Finance Bill 2025–26: CAP urges govt to overhaul retail tax structure
In a detailed appeal to Federal Minister for Finance Muhammad Aurangzeb, the Chainstore Association of Pakistan (CAP)—the official representative body for over 150 Tier-1 retail chains—called for inclusive policy-making through structured consultation with the private sector. CAP stressed that the upcoming budget presents a critical opportunity to resolve long-standing disparities and bring undocumented retailers into the tax net without penalizing compliant players.
CAP acknowledged the Finance Minister's leadership and reiterated its confidence in the government's commitment to reviving the economy. The association underscored the significant contributions of integrated retailers to employment, commerce, tax revenues, and export value chains, despite representing only a fraction of the retail and wholesale trade landscape.
At present, POS-integrated retailers contribute approximately 25–30% of their turnover in taxes under various heads. Meanwhile, the vast majority of the retail sector remains either under-taxed or entirely undocumented. CAP warned that this growing imbalance has placed an unsustainable burden on documented businesses, many of whom have been forced to downsize or shut down in recent years.
CAP Chairman Asfandyar Farrukh noted that strict enforcement actions and unresolved technical issues in the FBR-POS system have further disrupted operations for compliant retailers. The withdrawal of GST concessions for documented consumers last year, coupled with the failure of the Tajir Dost Scheme due to a lack of consultation and planning, has only worsened the situation. 'To prevent another setback, the Finance Bill 2025–26 must introduce bold, technology-led solutions that broaden the tax base without penalizing formal businesses,' Farrukh emphasized.
To drive formalization and promote a cashless economy, CAP proposed fixed GST rates on retail sales made via digital payments 1–2% for consumer goods and 3–4% for textile and leather items. These rates should be extended to all tiers of retailers, including small and mid-sized enterprises, along with simplified compliance measures and alignment with provincial digital payment incentives. CAP maintains that such a framework will reduce costs, encourage documentation, and accelerate tax collection.
The association also recommended a fixed quarterly advance income tax regime for small retailers, payable via mobile wallets and adjustable against annual income tax returns. Predictable rates for 3–5 years, coupled with incentives such as government service privileges or cash back offers, would increase voluntary compliance and build trust.
To reignite consumer engagement in tax compliance, CAP urged the government to revive the FBR-POS Prize Scheme, which has been suspended since November 2022. Additionally, the association demanded transparency in the use of the over Rs1.2 billion collected through the POS Re1 per invoice fee under the IRS Common Pool Fund.
Despite their large contributions, organized retailers remain restricted to just 10% of Pakistan's retail sector, compared to 15–20% in comparable regional economies. CAP warned that unchecked informal competition, coupled with rising compliance costs, continues to hamper sector growth.
The association reiterated its readiness to collaborate with government institutions, including the Ministry of Commerce, FBR, SBP, CCP, and others, to support the development of a fair, digital, and growth-oriented retail tax ecosystem. A formal meeting has been requested with the Finance Minister to present CAP's proposals and assist in shaping meaningful reforms in Budget 2025–26.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Weekly Cotton Review: Price plunge hits linked sectors
KARACHI: In recent days, a significant drop in cotton prices has been observed, impacting sectors associated with the commodity. Due to reduced supply of phutti in the market, several ginning factories are operating partially, raising concerns among industry circles. The price of cotton has decreased by PKR 300 to 400 per maund, while phutti rates have also fallen. Recently, a delegation from the All Pakistan Textile Mills Association (APTMA) met with Chief of Army Staff (COAS) Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir, briefing him on the challenges faced by the textile industry. On this occasion, industry representatives discussed key issues with the authorities. Meanwhile, the Pakistan Business Forum (PBF) has urged the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to immediately issue a statutory regulatory order (SRO) to impose an 18% General Sales Tax (GST) on imported cotton. They argue that this measure will protect the local cotton industry. In another significant development, questions have been raised about the cotton production data released by the Crop Reporting Center Punjab. Ahsan ul Haq, Chairman of the Ginners Forum, revealed that these figures are contrary to reality, misleading farmers and industrialists. Additionally, agricultural experts have advised farmers to take precautionary measures to protect cotton crops from monsoon rains. Head Transfer of Technology Central Cotton Research Institute Multan Sajid Mahmood emphasized that farmers must follow expert guidelines to ensure the safety of their crops. The local cotton market experienced sluggish trading activity last week due to low interest from textile mills in purchasing cotton. Prices saw a decline of PKR 300 to 400 per