Apple ordered by UK government to let it access users' encrypted files
Apple has reportedly been ordered by the UK government to allow it access to encrypted data stored by the company's users worldwide in its cloud service.
At the moment, only the Apple account holder can access such data - not even the US technology giant can see it.
Apple, which makes iPhones, iPads and iMacs, has been issued with a Technical Capability Notice (TCN), the Washington Post and BBC are reporting.
This order, which does not get published, is said to require a blanket ability for the government to view people's encrypted data - both in the UK and abroad.
The Home Office will not confirm or deny the existence of the order. Apple has been approached for comment.
Getting technology companies to break encryption has long been a contentious issue in the UK government.
Ministers have argued they want to use it for purposes like protecting children, identifying criminals and keeping the public safe.
What are the concerns?
Opponents say it is a breach of privacy, they highlight the risk to whistleblowers and journalists, and point out that any tool the government has to break into people's information has a danger of being hijacked by bad actors.
There are also concerns that, if implemented, the UK's order could lead nations like China to force Western companies to break their users' privacy.
The debate stretches as far back as 2017, when then home secretary Amber Rudd stated that "I don't need to understand how encryption works" to want it broken.
Much of the debate around encryption has been around "end-to-end" encryption, which means that messages and data sent between two devices can only be read by the person they are sent to - and are scrambled if anyone else tries to intercept or access them.
'Advanced Data Protection'
On Apple products, users have the option to use "Advanced Data Protection", which means certain data can only be decrypted by the user. Apple promises that even a cloud data breach would not make the information readable.
Users are also told that Apple cannot see the data due to the end-to-end encryption used to share the information.
The order from the UK government was made under the UK Investigatory Powers Act 2016, according to The Washington Post. The act says the orders can be applied to companies outside the UK.
There are avenues for Apple to appeal against the TCN, but this process would not be made public.
The Labour government has been outspoken in its desire to target social media and technology companies while in power.
This includes recently trumpeting its plans to be the first country in the world to create a new AI sexual abuse offence to punish those generating and facilitating the creation of AI child sexual abuse images.
And Home Secretary Yvette Cooper has criticised social media companies for not being fast enough to take down videos previously viewed by Southport killer Axel Rudakubana.
Last year, Apple provided written evidence to MPs on its many oppositions to the Investigatory Powers Act and TCNs.
It noted that the law gives the UK government the power to "act as the world's regulator" of security technology - something which could put it at odds with authorities like the EU and the United States.
Order would 'undermine fundamentally human rights'
The American company also said that an order to force decryption would "undermine fundamentally human rights" and potentially put the UK at odds with the European Court of Human Rights.
"There is no reason why the [UK government] should have the authority to decide for citizens of the world whether they can avail themselves of the proven security benefits that flow from end-to-end encryption," Apple said.
It added: "Moreover, any attempt by the [secretary of state] to use its extraterritorial powers to compel technology companies to weaken encryption technology will only strengthen the hands of malicious actors who seek to steal and exploit personal data for nefarious purposes."
A spokesperson for privacy and civil liberty campaign group Big Brother Watch said: "We urge the UK government to immediately rescind this draconian order and cease attempts to employ mass surveillance in lieu of the targeted powers already at their disposal."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
France's Mistral launches Europe's first AI reasoning model
PARIS, June 10 (Reuters) - Mistral on Tuesday launched Europe's first AI reasoning model, which uses logical thinking to create a response, as it tries to keep pace with American and Chinese rivals at the forefront of AI development. The French startup has attempted to differentiate itself by championing its European roots, winning the support of French President Emmanuel Macron, as well as making some of its models open source in contrast to the proprietary offerings of OpenAI or Alphabet's (GOOGL.O), opens new tab Google. Mistral is considered Europe's best shot at having a home-grown AI competitor, but has lagged behind in terms of market share and revenue. Reasoning models use chain-of-thought techniques - a process that generates answers with intermediate reasoning abilities when solving complex problems. They could also be a promising path forward in advancing AI's capabilities as the traditional approach of building ever-bigger large language models by adding more data and computing power begins to hit limitations. For Mistral, which was valued by venture capitalists at $6.2 billion, an industry shift away from "scaling up" could give it a window to catch up against better capitalized rivals. China's DeepSeek broke through as a viable competitor in January through its low-cost, open-sourced AI models, including one for reasoning. OpenAI was the first to launch its reasoning models last year, followed by Google (GOOGL.O), opens new tab a few months later. Meta (META.O), opens new tab, which also offers its models open-sourced, has not yet released a standalone reasoning model, though it said its latest top-shelf model has reasoning capabilities. Mistral is launching an open-sourced Magistral Small model and a more powerful version called Magistral Medium for business customers. "The best human thinking isn't linear - it weaves through logic, insight, uncertainty, and discovery. Reasoning language models have enabled us to augment and delegate complex thinking and deep understanding to AI," Mistral said. American companies have mostly kept their most advanced models proprietary, though a handful, such as Meta, has released open-source models. In contrast, Chinese firms ranging from DeepSeek to Alibaba have taken the open-source path to demonstrate their technological capabilities. Mistral Small is available for download on Hugging Face's platform and can reason in languages including English, French, Spanish, Arabic and simplified Chinese.
