Murder trial jury watch Snapchat video allegedly showing bloodied victim
Mr Ilyas was allegedly beaten to death after a row over a stolen bag of cannabis
Mahamud Ilyas
Viorel Doroscan (23), of Bay Meadows Square, Hollystown, West Dublin, and Otniel Richardo Clejan (24), with a former address at Verdemont in Blanchardstown in Dublin 15, have pleaded not guilty to the murder of Mahamud Ilyas on December 9, 2022.
Mr Ilyas was allegedly beaten to death after a row over a stolen bag of cannabis, sustaining depressed fractures to his head which a State pathologist said were 'typical of hammer blows'.
At the Central Criminal Court today, trial judge Mr Justice Tony Hunt briefed the jury before they watched the Snapchat video, saying that they must approach the evidence in an 'unemotional and dispassionate' manner, despite its potentially upsetting contents.
The video showed a man lying on the ground, face up, with visible blood on his face and a large blood stain on the wall behind him. Read more
The short clip showed the video-taker moving in closer to the head of the man on the floor and the shoe of the video-taker can be seen briefly.
Detective Inspector Liam Donoghue, of Blanchardstown Garda Station, told prosecution counsel Eoin Lawlor SC that he contacted Snapchat's office in the United States to request that they preserve data in regards to Mr Doroscan, Mr Ilyas and Mr Clejan. He said he believed Mr Doroscan had possession of a video relating to Mr Ilyas.
The witness proceeded to show a comparison of the shoe in the video and CCTV footage of Mr Doroscan on the same day, wearing shoes that Det Insp Donoghue said visually matched those in the video.
He said the video, which was posted as a 'Memory' on the Snapchat app, was confirmed to have come from Mr Doroscan's account and metadata provided by Snapchat said that the clip had been taken on 2.51pm on December 9, 2022 in the area of the Verdemont estate in Blanchardstown.
Assistant State pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster previously told Mr Lawlor SC that the cause of Mr Ilyas' death was blunt force trauma to the head.
She said the application of force to the head was from a blunt object such as a hammer, blows, and kicks.
Last week, witness Abdi-Aziz Mohamed testified that he met Mr Doroscan on December 9 2022, where the accused allegedly told him that 'we hit Mo with a hammer' - meaning the deceased Mahamud Ilyas - during a fight before leaving him 'on a field'.
At the opening of the trial Mr Lawlor said the prosecution intended to show that Mr Doroscan and Mr Clejan were involved in the sale and supply of drugs.
On December 8, 2022, counsel said, a house at Verdemont in Blanchardstown, Dublin 15 was being used to store cannabis. That evening Mr Ilyas called to the house and was seen leaving carrying a shopping bag containing cannabis. Mr Lawlor said Mr Ilyas 'wasn't supposed to' take the cannabis and then tried to sell it to others.
The following afternoon, Mr Lawlor said Mr Doroscan made contact with Mr Ilyas and told him he wished to speak to him urgently. Mr Ilyas went into the house at Verdemont at about 2.41pm.
Witness Vlady Ndosimau previously told the trial that he was at the bottom of the steps when Mr Ilyas went inside but ran up and barged through the door after hearing a loud banging noise. Inside, he said he witnessed Mr Ilyas sitting on the floor, with his back against a radiator, looking as if he had been beaten and with blood coming from his nose. His hands and feet were tied using a rope or a zip tie and he was moaning while Mr Clejan and Mr Doroscan shouted at him, the witness said.
Mr Doroscan, holding a fruit knife, stood between Mr Ilyas's legs while Mr Clejan stood close to his head with a hammer in his hand, the witness said. Mr Doroscan, he said, kept on shouting "where is the stuff" while Mr Ilyas responded by "groaning and groaning".
The trial continues tomorrow before Mr Justice Tony Hunt and a jury of five women and seven men.
