2 outgoing justices say Constitution must be abided by as prerequisite for democracy
Constitutional Court of Korea Justices Moon Hyung-bae and Lee Mi-son said the South Korea's Constitution and any ruling by the court must be abided by, as the order of the sovereign people, because otherwise social instability will ensue, as Friday marked the end of their six-year terms as justices on the bench, two weeks after the same court removed disgraced former President Yoon Suk Yeol from office in a unanimous 8-0 ruling.
In a farewell speech, Moon, who served as the acting chief justice of the Constitutional Court, said, "(the Constitutional Court's) decisions must be respected."
He highlighted the Constitutional Court's role in resolving deadlock, or disputes over authority, between the executive and legislative branches through making "factual and valid decisions," followed by respect for such rulings from these branches as institutions established under the Constitution.
The process of how the Constitution is interpreted, developed and implemented based on checks and balances shall be further strengthened through respect for the Constitutional Court's decisions, Moon said.
Outgoing Justice Lee said in her speech that state institutions must abide by the Constitution, which is the order of the people as the sovereigns of the country and serves as a prerequisite for the existence of a free democratic nation.
'If state institutions do not abide by the Constitution and ignore it, the order that supports our society is shaken," she said in her farewell speech.
Their historic decision on April 4 upheld the parliament's motion to impeach Yoon for violating law and democratic principles in leading a self-coup by declaring martial law Dec. 3.
Before the landmark 8-0 decision, the Constitutional Court had constantly been under attack by Yoon's legal team and the ruling People Power Party, who claimed "political bias" and demanded Moon be recused from Yoon's impeachment trial.
Moon said in his farewell speech that while academic debates and criticism can of course be permitted, any ad hominem arguments attacking the justices personally cannot be tolerated.
Moving forward, Justice Kim Hyung-du will serve as the acting chief justice, taking Moon's place.
Moon and Lee were both nominated by liberal former President Moon Jae-in in 2019 and served six-year terms.
The two outgoing justices' posts will remain vacant for the time being, at least until South Korea's new president takes office after the June 3 election.
The Constitutional Court on Wednesday suspended in a unanimous 9-0 ruling the effect of conservative acting President Han Duck-soo's nomination of two Constitutional Court justice candidates to replace Moon and Lee.
The suspension will last until the court delivers a final ruling in the future over attorney Kim Jung-hwan's filing of an injunction challenging the legality of Han's nomination of two right-leaning figures -- Minister of Government Legislation Lee Wan-kyu and senior judge Ham Sang-hoon.
The court found Wednesday that it cannot assume that an acting president may exercise the authority to independently nominate justices, given that he is not an elected leader.
In South Korea, the nine-member bench of the Constitutional Court consists of three judges appointed by the president, three recommended by the chief justice of the Supreme Court and three selected by the National Assembly, under the principle of the tripartite separation of powers. They each serve a six-year term.
Wednesday's court ruling suggested that the court will rule that the country's president is the only eligible person to appoint replacements for Moon and Lee. The current front-runner in the presidential race slated for June 3 is Rep. Lee Jae-myung, former chair of the Democratic Party of Korea.
Wednesday's verdict stated that the seven-member bench could hear and decide the case, but that in cases where the direction of the case might change depending on the opinions of the remaining two justices, hearings and the decision could wait until the two justice are appointed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Korea Herald
4 hours ago
- Korea Herald
Will S. Korea see 'civilian' defense minister?
One of President Lee Jae-myung's key campaign pledges made during his latest run was to appoint a 'civilian' defense minister, referring to a nominee with zero to brief military experience. His pledge came as several high-ranking military officials, including former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun, are currently on criminal trial on charges of conspiring in insurrection and of abuse of official authority tied to impeached President Yoon Suk Yeol's failed Dec. 3 martial law bid. The position is currently filled by acting Defense Minister and Vice Defense Minister Kim Seon-ho, who took on the role following Kim Yong-hyun's resignation after the martial law bid in early December. Lee kicked off the appointment of members of the presidential office and the Cabinet last week, and all eyes are on who will become the next defense minister amid growing security concerns on the Korean Peninsula. North Korea's advancing nuclear weapons program, coupled with reports of the Trump administration's potential troop cut of the 28,500-strong US Forces Korea, has fueled the worries. In South Korea, the position of defense minister has usually been held by a retired four-star Army general or Navy admiral. Of all 50 defense ministers so far, only five held the position without military experience. On top of it, most defense ministers were nominated while in active duty or almost immediately after announcing retirement. Though the moves managed to uphold Article 87 of the Constitution of Republic of Korea, which states that 'No member of the military shall be appointed a member of the State Council unless he (or) she is retired from active duty,' it has been criticized for building a tradition that led to lack of reform within the military. If Lee appoints a 'civilian' nominee, it would mark the first time such a person takes office since May 1961, after former Defense Minister Hyeon Suk-ho, who had no military experience at all, stepped down. Sources close to the matter said that Lee is considering the five-term lawmaker and ruling Democratic Party of Korea Rep. Ahn Gyu-back as a strong candidate for defense minister. Ahn is a former chair of the National Assembly's defense committee and a close aide of Lee. He also led the parliamentary committee probing into Yoon's martial law bid. Though Ahn has completed his two-year mandatory military service from 1983 to 1985, he has no professional military background. Meanwhile, the US law mandates a cooling-off period of seven years between active-duty service and appointment to the Secretary of Defense, aiming to ensure civilian control over the military.
Korea Herald
4 hours ago
- Korea Herald
Who is Lee Jae-myung's pick for prime minister, Kim Min-seok?
