SC to hear on Aug 14 plea for restoring Jammu & Kashmir statehood
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
The Supreme Court would on Thursday hear a plea for the restoration of statehood to Jammu and Kashmir.A bench of Chief Justice of India B R Gavai and Justice K Vinod Chandran is likely to hear the matter, according to the causelist.On December 11, 2023, the Supreme Court unanimously upheld the revocation of Article 370, even as it ordered that assembly elections be held in Jammu and Kashmir by September 2024 and its statehood be restored "at the earliest".Last year, a plea was filed in the top court seeking directions to the Centre for the restoration of statehood to Jammu and Kashmir within two months.The application was filed by Zahoor Ahmad Bhat, an academician, and Khurshaid Ahmad Malik, a socio-political activist."It is submitted that the delay in the restoration of statehood would cause serious reduction of democratically elected government in Jammu and Kashmir, causing a grave violation of the idea of federalism which forms part of the basic structure of the Constitution of India," the application said.The assembly elections and the Lok Sabha polls were conducted peacefully in Jammu and Kashmir without any incident of violence, disturbance or any security concerns being reported, it said."Therefore, there is no impediment of security concerns, violence or any other disturbances which would hinder or prevent the grant/restoration of the status of statehood to Jammu and Kashmir as had been assured by the Union of India in the present proceedings," the plea said.The non-restoration of the status of statehood of Jammu and Kashmir, the plea said, would result in a lesser form of elected democratic government to the state, particularly given legislative assembly results were declared on October 8, 2024.Despite the apex court's directions for the restoration of statehood to Jammu and Kashmir "at the earliest and as soon as possible", no steps have been taken by the Centre to provide any timeline for the implementation of such directions, it claimed."Jammu and Kashmir is being operated as a Union Territory for a period of almost five years now, which has caused many impediments and grave losses to the development of Jammu and Kashmir and has affected the democratic rights of its citizens," the plea added.In its December 2023 verdict, the apex court held that Article 370, which was incorporated in the Indian Constitution in 1949 to grant special status to Jammu and Kashmir, was a temporary provision. The President of India was empowered to revoke the measure in the absence of the Constituent Assembly of the erstwhile state whose term expired in 1957, the court said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
3 minutes ago
- Hans India
Can't share machine-readable voter list as it may lead to breach of privacy: CEC Gyanesh Kumar
Sticking to its firm stand of protecting the privacy of voters, the Election Commission of India (ECI) on Sunday refused to release machine-readable voter list – a demand repeatedly made by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi. Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar said machine machine-readable voter list has been banned since the 2019 verdict of the Supreme Court, as in such a list, the entries and photos can be tinkered with. 'We recently saw some media reports displaying voter lists with photos of electors without consent, which is a breach of privacy,' he said, adding that the poll panel was obligated not to circulate photos of mothers or sisters. He said machine machine-readable voter list is different from the searchable voter list, which is available on the ECI, where a voter can enter his details to check if his name is in the voter list. CEC Gyanesh Kumar said the ECI is standing like a rock with voters, and no eligible voter's name can be deleted to deny him or her the right to vote. He said within 56 hours of a Supreme Court order, the ECI has created a website for each district in Bihar, and it can be used to search a voter's name usingthe EPIC number. Earlier last week, the ECI accepted three key suggestions from the Supreme Court over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the electoral roll in Bihar, agreeing to the addition of a list of non-included voters with reasons in the draft roll. For the convenience of citizens, the ECI said that in addition to the list of deceased, voters at two places and permanently shifted given by BLOs to all political parties since July 20, a list of non-included voters with reasons shall also be put in the draft roll. The list of non-included voters could be searched with the EPIC number, booth-wise, on the website of DEOs and the CEO, it said. The poll panel said those aggrieved can file their claim along with a copy of Aadhaar, a key second suggestion of the apex court. The ECI accepted the apex court's suggestion that those aggrieved can file claims along with a copy of Aadhaar. A source in the ECI said an aggrieved person can be defined as a person whose name is not present in the draft list (65 lakhs), and he or she can only file a claim, which has to be in Form 6 under the rules. The Form 6 already contains a column for Aadhaar. Earlier, during a hearing, the apex court directed the ECI to publish online the list of over 65 lakh voters proposed for deletion during SIR. However, citing ground reports and official documentation, ECI officials assert that the process has been far more transparent and collaborative than some Opposition voices suggest. The apex court's directions include uploading the full list of deletions, stating reasons for each deletion, allowing claims with Aadhaar for identification (not citizenship), and displaying these lists at Panchayat and BDO offices.
