Air India crash: Not easy to ‘accidentally' cut off fuel switches, expert says
The London-bound Boeing 787 Dreamliner crashed into a medical college shortly after taking off from Ahmedabad Airport on June 12th, killing 241 people on board.
Advertisement
Another 19 other people also died and 67 were seriously injured.
A preliminary report from India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau, published on Friday, said both of the plane's fuel switches moved to the 'cut-off' position 'immediately' after take-off, stopping fuel supply to the engine.
Officials inspect the site of the crash. Photo: Ajit Solanki/AP
'In the cockpit voice recording, one of the pilots is heard asking the other why did he cut-off. The other pilot responded that he did not do so,' the report reads.
The switches were then returned to their normal inflight position, which triggered an automatic engine relight and a thrust recovery procedure.
Advertisement
While the engines started to recover, one of the pilots transmitted 'mayday, mayday, mayday', before the plane was seen by air traffic control to crash outside the airport.
The fuel switches are used at the end of every flight and in emergency scenarios such as a fire, director of aerospace and aviation at Cranfield University, Professor Graham Braithwaite said.
They are designed so they cannot easily be 'accidentally' turned off and pilots would generally run through a checklist before doing so, he said.
'For obvious reasons, the two switches are a distance apart, so not a huge distance, but enough that you couldn't accidentally switch two when you're trying to switch one.
Advertisement
'So it's not like the lights in your house, where they're right next to each other, so there is some space between them.
'They're in that centre console, so that's in between the two pilots, so they can each reach them with the same ease.'
A preliminary report into the crash was published on Friday. Photo: Ajit Solanki/AP
Professor Braithwaite said that if the switch had been moved by a person, that would have been a 'very unusual thing to do' at below 1,000 feet.
'It's not the point of flight where you try and call for your coffee, it's a period of flight where your focus is very, very clear, and that first 1,000 feet, it's about keeping the airplane climbing and that's not about clicking switches.'
Advertisement
He added: 'I could see why a nervous flyer would be nervous at the thought that it's possible to shut both engines down at a critical stage in flight, but for whatever reason, and that there are a number of things that are in place to stop it from accidentally happening.'
The aircraft was about 11 years old, the fuel switches had been changed two years ago, and the crash was a 'really, really unusual event', Professor Braithwaite said.
Of the next stage of the investigation, he said: 'If somebody did wilfully move a switch, then was it on the one hand a wilful active sabotage, in which case the investigation changes considerably, because this safety investigation that published the report yesterday will not be leading on that, that would be a police investigation.
'So that would change at that point, but if it wasn't clear that it was that wilful action, you'd be looking at, well, what kind of mistake might somebody have made?'
Advertisement
Of his general thoughts on the preliminary report, he said the authors have been 'very careful in their wording' to demonstrate they remain 'open minded' about what could have happened.
A lawyer advising some of the families affected by the crash said the findings were 'deeply concerning'.
Demetrius Danas, an aviation lawyer at Irwin Mitchell, said: 'Our thoughts and sympathies remain with those who've lost loved ones in such devastating circumstances.
'The findings of the initial report are deeply concerning and certainly merit further scrutiny to establish the full facts around how this tragedy happened.
'We're continuing to speak with and advise families who've been affected by the Air India crash. Understandably, all they want is to be provided with answers.'
The only surviving passenger on the plane was Briton Vishwash Kumar Ramesh, who previously told The Sun it was a 'miracle' he was alive but felt 'terrible' he could not save his brother Ajay.
Air India stands in solidarity with the families and those affected by the AI171 accident. We continue to mourn the loss and are fully committed to providing support during this difficult time.
We acknowledge receipt of the preliminary report released by the Aircraft Accident…
— Air India (@airindia)
July 11, 2025
Some 169 Indian passengers and 52 British nationals were killed, making it one of the deadliest plane crashes in terms of the number of British fatalities.
If the final investigation takes more than a year to complete, an interim report would be issued on the anniversary of the crash, Professor Braithwaite said, adding that interim recommendations could be made at any time.
The preliminary report says that all crew members had been breathalised on their arrival at Ahmedabad airport, which found they were 'fit to operate the flight'.
No significant bird activity was spotted near the flight path and the aircraft started to lose altitude before crossing the airport perimeter wall.
Both engines were retrieved from the wreckage and quarantined at a hangar in the nearby airport.
