logo
My Brother and I Haven't Spoken in 4 Years. Can We Reconcile?

My Brother and I Haven't Spoken in 4 Years. Can We Reconcile?

New York Times10 hours ago
My brother and I haven't talked for four years over a dispute about a family property. Our parents were looking to downsize from our family farm. I offered to buy the farm, but the price was beyond my budget. So I asked them to give me the undeveloped smaller portion of the farm instead, and proposed that this would be considered my version of my brother's having previously received financial support with his own down payment at roughly the same value.
When I told my brother about this, he became angry that I had done an 'accounting' of the support that we have each received. We both said things in the exchange that were not nice. I attribute some of my not-so-nice words to unconscious resentment that my brother and I used to talk about how we would do our best to keep the farm in the family, and when the moment came to do something, he didn't.
I think about our argument frequently, but my brother seems to have written off the relationship entirely. Even when I have implored him that our parents are in the last years of their lives, our kids are growing up without uncles, aunts or cousins, and we ourselves will get old and die, he doesn't show any willingness to reconcile. He even rejects that we tolerate each other in the name of our parents and children having the opportunity to be together.
I don't even fully understand how our once-strong relationship ruptured so traumatically in the first place, given that it seems like a fairly normal inheritance dispute, which makes me think that the relationship wasn't as strong as I had thought.
Is there anything I can do to heal this rupture?
From the Therapist: You're carrying a great loss — not only of the relationship with your brother, but also of a future in which your family remained cohesive, the farm stayed in the family, and your children grew up with a sense of connection across generations.
I don't know if your brother will be willing to reconnect, but you can make it more possible by changing your approach.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Dear Richard Madeley: ‘My partner hates my politics but I don't want to lose her'
Dear Richard Madeley: ‘My partner hates my politics but I don't want to lose her'

Yahoo

time42 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Dear Richard Madeley: ‘My partner hates my politics but I don't want to lose her'

I am a 68-year-old widower who finds it difficult to meet prospective partners, but I have recently met a nice lady who I thought was the perfect match for me. She is attractive, funny, gregarious and has many other characteristics I enjoy. Friends and family like her very much. However, sadly, of late it has become clear that she has different politics to me and has become very judgmental about my opinions. She also finds my sense of humour challenging and, while she always expresses her opinion, however ridiculous it may seem to me, I never question her. The opposite is true whenever I mention my point of view – to the extent that I now don't bother to proffer my opinions. While she says she loves me, she has also said that this could be the beginning of the end for us. I am tempted to call her bluff but I don't want to lose her, despite the fact that I feel she is preventing me from being myself. What should I do? — A OK. Deep breaths. Straight answer coming up. Brace yourself. This relationship is doomed. DOOMED, I tell ye (channelling my inner Private Frazer from Dad's Army). Come on, A. How can you possibly have a lasting, meaningful relationship with someone who refuses to even listen to what you think? Who (judging by your longer letter) metaphorically sticks her fingers in her ears whenever you dare to venture an opinion? Or heckles and interrupts you before you can develop an argument? So much so, that you are increasingly cowed into complete silence. The fact is that at some point, probably sooner rather than later, you're going to meet someone who is prepared to let you express yourself – whether or not they agree with you. You can't spend the rest of your life with someone so inherently rude that they think they have the right to constantly shut you down. It's an extraordinarily imperious, arrogant way to behave, clearly making you increasingly resentful. And it's one step from resentment to anger. You should bale out before you get to that point. So the next time she says that this may be the beginning of the end for you both, tell her you must disagree (again) with her. Because this is not the beginning of the end: it's the end. Then walk away. Come on, A. I know it must be daunting trying to find love as a 68-year-old widower. But you know you can do better than this. You can find more of Richard Madeley's advice here or submit your own dilemma below. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store