The UK supreme court and the definition of a woman
On paper it does not sound like something that would spark nationwide interest. Last week the UK supreme court gave its judgment on a case brought by a women's group against the Scottish government over the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018.
But its judgment – that the word 'woman' in equality law refers only to biological sex – has upended years of legal interpretation. And the news of the ruling led to celebrations, protest and an outpouring of emotion.
For some, such as the Guardian Weekly deputy editor, Isobel Montgomery, who is a trustee of the domestic violence charity Rise, the court's decision is reassuring. The Brighton charity offers women-only services based on biological sex, as well as separate LGBTQ services.
This, she says, is essential for women who have been subject to male violence and only feel safe if they are in a space with other cis women. 'You are dealing with a cohort of people who are in great distress and deserve to be met where their trauma is,' she says.
But for others, such as Ellie Gomersall, an activist for the Scottish Greens who campaigns for trans rights, the judgment is heartbreaking.
'I think this ruling means that, as trans people, it's now completely impossible for us to ever be able to just put our trans-ness behind us and go about our normal day-to-day lives. It's always going to be a question for us – are we going to be told: 'Actually, no, you can't come in here'?'
The Guardian's Scotland correspondent, Libby Brooks, explains how the ruling came about and what it could mean. She tells Helen Pidd that some legal experts have explained that this legal ruling means organisations can exclude trans women from women-only facilities – but they're not obliged to do so.
Yet with the head of the Equalities and Human Rights Commission saying trans people must use toilets that fit their biological sex at birth, and that changing rooms and hospital wards should use the same criteria, it marks a serious change in public life.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
SNP will win Holyrood election by ‘country mile', says Swinney
John Swinney has insisted that the SNP is on course to win next year's Holyrood election despite a humiliating by-election defeat. The First Minister had claimed that the vote to elect a new MSP for the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse constituency last Thursday was a ' two-horse race ' between the SNP and Nigel Farage's Reform UK. Both parties were beaten by Scottish Labour, which won 31.6 per cent of votes, while SNP trailed behind at 29.4 per cent and Reform came third with 26.1 per cent. Appearing on Sky's Sunday Morning with Trevor Phillips, Mr Swinney described the loss as 'disappointing' but insisted that his party was still on course to win a fifth consecutive term in Government at the Holyrood elections in May 2026. 'If you look at the result on Thursday, all the polls are saying that if that was applied across the wider election in Scotland, the SNP would remain by a country mile, the largest political party in the Scottish Parliament,' said Mr Swinney. Labour's Davy Russell took the Hamilton seat from the SNP with 8,559 votes, compared to the SNP's Katy Loudon who came second on 7,957. Reform's Ross Lambie came away from the by-election with 7,088 votes. Speaking separately on BBC Scotland's Sunday Show, Mr Swinney said those who backed Reform, more than a quarter of the vote, were 'angry at the cost-of-living crisis'. The First Minister said that since the general election campaign last year, people he has met have sworn never to vote Labour because of the winter fuel allowance being cut, while Reform's support increased. Mr Swinney said: 'People were telling us on the doorsteps, they were giving us reasons why they weren't supporting Labour. We could also see that Farage's support was rising dramatically, and that's happening across the United Kingdom, it's not unique to Hamilton. 'I positioned the SNP to be strong enough to stop Farage, and that's what we were determined to do.' Anas Sarwar, the leader of Scottish Labour, appeared on The Sunday Show and branded the SNP's campaign 'dishonest and disgraceful'. He accused Mr Swinney of 'attempting to push people into the arms of Reform', following the Hamilton by-election. 'The best John Swinney had to offer after 18 years was 'vote SNP to stop Farage' – a dishonest, shameful campaign.' He said that it showed a 'lack of ambition' from a Government ' running down the clock ', adding that commentators had been 'embarrassed' by the result. Mr Swinney denied his 'two-horse race' comment was an attempt to eat into Labour's vote by spotlighting Reform and said he had been 'standing up to Farage for months'. The SNP leader indicated that he would consider a reshuffle of his Cabinet 'in due course' following the Hamilton by-election defeat, which was triggered by the death of Christina McKelvie, the constituency's SNP MSP. Mr Swinney also said he would focus on improving public services, such as cutting waiting times for GPs, and mitigating the cost-of-living crisis before the 2026 Holyrood election. Rachael Hamilton, the Scottish Conservative deputy leader, said: 'It's no secret that John Swinney has hit the panic button ahead of next year's election and is shamelessly trying to hold on to support by peddling the same tired nationalist rhetoric. 'After 18 years of broken promises and divisive politics, the SNP simply have nothing new to offer hard-working Scots.
