
There is no sense of urgency from politicians for radical land reform
I'd wager that since the inception of The National, land reform has been one of its most popular topics.
I had hoped that Ms Burgess would show a commitment to it beyond the woolly platitudes we are tired of hearing from the ranks of politicians and various players in land whose living is made from it.
What they do either on purpose or by direction is avoid the central question: when is the Scottish Parliament going to get serious about taxing land? Why did Ms Burgess give that a body swerve too?
READ MORE: Historic ruling paves way for first forced private land sale to community in Scotland
She cites the current Land Reform Bill as having the potential 'to break up big estates and empower communities to buy and transform the land around them'.
I have spoken with representatives of two large landowners. They have indicated to me that if their land was taxed annually and became a significant financial burden, they would dispose of much of the land as their business model can operate without it.
So why would any serious politician with the interests of communities at heart encourage them to buy land with good public money without first establishing just how much of the land owners would retain if it was taxed?
Poverty is the greatest blight on our people, yet we commend our government for introducing the Scottish Child Payment when it has the power to eliminate child poverty. Our political classes in national and local government and their advisors pussyfoot around with initiatives here and there to increase and spread public funds at the margins, instead of dealing with the fundamentals through the legislative powers they have enjoyed for years.
READ MORE: Scottish Tory council leader appears to promise 'pals' contracts
Our politicians and media institutionalise the fixed budget when it is not Westminster which fixes the budget; it's the Scottish Government which chooses to do so. Incredibly, the opposition parties are complicit in this, as one never hears them bring forward any proposal which would expand the budget to such an extent that all our lives can be transformed.
Over recent years I have been present when politicians and their officials engage with stakeholders on matters of great national and human importance. The common denominator of all such experience is that there is no sense of any urgency.
Tinkering at the edges is our national political sport. The ball is at their feet, but it's what's under their feet which is the solution.
Graeme McCormick
Arden
IN a few years Visit Scotland will be adding a new tourist experience for the people of Scotland and their visitors. This will be a wonderful addition to our iconic NC500, The West Highland Way and the Southern Upland Walk.
It's the Pylon Paths. Routes stretching from our islands in the west and north. Running through our stunning Highland landscapes, then cutting through our best arable farming land on the east coast and continuing through the tranquil Tweed Valley and finishing up on the rolling Border Hills.
READ MORE: Stephen Flynn speaks out as Labour snub Scottish carbon capture scheme
Hundreds of miles of majestic steel structures. Some the biggest anywhere, the envy of our European neighbours and a tribute to the multinationals who decided Scotland was the best place for this attraction.
VisitScotland will host an opening launch and pay tribute to our First Minister and his government for their unstinting and selfless support to enable this magnificent undertaking to come to fruition. Also attending the launch will be Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer. He will echo the words of VisitScotland in praising the Scottish Government for delivering this unique development and with its completion a milestone for his task of delivering net zero emissions by 2050. Job done.
David Smart
via email
HUGE interest will have to be paid to the banks for money borrowed to finance the cost of net zero, as the UK operates a deficit economy.
The weakness of the present UK system is that the banks create the government's money supply from thin air, in exchange for government guarantees, rather as they might demand guarantees for a personal loan or business overdraft.
At present, government pays interest to the banks of around £120 billion a year on such money, as its debt to the banks is around £3 trillion.
READ MORE: Scotland shouldn't aim for independence without a currency plan, says expert
The answer of course is for government itself to create and issue the money supply, but interest-free. This would save those billions for better use, and could also keep expenditure in proportion to the assets of the nation, such as roads, schools, public housing, the NHS, and so on, and of course those assets would be more cheaply created without an interest burden.
Equally, the banking system itself would be unlikely to fund the massive cost of net zero without guarantees that would bankrupt the nation if ever exercised. In effect, Britain would become the property of the banks.
It is clear that in an independent Scotland, government itself must issue and control the volume of the money supply, as well as directing its proper use, and thus be free of the banks that are presently in a position to tell the UK Government what it can and can't do.
