&w=3840&q=100)
Why pay toll for highways that don't offer what they promise?
A parliamentary panel has called out the practice of charging tolls on national highways that fail to deliver promised services, urging the government to put in place a clear framework for refunds or waivers when road quality falls short.
In its latest report, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) said it was 'unacceptable' that motorists continue to pay user charges even on stretches that are incomplete under prolonged construction or marred by poor safety and traffic management.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
'The committee finds it unacceptable that tolls continue to be collected even in situations where essential service is not available. This includes highway stretches that are incomplete, under prolonged construction, or marked by serious deficiencies in safety and traffic flow. Continuing to levy toll without delivering the promised level of service violates both the user-pay principle embedded in Section 7 of the National Highways Act and the norms of fair commercial conduct envisaged under Section 10 of the NHAI Act,' the report stated.
The panel recommended a government-backed mechanism to assess highway service levels and determine when users are entitled to refunds or exemptions. Such a system, it said, would not only protect commuters' rights but also ensure that toll collection remains tied to the quality of infrastructure on offer.
With toll revenues forming a major part of the National Highways Authority of India's funding, the recommendation is likely to reignite debate over how to balance financial needs with accountability. For road users, however, the question remains as straightforward as the report's title suggests: why pay for a highway that doesn't deliver what it promises?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Why perpetual toll? Parliamentary panel questions collection of highway tolls even after project costs are recovered
A parliamentary panel has raised concerns over the continued collection of tolls on national highways even after project costs are recovered. The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) highlighted that current practices allow tolls to rise annually by 3%, regardless of highway quality, traffic levels, or affordability for users, a TOI report stated. Independence Day 2025 Before Trump, British used tariffs to kill Indian textile Bank of Azad Hind: When Netaji gave India its own currency Swadeshi 2.0: India is no longer just a market, it's a maker The PAC, headed by Congress MP K C Venugopal, recommended a rationalisation and substantial reduction in toll charges on such stretches. The committee also suggested setting up a 'tariff authority' for toll fixation. It said, "Any continuation of tolls beyond this point should be permitted only if clearly justified and approved by the proposed independent oversight authority." Proposal for independent toll oversight The panel recommended that the road transport ministry establish a regulatory authority on the lines of the Airports Economic Regulatory Authority (AERA). The authority would ensure transparency and fairness in toll fixation, collection, and regulation. It would also be tasked with reviewing and determining the periodicity of toll revisions based on set parameters. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Do you have a mouse? Desert Order Undo Ministry response and ongoing study Responding to the PAC's observation that there is no institutional mechanism to independently evaluate toll charges against actual operation, maintenance costs, or future service needs, the ministry said it has initiated a study with NITI Aayog. This study aims to revise the framework for user fees, including base rates, inflation indexing, and concession structures. As per the PAC report, the ministry has requested NITI Aayog to conduct the study in collaboration with IITs and IIMs. Live Events Review of existing contracts The panel also called for a review of all existing contracts and publicly funded toll plazas that continue tolling beyond cost recovery periods. The PAC emphasised that while higher tolls may be justified during the concession period, continued collection afterwards must have clear justification to protect user interest and uphold equity principles.
The Print
4 hours ago
- The Print
Starting this I-Day, Rs 3,000 annual toll pass will allow you to zip through national highways
Currently, a private car owner needs to cough up at least Rs 10,000 a year for 200 trips. Now, this will come down to Rs 3,000. The National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) began accepting applications for annual passes from mid-July. The pass will get activated on the existing FASTag and will be valid for a year from the date of activation or up to 200 trips, whichever comes first. Each crossing of a national highway toll plaza will count as one trip. A round trip will count as two trips. New Delhi: Starting Friday, non-commercial private vehicle drivers will be able to enjoy a seamless ride across national highways, with the Union Ministry of Road Transport and Highways' decision to introduce an annual toll pass priced at Rs 3,000 coming into force. Union Road Transport and Highways Minister Nitin Gadkari announced the decision on 18 June. Taking to the social media platform 'X', Gadkari had called it a transformative step towards hassle-free highway travel. The annual pass will not only enable seamless and cost-effective travel across National Highways throughout the country but will also reduce congestion at toll plazas. A dedicated link for its activation and renewal will soon be available on the Rajmarg Yatra App as well as on the official websites of NHAI and MoRTH. The annual pass, however, will not apply to state highway toll plazas. Users can still pay at state and other toll plazas through their FASTag, but money will get deducted from the annual pass account only at national highway toll plazas. FASTag, an electronic toll collection system affixed to the vehicle windscreen, uses radio frequency identification (RFID) technology, deducting the toll directly from the prepaid or savings account linked to it, without requiring the driver to stop for transactions at the toll gate. Currently, only monthly passes are issued at Rs 340 to frequent local commuters for crossing a single toll plaza. Earlier, Gadkari also said that the policy addresses long-standing concerns regarding toll plazas, located within a 60-kilometre range. According to the National Highways Fee Rules, 2008, the distance between two toll plazas is 60 km. 'As of now, the average cost of crossing a single toll plaza varies anywhere between Rs 50 and Rs 100. This will come down to Rs 15 now,' Gadkari said in a video statement issued by the road ministry. 'By reducing wait times, easing congestion, and minimising disputes at toll plazas, the annual pass aims to deliver a faster and smoother travel experience for millions of private vehicle owners,' he added. A FAQ issued by the Union Road Ministry said that after verifying the eligibility of the vehicle and the associated FASTag, the annual pass will get activated. 'Upon successful verification, the user must make a payment of Rs 3,000 for the base year 2025-26 through the Rajmargyatra mobile application or NHAI website,' stated the FAQ. The Union Road Transport and Highways Ministry has mulled the introduction of annual passes for some time now. Earlier, it also planned to introduce distance-based toll charges, but no decision has been taken on that yet. (Edited by Madhurita Goswami) Also Read: 'Unacceptable to charge toll with safety, traffic issues'—House panel bats for new road tariff authority
NDTV
6 hours ago
- NDTV
FASTag Annual Pass Starts August 15: What Happens After 200 Trips?
NEW DELHI: Starting August 15, the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) is launching a new FASTag Annual Pass, offering a prepaid solution for frequent highway travellers. Priced at Rs 3,000, the pass is designed for non-commercial private vehicles and provides a fixed fee for up to 200 toll transactions (toll crossings) or one year of validity, whichever comes first. The introduction of the pass aims to streamline travel, reduce traffic congestion at toll plazas, and offer cost savings for commuters. It addresses long-standing concerns, particularly for those who frequently navigate routes with multiple toll booths. The FASTag Annual Pass offers up to 200 toll crossings or one-year validity, easing the need for frequent payments. It supports contactless transactions like the current system. Existing users can simply upgrade their current FASTag to the annual subscription without needing a new tag, ensuring a smooth and hassle-free transition. The FASTag Annual Pass can be purchased via the Rajmarg Yatra app or NHAI/MoRTH website using your vehicle number and FASTag ID. Ensure your FASTag is active and linked, then pay Rs 3,000. Once confirmed, the annual pass activates immediately for use. What Happens After 200 Trips? Once you complete 200 trips or one year (whichever comes first), the FASTag Annual Pass automatically reverts to the regular FASTag system. To continue enjoying annual pass benefits, users must manually reapply and pay Rs 3,000 again. Note: there is no auto-renewal, and the pass expires exactly one year from the date of purchase.
