Minister criticised after recent deportation flight took off without human rights monitor on board
Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon accused the government of 'skipping independent scrutiny' in favour of 'theatre' by allowing the flight to make its journey without a monitor on board.
These independent human rights observers were on board the government's two previous charter flights, which saw a combined 71 people deported to Georgia.
This was followed by a special charter flight this month where some 35 people, including five children, were deported from Ireland to Nigeria.
The flight was heavily criticised afterwards
by a Dublin school
and
by a Clondalkin community group
as each had members of their community on board.
In response to a Parliamentary Question from Gannon about the makeup of the professional personnel involved in the flight, Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan disclosed that 'due to technical reasons outside the control' of the Department of Justice, the human rights observer was not able to accompany the flight to Lagos.
O'Callaghan defended himself from criticism of the flights, telling Gannon that planning and consideration had been given to 'ensure the safety and wellbeing' of the people being removed from Ireland to Nigeria.
Role of human rights observers
The role of the independent human rights observer is to monitor the use of force and restraints for deportees on the flight.
Such observers are currently not mandatory for charter deportation flights in Ireland. However, there are requirements to have such monitors so as to ensure fundamental rights are upheld during forced returns of people.
These requirements feature in the Optional Protocol to the UN Convention against Torture (OPCAT) but Ireland
remains the only EU member state yet to ratify the protocol
, despite having signed it in 2007. It is included in the current
Programme for Government
.
They had been present at Dublin Airport before the flight took off and later received a debrief from gardaí who were on board the plane, according to O'Callaghan. In addition to Garda personnel, the returnees on the flights were accompanied by a doctor and an advanced paramedic.
The flights are carried out by the Garda National Immigration Bureau.
Advertisement
In his response to Gannon, seen by
The Journal
, O'Callaghan said the independent observer was briefed by gardaí afterwards.
'For the charter flight to Nigeria the observer was present in Dublin Airport to monitor the operation prior to departure of the charter flight on 4 June 2025 and meet with returnees including the families concerned,' O'Callaghan said.
'However, due to technical reasons outside the control of my Department, the observer was not able to accompany the flight to Lagos. The observer has been debriefed by a nominated Garda escort on the operation of the flight.'
Gannon had asked about the number of professionals present on board, including medical staff, child protection professionals and psychological support personnel.
The Dublin Central TD told
The Journal
that the minister needed to clarify whether he believes a human rights observer is 'essential' for the flights. If so, then O'Callaghan needed to outline 'why did he let the Nigeria flight go ahead' without an observer.
He repeated a criticism of the minister's use of the flights as a form of PR and a submission to anti-migrant demonstrations seen over recent years.
'Having the Gardaí who carried out the deportation 'debrief' the observer afterwards isn't oversight, it's theatre,' Gannon said.
'This flight involved children. The State has a legal and moral duty to safeguard their rights at every stage, not just when it's convenient.
Skipping independent scrutiny when children are being forcibly removed strips away any pretence of a rights-based approach. What we're seeing is a government more committed to appearing tough than doing things properly.
Gannon added that the deportation flights will 'go down as a shameful episode' in the life of the current government.
'It may play well in certain corners of the political world, but anyone with a shred of decency can see how wrong this was,' Gannon claimed.
The Fianna Fáil minister said he accepted that deportations were 'challenging' for the people involved. He added that they had received legal orders to leave the State and that the flights were required to ensuring that Ireland's immigration system is 'robust and rules based'.
He noted that any person who has been ordered to leave the State is committing a criminal offence and 'can be arrested without warrant if they come into contact with An Garda Síochána'.