Malcolm Parkin
Kinross
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

South Wales Argus
17 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Scottish Government refuses to rule out changes to pensioners' winter payment
A spokesperson for First Minister John Swinney said ministers at Holyrood were 'trying to understand the fiscal implications' of Monday's policy change by the UK Government. After cutting the winter fuel payment for all but the poorest pensioners last year, Chancellor Rachel Reeves has now confirmed some nine million pensioners in England and Wales will receive the benefit this winter. The payment, worth up to £300, will be restored to the vast majority of pensioners who previously received it, with those with an income of under £35,000 a year qualifying for the UK Government's payment. Today we are expanding Winter Fuel Payments to benefit nine million pensioners this winter. It is right that we continue to means-test this payment so that it is targeted and fair. That's why we have acted to expand eligibility so no pensioner on a lower income will miss out. — Rachel Reeves (@RachelReevesMP) June 9, 2025 In Scotland, ministers had already announced plans to ensure all pensioner households receive a payment. The Pension Age Winter Heating Payment will see all pensioner households get at least £100, with poorer pensioners getting either £200 or £300 depending on their age. Labour, however, challenged SNP ministers to ensure that 'no struggling Scottish pensioners will be left out of pocket under their plans'. Mr Swinney's spokesperson confirmed that, as it stands, the policy in Scotland has not been changed. But adding that ministers are 'trying to understand the fiscal implications' of what has been announced', the spokesperson refused to rule out future changes to the payments. 'We will always seek to support pensioners in Scotland the best we can, we are absolutely committed to that,' the spokesperson said. The change in policy from the UK Government will bring additional money for the Scottish Government – with the spokesperson stressing SNP ministers are 'still trying to understand' how much extra cash could be due. Here, the spokesperson stressed the Scottish Government's budget is 'set largely by Westminster', adding: 'We have to, frankly, read the tea leaves sometimes about what is going to happen to our block grant throughout the year.' The comments from the First Minister's spokesperson came as Scottish Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville described the UK Government's handling of of the benefit as 'shambolic'. Shirley-Anne Somerville said she was 'deeply disappointed' in how the UK Government had handled the change (Jane Barlow/PA) Ms Somerville welcomed Labour's U-turn on the benefit cut, but said the decision should never have happened in the first place. She told BBC Radio Scotland it was 'very difficult to try and run a devolved social security system when you're actually finding out some of the details on social media before you can actually find out the details from the Government'. The Social Justice Secretary insisted that was 'no way for the Governments to work together,', adding she was 'deeply disappointed in the way that the UK Government have handled this once again with the Scottish Government'. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray stressed the benefit was devolved to Scotland, saying: 'This is a devolved payment. There's lots of social security that is devolved in Scotland. It is up to the Scottish Government to develop that and come up with their own policy.' The Labour MP also told BBC Radio Scotland the Scottish Government's winter fuel payments system meant that 'limited public money' will go towards helping millionaire pensioners with their heating bills. He insisted the initial decision by the UK Government to scrap the universal payments had been the 'right thing to do at the time', but added that changes could be made to this now the economy has been 'stabilised'.


Telegraph
23 minutes ago
- Telegraph
‘Pride crumble' served in House of Lords
The House of Lords canteen has served peers a 'pride crumble' dessert with a rainbow-coloured topping. The River Restaurant in Parliament, which caters for peers and other staff on the parliamentary estate, offered as its hot dessert option on Tuesday a 'pride crumble'. The topping of the £2.15 pudding appeared to be dyed with red and blue food colouring in horizontal stripes, and was served with custard to mark Pride month. It is unclear whether the crumble was designed to resemble a particular LGBT flag, such as the rainbow flag, or the pink, blue and white transgender flag. It comes after the House of Lords removed Pride flags from its canteen put up at the start of June following a complaint from a peer. The 'Progress Pride' flag, which was among the decorations, includes the colours of the transgender movement and is seen by many as indicative of support for gender ideology – the idea that sex is a spectrum and that people can change their identity. Baroness Nicholson, a Tory peer, complained to the Lord Speaker, Lord McFall, and officials agreed that the flags should be taken down as they had not been sanctioned by the authorities. During her time in Parliament, she voted in favour of section 28, which banned the 'promotion of homosexuality' by local authorities, and against gay marriage. The Progress Pride flag, designed in 2021, is replacing the traditional rainbow Pride flag in many venues. It includes an extra triangle of colour on the left hand side, made up of stripes including white, pink and light blue – the colours of the transgender movement. The flags were not on display in the House of Commons restaurants. The canteen also served rainbow couscous for peers last week as part of its Pride celebrations. The Pride flag was flown from Parliament for the first time in history in June 2016. Last month, Reform UK announced that its councils would not be allowed to fly any LGBT or Pride flags, restricting local authorities to flying only the Union Jack and the St George's Cross.


