Murder trial jury watch Snapchat video allegedly showing bloodied victim
'UPSETTING' |
Mr Ilyas was allegedly beaten to death after a row over a stolen bag of cannabis
Mahamud Ilyas
Viorel Doroscan (23), of Bay Meadows Square, Hollystown, West Dublin, and Otniel Richardo Clejan (24), with a former address at Verdemont in Blanchardstown in Dublin 15, have pleaded not guilty to the murder of Mahamud Ilyas on December 9, 2022.
Mr Ilyas was allegedly beaten to death after a row over a stolen bag of cannabis, sustaining depressed fractures to his head which a State pathologist said were 'typical of hammer blows'.
At the Central Criminal Court today, trial judge Mr Justice Tony Hunt briefed the jury before they watched the Snapchat video, saying that they must approach the evidence in an 'unemotional and dispassionate' manner, despite its potentially upsetting contents.
The video showed a man lying on the ground, face up, with visible blood on his face and a large blood stain on the wall behind him. Read more
The short clip showed the video-taker moving in closer to the head of the man on the floor and the shoe of the video-taker can be seen briefly.
Detective Inspector Liam Donoghue, of Blanchardstown Garda Station, told prosecution counsel Eoin Lawlor SC that he contacted Snapchat's office in the United States to request that they preserve data in regards to Mr Doroscan, Mr Ilyas and Mr Clejan. He said he believed Mr Doroscan had possession of a video relating to Mr Ilyas.
The witness proceeded to show a comparison of the shoe in the video and CCTV footage of Mr Doroscan on the same day, wearing shoes that Det Insp Donoghue said visually matched those in the video.
He said the video, which was posted as a 'Memory' on the Snapchat app, was confirmed to have come from Mr Doroscan's account and metadata provided by Snapchat said that the clip had been taken on 2.51pm on December 9, 2022 in the area of the Verdemont estate in Blanchardstown.
Assistant State pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster previously told Mr Lawlor SC that the cause of Mr Ilyas' death was blunt force trauma to the head.
She said the application of force to the head was from a blunt object such as a hammer, blows, and kicks.
Last week, witness Abdi-Aziz Mohamed testified that he met Mr Doroscan on December 9 2022, where the accused allegedly told him that 'we hit Mo with a hammer' - meaning the deceased Mahamud Ilyas - during a fight before leaving him 'on a field'.
At the opening of the trial Mr Lawlor said the prosecution intended to show that Mr Doroscan and Mr Clejan were involved in the sale and supply of drugs.
On December 8, 2022, counsel said, a house at Verdemont in Blanchardstown, Dublin 15 was being used to store cannabis. That evening Mr Ilyas called to the house and was seen leaving carrying a shopping bag containing cannabis. Mr Lawlor said Mr Ilyas 'wasn't supposed to' take the cannabis and then tried to sell it to others.
The following afternoon, Mr Lawlor said Mr Doroscan made contact with Mr Ilyas and told him he wished to speak to him urgently. Mr Ilyas went into the house at Verdemont at about 2.41pm.
Witness Vlady Ndosimau previously told the trial that he was at the bottom of the steps when Mr Ilyas went inside but ran up and barged through the door after hearing a loud banging noise. Inside, he said he witnessed Mr Ilyas sitting on the floor, with his back against a radiator, looking as if he had been beaten and with blood coming from his nose. His hands and feet were tied using a rope or a zip tie and he was moaning while Mr Clejan and Mr Doroscan shouted at him, the witness said.
Mr Doroscan, holding a fruit knife, stood between Mr Ilyas's legs while Mr Clejan stood close to his head with a hammer in his hand, the witness said. Mr Doroscan, he said, kept on shouting "where is the stuff" while Mr Ilyas responded by "groaning and groaning".
The trial continues tomorrow before Mr Justice Tony Hunt and a jury of five women and seven men.
