logo
Why this single photo exposes the brutal reality of Sydney's housing crisis

Why this single photo exposes the brutal reality of Sydney's housing crisis

Daily Mail​5 hours ago

A Sydney two-bed apartment that's listed as part of an 'affordable' state government housing scheme is on the market for $1,100 a week.
The two-bedroom two-bathroom apartment on Waverley Crescent in Bondi Junction, comes with income eligibility guidelines, which advocates say proves 'affordable' housing is out of reach for low-income Aussies.
To be eligible to rent the property, applicants must not earn more than a combined income of $121,000 for a couple, $161,500 for three adults, $145,300 for a couple with one child and $169,500 for a couple with two children.
NSW Affordable Housing Ministerial Guidelines states a home is 'usually considered affordable if it costs less than 30 per cent of gross household income'.
However, the Bondi Junction apartment would see a couple spending more than 47 per cent of their income, three adults would pay 35 per cent, while a couple with a child would spend 39 per cent.
The apartment, which has a $4,400 bond, is listed under Affordable Housing Scheme by HomeGround Real Estate Sydney.
NSW government sets out the guidelines for the scheme.
After a report in The Guardian on Tuesday, the listing price dropped to $1,040 a wekk and then to $1,000.
A HomeGround spokeswoman said the price reduction was because of winter fluctuations in the market.
'Initially, we advertised the property with a market rent set at $1100 per week,' they said.
'However, as market conditions fluctuate weekly, especially in the Bondi area, we have adjusted the asking price to $1000 per week as we transition into the winter market.'
They had previously said the below-market price point for the apartment may seem highly because the market rent is high in locations such as Sydney's eastern suburbs.
However, they insisted the listing was 'more affordable' for families.
In NSW, affordable properties must be rented out with a discount of 20 per cent on the market rent, but guidelines state 'flexibility in pricing may be applied to moderate income households'.
However, as a result of rising market rates, this discount still means many low-income families are expected to rent properties that cost more than 30 per cent of their household income.
A spokesperson for Everybody's Home Maiy Azize told Daily Mail Australia: 'Our governments keep spruiking so-called 'affordable housing' schemes, but nothing beats the real thing: social housing.
'We need genuinely low-cost rentals that people can actually afford. Even people receiving an average income in Sydney don't qualify for social housing, yet they're priced out of the private market.
'Families are falling through the cracks and entire communities are suffering. The only real fix is to build more social housing and open it up to more people.'
Managing director of the Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute, Michael Fotheringham said many 'affordable' listings do not live up to the name.
'It's a really loose terminology that different state rules apply across the country, and we have both federal and state government investing in programs to deliver affordable housing,' he added.
'But what 'affordable housing' is, is really unclear.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Scottish Government sets date for end of two-child cap in Scotland
Scottish Government sets date for end of two-child cap in Scotland

South Wales Argus

time17 minutes ago

  • South Wales Argus

Scottish Government sets date for end of two-child cap in Scotland

The Social Justice Secretary said the Westminster policy will be mitigated from March 2 next year – just weeks before the Holyrood election. Shirley-Anne Somerville said the move will lift 20,000 children out of relative poverty, according to Scottish Government estimates. The decision was first announced last year but First Minister John Swinney said his Government needed time to set up a system to mitigate the cap. Scottish Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville announced the date on Tuesday (Jane Barlow/PA) Introduced by the last Conservative UK government, the two-child cap limits benefits in most cases to the first two children born after April 2017. Labour has been reluctant to end the cap, citing economic reasons, but in May the Prime Minister said he will be 'looking at all options' to tackle child poverty, when asked about his intentions on the policy. Ms Somerville said Scotland cannot wait for a decision at Westminster. She said: 'The Scottish Government has consistently called on the UK Government to end the two-child cap. 'Reports suggest that they are looking at the impact it is having. 'But the evidence is clear and families and Scotland can't wait any longer for the UK Government to make up its mind to do the right thing and scrap the cap once and for all. 'The two child limit payment will begin accepting applications in March next year.' She said the policy will begin 15 months after the initial announcement, which she said is the fastest a social security benefit in Scotland has ever been delivered. She added: 'This builds upon the considerable action we have taken in Scotland, including delivering unparalleled financial support through our Scottish child payment, investing to clear school meal debts, and continuing to support almost 10,000 children by mitigating the UK Government's benefit cap as fully as possible. 'However, austerity decisions taken by the UK Government are holding back Scotland's progress. 'Modelling published in March makes clear that if the UK Government act decisively on child poverty, they could help to take an estimated 100,000 children out of poverty this year.' The Scottish Fiscal Commission said the mitigation will cost around £150 million next year, before rising to nearly £200 million by the end of the decade. In March, the Institute for Fiscal Studies warned the policy could harm incentives to work because some of the lowest-paid workers could earn more on welfare than in employment. The move has been welcomed by anti-poverty charities, who have urged the UK Government to scrap the cap, with the Child Poverty Action Group saying the move would lift 350,000 children across the UK out of poverty.