Scotsman
24 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Why Scotland 'must work together' to build on £317m St Andrews boost
Call for collaboration in bid to ride on back of 'momentum in golf' in sport's birthplace Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... A call to action has been issued for the whole of Scotland to help the country 'harvest an opportunity' to use golf as a tool for growing economic benefit. The idea is to create a 'ripple effect' from St Andrews being at the heart of visitors from around the world flocking in huge numbers to the sport's cradle. According to a report that has just been released following a survey conducted by the Sport Industry Research at Hallam Sheffield University, golf's economic value to St Andrews, Fife and the wider Scottish economy is £317 million annually - the equivalent of the country hosting three Open Championships every year. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The figure was described as 'astonishing' as St Andrews Links Trust, which commissioned the survey, hosted an event at Dynamic Earth in Edinburgh attended by North East Fife MP Wendy Chamberlain, Scottish Government Business Minister Richard Lochhead and various other stakeholders on Tuesday. Neil Coulson, CEO of St Andrews Links Trust, is flanked Scottish Government Business Minister Richard Lochhead and Rob Dickson, Director of Industry & Events at VisitScotland, at Dynamic Earth in Edinburgh | St Andrews Links Trust The economic impact assessment focused on St Andrews, with the Links Trust, a charitable organisation that currently operates seven courses in the Fife town and is negotiating at the moment to add The Duke's to that list, being praised for having the 'foresight and tenacity' to commission the survey by VisitScotland's Director of Industry & Events, Rob Dickson. In 2023 alone, the Links Trust courses hosted more than 280,000 rounds - 54 per cent were played by visitors and 46 per cent by local ticket holders - with Americans making up nearly half of the 72 per cent of the visitors coming from overseas. 'I think there is much to celebrate - we are in a fantastic position,' said Chamberlain of where St Andrews stands in the game around the world. On a golf engagement at the same venue last year, Lochhead had been delighted about the Scottish Government and VisitScotland agreeing a new 11-year partnership with The R&A that will see 14 majors, including the 155th Open at St Andrews in 2027, being staged in the home of golf in a ten-year period. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Golf at the moment is very vibrant - there is a lot of momentum,' he said on this latest visit across the road from the Scottish Parliament, adding with a smile: 'Golf is playing a big role in tourism and the role it plays is super important.' Concurring, Dickson described playing golf in Scotland as a 'flagship experience' that was 'top of the wishlist for many golfers' and said of the new report: 'We wish to be the world's best when it comes to tourism and looking at the success of St Andrews is no bad place to start'. In a speech, Neil Coulson, the chief executive of the Links Trust, said in a proud tone that St Andrews is where golfers from far and wide 'make their dreams come true' by playing there, especially the Old Course, but also said it was a 'national, economic, cultural and social asset'. On the back of a Drive initiative launched this year that is offering cut-price rounds to Scottish golfers, he vowed to ensure that St Andrews 'remains a place that is accessible and belongs to the many, not the few' and also that local golfers 'continue to have access to play on our courses and that tee times don't just become trophies for the privileged'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Old Course at St Andrews is where golfers from around the world 'make their dreams come true' | St Andrews Links Trust In a message to stakeholders, meanwhile, it was stressed that a bid to use the report as a tool for growth extended well beyond the boundaries of the most-famous golfing venue in the world. 'This just isn't about golf at St Andrews,' declared Coulson. 'It's about how we work together to recognise what the country has to offer, the potential of 'Brand Scotland', to support local communities and to build a thriving local economy. We must work together. Collaboration is required across Government, industry, tourism and transport to harvest the opportunity to grow.' Asked later by The Scotsman what he saw that growth being, he added: 'I think there has to be some joined-up conversations about infrastructure and how people move around. And also about the experiences of people. There's lots of different sports and tourism sectors doing really good things, but it is how you join those up so the distillery piece is connected to a golf piece that is connected to a heritage piece. At the moment, they are a little bit isolated. They do really good things on their own, but I think the power of joining those up has got to be huge.' He acknowledged that the potential for growth in St Andrews itself in terms of attracting even more visitors was limited. 'At the end of the day, we have a finite amount of capacity,' conceded Coulson. 'So we need to maintain a balance between local and international and that is very important. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'St Andrews is an intrinsic link between the community and the golf course. We can't just flood it with visitors and ignore that local dynamic. It is not a case of introducing more visitors. In our space, it is understanding what the value of the visitors is that we have now and then looking at how we spread the benefit. 'We can't grow economic and social benefit by just getting more people into St Andrews. But we can do it by trying to collaborate and pushing some of that around Scotland, so we can be a catalyst for people coming - that would be a good thing. 'There are lots of great places to visit and great places to go and stay and experience. It doesn't have to be St Andrews. We might be the driver for them to come in but they can then go out and do other things. That's how I think we grow. It's not just about St Andrews; it's about the national assets that are out there.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad