
Tesla's sales and shares are slumping. Are Elon's antics to blame?
Tesla has emerged from the latest European car registration numbers looking like a mangled wreck at the side of the road.
Across the continent, the EV maker's sales slumped by 45 per cent in January, according to the European Automobile Manufacturers' Association (ACEA). This begs the question: could the politics of Elon Musk, CEO and chainsaw-wielding head of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), be hitting the bottom line?
Well… it's complicated.
For a start, Tesla's popular model Y has undergone a redesign, which is the sort of thing that inevitably hits sales: people who buy pricey new cars usually want the most up-to-date model sitting on their driveway, so would be prepared to buy later.
This delay has clearly had an impact. Tesla has also faced increased competition from other makers that produce smart, attractive EVs at what can be more competitive prices.
'Tesla's car sales fell year-on-year for the first time in more than a decade in 2024 and the early 2025 numbers from key markets like California and the EU look worse still,' said Russ Mould, from broker AJ Bell. "Whether this is down to wider slowdown in EV sales, stiff competition from BYD and other Chinese rivals or a buyers' strike because of Mr Musk's high-profile politics is hard to divine.'
It's quite possible, even probable, that they're all playing a role.
When I asked Fleet Alliance, a fleet management company which looks after more than 30,000 vehicles for business customers, whether they had seen an impact, the company said Tesla remained 'at the top of our order bank'. The Model 3 topped its sales charts in 2024, with the Model Y in second place for the second year in a row.
However, business customers may be less sensitive to brands and the eccentric activities of CEOs so long as the product and the terms offered to them remain good. That's the case with Tesla.
'Both models offer benefits in terms of low monthly rentals and BIK (Benefits In Kind) rates which really appeal to our customers,' said CEO Andy Bruce, by way of explanation.
But individual buyers may take a different view.
'It's no surprise that a brand so closely tied to its founder and main visionary is affected by the actions and ideas of its leader, for better or worse. The relationship between a brand and an associated celebrity has always been a double-edged sword,' said Gabor Schreier, chief creative officer at branding and design agency Saffron Brand Consultants
'In the automotive industry, facing massive transformation, global uncertainty, and intense competition, a brand like Tesla is particularly exposed.
'It's striking to see how quickly Tesla's customer base is reacting. Electric mobility is not yet for everyone, and people buying Tesla's may be more closely aligned with ideas that don't necessarily reflect what is dominating international headlines. A costly product like Tesla depends on audiences willing to invest in it, and those buyers often want to identify with the product, whether as a status symbol or a statement for progressive thinking.'
So far, it's worth noting that the UK sales have declined by much less than in Europe. The Society of Motor Manufacturers here, which contributes to the ACEA figures, found sales in January fell by just 7.8 per cent. It seems that Musk's UK fans are more solid than their European peers.
But Shreier's point makes a lot of sense. Tesla has clearly benefited from its powerful brand and been seen as a status symbol among EV drivers, in the same way as marque brands like Mercedes or Audi have been seen by petrol engine drivers in years past.
Whether it still retains that is now open to question. Musk's deliberate seeking out of controversy, his provocations and his public statements stand in stark contrast to the way other big ticket CEOs of America's mega-cap tech businesses behave.
It's not that the likes of Apple's Tim Cook, Alphabet (Google) boss Sundar Pichai, Meta's Mark Zuckerberg or Amazon founder Jeff Bezos don't have opinions. They do. And they aren't shy about making them known.
Zuckerberg went so far as to appear on Joe Rogan's podcast, talking of the need for the company to have more 'masculine energy'.
However, as a rule, tech bosses' views tend to be closely aligned to the interests of their businesses, and they are far more cautious and strategic in the way they voice them than Musk.
Zuckerberg's statements, accompanied by the elimination of some safeguards over what had been perceived by some as 'hate speech', might have been cringeworthy. But they clearly had an aim in mind.
President Trump and his supporters have been highly critical about what they see as censorship of conservative views and voices on social media. Zuckerberg's musings and his business moves were clearly aimed at heading off any possible blowback and cosying up to the White House. It isn't the first time Zuckerberg has said something cringey. But he is much less inclined to shoot from the hip, as Musk does.