Sky News
3 hours ago
- Sky News
Trump's 'anti-migrant rhetoric' gives the UK's tech industry a competitive edge, say experts
President Trump's "anti-migrant rhetoric" may be helping the UK's tech industry, according to tech executives. "If the US continues its foreign policy, anti-migrant rhetoric, it's going to put founders off and operators off," said Husayn Kassai, a founder of the UK's AI Hub and the chief executive of Quench AI. "Already you have some students that were considering moving to the US [now] considering the UK, and you have tech founders and operators, which are just as important, again increasingly considering the UK relative to the US," he said to Sky News during London Tech Week. His comments come amid a US political landscape in which immigrant communities across America have been surprised at the speed and ferocity with which new policies, including crackdowns and deportations, have been enacted in Mr Trump's first 100 days in office. In the last few days, some in California - the home of tech hotspot the San Francisco Bay area - have been taking direct action in protest at the Trump administration's actions. After selling his previous company Onfido for a record amount last year, Mr Kassai decided to found his new start-up in the UK because of its talent pool. 1:29 "In the US, there's talk of there being more talent, more AI talent in particular. That's changing because of some of the US politics. "[Also,] in places like San Francisco, there may be more AI talent but it's not accessible to early-stage startups," he added, saying that's because huge companies like Meta and Google are able to offer such high salaries. Talent is often the deciding factor in where companies move their operations, according to one expert whose job it is to persuade them to come to the UK. Laura Citron, chief executive of London and Partners, said she often talks to international founders thinking about where to expand globally. "Making sure that businesses feel [...] it will be easy for them to bring international talent into the market, that will always be the most important factor." "Particularly at the moment, with what's happening geopolitically, that fundamental strength of London in openness and being inclusive and welcoming has suddenly really shot up in people's importance," she said. The UK is the third-largest AI market in the world, according to the government, only beaten by the US and China. Yesterday, Jensen Huang, chief executive of NVIDIA predicted that within ten years, "every industry in the UK will be a tech industry". 0:36 The government seems to be banking on that, with investments being announced like yesterday's unveiling of a £187m AI training plan for school students and schemes to encourage infrastructure like data centres to be built around the UK. In January, the government claimed that, if AI is "fully embraced", it could bring £47bn to the economy every year. But although President Trump's changes to US immigration policy may push more tech workers to the UK, the US still has its draw - and cash. "When we've been looking to raise [funding], some people that I've spoken to said: 'You should go to America because they would be talking in millions'," said Jemma Bowles, founder of endometriosis support app Endi. She is currently staying in the UK because her knowledge of the NHS makes it more practical but "I'm not saying no to it," she said. "We'll just see what happens." This week alone, US companies have taken over two UK tech businesses, and Mr Kassai doesn't seem surprised. "Shareholders, investors, board members are going to find the highest bidder and the US tends to pay more," he said. "There's four times as much capital invested into startup companies than there is in the whole of Europe, so naturally when it comes through a sale, the US is often able to pay a higher price." However, he doesn't think that will be the case forever. "The US is going to lose its edge. Historically, it's had four times as much financial capital to invest in startups than Europe, but AI has meant that you don't need as much money to build big companies, and as a result, the US loses its advantage."
Sky News
3 hours ago
- Sky News
UK tech firms agree takeovers as Starmer backs AI future
Why you can trust Sky News Two UK tech firms have agreed takeovers by US rivals on the day Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has spoken of the importance of tech and AI to the UK economy. US chipmaker Qualcomm revealed a $2.4bn (£1.8bn) takeover of Alphawave. Shareholders in the UK firm, which designs semiconductors attractive in artificial intelligence (AI) development, will receive 183p per share under the terms. The price represents a 95% premium to that seen before Qualcomm disclosed its interest. It was separately announced that another US firm, Maryland-based IonQ, had agreed to acquire quantum computing startup Oxford Ionics for $1.1bn (£820m). Both deals will heighten concerns about the ability of UK firms to stave off takeover interest. 0:57 Softbank-owned chipmaker ARM - previously a London-listed firm before it was snapped up under a £32bn deal in 2016 - had also been chasing Alphawave but has since walked away. The UK company's "serdes" technology is said to be the main prize within the deal. It underpins the speed at which data is processed by chips - crucial for AI development. Qualcomm said the deal would bolster its enhancement of AI. Its chips have been widely used by Apple and Samsung though its interest in iPhones has recently been curtailed through the development of Apple's own chip components. Alphawave said it considered the terms of the cash offer to be fair and reasonable and that it intended to unanimously recommend it to its shareholders. In a speech marking the start of London Tech Week, the PM said tech and AI were "absolutely central" to the UK. Cheap valuations and a weak pound have made UK firms attractive to US investors in recent years, while a number of UK listed firms have shifted primary listings to the United States in a bid to attract greater investment. The government has moved to make UK listings more attractive as part of its growth agenda. The prime minister launched a new free government partnership with industry, including Nvidia, Amazon, Google and BT, to train 7.5 million UK workers in essential skills to use AI by 2030. A separate "TechFirst" initiative will roll out AI training to every secondary school over three years. Sir Keir told the audience in central London: "AI and tech makes us more human, which sounds an odd thing to say, but it's true. "We need to say it because... some people out there are sceptical. They do worry about AI taking their job." He said: "For people listening to us, they worry about will it make their lives more complicated? Even for businesses who get it, the pace of change can feel relentless."
