr Upton in the workplace female-only changing room on Christmas Eve 2023. "Sandie is relieved and delighted that this 18-month-long internal process has concluded and cleared her of all allegations." It comes as an employment tribunal brought by Ms Peggie against the health board is set to resume this week. JK Rowling has been a prominent women's rights campaigner and has often been vocal on what she calls "sex-based rights" for several years. The writer praised BBC newsreader Martine Croxall last month after she refused to say "pregnant people" on air. Gender row nurse cleared of gross misconduct She joked she had a "new favourite BBC presenter" after Martine overruled her autocue which referred to "pregnant people" being at risk during the recent hot weather. Rowling has come under fire for comments made in the past towards trans people. In 2020, the esteemed author slammed the growing trend of replacing "biological sex" with "gender identity". Her stance, that declared "sex is real", led to death threats, but also moulded her into a figurehead for the "gender-critical" movement. Activists accused her of transphobia in 2020 when replying to an article with the headline: "Opinion: Creating a more equal post Covid-19 world for people who menstruate." She tweeted: "'People who menstruate'. I'm sure there used to be a word for those people. "Someone help me out. Wumben? Wimpund? Woomud?" Her remarks led to criticism from Potter actors Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson, Rupert Grint, who ignored the fact her books had made them famous to launch a string of attacks. It was Rowling's beloved group For Women Scotland which also launched a long-running legal battle with the Scottish government over how a "woman" was defined in Scottish law. The Scottish government had argued people with gender recognition certificates (GRCs) should be protected from sex-based discrimination, meaning a transwoman would be considered a woman. However, campaign group For Women Scotland claimed this only applied to people born as a female. In April, the Supreme Court's landmark judgement ruled that it was unanimously determined "sex is binary" and that female-only spaces must be protected on the basis of biology.
BBC News
4 hours ago
- BBC News
Health experts issue new warning over synthetic drugs
Health experts have issued a new warning over synthetic drugs which could explain a sharp rise in suspected drug deaths. An update from Public Health Scotland (PHS) revealed there were 312 suspected drug-related fatalities between March and May, a 15% rise on the previous quarter. The latest Rapid Action Drug Alerts and Response report said potent synthetic opioids known a nitazenes were increasingly mixed with other drugs such as heroin. Nitazenes were found to be present in 6% of all deaths and one expert said the figure was probably an "underestimate" because of issues with testing. Nitazene-type opioids are often found in drugs sold as heroin, benzodiazepines and oxycodone and have been in Scotland since report noted an increase in reports of heroin overdoses in recent months, suspected to involve these synthetic opioids. As well as a rise in suspected deaths, there was a 45% increase in the administration of naloxone, which is used as an emergency antidote for opioid overdoses. Attendances at hospital emergency departments also rose by 19%. Toxic combinations Dr Tara Shivaji, consultant in public health medicine at PHS, said: "There are complex reasons for the increase in harms we're seeing. "Scotland has an evolving drug supply, which is often contaminated with toxic substances. "Most of the harm also involves the use of more than one substance. We urge caution to all people who use drugs. There's no way of telling which substances may be contaminated or what the combined effects will be."Scotland continues to have a far higher rate of recorded drugs deaths than other European nations, including other parts of the suspected drug death data is based on police reports and is different to the finalised annual figures published annually by National Records of Scotland (NRS). The most recent NRS figures showed there were 1,172 drug misuse deaths in Scotland in 2023,an increase of 121 compared with 2022 which had seen the first fall in fatalities in several years. A new set of official NRS statistics is due to be published in September.
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Woman who lost both parents to Covid recalls seeing ‘cruel' Downing Street party photos
A woman who lost both her parents to Covid-19 within 17 days has described her anguish to the UK Covid-19 Inquiry, stating that seeing photos of a Downing Street drinks party on the day her mother died felt "cruel". Rhona Arthur, representing Scottish Covid Bereaved, gave her testimony on Wednesday. The inquiry, led by Baroness Heather Hallett, is currently in its concluding week of hearings, focusing on the pandemic's impact within the care sector. Ms Arthur told the inquiry her father William and mother Violet were both living in the same care home in Scotland when the pandemic began in 2020. She explained her mother had moved into the care home following a long stay in hospital in 2017, and some time later her father had chosen to move into the same home. 'They were devoted to each other,' Ms Arthur said. 'They were a pair of bookends, and one was not very helpful without the other, so he chose to move into the nursing home beside her.' Ms Arthur told the inquiry her father tested positive for Covid-19 on April 30, 2020 after developing a 'slight temperature', and was admitted to hospital the same day. She recalled speaking with him on the phone that afternoon and that he was doing 'quite well', but within hours he began to deteriorate. He died in hospital a few days later on May 3, 2020 aged 90. She told the inquiry she had 'no other option' but to break the news of his death to her mother over the phone, and a member of staff at the care home had sat with her to provide 'emotional support'. Her mother then tested positive for Covid-19 on May 9, and Ms Arthur said as she was going into the crematorium for her father's funeral on May 18, the care home called to say her mother's health was a 'cause for concern'. Two days later, she said, she got another call to say her mother's oxygen levels had 'dropped', and the home had offered an end-of-life visit. She said she 'paused' to pass on the news to other family members, but less than half-an-hour later the care home called again to say her mother had died, aged 93. Asked about the impact the double bereavement had had on her and her family, Ms Arthur said: 'For a long time, I described it as being like a house with the roof ripped off, because that's just that kind of idea about how empty and devastating a double loss is. 'It's very difficult to talk to people about. ' People say, 'what happened to you during Covid?' You cannot just say to somebody, 'well, actually, both my parents died within a fortnight.' 'It's a complete and utter and devastating blow in a conversation.' She was also asked about the impact of seeing photos of a Downing Street drinks party held on the day her mother died. 'It just felt so cruel that we had done all the right things, that we had followed all the rules, down to the funerals, to then see that,' Ms Arthur said. 'And of course, that picture is regularly reprinted, which means that it just brings that terrible day back all the time.' The inquiry continues.
