‘Splitting' raises questions about oversight of Help to Buy scheme, says Simon Harris
Simon Harris
has said the issue of 'splitting' a
Help to Buy
transaction raises important questions over the oversight of the Government scheme
He was speaking after estate agent Sherry FitzGerald launched an internal investigation after a home buyer was offered a 'split' sale for a
new-build property
, in order for it to qualify for the Help to Buy scheme. The case was
first reported in The Irish Times on Tuesday
.
Mr Harris reaffirmed the Government's commitment to the scheme for the lifetime of the Coalition, but he said that important questions had been raised by the issue of 'split' sales.
'When issues like that come to the fore it does raise important questions in relation to the oversight of the scheme,' he said. Mr Harris said he had total confidence in the
Revenue Commissioners
operation of the scheme but added that it was ultimately taxpayers money being used.
READ MORE
'It's important that the integrity of the scheme is protected at all costs.'
He said the Government would await any guidance or advice from the Revenue Commissioners or the Department of Finance in relation to the scheme.
The Help to Buy (HTB) scheme is administered by Revenue and provides a refund on income tax of up to €30,000 to first-time buyers on new-build properties up to a value of €500,000.
Social Democrats
' spokesman on housing Rory Hearne said it was 'alarming to see evidence of such blatant breaches of the scheme'.
'Questions need to be answered now about how widespread this issue is and if this case is just the tip of the iceberg,' the Dublin North-West TD said.
The story 'shows that estate agents are playing a role in pushing for and facilitating higher house prices, which developers are also lobbying for'.
[
The 'emotional toll' of buying a home in Ireland: 'split' deals and queueing for houses already sold
Opens in new window
]
'The Government has done nothing to challenge the various market actors pushing up house prices, and has actually added to and facilitated house price inflation through the help to buy schemes. We need to see proper regulation and transparency in the house purchase market to stop the price gouging going on now,' Mr Hearne said.
Mr Harris also spoke about the potential impact of trade tensions between the United States and the European Union as the clock ticks down on a 90-day tariff pause to charges announced by the White House earlier this year.
The Tánaiste said this week would be an 'extremely intense' period in trying to secure a framework agreement between Brussels and Washington. He said that at the very least, the aim was to provide a sense of certainty where there was a 'vacuum' at the moment.
He said the current situation was 'holding back people in terms of jobs decisions and investment decisions. We need clarity and certainty as to what the trade environment works like.'
He said Europe and Ireland wanted to see 'zero-for-zero' tariffs as widely as possible and that the Dublin Government was working hard on the issue of pharmaceutical exports to the United States.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
30 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Dáil passes Defamation Bill by 83 votes to 61
Retailers should fight false defamation claims and 'not take the easy route' of paying out because that just encourages further claims, Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has warned. He was highlighting a new defence for retailers subjected to defamation claims for challenging people on whether they had paid for goods before leaving a shop. The provision is part of the Defamation (Amendment) Bill, which includes the abolition of juries in such cases and protections for media organisations against strategic lawsuits against public participation (Slapps), actions taken by usually rich or powerful individuals designed to intimidate media organisations in their coverage of such people. The Dáil on Wednesday night passed the legislation by 83 votes to 61 and it now goes to the Seanad . READ MORE Mr O'Callaghan said there had been 'ill-informed inaccurate commentary' that he had amended provisions of the Bill on protections for retailers. This was 'completely incorrect'. The Minister said the provision was a 'very powerful defence' and this power was to 'ensure that they aren't subjected to unnecessary defamation actions'. Sinn Féin justice spokesman Matt Carthy suggested the Minister talk to retailers because a representative group member had expressed 'real concerns' to him that the provision would not do what it was supposed to. Claims are encouraged when retailers have a 'tendency not to contest', Mr O'Callaghan said. If retailers contest claims which are not valid, 'the message will go out to litigants there is no point in taking those claims', he added. The Minister also said politicians 'should have a thick skin' about commentary in traditional media and 'perhaps we should also have a thick skin when it comes to comments made about us online, although that's a matter for each individual politician'. Introducing a measure to provide protections to individuals against online defamation, he said 'there has to be a statutory response' where 'really egregious defamatory statements are made about an individual falsely accusing them of the most heinous and serious offences'. The Bill also contains a provision to protect media organisations on occasions 'where a responsible journalist may have made a mistake in one or two details'. It was not Mr O'Callaghan's experience that 'the media has gone out of their way to tell lies'. But Mr Carthy said the Minister was saying this 'from the luxury' of representing Fianna Fáil . It was his experience as a Sinn Féin representative that 'there have been instances where our media outlets have published downright lies about my party and they done so knowing that [they] were lies'.
