I Asked ChatGPT What Would Happen If Billionaires Paid Taxes at the Same Rate as the Middle Class

Yahoo

05-07-2025

Taxes can get you thinking about fairness. For instance, when I'm calculating deductions on my salary and watching a decent chunk go to Uncle Sam, I can't help but wonder: What if the ultra-wealthy paid the same percentage of their income in taxes that regular people do?
Find Out:
Read Next:
So I decided to ask ChatGPT a simple question: 'What would happen if billionaires paid taxes at the same rate as the middle class?' The AI's response was more nuanced than I expected — and revealed some surprising truths about how our tax system really works.
First, ChatGPT corrected a common misconception I had. Based on actual data from PolitiFact and ProPublica investigations, the 25 wealthiest Americans currently pay an average federal income tax rate of 16% under existing law.
Meanwhile, households earning $50,000-$100,000 (where most teachers, firefighters and other middle-class workers fall) typically pay an effective tax rate between 0% and 15%.
So contrary to what I'd heard, billionaires don't actually pay less than teachers under current tax law. But here's where it gets interesting.
Learn More:
ChatGPT explained that the issue isn't necessarily the tax rates themselves, but how different types of income get taxed. This is where the system becomes genuinely unfair.
'Billionaires benefit from tax strategies that lower their effective tax burden compared to what ordinary income earners face on wages,' the AI explained. 'The current system taxes work more than wealth.'
Here's what that means in practice: When I get my salary, taxes come out immediately. When a billionaire's stock portfolio increases in value by millions, they don't pay taxes on that growth until (or unless) they sell those stocks.
ChatGPT broke down something called the 'buy-borrow-die' strategy that wealthy people use to minimize taxes. It sounds like financial wizardry because, honestly, it kind of is.
Here's how it works: Billionaires borrow money against their stock holdings (which isn't taxed), live off those loans and then pass their assets to heirs largely tax-free when they die. Meanwhile, regular people like me can't defer taxes on our paychecks or borrow against our retirement accounts without major penalties.
The AI used ProPublica data to illustrate this: 'The top 25 billionaires saw their wealth grow by $401 billion from 2014-2018, but paid just $13.6 billion in federal income taxes — an effective rate of 3.4% on wealth growth.'
That 3.4% figure is what really stung. While they're paying their legal tax obligations on realized income, their actual wealth is growing at a rate that's taxed far below what middle-class workers pay on their salaries.
ChatGPT ran the numbers on what would happen if billionaires paid taxes at the same rate middle-class families do — around 15%-22%.
Using the ProPublica data, if those top 25 billionaires had been taxed at a 20% rate on their wealth growth, they would have paid around $80 billion instead of $13.6 billion.
'Extrapolate that across approximately 1,000 billionaires?' the AI asked. 'You're talking hundreds of billions in added revenue annually.'
The AI outlined several ways this massive revenue increase could transform government services:
Healthcare: We could expand Medicare and Medicaid, potentially moving toward universal coverage.
Education: Fund universal pre-K or make community college free for everyone.
Infrastructure and climate: Invest seriously in clean energy projects and fix our crumbling roads and bridges.
Debt reduction: Actually pay down the national debt instead of adding to it every year.
ChatGPT noted that this extra revenue could 'stabilize the economy by boosting the spending power of everyday Americans.' Basically, reducing inequality in a way that helps everyone, not just those at the bottom.
The most eye-opening part was learning that the problem isn't necessarily that billionaires are breaking the law or even paying lower rates on their taxable income. The issue is that our entire tax system is designed around taxing work rather than wealth.
'Middle-class families can't defer taxes on wages or borrow against stocks tax-free,' ChatGPT pointed out. This creates a fundamental unfairness where people who work for their money get taxed immediately, while people whose money grows through investments can delay or even avoid those taxes entirely.
After diving into ChatGPT's analysis, I realized the conversation about billionaire taxes is more complicated than simple rate comparisons. Under current law, wealthy Americans do pay their required taxes. But the system allows their wealth to grow in ways that are largely untaxed, while regular workers pay taxes on every dollar they earn.
The AI concluded that if we could successfully tax billionaires more like middle-class workers, the results would mean hundreds of billions in additional revenue annually and potentially better funding for health, education and climate programs. What's more, it could have the power to reduce inequality and improve public trust in the tax system.
Maybe the real question isn't whether billionaires should pay more taxes, but whether our entire approach to taxing work versus wealth makes sense in an economy where most billionaires' fortunes come from asset appreciation rather than traditional income.
As ChatGPT put it: 'The U.S. could significantly reshape its fiscal and social landscape' — if we can figure out how to make it work in practice.
More From GOBankingRates
Mark Cuban Warns of 'Red Rural Recession' -- 4 States That Could Get Hit Hard
9 Downsizing Tips for the Middle Class To Save on Monthly Expenses
10 Genius Things Warren Buffett Says To Do With Your Money
This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: I Asked ChatGPT What Would Happen If Billionaires Paid Taxes at the Same Rate as the Middle Class