Investigators have identified 'components of interest for further examinations', the report says.
Fuel samples taken from tanks used to refuel the aircraft were 'satisfactory'.
Statements have been taken from Mr Ramesh and witnesses by investigators, who will also be looking at the post-mortem examination reports of the crew and the passengers.
This is being done 'to corroborate aeromedical findings with the engineering appreciation', the report adds.
An Air India spokesman said: 'Air India stands in solidarity with the families and those affected by the AI171 accident. We continue to mourn the loss and are fully committed to providing support during this difficult time.'
World
It is a miracle, says lone survivor of Air India p...
Read More
The spokesman added: 'Air India is working closely with stakeholders, including regulators.
'We continue to fully co-operate with the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) and other authorities as their investigation progresses.
'Given the active nature of the investigation, we are unable to comment on specific details and refer all such inquiries to the AAIB.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
6 hours ago
- The Independent
Medical community heartbroken after fatal plane crash on Navajo Nation
Federal investigators on Wednesday were trying to piece together what caused a medical transport plane to crash on the Navajo Nation in northern Arizona, killing the four people on board and leaving the medical community in neighboring New Mexico heartbroken. The two pilots, flight nurse and paramedic who were onboard were based out of Albuquerque and had worked with hospitals throughout the area. While authorities had yet to release their names, colleagues and friends shared condolences and prayers on social media. Many shared details about the crew's dedication to patients and the incredible void left by the tragedy. The crew was on its way to pick up a patient from the federal Indian Health Service hospital in Chinle when the plane crashed near the airport there, Navajo authorities said. The plan was to return to Albuquerque. The Beechcraft King Air 300 was owned by CSI Aviation. The company said in a statement that it was devastated and that the four were more than just colleagues. 'Their courage, care, and dedication will never be forgotten,' the company said. 'Our hearts are with their families, friends, and loved ones.' According to CSI Aviation's website, the nationally accredited carrier never had an accident or incident and never had any FAA sanctions. It provides medical flights in Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, Colorado and South Dakota. Medical transports by air from the Navajo Nation are common because most hospitals are small and do not offer advanced or trauma care. The Chinle airport is one of a handful of airports that the tribe owns and operates on the vast 27,000-square-mile (70,000-square-kilometer) reservation that stretches into Arizona, New Mexico and Utah — the largest land base of any Native American tribe. Aviation safety consultant Jeff Guzzetti, who is a former NTSB and FAA crash investigator, said it's difficult to say what caused this crash in a remote area like Chinle because so few details are readily available. The high altitude of Chinle, which sits just over 5,500 feet above sea level, and the high temperatures Tuesday around 95 degrees can make it harder for a plane to get the lift it needs to fly, but Guzzetti said that is usually more of an issue at takeoff — rather than landing — and this kind of Beechcraft Super King Air plane has plenty of power with its twin turboprop engines. The plane also shouldn't have been overweight because it had already burned off fuel during its flight and hadn't yet picked up the patient. At the time the plane was trying to land, the wind was gusting up to 28 knots, which could have made landing difficult at the Chinle airport, which has a narrow, 60-foot-wide runway. 'Gusting crosswinds to 28 knots can make things a little bit challenging,' Guzzetti said. 'The winds might have been an issue.' Aside from examining the wreckage, NTSB investigators will be reviewing flight data, any air traffic control communications, aircraft maintenance records and weather conditions at the time as they try to determine what caused the crash. ___ AP Transportation Writer Josh Funk reported from Omaha, Nebraska.