Co-accused Lorenzo Cantaragiu (21), of Castlegrange Park, Blanchardstown, faces various charges of impeding the prosecution or apprehension of Mr Clejan and Mr Doroscan, by committing various acts while knowing or believing them to have committed the offence of causing serious harm to Mr Ilyas. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
19 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Man charged with murdering his mother sent for trial
A man charged with the murder of his mother, whose body was discovered in bogland in south Roscommon in December, has been served with a book of evidence and sent forward for trial at the Central Criminal Court. 32-year-old Nebojsa Pap, with an address at Beechville, Athlone, appeared at Athlone District Court today. He has been charged with the murder of his mother, Mirjana Pap, of the same address, on 28 December 2024. Garda Olivia Connolly gave evidence of service of the book of evidence this afternoon. Sergeant Paul McNally, for the State, indicated that Mr Pap would be sent forward for trial at the next sittings of the Central Criminal Court. The book of evidence relates to one charge of murder and one charge of producing an article capable of inflicting serious injury in the course of the attack, which allegedly took place at the victim's home in Athlone. Judge Bernadette Owens noted that Mr Pap had not made an application for bail and was going forward in custody. She gave an alibi warning, and told him he was obliged to inform the state of any alibi evidence on which he intended to rely on within 14 days. Solicitor for the accused, Ciara Macklin, applied for legal aid, which Judge Owens granted to include one senior and one junior counsel to represent Mr Pap in his trial. Ms Pap, a 58-year-old widow and mother of three, was a Croatian native and a long term resident of Athlone. Her body was discovered on a bogland at Curraghaleen, Co Roscommon, on 30 December 2024 after she had been reported missing two days earlier. Her son, Mr Pap, was arrested on 3 January 2025 and later charged with the murder of Ms Pap at Beechville, Athlone on 28 December 2024, contrary to common law.
Sunday World
2 days ago
- Sunday World
Teen (18) produced child pornography by sharing intimate images of girl (15), court told
As the female teenager was a minor at the time of the alleged offence, the man is also facing two charges under the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act on November 15th 2022. A Clare teenager, just turned 18, posted a collage of intimate images of a 15 year old girl onto his Snapchat stories in a so-called Coco's Law prosecution, a court has heard. In the case before Kilrush District Court on Tuesday, the accused - now aged 20 - appeared in connection with being charged with three alleged offences over the posting of the intimate images in November 2022. Judge Alec Gabbett said that the case comes under Coco's Law, which is formally known as the Harassment, Harmful Communications and Related Offences Act 2020 which criminalises the non-consensual distribution of intimate images. In the case, the accused, aged 18 at the time, is charged with on November 15th 2022 publishing or distributing an intimate image of the female without her consent with the intention to cause her harm contrary to Section 2(1) and (3) of the Harassment, Harmful Communications and Related Offences Act 2001. Stock image News in 90 Seconds - Tuesday June 10 As the female teenager was a minor at the time of the alleged offence, the man is also facing two charges under the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act on November 15th 2022. The man is accused of knowingly having in his possession child pornography, the image of the female aged under 17 which, the charge says, depicts her genitals on the date. The man - accompanied to court by his mother and a sister - is also charged with producing child pornography for the purpose of distribution, publication, exportation, sale or show contrary to Section 5(1) of the Child Trafficking Act and Pornography Act1998. In court, Garda Nadine Keane, now of Roxboro Garda Station, Limerick said it will be alleged that the accused had in his possession a collage of four intimate images of the female on November 15th 2022 and posted them to his online Snapchat stories on the same date. Garda Keane said that one of the images depicting the girl's genitalia was a Category Two image as categorised under the Child Trafficking Act and Pornography Act. Judge Gabbett said that Category One would be regarded as the most serious followed by Category Two. Garda Keane said that the images were left online for a number of hours before they were taken down by the man who allegedly posted them. He continued by saying that the female - who turned 18 earlier this year - made a statement of complaint to Gardai and was interviewed by specialist Garda interviewers. The Garda said that the case was investigated by the Clare Division Protective Services Unit based at Crusheen. Garda Keane said that when charged at Kilrush Garda Station on May 29th, the accused made no reply after caution. He added that the DPP has directed that the case be heard in the district court on a plea of guilty only. After hearing an outline of the facts, Judge Gabbett said that he was declining district court jurisdiction and the case will now be transferred to the circuit court where more serious penalties apply on conviction. Judge Gabbett said that he was declining jurisdiction due to the seriousness of the alleged offences, the categorisation of the images and that the case warrants consideration by the circuit court taking into account the impact on the alleged injured party. The judge said that if the accused was aged under 18 at the time, he would have kept the case in the district court. In the district court, penalties for the Coco's Law offence can be up to one year on prison on conviction and Sgt John Burke said that before the circuit court, a 14 year prison term can apply on conviction. Judge Gabbett remanded the man on continuing bail to appear at Kilrush District Court to July 15th. Judge Gabbett imposed reporting restrictions on the identity of the accused and the injured party due to the age of the injured party at the time of the alleged offences.
