Ditching payment systems a right: cafe owner
Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Scott Simpson announced this week the government planned to ban some surcharges for in-store payments by May next year.
"Shoppers will no longer be penalised for their choice of payment method, whether that's tapping, swiping or using their phone's digital wallet."
The ban would cover most in-store payments made using Visa and Mastercard, including contactless and eftpos, but not online payments, foreign-issued cards, travel cards or cards issued by other networks.
The Swan and Commons Eatery owner Dane Wall believed a lot of businesses would end up increasing their prices.
Both his businesses had surcharges, but at a rate where it did not make or lose him any money, and he was "not super salty" about a ban going ahead.
"I think it's great that the government are actively trying to free up money in the back pockets of everybody."
Consumers still had the choice as to whether they paid using credit card and PayWave, and the impact on them would depend on how often they dined out, Mr Wall said.
"I think if anyone is really concerned about how much this is going to cost their business, they are well within their right to disable PayWave and disable credit card payments.
"That's not uncommon in a lot of small businesses in New Zealand."
The Perc Central, Exchange and Plaza co-owner Sarah Hussey said they had never placed surcharges on credit card and contactless payments, but had for the past two years charged an extra 15% on public holidays due to "skyrocketing" wage and food costs.
"We did look into it, and we thought it's just not worth it because people are quite against it.
Surcharges annoyed more customers than what it was worth, Mrs Hussey said.
"I honestly think that people stop going places because people have the surcharge on there.
"The last thing you want is losing your customers at the moment."
She believed a lot of vendors were charging consumers more than what the transaction services were costing them.
"I was somewhere ... where they were charging 2.5% — and if they are paying 2.5% for their merchant facilities then they are paying too much.
"I often think that people are capitalising on it."
The Commerce Commission earlier this month issued a decision to reduce the interchange fees paid by New Zealand businesses to accept Visa and Mastercard payments.
This would reduce the estimated $1 billion annual cost to businesses by about $90 million per annum — saving the average small business about $500 each year in fees.
New Zealand consumers paid up to $150m in surcharges every year, including "excessive surcharges" of up to $65m, Mr Simpson said.
Surcharges were "a hassle and an unwelcome surprise when shoppers get to the till".
"That pesky note or sticker on the payment machine will become a thing of the past.
"We're banning surcharges so consumers can shop with confidence knowing how much they will pay for their purchases."
tim.scott@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
9 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Hawke's Bay retailers could suffer after ban on card surcharges
'They are going through a rough enough time as it is,' she said. 'The PayWave options are a really quick and easy option for us to go and pay for something, but that might be taken away, because why would the business owner want to pay for that when they can't on-charge? 'We are going to go backwards. 'They will remove the flexibility and the convenience of us just using our phones and going 'ding'.' Pip Thompson on Napier's Emerson St. Photo / Gary Hamilton-Irvine She said, alternatively, business owners would be forced to up prices to absorb the cost. There is no merchant service fee for Eftpos payments, such as when you insert your card. Thompson questioned why banks weren't doing more to support local businesses with reducing the merchant service fee (for which the surcharge covers). 'I think we have cut the pie only in half, and they need to sort the other side of the pie out, so to speak, and go to the banks and say how are you going to help this process?' Banks say they do not receive any benefit from surcharges, and the merchant service fee is required - part of which goes to Visa and Mastercard. 'New Zealand is unique globally in that our domestic card payments network [Eftpos], which is used for Eftpos cards and debit cards when they are inserted, is free for merchants, even though there is a cost to run this network,' an ANZ spokeswoman said. 'However, as in other jurisdictions, there are fees for accepting other means of payment including PayWave, credit and international cards. 'ANZ recovers its costs of providing our customers with payment facilities through a merchant service fee.' She said the average merchant service fee was 1% of a transaction. A merchant service fee is made up of 'scheme fees' and 'interchange fees', as well as some other costs. The 'scheme fees' portion goes to either Visa or Mastercard (dependent on the card used), and the 'interchange fees' portion goes to the bank to cover costs such as fraud prevention, handling disputes, and authorising transactions. The merchant service fee is initially paid to a 'payment acquirer' which can either be a bank or another provider like Windcave. 