Indian Express
3 minutes ago
- Indian Express
CEC defends SIR; says some parties spreading ‘misinformation', firing from EC's shoulder
The electoral roll revision is aimed at removing all shortcomings in voter lists and it is a matter of grave concern that some parties are spreading misinformation about it and 'firing from the Election Commission's shoulder', CEC Gynaesh Kumar said on Sunday as the INDIA bloc parties launched 'Voter Adhikar Yatra' in poll-bound Bihar against alleged 'vote-chori'. Addressing a press conference, the Chief Election Commission (CEC) rejected as baseless the allegations of double voting and 'vote theft' and asserted that all stakeholders are working to make Special Intensive Revision (SIR) a success in a transparent manner. 'It is a matter of grave concern that some parties and their leaders are spreading misinformation on SIR in Bihar… some political parties are firing from the Election Commission's shoulder. The EC exhorts all political parties to file claims and objections on draft electoral rolls in Bihar … 15 days are still remaining. 'Doors of the Election Commission are open to everyone, and booth-level officers and agents are working together in a transparent manner,' he said. Kumar said the EC cannot discriminate among political parties, and both ruling and opposition parties are equal before the poll authority. 'It is an insult to the Indian Constitution if election petitions are not filed within 45 days but allegations of vote chori are raised,' he said. Neither the EC nor the voters are scared of 'baseless allegations' of double voting and 'vote chori', Kumar stressed, adding that the Election Commission will remain steadfast with voters of all classes without bothering about politics being played by some. 'More than one crore employees are engaged in the election exercise. Can 'vote chori' happen in such a transparent process?' he questioned. The comments come as the Opposition stepped up its attack against the poll roll revision in Bihar and on the allegations of 'vote chori' raised by Congress. Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Sunday alleged that the whole country now knows that the Election Commission is 'stealing' elections in collusion with the BJP and asserted that the INDIA bloc will not let them succeed in their 'conspiracy' to steal the Bihar Assembly polls by voter additions and deletions through SIR. He was addressing a gathering in Sasaram at the launch event of his 1,300 km 'Voter Adhikar Yatra' covering over 20 districts in Bihar. The CEC said that the latest SIR became necessary in the wake of complaints by many parties and migration of voters within the country. 'Knowingly, unknowingly, some people ended up having multiple voter cards due to migration and other issues…. It is a myth that SIR has been carried out in haste. It is EC's legal duty to correct voter lists before every election,' he said.
Mint
3 minutes ago
- Mint
‘Desh se maafi maangni hogi…' CEC Gyanesh Kumar BIG challenge to Rahul Gandhi on ‘vote chori' claims
Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar said on Sunday that he rebuked Rahul Gandhi over his 'vote chori' allegation and asked him to either sign an affidavit or apologise to the nation for his remarks, which he described as an 'insult' to the Constitution of India. The Election Commission's remarks came on a day when Congress Member of Parliament (MP) Rahul Gandhi launched his 1,300 km-long 'Voter Adhikar Yatra' from poll-bound Bihar's Sasaram to step up the Opposition INDIA bloc's campaign against its "vote chori" (vote theft) claims. On 7 August, Rahul Gandhi had alleged 'vote chori (theft)' of 1,00,250 votes in an assembly of a Karnataka Lok Sabha constituency, with 11,965 duplicate voters in the segment, 40,009 voters with fake and invalid addresses, 10,452 bulk voters or single-address voters, 4,132 voters with invalid photos, Here are the top 10 remarks from Gynesh Kumar during the press conference on Sunday: Gynesh Kumar said India is the world's biggest democracy, we have the largest electoral roll, about 90 crore, the biggest team of election officials and the highest number of voters. 'And amid all this in the presence of the media, if you say that there are duplicate voters and some people have voted twice and call my voters criminals, it is not possible that the Election Commission will not react. You will have to sign an affidavit or apologise to the nation (desh se maafi maangni padegi.) There is no third option. I want to say if there is no affidavit it seven days, it means the allegations are baseless,' he said. When more than 7 crore votes of Bihar are standing with the Election Commission of India,then neither can any question mark be raised on the credibility of the Election Commission nor on the credibility of the voters, Gyanesh Kumar said. "When the voter doesn't challenge his candidate selection in the