South Wales Guardian
2 hours ago
- South Wales Guardian
Swinney – Reform voters in Hamilton by-election ‘angry', not racist
The First Minister was asked on the BBC Scotland's Sunday Show if those who backed Reform were 'gullible' or 'racist' – a term the SNP leader has previously used to describe the party. Mr Swinney said the 7,088 people who backed Reform – more than a quarter of the vote – in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse ballot were 'neither', but were instead 'angry at the cost-of-living crisis'. He added: 'I think that's what motivates the Reform vote. People have got poorer because of one central thing – Brexit, and the author of that is (Reform UK leader Nigel) Farage. 'I'm standing up to Farage. I'm going to make no apology for it.' He said the SNP is 'in the process of recovery' and he had come into office as First Minister a year ago 'inheriting some significant difficulties' within the party, and that it needs to get stronger before the Holyrood election in 2026. He said voters are 'having to work hard for less' and are concerned about public services, particularly the NHS. Mr Swinney was asked about comments he made prior to the vote saying 'Labour were not at the races' and claiming it was a 'two-horse race' between the SNP and Reform. Labour's Davy Russell gained the seat from the SNP with 8,559 votes, while SNP candidate Katy Loudon came second on 7,957, ahead of Reform's Ross Lambie. The First Minister said that since the general election campaign last year, people he has met have pledged never to vote Labour due to the winter fuel allowance being cut, while Reform's support increased. Mr Swinney said: 'People were telling us on the doorsteps, they were giving us reasons why they weren't supporting Labour. We could also see that Farage's support was rising dramatically and that's happening across the United Kingdom, it's not unique to Hamilton. 'I positioned the SNP to be strong enough to stop Farage, and that's what we were determined to do.' Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has branded the SNP's campaign 'dishonest and disgraceful' and said it had put the spotlight on Reform. Those comments were put to the First Minister, who said he had previously been allies with Mr Sarwar in a campaign to 'stand up to far-right thinking'. Mr Swinney said: 'That was months ago and then we found ourselves in the aftermath of the UK local authority elections, the English local authority elections where Farage surged to a leading position and won a by-election south of the border. 'So the dynamic of our politics change in front of us. 'I've been standing up to Farage for months, I've been warning about the dangers of Farage for months, and they crystallised in the rise of Farage during the Hamilton, Stonehouse and Larkhall by-election.'
STV News
3 hours ago
- STV News
Reform voters in Hamilton by-election ‘angry', not racist, says Swinney
John Swinney has said Scots who voted for Reform in a by-election last week were 'angry', not racist. The First Minister was asked on the BBC Scotland's Sunday Show if those who backed Reform were 'gullible' or 'racist' – a term the SNP leader has previously used to describe the party. Swinney said the 7,088 people who backed Reform – more than a quarter of the vote – in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse ballot were 'neither', but were instead 'angry at the cost-of-living crisis'. He added: 'I think that's what motivates the Reform vote. People have got poorer because of one central thing – Brexit, and the author of that is (Reform UK leader Nigel) Farage. 'I'm standing up to Farage. I'm going to make no apology for it.' PA Media John Swinney said those who voted Reform in Hamilton were 'angry' (PA). He said the SNP is 'in the process of recovery' and he had come into office as First Minister a year ago 'inheriting some significant difficulties' within the party, and that it needs to get stronger before the Holyrood election in 2026. He said voters are 'having to work hard for less' and are concerned about public services, particularly the NHS. Swinney was asked about comments he made prior to the vote saying 'Labour were not at the races' and claiming it was a 'two-horse race' between the SNP and Reform. Labour's Davy Russell gained the seat from the SNP with 8,559 votes, while SNP candidate Katy Loudon came second on 7,957, ahead of Reform's Ross Lambie. The First Minister said that since the general election campaign last year, people he has met have pledged never to vote Labour due to the winter fuel allowance being cut, while Reform's support increased. PA Media Reform UK came third in the by-election (Jane Barlow/PA). Swinney said: 'People were telling us on the doorsteps, they were giving us reasons why they weren't supporting Labour. We could also see that Farage's support was rising dramatically and that's happening across the United Kingdom, it's not unique to Hamilton. 'I positioned the SNP to be strong enough to stop Farage, and that's what we were determined to do.' Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has branded the SNP's campaign 'dishonest and disgraceful' and said it had put the spotlight on Reform. Those comments were put to the First Minister, who said he had previously been allies with Mr Sarwar in a campaign to 'stand up to far-right thinking'. Swinney said: 'That was months ago and then we found ourselves in the aftermath of the UK local authority elections, the English local authority elections where Farage surged to a leading position and won a by-election south of the border. 'So the dynamic of our politics change in front of us. 'I've been standing up to Farage for months, I've been warning about the dangers of Farage for months, and they crystallised in the rise of Farage during the Hamilton, Stonehouse and Larkhall by-election.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