'Banks don't set or require surcharges - they are added by retailers/merchants at the point of sale,' a BNZ spokesman said. 'If it's more than what they're charged in fees, they keep the difference. Not the bank, not the acquirer, and not the card company.' What local businesses think Vinci's Pizza in Napier owner Vincent Michaelsen said he was supportive of the surcharge ban. 'We do PayWave and we don't do surcharges,' he said. 'I don't think there is necessarily a right or wrong [on whether you do surcharges or not]. 'But my perspective, from a customer angle, is that I just want to make it easy.' He said he felt that was the best decision for his business. 'I think as a business operator, you need to know your costs and make sure that it is covered in the back end.' However, he said the best solution would be tackling the problem from both ends - with no surcharge and also no merchant service fee for businesses. Cool Toys in Napier owner Glen Chan said he expected most retailers would have to build the extra cost into their pricing, after the surcharge ban. 'It tallies up. It really mounts up,' he said, of covering the merchant service fees. He said he offers contactless payments with a surcharge currently, and a problem with potentially removing PayWave as an option in future was that customers liked and were used to it. Adore Collection in Napier co-owner Sally Holyer said they did not charge a surcharge on contactless card payments. 'Yes it costs [us] but we find, especially when it is really busy in the summer in the cruise season, it speeds things up so much that is actually worth us doing.' Gary Hamilton-Irvine is a Hawke's Bay-based reporter who covers a range of news topics including business, councils, breaking news and cyclone recovery. He formerly worked at News Corp Australia.
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Surcharge ban a win for consumers but will it save them money?
But will it ultimately save shoppers money? This is the question, after the Government revealed its proposed surcharge ban this week. The Retail Payment System (Ban on Surcharges) Amendment Bill is expected to be introduced by the year's end, and the change made by May. The proposed ban follows the Commerce Commission's decision to reduce bank interchange fees that businesses pay to accept credit card payments. This change is expected to save businesses about $90 million a year. Surcharges at the till allow businesses to recoup additional costs associated with providing certain payment methods, such as credit cards and contactless. New Zealanders are paying up to $150m in surcharges every year. The Government says this includes excessive surcharges of up to $65m. Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Scott Simpson describes them as 'a hassle and an unwelcome surprise' for shoppers at the till, and says consumers will be able to 'shop with confidence knowing how much they will pay for their purchases'. The Commerce Commission will oversee enforcement. Consumers will be entitled to a refund if a business applies a surcharge. Consumer NZ welcomes the change, describing it as 'a no-brainer'. Retail NZ chief executive Carolyn Young is pleased changes are being made but warns that retailers will continue to face costs to accept debit and credit card payments and 'these costs will likely be added to product prices in future'. Hospitality New Zealand agrees, saying the move could result in higher prices because margins are tight. There was strong criticism from Dairy and Business Owners Group chair Ankit Bansal, who argues the proposed changes unfairly target small retailers instead of fixing the real problem – the banks. 'The reality is that large retailers enjoy significantly lower banking fees, while small businesses – with no power to negotiate – are left paying inflated rates.' The Government deserves praise for tackling the wider issue of costs associated with people using certain credit cards and contactless cards in shops. The reduction in interchange fees will help businesses. The surcharge ban will be positive for consumers and mean a more transparent process. But it's a fair bet that most businesses, especially those under pressure, will be unable to absorb any extra cost. Some consumers may well ultimately end up paying higher product prices at the till to compensate. Sign up to the Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
NZ Herald
3 days ago
- NZ Herald
Listen to The Country online: Christopher Luxon talks PayWave surcharges and netball
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon spoke to Hamish McKay on The Country today. Photo / Mark Mitchell Today on The Country radio show, host Hamish McKay catches up with Prime Minister Christopher Luxon for a yarn about farmer confidence and PayWave surcharges. He also discusses being booed at the ANZ Premiership netball final on Sunday. On with the show: Christopher Luxon: We ask the Prime Minister about