courts and then wrong words like 'vote chori' are used to mislead the people, isn't it ani nsult to the Constitution of India," Gyanesh Kumar also explained how duplicate voter ID cards can be possible. "Duplicate EPICs can happen in two ways. One, that a person who is in West Bengal, who is a different person, has one EPIC number and another person who is in Haryana has the same EPIC number. When this question came up around March 2025, we discussed it and we solved it across the country. About three lakh such people were found, whose EPIC number were the same, so their EPIC numbers were changed. The second type of duplication comes when the name of the same person is in the voter list at more than one place and his EPIC number is different. That is, one person, many EPICs,' he said. Gyanesh Kumar also responded to theCCTV footage demand. "We saw a few days ago that photos of many voters were presented to the media without their permission. Allegations were made against them, they were used. Should the Election Commission share the CCTV videos of any voter including their mothers, daughters-in-law, daughters? Only those whose names are in the voter list cast their votes to elect their candidate," he said. The truth is that step by step all the stakeholders are committed, trying and working hard to make the SIR of Bihar a complete success, Gyanesh Kumar said. When more than seven crore voters of Bihar are standing with the Election Commission, then neither can any question mark be raised on the credibility of the Election Commission nor on the credibility of the voters, he said. '...The SIR exercise has not been done in the last 20 years... The SIR exercise has been carried out more than 10 times in the country. The main purpose of SIR is to purify the voter list... The SIR exercise is being carried out after receiving many complaints from political parties,' the CEC said. Kumar said about 1.6 lakh Booth Level Agents(BLA) have prepared a draft SIR list in poll-bound Bihar. "As this draft list was being prepared in every booth, the Booth Level Agents of all political parties verified it with their have submitted a total of 28,370 claims and objections," he said. The three Election Commissioners will decide when the exercise of SIR will be carried out in West Bengal or other states" "Some voters alleged double voting. When asked for proof, no answer was given. Neither the Election Commission nor any voter is afraid of such false allegations. When politics is being done by targeting the voters of India by keeping a gun on the shoulder of the Election Commission, today the Election Commission wants to make it clear to everyone that the Election Commission fearlessly stood like a rock with all the voters of all sections and all religions including the poor, rich, elderly, women, youth without any discrimination, is standing and will continue to stand." The machine-readable voter list is prohibited, Gyanesh Kumar said citing a decision of the Election Commission after the judgment of the Supreme Court and is from 2019. 'We have to understand the difference between a machine-readable voter list and a searchable voter list. You can search the voter list available on the Election Commission website by entering the EPIC number. You can also download it,' Gyanesh Kumar said. This, he said, is not called machine-readable. Regarding machine-readable, in 2019, the Supreme Court also studied this subject in depth and found that giving a machine-readable electoral roll can violate the privacy of the voter... "The machine-readable voter list is prohibited. This decision of the Election Commission is after the judgment of the Supreme Court and is from 2019..." the CEC said. Kumar said that according to the Constitution of India, only Indian citizens can vote for the election of MP and MLA. "People from other countries do not have the right. If such people have filled out the enumeration form, then during the SIR process, they will have to prove their nationality by submitting some documents. Their names will be removed after the investigation," he said. In Lok Sabha elections 2024, Kumar said, more than one crore employees, more than 10 lakh booth level agents, more than 20 lakh polling agents of candidates work for the elections. "In such a transparent process in front of so many people, can any voter steal votes?..." he asked. As per the Constitution of India, every citizen of India who has attained the age of 18 years must become a voter and must also vote, the CEC said. 'You all know that, as per the law, every political party is born through registration with the Election Commission. Then how can the Election Commission discriminate among the same political parties? For the Election Commission, all are equal. No matter who belongs to any political party, the Election Commission will not step back from its constitutional duty,' Gyanesh Kumar said.