The 2,113 deportation orders signed this year are nearing last year's total of 2,403 orders.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Espionage and ‘destructive ideologies' are among main threats to State, says Garda report
The Garda 's national security service has warned about the 'ever present' threat from foreign spies intent on stealing sensitive political information and intellectual property. In a newly published document, the Security and Intelligence branch also raises concerns about the threat of 'destructive ideologies' and the rise of extremism in Ireland. The force 's Annual Security Services Plan offers a rare, though vaguely worded, insight into what it believes are the main threats facing the State. It comes amid efforts by the Government to revamp the State's clandestine security services in the face of increasing foreign threats. Almost uniquely among western countries, the Garda is responsible for both day-to-day policing and State security. READ MORE It says the Garda's secretive Security and Intelligence Service is responsible for State security. One of its key roles is liaising with overseas secret services, while the role of its operational arm, the Special Detective Unit, is 'identifying, investigating and reporting for prosecution' threats to State security, it says. The report says the service will also be required to carry out threat assessments and security operations relating to Ireland's presidency of the EU next year. According to the report, the main threats to the State are 'terrorism, violent political extremism, espionage, sabotage and subversion'. Ireland is a 'potential target of hostile state actors' that are intent on stealing information on 'intellectual property, as well as policies and political information of the State'. The report does not specify which countries are a threat, although senior security officials have previously raised concerns about espionage activities by Russia, China and Iran. In particular, China is believed to regularly attempt to gain access to the intellectual property of technology and pharmaceutical companies here. A Russian expatriates network accused of acting as an extension of the Kremlin's security services has also been active in Ireland , while there is evidence China has been using a Dublin-based overseas Chinese service centre to coerce its citizens living here . In recent years, the Government has taken steps to reduce the number of Russian intelligence agents in Ireland. It has introduced national security legislation preventing Russia from extending its embassy and has refused to issue visas to multiple incoming diplomats. In a sign of the evolving security landscape, the threat from 'subversion', typically a reference to violent Republican groups, is only alluded to once in the document. However, Ireland is 'not immune' from the threats of terrorism and extremism seen in other EU countries, including 'lone wolf' extremists, the report warns. A stabbing attack on a Defence Forces chaplain in Galway last year by a radicalised teenager has been officially designated as Ireland's first Islamic terrorist attack. Another stabbing attack on a Garda, which is currently before the courts, is also been investigated as potential Islamic-inspired terrorism, while there are also concerns about possible attacks from far-right extremists, sources say. 'The proliferation of destructive ideologies poses a direct threat to the values of democratic society, threatens lives and endangers the freedoms and norms that we have become accustomed to in a secure society,' the report warns. 'Interconnected groupings/individuals displaying extremist and terrorist ideologies present a potential threat to the security of the State and our citizens.' The Government has committed to a ring-fenced budget that will allow the security service to expand recruitment of civilians with specialist skills, it says. In a forward to the plan, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris , who retires at the end of August, says Garda capabilities in the areas of national security, counter-intelligence and counter-terrorism 'will continue to be enhanced and partnerships between national and international partners will be developed, maintained and strengthened'.
Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Brute who attacked female jogger shows Government and Gardaí 'not in control'
A brute who sexually assaulted a woman in the UK before coming to Ireland and attacking a female jogger shows 'the Government and Gardai are simply not in control', it's been claimed. Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín made the stark admission after the Irish Mirror unmasked 'Hoyda Hamad' as a pervert with 27 aliases and 20 convictions earlier this week. The 'non-binary' barber was sentenced on August 6 for kicking the jogger near Fairview Park on the East Wall Road in Dublin on July 26. It then transpired last Wednesday before Cloverhill District Court, the 'genderfluid' deviant had multiple identities and had a rake of offences including theft, burglary and a sexual assault conviction from the UK. This emerged while they were being sentenced for breaching the Sexual Offenders Act. Garda Patrick Watson from Clontarf Garda Station, who gave evidence last Wednesday, said: 'I don't think anybody knows who he is'. Garda Watson said extensive inquiries had taken place at national and international level along with Interpol. He said once his fingerprints were run through the system - 27 aliases popped up. Some of these listed the accused as being from Syria, Libya and Algeria. The court also heard that the Garda National Immigration Bureau had no record of the accused and the accused never sought International Protection - but presented to TUSLA as a minor. Tests later proved he was an adult. Hoyda Hamad being arrested by gardai Speaking yesterday, Mr Tóibín said: 'This particular case makes a mockery of the Criminal Justice System in Ireland. It shows you both that the Criminal Justice System and the immigration system is highly porous. It feeds into the narrative that the Government and the Gardaí are simply not in control of this issue.' The accused will likely be released in the coming weeks but it was said in court, the Gardaí wouldn't even know what country to deport him to. Mr Tóibín stressed he would be raising this particular case with Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan and said the accused needs to be booted out. He continued: 'No one such as this should have been allowed into Ireland and no one such as this should be allowed to remain in Ireland. 'And yet it's quite clear the Government does not have the systems to prevent the entry of such individuals or to remove them. It's quite clear that the Minister for Justice must get on top of this issue. 