Co-accused Lorenzo Cantaragiu (21), of Castlegrange Park, Blanchardstown, faces various charges of impeding the prosecution or apprehension of Mr Clejan and Mr Doroscan, by committing various acts while knowing or believing them to have committed the offence of causing serious harm to Mr Ilyas. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
a day ago
- Sunday World
Dublin thief posted videos of stolen €90,000 on Snapchat, court told
Stephen McMullen (27) stole €90,000 from a shop manager using "extreme threats of violence", it is alleged A HAMMER-wielding robber stole €90,000 from a shop manager using "extreme threats of violence" and later sent videos of the cash to his friends on Snapchat, it is alleged. Stephen McMullen (27) is accused of brandishing the hammer while ordering the manager to take cash from safes in a supermarket in Co Kildare. He was granted bail despite garda objections and the case against him was adjourned at Dublin District Court today. Mr McMullen, of Rowlagh Gardens, Clondalkin, is charged with robbery and production of a hammer capable of inflicting serious injury at Costcutter, Castle Village Drive, Celbridge, Co Kildare on July 17 this year. Objecting to bail, Garda Jennifer Finnegan told Judge John Brennan the store manager was opening up at 4.53am when two men arrived in a Ford Transit van that had been stolen in an earlier burglary in Maynooth. They entered the shop and one, alleged to be the accused, had a hammer. According to the prosecution, he 'threatened the store manager's life' and told him to open two safes. He also allegedly told the manager to destroy the CCTV. Footage showed a man armed with a hammer who was a similar height and build to the accused, Gda Finnegan said. In a later search of the accused's home address, some €27,870 was found in a Lidl bag in the attic. The money was wrapped in 'distinctive white bands' identical to those used by the alleged victim, the garda said. It was alleged the accused was seen on CCTV arriving at the address in a taxi carrying a Lidl bag. A phone alleged to be Mr McMullen's was seized at the address and, according to the gardai, it had "pinged" off a mast in Celbridge less than 2km from the shop, 13 minutes after the alleged robbery. It was alleged Mr McMullen had posted videos of the stolen cash on Snapchat and told friends he 'got €90,000 in a robbery.' The garda said the accused flew to Lanzarote 24 hours after the robbery and did not take the booked return flight but came home on another flight to attend his brother's funeral. Gda Finnegan believed the accused was a flight risk and would flee if bailed. She also feared he had access to the outstanding €63,000 cash and would dispose of it, and that he would contact the alleged victim to intimidate him. Applying for bail, defence solicitor Catherine Dolan said Mr McMullen, who was presumed innocent, made no admissions in interview. There was no forensic evidence linking him to the hammer, the stolen van or the cash found at his family home. There were five other adults there and he was living in a granny flat with a separate entrance, she said. Mr McMullen denied the Snapchat account was his and there was no evidence linking him to it, other than a username that did not require any identification to set up, Ms Dolan said. The accused had gone to Lanzarote for a holiday with his girlfriend who was pregnant and flew home early when his brother died in 'tragic circumstances." Judge Brennan said the charges were serious but granted bail with a €3,000 independent surety, to be approved by the court. Under conditions, the accused must surrender his passport, sign on daily at Ronanstown garda station and keep a night-time curfew. He was remanded in custody to appear in Cloverhill District Court next week. Stock photo Today's News in 90 Seconds - August 19th
The Irish Sun
3 days ago
- The Irish Sun
Heartbroken dad of missing teen Hannah Osborn says ‘everyone will know soon' in cryptic message after ‘foul play' fears
THE heartbroken dad of a missing teen has posted a cryptic social media message more than a week after she vanished. Hannah Osborn, 17, was last seen on August 9, leading to a major search to track her down. 6 Her family have feared the worst since her disappearance Credit: Facebook/@wesley osborn 6 Hannah Osborn, 17, was last seen on August 9 Credit: Facebook 6 Her dad Wesley has called the days she has been missing 'the hardest' of his life Credit: Facebook Her family have feared the worst since her disappearance in rural Arkansas. But suspicions have grown that an element of foul play may be involved, as reported by ABC affiliate KATV-TV. Hannah is a fan of the social media site Snapchat, according to her family. Her dad Wesley has called the days she has been missing "the hardest" of his life. read more in us news MONSTER STORM Hurricane Erin intensifies to 'catastrophic' category 5 with 160mph winds But in a cryptic Facebook post, he shared a picture of himself with his daughter along with a brief message. He wrote: "It's been a whole week since I've seen your beautiful face! "I'm coming and