Irish Times
42 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Trade and economic uncertainty reaches record levels, Government trade forum hears
Uncertainty over trade and economic policy has soared to highs not seen since the pandemic, the Government's trade forum has been told. A presentation to the group by Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe underlined an 'exceptionally uncertain' near-term outlook. The forum, established earlier this year, comprises various members including Government and business and is aimed at facilitating engagement on new and emerging trade developments. The Department of Finance is conducting assessments of the macroeconomic impact of tariffs along with the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI), focusing on the most likely landing zone. READ MORE Officials believe that is a level of 10 per cent tariffs imposed unilaterally by the US on the rest of the world with carve outs for certain sectors. However, Mr Donohoe's presentation to the trade forum struck a cautionary tone, noting that the carve outs are assumed 'at least for now'. It said uncertainty was the key factor shaping the economic outlook, with trade policy uncertainty at an all-time high and economic policy uncertainty greater than during the Covid-19 pandemic. A weakened dollar is a headwind for some exporters, the forum was told, while oil prices have been volatile. Mr Donohoe outlined that the economy and employment would continue to expand, albeit at a slower pace. In the short term, modified domestic demand – a measure of demand in the real economy – would grow by 2 per cent versus 2.5 per cent in a no-tariff scenario in 2025. The following year it would grow by 1.75 per cent, a point lower than the no-tariff scenario. Employment, meanwhile, would grow at 1.75 per cent in 2025, versus 2 per cent without tariffs, and 1 per cent in 2026 rather than a predicted 1.5 per cent without tariffs. Overall, it is estimated that employment would be 1.5 per cent lower over the medium term – equivalent to almost 50,000 fewer jobs compared with a no-tariff baseline. Employment will still rise overall, however. The forum was cautioned that modelling the Irish economy was less reliable than elsewhere, due to the impact of specific firm's decision on exports and GDP, and that the model does not take into account the impact on foreign direct investment as this concentrated sector is difficult to model. The forum was warned that there was no clear precedent upon which confident projections could be made. Government sources said its assessment was that the economy remained robust and would continue to grow, albeit at a slightly slower rate. More impact analysis will be presented on the day of Budget 2026, focusing on the potential hit to the public finances. Tánaiste Simon Harris will be in Berlin on Friday for talks with his German counterpart, having recently engaged with his US counterpart Jameson Grier and EU trade ministers. The Coalition intends to focus on bilateral engagements and trade missions such as Taoiseach Micheál Martin 's current Japan trip. The forum also got an update on the Government's upcoming action plan on market diversification, intended to help exporters tap new markets, due to go to Cabinet in July. A renewed focus is also expected on competitiveness. It examined the semiconductor sector in Ireland, looking at current issues, and positioning Ireland as a global hub, which the Government says will be underpinned by a new national semiconductor strategy. Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers told the forum that the review of the National Development Plan will be finalised in July with a focus on investment in sectors such as water, energy and housing.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Customs officers boarded ship suspected of delivering €31 million drugs haul off Cork coast
Customs officials boarded and examined a ship suspected of delivering cocaine worth almost €31 million to an international drugs trafficking gang off the south-west coast of Ireland. The officers examined ship movements off Broad Strand near Courtmacsherry in West Cork and identified a bulk carrier, which they believe may have brought the drugs across the Atlantic from South America for collection off the Cork coast. The carrier passed 20 miles off Broad Strand in the early hours of Tuesday morning, leading customs officials to believe it may have been the ship that delivered the drugs to the gang waiting in a rigid inflatable boat (RIB). Customs rummage crews boarded the ship in Irish waters on Tuesday and carried out an examination of it. However, they found nothing of evidential value to the criminal investigation and the ship was told it was free to continue on its voyage. READ MORE Meanwhile, detectives from the Garda National Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau (GNDOCB) continue to work with international police forces and the Maritime Analysis and Operations Centre – Narcotics (MAOC- N) in Lisbon in a bid to trace the origin of the huge drugs haul. Gardai from GNDOCB backed up by armed officers from the Emergency Response Unit (ERU) seized the drugs as they were being driven away from Broad Strand near Courtmacsherry by two of the four-man gang involved in landing the cocaine at the empty beach at around 4am. Armed officers stopped the UK-registered rental van and arrested the driver, a a 40-year-old man from Glasgow in Scotland and his passenger, a 31-year-old German from Bavaria. The officers recovered 440kg of cocaine in 18 vacuum packed blocks from the back of the van. The two men, whom gardai believed travelled from the UK with the van at the weekend, were taken for questioning to Bandon Garda station. They can be detained for up to seven days under drugs trafficking legislation. The Naval Service apprehended two other members of the gang, a 44-year-old Englishman from Cornwall and a 36-year-old Scot from Aberdeenshire, when two Maritime Interdiction Teams stopped and boarded their RIB off Waterford. The Naval Service detained the two men, whom they believe were returning to the UK, and brought them back to Naval Service headquarters where they were handed over to gardaí. The two men were arrested and taken to Togher Garda station for questioning. They too are being held under drugs trafficking legislation. The haul of drugs has been sent for analysis by scientists at Forensic Science Ireland to establish the purity of the cocaine. This will give a more accurate estimate as to the potential street value of the consignment.