maund. Meanwhile, intermittent rains in several cotton-producing regions of Sindh and Punjab have disrupted the ginning process, leading to a shortage of phutti. As a result, many ginning factories have shut down, while others are operating partially. Some ginning factories still hold old stock of cotton, which is being traded at PKR 15,500 to 15,700 per maund. Factory owners have faced significant losses due to the current market conditions. A prominent ginner from Rahim Yar Khan, who owns seven ginning factories, revealed that he had been operating five units but suffered heavy losses. He stated that fewer ginning factories in Rahim Yar Khan would remain operational this year. In recent days, some ginning factories in the area sold old cotton stock at PKR 15,500 to 15,700 per maund, incurring substantial losses. Industry sources suggest that some factory owners are also to blame for not selling their stock at the right time. Despite these challenges, market observers believe that this year's cotton production is likely to remain similar to last year's output. This year, textile mills have shown significant interest in importing cotton and have already secured contracts for approximately one million bales. The textile sector is currently awaiting the official notification regarding the imposition of an 18% sales tax on cotton imports, as the federal budget for 2025-26 proposed the discontinuation of the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS) facility. However, the formal notification for this fiscal year has not yet been issued. In Sindh, the price of cotton per maund is in between PKR 16,000 to PKR 16,300, while Phutti is being traded at PKR 6,600 to PKR 7,000 per 40 kg. In Punjab, cotton prices stand at PKR 16,200 to PKR 16,500 per maund, while the rate of Phutti is in between PKR 6,500 to PKR 7,200 per 40 kg. Meanwhile, in Balochistan, cotton is priced at PKR 16,100 to PKR 16,300 per maund, Phutti is being sold at PKR 6,600 to PKR 7,200 per 40 kg. The Spot Rate Committee of the Karachi Cotton Association has maintained the spot rate stable at PKR 16,300 per maund. Karachi Cotton Brokers Forum Chairman Naseem Usman said that international cotton prices remained stable overall. New York cotton futures were priced between 68 to 70 cents per pound. According to the USDA's weekly export and sales report, 32,700 bales were sold for the 2024-25 season. Vietnam led the buyers with 4,600 bales, followed by Honduras with 200 bales, and Nicaragua with 200 bales. For the 2025-26 season, sales reached 132,600 bales, with Vietnam again topping the list by purchasing 42,800 bales. Pakistan secured the second position with 20,400 bales, while Guatemala came in third with 19,700 bales. The All Pakistan Textile Mills Association (APTMA) extends its deepest and most heartfelt gratitude to Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir, NI (M) for graciously meeting with a business delegation led by Dr Gohar Ejaz, HI, SI (Civ). 'We salute the Field Marshall's exemplary commitment to engaging with the business community and industry, demonstrating both patience and concern for economic issues faced by the businesses and people of Pakistan.' During the highly constructive meeting, the delegation commended the government and SIFC's monumental efforts that have brought much-needed economic stability to the country and thanked the Army Chief for his unwavering support and resolve. It presented a comprehensive overview of the challenges faced by the industrial sector, with particular emphasis on the recently enacted expansions of the Federal Board of Revenue's (FBR) powers. We are immensely thankful to Field Marshall Munir for immediately directing that the new provisions, particularly those added under Sections 37A and 37B of the Sales Tax Act, 1990 pertaining to arrest and detention, be held in abeyance, and for instructing the FBR to enter meaningful, solution-oriented dialogue with stakeholders and address their concerns. The GHQ will oversee progress through the Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC), fostering an environment of collaboration and trust. The delegation called for interest rates to be brought down in line with inflation to stimulate businesses and economic activity. It also highlighted the significant delay in notification of the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS) amendments relating to exclusion of cotton, cotton yarn, and fabric from the scheme and imposition of an 18% sales tax on their imports. Field Marshal Munir assured the delegation that these measures, as announced in the Finance Minister's budget speech, will be implemented without delay. APTMA is grateful for the Field Marshall's attention to unsustainable electricity prices that are burdening manufacturers and businesses across the country. We appreciate his ongoing commitment to securing more competitive electricity rates for consumers nationwide, with special emphasis on revitalizing the industrial and export sectors. His unwavering support is a testament to his overarching vision to propel Pakistan's economic landscape to new heights. On behalf of the entire textile sector and business community, APTMA once again extends its profound gratitude to Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir NI (M) for his visionary leadership and steadfast dedication to Pakistan's progress and growth. The Pakistan Business Forum (PBF) has called on the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to immediately issue a Statutory Regulatory Order (SRO) for imposing 18% general sales tax (GST) on imported cotton, as outlined in the Finance Bill 2025. In a statement, the PBF emphasised that despite clear announcement in the federal budget to tax the imported cotton, its implementation was pending due to the absence of the required SRO. 'More than three weeks have passed since approval of the budget, yet the delay continues without any justifiable reason.' According to the PBF, credible reports indicate that certain influential interest groups are obstructing the issuance of the SRO. 'The government must ensure transparency and move forward in the interest of local cotton growers and the economy,' said PBF Chief Organiser Ahmad Jawad. The forum cautioned that cotton imports had exceeded domestic production for the first time in Pakistan's history – a development that poses serious risks to sustainability of textile and agriculture sectors. 'The FBR must act urgently, keeping in view the seriousness of the issue and release the SRO without further delay,' it said. The forum disclosed that importers had already entered into agreements for 7.5 million bales of cotton from international markets. 'After much effort, local cotton farmers finally achieved a level playing field through legislation. The time has come to translate that into action,' Jawad said. To reclaim Pakistan's status as a leading cotton-producing nation, he underlined the need for federal and provincial governments to launch a nationwide cotton revival programme. He recommended that the import of raw material, especially those impacting domestic industries, should be entirely excluded from the Export Facilitation Scheme. The forum also expressed concern over the current state of cotton crops. According to the latest figures, Sindh's performance remains particularly troubling, with reported supply of only 152,650 bales so far this year, compared to 327,666 bales in the same period of last year – a decline of 53%. In contrast, Punjab has shown relatively better results, with supply of 145,101 bales, reflecting a 27% rise over last year. Notable growth has been observed in several districts, including Khanewal (28,825 bales), Vehari (33,950 bales), Dera Ghazi Khan (19,397 bales) and Rajanpur (9,200 bales) – all recording improved yields. The Cotton Crop Reporting Center (CCRC) Punjab has been accused of releasing exaggerated cotton production data, contrary to actual facts. Investigations reveal that CCRC determines Punjab's total cotton yield by extrapolating the weight of cotton from a single boll to an assumed number of bolls per acre across the province. In some districts, production estimates are based on small experimental plots measuring just eight feet in length and six feet in width. For years, Pakistan Cotton Ginners Association (PCGA) has alleged that CCRC Punjab's production figures are consistently higher than actual market data, causing significant challenges for cotton stakeholders in planning their strategies. Some industry players have even suggested that the inflated numbers may be linked to undocumented sales by certain ginners. The discrepancy in data has also led to confusion in international forums, where Pakistan faces skepticism over its official cotton production claims due to conflicting reports. Ahsan-ul-Haq, Chairman of the Cotton Ginners Forum, highlighted that as of July 15, PCGA reported Punjab's cotton production at 145,000 bales, while CCRC Punjab claimed 335,000 bales—a staggering difference. He criticized CCRC's methodology, stating that estimating province-wide production based on a few bolls or small test plots is unrealistic and misleading. Haq urged CCRC Punjab to adopt a more transparent approach, similar to PCGA's practice of collecting bi-weekly sales and stock data from ginning factories. He recommended that CCRC staff gather real-time data from ginning units and grain markets to provide accurate production figures, ensuring better decision-making for stakeholders and restoring credibility in Pakistan's cotton. Sajid Mahmood, Head of the Technology Transfer Department at the Central Cotton Research Institute (CCRI) Multan, has urged cotton farmers to follow the recommendations of CCRI's agricultural experts regarding the impact of monsoon rains on the cotton crop. He stated that while timely and moderate monsoon rains can be beneficial for the crop, continuous and heavy rainfall can cause severe damage. Last year as well, heavy rains and other challenges significantly affected cotton production, resulting in only 6 million bales. Therefore, proactive precautionary measures are essential to prevent potential losses this season. He explained that excessive rainfall can lead to unwanted plant overgrowth, rapid weed development, and increased risk of pest attacks—especially pink bollworm. Immediate steps must be taken to ensure proper drainage in the fields, and rainwater should be removed within 24 hours. Digging a pit about four feet deep in one corner of the field can help collect water and ease drainage. Regarding weed control, Sajid Mahmood advised hoeing (godi) as soon as the field conditions allow. If the crop has reached a height of three feet or more, the use of tractors should be avoided to prevent damage. Instead, lighter agricultural tools like kusola should be used. For managing weeds, he recommended spraying glyphosate (1 liter per 100 liters of water) only in triple-gene cotton varieties. In conventional varieties, the use of 'Shield' is mandatory. He emphasized the importance of eliminating weeds before they begin to seed. Furthermore, Sajid Mahmood advised farmers to avoid unnecessary irrigation in anticipation of rainfall. If irrigation is required, it should be done lightly in the evening. In case symptoms of parawilt or wilting appear on the crop, apply 500 grams of potassium nitrate or potassium sulfate as a foliar spray, or apply 10 to 15 kilograms of potassium sulfate through irrigation. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