BBC News
6 hours ago
- BBC News
Wrong remains from Air India crash 'adds to trauma', says family
A woman whose brother died in the Air India crash and then received the wrong body says it has "added trauma" to her Greenlaw-Meek, 39, and his husband Jamie, 45, were among the 242 people on board the flight which crashed on 12 June soon after taking off for London Gatwick from sister Arwen Greenlaw told BBC Newsnight her family was seeking dignity and closure as well as accountability for those who mislabelled her brother's Foreign Office said it continues to support families affected by the Air India crash with "dedicated caseworkers", adding that the "formal identification of bodies is a matter for the Indian authorities". Ms Greenlaw, from Cambridge, told the BBC she wanted "dignity" for her brother and "closure for the family"."If that is not possible - because the worst case scenario is that he has been cremated as somebody else - then we need to know that in order to move on," she added."Somebody mislabelled remains - that has added trauma."She said it appeared there was a "lack of forensic protocols" at the scene of the crash, and the site was "not closed for 48 hours"."It just can't happen again," she said."I think the whole family were and still are in complete disbelief because it is things that happen on the news and to other people. It was shocking and is confusing." What we know so far about Air India crash investigationRead the preliminary reportAre India's skies safe? Air safety watchdog responds amid rising concerns There were 230 passengers and 12 crew on the Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner, including 169 Indian nationals, 53 Britons, seven Portuguese nationals and one people living in a residential neighbourhood near Ahmedabad's Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport where the jet came down were also killed, taking the number of confirmed casualties to at least 270. This included a number of medical students staying in the area.A preliminary investigative 15-page report published last month said fuel to the engines of the plane cut off just seconds after take-off. Circumstances around how or why that happened remain unclear. The report said in recovered cockpit voice recordings, one of the pilots can be heard asking "why did you cut off?" - to which the other pilot replied he "did not do so".A final report into the crash is expected in 12 months. In the days after the fatal crash, Ms Greenlaw said their mother flew out to India as part of the formal identification process."By her own words it was a chaotic scene," Ms Greenlaw recalled. "She went straight to the hospital to give a blood sample, we were told it would be up to 72 hours to get a positive identification - and that was about right."She returned from India with what she thought were her son's remains. It has been the equivalent of losing him twice. "Mum had seen the situation there, smelt the smells, seen the sights, seen the crash site. I think for her that made it more real to be able to see that." Ms Greenlaw explained when the casket was returned it was tested and found to be "the remains of two different people".As a result, a coroner in London decided to carry out further tests and the family were able to get some DNA from Fiongal's headphones that proved the remains were not his."I would say we go up and down with feelings," Ms Greenlaw said when asked how the family are feeling."We are not naïve, we understand it must have been a horrendous situation and my heart goes out to those who did the clear up - but we know Finn's remains were found. "At that point you would expect the remains to come home. If he had not been matched we could get our heads around that." Mr Greenlaw-Meeks founded The Wellness Foundry in Ramsgate, in Kent, in 2018 with his husband joining as a managing director five years had also been due to be hosting workshops at Ramsgate Pride event in before boarding the Air India flight, the pair posted a video to social media on their last night in the country, where Mr Greenlaw-Meeks reflected on a "magical experience"."They were amazing," Ms Greenlaw said. "Two parts of the one soul. They lived together, they married and they died together. They were two halves of one." The Foreign Office told the BBC it is continuing to liaise with the Gujarati government and the Indian government on behalf of the Inner West London Senior Coroner to support the coronial process."We understand that this is an extremely distressing time for the families, and our thoughts remain with them," a Foreign Office spokesperson said."Foreign Office staff continue to support the families and loved ones in line with our consular remit. "We have allocated dedicated caseworkers to each family who wish to have one." Ms Greenlaw's comments come days after a separate memorial service was held on Sunday in Wembley to remember two other victims who died on the flight - Ashok and Shobhana son Miten Patel told the BBC last month that he had discovered "other remains" were in his mother's casket when her body was returned to the had to re-identify Mr Patel's mother's remains and his family were also able to recover his father's ring, which he was wearing when the plane crashed. India's foreign ministry previously said: "In the wake of the tragic crash, the concerned authorities had carried out identification of victims as per established protocols and technical requirements."All mortal remains were handled with utmost professionalism and with due regard for the dignity of the deceased."We are continuing to work with the UK authorities on addressing any concerns related to this issue."
The Independent
10 hours ago
- The Independent
Atomic bombing survivor issues stark warning over current threat on Hiroshima anniversary
An atomic bombing survivor has issued a stark warning over the use of nuclear weapons on the 80th anniversary of the attack on Hiroshima. Wednesday, 6 August 2025 marked 80 years since the bombing destroyed the city and killed 140,000 people. A second bomb killed 70,000 in Nagasaki days later. Masako Wada was only almost two years old when Nagasaki was hit. She is part of a Japanese grassroots organization of survivors, known as hibakusha, that won the 2024 Nobel Peace Prize for its pursuit of nuclear abolishment. The fast-dwindling group of atomic bomb survivors are facing down the shrinking time they have left to convey the firsthand horror they witnessed in 1945. 'Nuclear weapons were made by humans and used by humans. So it is also up to the humans to abolish them," Wada urged.