I'm bringing Hell with me! I know, they know, and everyone will know soon enough! "Bring my baby girl home or give her a phone so she can call me!" It is unclear who the "they" he refers to in the post is, and whether he believes for certain that he knows who has Hannah. Wesley, from the small city of Bradford, previously said his daughter had "problems" on Snapchat. Desperate hunt for missing teen Hannah Osborn who vanished after Snapchat 'problems' – as family fear 'foul play' He said she met people from out of town and became worried when she failed to return home. Wesley further claimed there were some cars in their neighborhood at the time she left home. He shared a picture of a vehicle that was seen in the area around the time of his daughter's disappearance. "It leads me to believe there might be some foul play," he previously said. It is not known if Hannah got into a car. She was last seen at around 7:40pm on August 9, and was last known to be wearing a white t-shirt and blue jeans. Timeline of Hannah Osborn's disappearance HANNAH Osborn, a teenager from Arkansas, has gone missing. The U.S. Sun breaks down the timeline of her disappearance. August 9 - Hannah is last seen at around 7:40pm leaving her dad Wesley's house in Bradford, Arkansas. August 10 - Wesley posts online in the early hours and reveals that his daughter will be a missing person at 8am local time. Hours later - Wesley posts online with a heartfelt plea. He writes: "Hannah, I love you and I miss you, and I really need you to just to come back home." August 11 - Wesley speaks of his heartache. He revealed he's overwhelmed with emotion and asks Hannah for some sort of "assurance." August 14: Wesley and his wife Crystal (Hannah's mom) open up about their fears that she may have met someone on Snapchat in an interview Hannah also had an orange and black backpack with her, according to a missing persons poster. In a previous social media post, her dad wrote: "Please, if you see this pick up a phone and call me and tell me that you are ok. "It's been the hardest five days of our lives not knowing where you are or what may have happened to you. "We have turned this country upside down searching for you, following every single lead without hesitation hoping we would see your beautiful face at the end of each one! "I would beat down the doors of Hell to find you and make sure you are safe, and I hope you realize that and know that you are loved and greatly missed." Hannah's mother Crystal said: "I don't even have the words to express how I'm feeling right now. "The heartache, anxiety, worry, lack of sleep and overall fear is overwhelming." 6 Her dad shared a picture of a vehicle that was seen in the area Credit: Facebook/Wesley Osborn 6 Suspicions have grown that an element of foul play may be involved Credit: Facebook
Irish Daily Mirror
4 days ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Student, 20, accused of 14 counts of rape and sexual assault of male
A 20-year-old student has been charged with multiple counts of rape and sexual assault of another male in Dublin four years ago. The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was aged 16 and a juvenile, at the time of the sexual abuse over a three month period in 2021. He was arrested yesterday and charged with six counts of rape and eight for sexual assault at a specific address in south Co Dublin. He appeared before Judge John Brennan at a late sitting of Dublin District Court. Detective Garda Liam Conway said the young man replied "No" when each charge was put to him. The court heard that the Director of Public Prosecutions has directed that the man would face "trial on indictment". That means, due to the nature of some of the charges, he will be tried in the Central Criminal Court. Detective Garda Conway confirmed that the accused was a minor when the alleged offences occurred and there was no objection to bail provided he obeyed a series of conditions. Judge Brennan ordered him to provide gardaí with a contact phone number, remain contactable at all times, notify them of any address change, sign on at a north Dublin Garda station, and surrender his passport. Furthermore, he told the man that it was as conditions of bail that he must not communicate with the complainant, directly or indirectly, including by social media. Defence counsel Kevin McCrave consulted with the accused who did not address the court, before telling the judge that his client consented to those terms. Judge Brennan warned there would be consequences for breaching them and the barrister stressed that he would explain that to his client, who has yet indicate a plea. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Bail was set at €750 and he was ordered to appear at the Children's Court in September to be served with a book of evidence and returned for trial to the Central Criminal Court. Legal aid was granted after the court heard the accused was a student, on social welfare and unemployed. Sign up to the Irish Mirror's Courts and Crime newsletter here and get breaking crime updates and news from the courts direct to your inbox.