Wall Street will now be watching. Tesla's shares went on a tear following Trump's election as investors got excited about Musk's status as the US president's BFF. But recently they've been surrendering those gains, losing nearly a quarter of their value over the past month.
The sales data only exacerbated that.
'The harsh reality is that 2024's operational results were terrible as net profits more than halved,' said Mould. However, the shares still sit on a fancy valuation which those results do not justify.
'Tesla needs to generate some rapid growth and some earnings forecast upgrades, and quickly – something which its many supporters will say it has done before, more than once,' he added.
This is true. But it's tough to pull off repeatedly even with a fully engaged CEO who doesn't prance around with a chainsaw at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) with the aim of 'owning the libs '.
Tesla investors pay Musk billions for what looks like a part-time job. There are a lot of fanboys among them who worship the ground he walks on. But they may find their ardour cooling if their shares continue to act like an EV with a flat battery.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Spectator
19 minutes ago
- Spectator
Portrait of the week: Spending review, LA protests and Greta Thunberg deported
Home Yvette Cooper, the Home Secretary, was the last minister to agree funding in the government spending review. Once the NHS and defence were settled there wasn't enough to go round. The police wanted more. Everyone over the state pension age in England and Wales with an income of £35,000 or less will receive the winter fuel payment after all, at a cost of £1.25 billion, Rachel Reeves, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, announced. Capital spending included £39 billion on social housing over the next ten years. The government also committed £14.2 billion for the new Sizewell C nuclear power station, but did not say where the money was coming from. Rolls-Royce was selected as the preferred bidder to build the country's first small modular reactors. Unemployment rose to 4.6 per cent, its highest level since 2021, up from 4.5 per cent. Any child in England whose parents receive Universal Credit will be eligible for free school meals from September 2026, adding 500,000 to the scheme. Teachers in England can use artificial intelligence to mark homework, under government guidance. The NHS said that a blood shortage required an increase of donors from 800,000 to a million. David Lammy, the Foreign Secretary, announced sanctions against two Israeli ministers over comments which 'incited extremist violence', banning them from entering Britain. Zia Yusuf resigned as the chairman of Reform UK. He had criticised Sarah Pochin, the party's new MP, for urging Sir Keir Starmer to back a burqa ban, saying: 'I do think it's dumb for a party to ask the PM if they would do something the party itself wouldn't do.' Two days later he returned to the party in a role with the so-called Doge UK team, seeking savings in council spending. Labour won the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election for the Scottish parliament with 8,559 votes, ahead of the SNP's 7,957 and Reform's 7,088. There was rioting in Ballymena after an alleged sexual assault by two teenage Romanian-speaking boys. An audit commissioned by the secretary general of Unite found that there had been a 'pervasive fraud environment' in the union, which spent £112 million on building a hotel in Birmingham, losing £53.8 million. Last week Unite members voted to continue the dustmen's strike in Birmingham, which began on 11 March. Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, agreed with US warnings against a new Chinese embassy at the former Royal Mint site on Tower Hill, fearing espionage. Marks and Spencer began taking online orders for home delivery again, six weeks after a cyber attack. Peter Easterby, the only racehorse trainer to have sent out more than 1,000 winners both over jumps and on the flat, died aged 95. Novelist Frederick Forsyth died aged 86. Abroad About 2,000 National Guard troops were deployed in Los Angeles by the federal government, against the wishes of Governor Gavin Newsom of California, to confront violent protests against the migrant deportation policy of President Donald Trump. A curfew was imposed and 700 Marines and 2,000 more National Guard were sent in. Mr Trump said he was 'disappointed' that Elon Musk had called his 'big, beautiful' budget bill a 'disgusting abomination'; Mr Musk complained of the President's 'ingratitude', declaring: 'Without me, Trump would have lost the election.' He then tweeted: 'Time to drop the really big bomb: Donald Trump is in the Epstein files.' He later deleted it. Mr Trump signed a proclamation banning entry for people from 12 countries: Afghanistan, Myanmar, Chad, Republic of the Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Haiti, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and Yemen; a partial ban extended to Burundi, Cuba, Laos, Sierra Leone, Togo, Turkmenistan and Venezuela. Russia launched an attack with cruise missiles and hundreds of drones on Kyiv and other places in Ukraine; the next night Karkhiv was the target; on another night Kyiv and Odessa. Russia and Ukraine exchanged sick and badly wounded prisoners of war, those aged under 25, and bodies of 12,000 soldiers. Russia's mercenary group Wagner announced it was withdrawing from Mali after four years. A 75ft statue of Lenin in Osh, Kyrgyzstan, was quietly taken down. Eleven were killed in a shooting at a secondary school in the city of Graz in Austria, including the suspect. A yacht carrying Greta Thunberg and 11 others trying to bring aid to Gaza was towed to the port of Ashdod, after being seized by Israel, and she was put on a plane to Paris. CSH


Spectator
30 minutes ago
- Spectator
The Sizewell delusion
The Chancellor's promise of £14 billion for the Sizewell C nuclear power station in Suffolk is hardly news. The project has been talked about for 15 years while the existing UK nuclear estate has gradually been shut down and the only other new station, Hinkley Point in Somerset, has stumbled to a decade-long delay and £28 billion of budget overruns. Quite some optimism – verging on Milibandian delusion – is required to embrace the idea that Sizewell will come quicker and cheaper because it will replicate Hinkley Point while avoiding its mistakes. And since Chinese money has been ruled out, it's still a mystery as to who else will pay for the project beside HMG and the French utility company EDF. Unarguably, we need a constant baseload of nuclear power to stop the lights going out in mid-century: commitment to Sizewell can't be all wrong, despite local objections. But what's intriguing about this week's news is that it coincides with the naming of Rolls-Royce as 'preferred bidder' to deliver the UK's first small modular reactors, in theory much easier to bring to fruition. If SMRs can really deliver nuclear power one town at a time by the mid-2030s, as planned, Hinkley Point and unfinished Sizewell will begin to look like dinosaurs. The simple truth is that both should have been done and dusted a generation ago. But nuclear decision-ducking has been a shame on successive governments for as long as most of us can remember. Defensive stocks My recent suggestion of a 'Rearmament Isa' that would incentivise savers to buy shares in UK manufacturers of military kit brought a positive response from one former defence minister but not from the current Chancellor who, let's face it, may not be among my most devoted readers. Nevertheless, I'm hoping the idea might feature in an Isa overhaul this autumn, because last week's £68 billion defence review wish-list of everything from ammo factories to autonomous weaponry was a reminder of how vital it is to sustain an innovative, well-capitalised, British-owned defence industry, rather than one that is picked off piece by piece by US and other foreign predators. And it's fair to say that the review's call for 'warfighting readiness' makes the sector a strong bet for investors anyway, with or without Isa tax benefits. Blue-chip defence stocks have already soared since the beginning of the year – BAE Systems up 68 per cent, Rolls-Royce 55 per cent – but may pause as the market discovers how much of the wish list the government actually commits to buying and to what extent UK firms are impeded (as President Emmanuel Macron of France has signalled) from supplying EU rearmament demand. In the meantime, smart stock-pickers will hunt for defence-related businesses that have yet to catch the upswing. Naturally on this theme I consult this column's veteran investor Robin Andrews, who suggests taking a look at 'engineering and electronics companies that are vital in the supply chain and whose customers are major defence companies and in some cases governments directly'. Here's his promising half-dozen: Melrose Industries in aerospace; Hunting in precision engineering; Filtronic, already a hot stock in telecom systems; and in various aspects of IT, Concurrent Technologies, EnSilica and the curiously named Raspberry Pi. As ever, we urge you to do your own research. City stampede Here we go again: three more tech companies abandoning London. Spectris, a listed precision instrument maker that descends from the Fairey seaplane company and might have featured in our roll call of defence-adjacent stocks above, is selling itself to the US private equity giant Advent for £3.7 billion. Alphawave, an Anglo-Canadian designer of 'high-speed connectivity solutions' that listed in London in 2021, has fallen to US microchip maker Qualcomm for £1.8 billion. Both deals are at huge premiums over the companies' last quoted share prices, reflecting the pattern of chronic undervaluation that