Sunday World
6 days ago
- Sunday World
Man hired to burn down warehouse for Wagner Group wanted to link ‘Kinahans' in with Russia
The Old Bailey heard how Dylan Earl had grand ambitions to 'build a link' between the IRA, the Kinahans and Russia, as he declared: 'We have direct connection to the Kremlin, we can do something big' A court has heard how a man hired by the terrorist Wagner Group to burn down a warehouse linked to Ukraine boasted about linking up the IRA and the Kinahan crime cartel with Russian agents. Leicestershire man Dylan Earl has admitted orchestrating an arson attack on the warehouse in east London last year, as well as plotting to burn down Mayfair businesses and kidnapping their Russian dissident owner. Described as the 'architect' of the scheme, the Old Bailey heard how 20-year-old Earl had grand ambitions to 'build a link' between the IRA, the Kinahans and Russia, as he declared: 'We have direct connection to the Kremlin, we can do something big.' Earl, who had been recruited by the terrorist group that was conducting a sabotage campaign on behalf of Russian intelligence, has admitted aggravated arson on behalf of the Wagner Group on the warehouse in Leyton, East London. The fire destroyed over £100,000 worth of equipment, including generators and vital satellite equipment destined for Ukraine. Jurors at the Old Bailey were shown chats between Earl, of Elmesthorpe, near Hinckley, and a Wagner Group contact identified by the handle Privet Bot, on Telegram. Dylan Earl News in 90 Seconds - 6th June 2025 The day before the arson attack, Privet Bot instructed Earl to watch the television series The Americans, about KGB agents undercover in the US, "in order to understand (the) work". The court was told how Earl allegedly roped in Jake Reeves (23) from Croydon, south London, to help recruit people to carry out the arson attack on the warehouse. Earl also revealed his plans to Ashton Evans (20) from Newport, Gwent, on Signal, Snapchat and mobile phone messages, it is alleged. Four men accused of carrying out the arson attack, Jakeem Rose (23), Ugnius Asmena (20), Nii Mensah (23) and Paul English (61) were told to live stream it to Earl so he could report back to the Russians on the success of the 'mission'. The four have denied aggravated arson relating to the warehouse fire. Jake Reeves (23) from Croydon, south London The blaze at 11.40pm on March 20 last year started with a jerry can of petrol and caused more than £1 million in damage to the premises, which was targeted because of its connection to Ukraine, with the warehouse being used to store StarLink satellite equipment and humanitarian aid bound for the war zone. However, Russia refused to pay the arsonists because the blaze wasn't up to the Wagner Group's 'standards', the court heard, as the arsonists made a series of errors, forgetting to film the attack and having to return to the scene where they were captured on CCTV. Reeves, from Croydon, South London, who has already admitted his part in the conspiracy, later complained: 'They were supposed to make it burn.. but they just ran in there.' Two days after the attack, Earl admitted he was 'waiting on payment still, apparently it'll land today but it's nowhere near the amount because they didn't burn the whole thing'. The following day, the court was told Evans had asked Earl: "Did you light it up?" before discussing the plot to burn down Hide restaurant and Hedonism wine shop in Mayfair, snatch the owner and hand him over to Russia. On April 1 2024, Earl asked Evans to delete their chats and asked if he could make connections with the IRA or the Irish Kinahan crime family. Earl suggested he wanted to "build a link" between the Kinahans and Russia, saying: "We have direct connection to the Kremlin, we can do suin (something) big." After his arrest, Evans claimed he did not take the chat seriously, having jokingly told Earl: "And this is all in Minecraft (the computer game) right?" He also claimed in a police interview that he was just stringing Earl along to get a refund for £300 of fake cocaine he had bought. Both Earl and Reeves have pleaded guilty to aggravated arson of the east London warehouse and an offence under the National Security Act. Prosecutor Duncan Penny, KC, told jurors: 'This was deliberate and calculated criminality - at the behest of foreign influence. 'In the case of these defendants at the time of the fire they may have been ignorant of that influence and the motive may have been financial - good old-fashioned greed. 'For others, however, it appears to have been both political and ideological.' The case continues.