Utilita to pay £277,000 for Warm Home Discount payment failures
Utilita to pay £277,000 for Warm Home Discount payment failures

South Wales Argus

time17 minutes ago

  • South Wales Argus

Utilita to pay £277,000 for Warm Home Discount payment failures

The regulator found Utilita – which supplies 800,000 customers – failed to pass on the mandatory discount to more than 4,000 customers over 2023 to 2024 because of an internal error in processing payments. The Warm Home Discount scheme – which is administered by Ofgem on behalf of the Government – helps eligible energy consumers on low incomes by offering an automatic payment of £150 each year. Ofgem said Utilita had agreed to pay £247,000 of compensation to those affected, who will receive further payments of up to £150 each. ⚠️@utilitaenergy missed the 31.03.24 deadline to make Warm Home Discount payment by 12 days due to internal error. Utilita self-reported this to us last year Affected customers have been contacted, don't need to do anything and will be auto-compensated ➡️ — Ofgem (@ofgem) June 17, 2025 This is in addition to £30,000 of compensation Utilita paid to affected customers shortly after the error was identified. Cathryn Scott, regulatory director of market oversight and enforcement at Ofgem, said: 'The Warm Home Discount is a lifeline for vulnerable energy consumers on low incomes. Even a short delay in making these payments can cause harm to vulnerable customers, so it's vital that suppliers make these payments on time and without hassle. 'Unfortunately, on this occasion, Utilita fell short of our standards by failing to pay some of their customers in a timely manner. Utilita has conducted an audit of their Warm Home Discount processes to make sure this doesn't happen again. 'It's our duty to protect consumers. Today's outcome, as well as the findings set out in our Supplier Performance Report, serve as a reminder to all suppliers that failures to make scheme payments on time are unacceptable, and that we can and will take enforcement action to put things right for customers.'

Utilita to pay £277,000 for Warm Home Discount payment failures
Utilita to pay £277,000 for Warm Home Discount payment failures

Glasgow Times

time17 minutes ago

  • Glasgow Times

Utilita to pay £277,000 for Warm Home Discount payment failures

The regulator found Utilita – which supplies 800,000 customers – failed to pass on the mandatory discount to more than 4,000 customers over 2023 to 2024 because of an internal error in processing payments. The Warm Home Discount scheme – which is administered by Ofgem on behalf of the Government – helps eligible energy consumers on low incomes by offering an automatic payment of £150 each year. Ofgem said Utilita had agreed to pay £247,000 of compensation to those affected, who will receive further payments of up to £150 each. ⚠️@utilitaenergy missed the 31.03.24 deadline to make Warm Home Discount payment by 12 days due to internal error. Utilita self-reported this to us last year Affected customers have been contacted, don't need to do anything and will be auto-compensated ➡️ — Ofgem (@ofgem) June 17, 2025 This is in addition to £30,000 of compensation Utilita paid to affected customers shortly after the error was identified. Cathryn Scott, regulatory director of market oversight and enforcement at Ofgem, said: 'The Warm Home Discount is a lifeline for vulnerable energy consumers on low incomes. Even a short delay in making these payments can cause harm to vulnerable customers, so it's vital that suppliers make these payments on time and without hassle. 'Unfortunately, on this occasion, Utilita fell short of our standards by failing to pay some of their customers in a timely manner. Utilita has conducted an audit of their Warm Home Discount processes to make sure this doesn't happen again. 'It's our duty to protect consumers. Today's outcome, as well as the findings set out in our Supplier Performance Report, serve as a reminder to all suppliers that failures to make scheme payments on time are unacceptable, and that we can and will take enforcement action to put things right for customers.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store