has driven the decline of the London Stock Exchange and provoked a stampede of takeovers. Third to go this week is Wise, a money-transfer fintech founded in London by Estonian emigrés and now worth £11 billion, but moving its primary listing to New York. Time and again we're told City authorities, Treasury ministers and the Exchange itself are urgently pursuing reforms to make London's capital markets slicker and sexier; but so far, as the exodus accelerates, to no effect whatever. Top shopkeeper Last week, to some readers' irritation, I applauded a €100 million bonus for Michael O'Leary in his 31st year as the presiding genius of Ryanair. So if I'm in favour of high pay for high performance, logic might dictate that I should also favour the £7 million award to Stuart Machin for his third year's work as chief executive of Marks & Spencer. But I'm not so sure. The high street chain has certainly revived under Machin's leadership: profits are up, stores look fresher, the food offer outpaces rivals and the shares have risen 150 per cent since he took the helm in May 2022. And he's clearly not to blame for the cyber-attack that crippled M&S's website and cost the business £300 million. But nor is he a creator of the M&S brand: he's a hired hand (having previously worked for Sainsbury's, Tesco, Asda and in Australia) whose efforts have been closely mentored by his powerful chairman, Archie Norman. In that case, is it really fair to pay him 140 times the average store manager's salary? Then again, I hear you mutter, what's fairness got to do with it if £7 million is the going rate for global boardroom talent? Maybe, but it's a big number for running a shop and it puts Machin in a merciless media spotlight. Having said which, I'll pop out to buy my M&S picnic lunch.


Scottish Sun
32 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Over 27 MILLION Brits receive huge mobile upgrade for free as Vodafone and Three announce raft of changes for customers
Newly-merged network reveals the future for five brands that rely on their 5G UP TO SPEED Over 27 MILLION Brits receive huge mobile upgrade for free as Vodafone and Three announce raft of changes for customers MILLIONS of Vodafone and Three customers are set for a huge boost to their mobile signal as the newly-merged mega network reveals its £11billion grand plans. A major improvement to services will start for more than seven million users of Three and its budget sub-brand SMARTY in just two weeks time. 2 The £16.5billion tie-up makes VodafoneThree the UK's biggest mobile network Credit: Alamy 2 Both brands will continue to co-exist - but there are some changes coming Credit: PA Customers will receive a 20 per cent average speed uplift on 4G. And within a few months, 27million mobile subscribers across both Vodafone and Three will benefit from better signal with shared access across both networks at no extra cost, the new joint VodafoneThree firm claims. This will eradicate dreaded "not spots" from 16,500 sq/km of the country – the equivalent to 10x the size of London. VodafoneThree has confirmed that its various brands will remain separate. This not only includes Vodafone and Three, but also VOXI, SMARTY and Talkmobile which piggyback on their network kit. However, Vodafone will be the only brand for business customers. "A new era of connectivity has begun," said Max Taylor, CEO of VodafoneThree. "We will connect every nation, every community, in every corner of the UK. "We will build the UK's best 5G network with an unprecedented £11bn privately funded infrastructure project, laying the digital foundation for our country's growth ambitions." The network is pledging to bring 99.95 per cent of the population 5G Standalone - the fastest version of 5G speed around - by 2034. Brits will always have mobile phone & internet signal at home after tech breakthrough that beats Elon Musk's Starlink And by this time next year, bosses are planning to launch trials of space-based satellite mobile network coverage too to eliminate even more "not spots". Chancellor Rachel Reeves said: "I'm delighted that this huge investment is being made in mobile phone network infrastructure, better connecting people with families, loved ones and work by providing stronger, more widespread 5G coverage." BROADBAND SHAKE-UP Changes are afoot for broadband services too. Three's brand will disappear from its mobile broadband over the next 12 months and brought together with Vodafone's Full Fibre, all under the Vodafone name. The firm has announced a new partnership with Community Fibre on top of existing deals with CityFibre and Openreach. Two extra customer care centres are opening in Belfast and Sheffield as well, bringing 400 jobs back to the UK. Vodafone and Three both operate their own stores across the country but the company says it has "no planned retail redundancies". The £16.5billion tie-up makes VodafoneThree the UK's biggest mobile network.