Rep. Kim Min-seok, who was considered President Lee Jae-myung's "wingman" when they were in the Democratic Party of Korea leadership, has been nominated as his prime minister. As prime minister, Kim would steer Lee's Cabinet and serve as a key adviser. The position requires the National Assembly's confirmation. From as early as August 2024, Kim began raising alarms about former President Yoon Suk Yeol preparing to impose martial law. Kim had argued with conviction that Yoon was not only thinking about martial law, but taking concrete steps to go through with it. Kim was met by skepticism even within the Democratic Party, where a sizeable majority felt that the party was "taking things too far" with the martial law claims. Democratic Party lawmakers were seen distancing themselves from Kim's claims. When Yoon declared martial law on the night of Dec. 3, 2024, Kim's early warnings were revisited. Face of 'new pro-Lee' group Rep. Kim Min-seok, a former star politician who made a stunning return to the spotlight under Lee's Democratic Party, has been at the center of the new pro-Lee Jae-myung group. When Kim ran for a seat on the Democratic Party's supreme council last August, it soon became apparent that he was Lee's preferred choice to serve in the party's top decision-making body, a coveted and prestigious spot. Youngest lawmaker of his time to be elected Kim, the youngest in the batch of lawmakers elected in the 1996 general election, stepped into the limelight as soon as he entered politics. As a young politician, Kim served as chief secretary to former President Kim Dae-jung, when he was the leader of the Democratic Party. Jailed for occupying US-owned building in Seoul Kim was one of some 70 university students to occupy the US Cultural Center near the US Embassy in Seoul in May 1985 in an unarmed protest. Recalling the protest, Kim said in an interview with a local broadcaster in Gwangju on Oct. 12, 2024, that he was one of the first to raise suspicions that the US might have been behind the "massacre in Gwangju." Kim was referring to the series of pro-democracy protests in May 1980 in Gwangju against the then-government under Chun Doo-hwan, a military dictator. In the interview, Kim said that when he was the president of the student council at Seoul National University, he called for "uncovering the truths about the possible US intervention in the Gwangju massacre." "I said something on that scale (in Gwangju) would not have been possible without acquiescence from the US. That's what the US Cultural Center incident is about," Kim said. "It marked the first instance of getting what happened in Gwangju a recognition outside Korea." Kim served two years and eight months in jail for violating the laws on public demonstrations at the time. arin@
Korea Herald
4 hours ago
- Korea Herald
Lee signals major stimulus to revive growth, fight inflation
Second supplementary budget expected to exceed W20tr, with focus on AI, industrial upgrades Korean President Lee Jae-myung ordered immediate measures to curb rising food prices on Monday, signaling his administration's intent to roll out fiscal stimulus to revive growth and fulfill his campaign pledge of raising the country's potential GDP growth to 3 percent. 'The people are suffering greatly because of rising prices,' Lee said while presiding over a meeting of his emergency economic task force in Yongsan, Seoul. 'I've heard prices have gone up significantly. Is it true that a single packet of ramyeon now costs 2,000 won ($1.50)?' Less than a week into his term, the newly inaugurated president faces the twin challenges of easing cost-of-living pressures and stimulating an economy mired in weak domestic demand. While headline inflation fell to 1.9 percent in May, its lowest in five months, thanks to declining global oil prices, food costs remain elevated. Prices for processed foods, including staples such as bread, chocolate, ramyeon, coffee and frozen food, jumped 4.1 percent from a month earlier, according to Statistics Korea. Vice Finance Minister Kim Beom-seok warned that prices for eggs and chicken could spike 'if we don't respond properly," due to an outbreak of highly pathogenic bird flu in Brazil, a key exporter of boneless chicken to Korea. Analysts say food companies held off on price hikes earlier this year in cooperation with the previous government, but began raising prices en masse during the political vacuum triggered by former President Yoon Suk Yeol's impeachment. Lee's emergency task force, established via executive order on his first day in office, June 4, held its second meeting Monday, bringing together economic aides; key ministers from the economy, industry and infrastructure portfolios; and officials from the Financial Services Commission. It was expected that the size of the second extra budget would be revealed at the meeting, but the government deferred the announcement. To achieve the administration's 3 percent potential GDP growth target, above the OECD's 2.02 percent forecast for 2025 and the Bank of Korea's 2 percent range for 2024-2026, the government is expected to rely on two main pillars: a second supplementary budget, and major investments in emerging industries such as artificial intelligence, paired with structural reforms to enhance industrial competitiveness. The ruling Democratic Party of Korea signaled the additional budget will total between 20 and 21 trillion won, following the 13.8 trillion won supplementary budget passed in May to support disaster recovery and bolster industries affected by US tariff tensions. 'Amid an unprecedented domestic demand slump, small business owners and the self-employed are on the brink of collapse,' said Democratic Party spokesperson Rep. Jo Seoung-lae. 'We urge the opposition to actively cooperate in the prompt passage of the supplementary budget to protect the people's livelihoods.' Investor sentiment appears to be shifting. Global banks are revising their growth outlooks for Korea upward from previously pessimistic projections. Barclays recently raised its 2025 GDP forecast from 0.9 percent to 1.0 percent, citing the likelihood of expansionary fiscal policy regardless of political leadership. Goldman Sachs increased its projection from 0.7 percent to 1.1 percent, estimating that a second supplementary budget equal to 1 percent of GDP could lift this year's growth by 0.3 percentage points. Citigroup economist Kim Jin-wook expects the upcoming stimulus package, estimated to be between 20 trillion and 35 trillion won, to boost total Korean Treasury Bond issuance for 2025 to between 227.1 trillion and 242.1 trillion won, significantly above the 2020–2024 average of 169.5 trillion won. 'Given the limited room for excess tax revenue and public funds, the second extra budget will likely be financed mostly through additional net treasury bond issuance,' Kim said.