FC personnel deployed to monitor GLT units in KP
ISLAMABAD: Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) Member Inland Revenue (Operations) Dr Hamid Ateeq Sarwar has said that around 144 personnel of Frontier Constabulary force have been deployed in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to regulate/ monitor Green Leaf Threshing units, to strengthen enforcement for checking massive evasion in tobacco sector. During the last meeting of the Public Accounts Committee, Dr Sarwar stated that two platoons of FC have been deployed at 13 GLT units for the purpose of enforcement. There are only around 13 GLTs in Pakistan, all fully traceable, making them the most logical taxation choke point. In contrast, there are over 450,000 retail outlets, selling cigarettes and more than 50 cigarette factories – primarily in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK) and Azad Jammu & Kashmir (AJK) – where enforcement at post-processing levels is far more challenging. FBR to strictly monitor tobacco movement The FED at GLTs, fully traceable processing units—is a key tax enforcement mechanism designed to curb revenue leakage and illicit cigarette manufacturing. By documenting actual volumes processed by manufacturers, the system ensures declared production aligns with tax liabilities, strengthening the national economy. Unprecedented excise increase in recent years on the legitimate cigarette manufacturing companies and too low advance FED in previous years has led to the illicit sector to grow to more than 56% of the market. This increase has been fuelled by smuggled cigarette brands. FBR needs to analyse how much tobacco was processed at GLTs and how much adjustable FED was collected from cigarette manufacturers and how much of this adjustable FED was actually adjusted against the final liability. FBR also needs to check how the GLT processing corresponds with the leaf buying of these manufacturers. Sources told Business Recorder that the country's tax potential from the cigarette sector exceeds Rs 600 billion annually. The two multinational companies that hold 44% of the market paid Rs 292 billion in taxes. Contrary to this, more than 40 local manufacturers controlling the remaining 56% of the market paid a meagre Rs 5 billion. Over Rs 300 billion in tax revenue, more than the federal allocations for education and health combined, has disappeared into the black market. FBR Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial recently admitted that over 90% of the cigarette sector operates outside the formal tax system. The Track and Trace System, introduced to enforce compliance, is failing. Only 19 of 413 registered brands are compliant. The government has proposed deploying Frontier Constabulary units in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to regulate Green Leaf Threshing, signalling the extraordinary scale of the breakdown in civilian enforcement mechanisms. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
10 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Plugging tax leaks
Listen to article That more than Rs2.25 trillion have been lost to tax evasion through 'fake' and 'flying' invoices in just two years is a staggering admission — and one that lays bare the scale of institutional failure plaguing Pakistan's revenue machinery. The figure, disclosed by the Federal Board of Revenue, represents nearly a third of the total taxes collected on the customs side, showing just how deeply entrenched the problem has become. Such large-scale evasion at a time when the country is navigating a fragile economic recovery is not only unsustainable but damaging to the government's credibility. Successive administrations have repeatedly promised to broaden the tax base and improve documentation, yet loopholes that enable outright fraud continue to be exploited with impunity. The use of fake invoices to claim undue input tax credits or reduce tax liability has become a routine practice, facilitated in many cases by internal collusion. FBR has claimed that it is the only federal institution to have taken action against its own officers involved in such malpractices. However, internal accountability alone will not suffice. While punitive measures may deter some, the persistence of such fraudulent practices points to a structural rot that requires far more than selective disciplinary action. Pakistan's low tax-to-GDP ratio is a well-documented constraint on fiscal policymaking. It limits the state's capacity to provide essential services and meet its debt obligations without resorting to regressive indirect taxation or repeated external borrowing. To plug these revenue leaks, the government must move towards comprehensive digitisation of invoicing and supply chains along with stronger audit systems — all the while depoliticising the FBR's functioning. No serious economic recovery can be achieved while the state remains incapable or unwilling to curb fraud within its own revenue apparatus. This haemorrhaging must end if the country wants sustainable recovery.