'I believe it should be the case that people apply for asylum at the ports of entry and I believe there should be an Irish Sea border to make sure we can control the people coming onto the island of Ireland cause we simply can't control the border between the north and south in terms of the movement of people.' Aontu leader Peadar Toibin The TD for Meath West also stressed Ireland has no responsibility to provide refuge to criminals such as Hamad. He explained: 'It is quite incredible and I've seen this before where the Government is simply not using the legal rights that they have to deport people that have committed criminal acts. 'We have absolutely no moral responsibility to provide refuge for anybody who criminally breaks the law. There is a contract here that people who we bring into this country must abide by the laws of this country. 'The immigration system and the criminal justice system are completely incapable of dealing with situations such as this. This case proves that they are porous. This case proves neither are in control of these situations.' The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Mr Tóibín added: 'It's an incredible situation that a person who is a criminal isn't being tracked and isn't identifiable. My worry would be here - we have just one example of an individual who is flouting the law, who is completely immune it seems to the justice system and can act with impunity. 'Anybody who is involved in a criminal act who is not a citizen of this country is removed from this country and anybody who comes into this country with a verifiable criminal conviction should not be allowed into this country. We have a responsibility to help those fleeing war and violence, we have no responsibility to help those who are criminals.' Peadar Toibin (Image: Gareth Chaney Collins) It's understood Hamad came to Ireland where was convicted of a number of offences including burglary in Cork and put behind bars in the Midlands Prison for 11 months in January 2024. The accused was convicted of these offences under the name Youssouf Angelina. After his release from the Midlands, he went on to commit theft in Wexford. In July, the accused was given a three month suspended sentence for this under the name Hoyda Hamad. Following on from this conviction, the accused was then arrested for assaulting a female jogger on the East Wall Road. The sexual assault conviction from the UK and the conviction for breaching the Sex Offenders Act was under the name Youssouf Chergui. A spokesman for the Department of Justice said they don't comment on individual cases. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
The Journal
12 hours ago
- The Journal
Indian community celebrates independence day in Dublin
HUNDREDS OF PEOPLE have participated in an event marking India Day in Dublin, as gardaí and the government sought to assure the community it was taking action against racially motivated crime. The free event at Merrion Square came despite a separate celebration being called off following concern over recent attacks on the Indian community. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has expressed concern over 'totally unacceptable' attacks on the Indian community, adding that the majority appear to have been carried out by young people. O'Callaghan said he engaged extensively with the Garda commissioner on the matter, and senior investigating officers had been assigned to investigate all reported incidents. Sunday's celebration, organised for India's 79th independence day, featured music, dance, food stalls, exhibition stands and a range of cultural activities. Sanjeeb Barik, the secretary of organising group the Federation of Indian Communities in Ireland, said the event had gone well amid 'fantastic and beautiful weather'. 'Lots of people are here, there's food and dancing and lots of fun.' Asked about the engagement with government and gardaí, Barik said the event had received 'good support'. Speaking to the PA news agency, he said: 'Naturally, because there has been so many incidents there was some concern. 'We have been actively discussing with ministers, junior ministers and the Minister of Justice and they have all assured us that appropriate safety measures would be in place – and they are. 'We're working very closely to make sure everyone would be safe and, importantly, that it would be enjoyable for everyone.' Barik said they wanted to go ahead with the celebrations to send a message about the importance of standing together. Advertisement 'It has been a challenging time but the main thing is to come together as a community and celebrate our heritage 'There are people from all backgrounds here – Indian, Irish and others – from all over the the island. 'It is about the strength of bonding and sowing the richness of India and Ireland's multicultural spirit.' He added: 'We are saying come together, stand together. Celebrate unity and diversity – and I hope that will continue.' L-R: Areet Kaur Chandi, seven, Japleen Kaur, 10, and Preety Singh, eight, join People attending the India Day Festival at Merrion Square Park, Dublin. PA / Alamy Stock Photo PA / Alamy Stock Photo / Alamy Stock Photo Inspector Ciaran Nunan from the Garda diversity unit said hate crimes are attacks on the whole community. 'The mission statement of An Garda Siochana is keeping people safe, and this refers to individuals, families, communities and society as a whole. 'It also now includes hate crime. Hate crime is not just an attack on a person, it's an attack on the community. 'An Garda Siochana is very aware of the impact that hate crime has upon individuals and communities, and we take it very, very seriously. 'Since our last India Day celebration last year, we now have hate crime legislation in force and we're applying that legislation at every opportunity – but we need people to report incidents of hate crime to us so that we can then take them on board and react to those.' He added: 'So I would encourage everybody or anybody that perceives to be a victim of a hate crime to please report it to An Garda Síochána, and allow us to continue what we're doing and work with our communities to keep people safe.' The Dublin event was attended by Akhilesh Mishra, ambassador of India to Ireland, and Minister of State Emer Higgins. The Ireland India Council, a separate group, said there had been an organised social media campaign against the Indian community in the country and the number of violent attacks has intensified since January. Last week, it said it took the 'difficult' decision to postpone its planned event at Farmleigh House over concerns for the safety of the community.
