WHO warns unchanged FED on cigarettes may boost consumption
ISLAMABAD: World Health Organization (WHO) has expressed serious concern that the Federal Cabinet decision to keep Federal Excise Duty (FED) rates on cigarettes unchanged in budget (2025-26) would increase cigarette consumption in Pakistan.
According to a report of the WHO on post-budget analysis and review issued on Wednesday, since February 2023, the Federal Excise Duty (FED) rates on cigarettes have remained unchanged. The Cabinet has maintained these rates in the proposed budget for FY 2025–26.
With inflation rising by 26% over this period, the real value of FED rates and cigarette prices has declined, and this trend is expected to continue in the absence of any adjustment.
For FY 2024–25, WHO has estimated cigarette production at approximately 37 billion sticks, an increase compared to the previous fiscal year—and projected FED revenue at Rs. 208 billion.
Given the decision to keep FED rates unchanged for FY 2025–26, nominal cigarette prices are likely to remain flat, implying a further decline in real prices. This will likely result in increased cigarette consumption. Based on a simple simulation model, cigarette production (and consumption) is projected to reach around 38 billion sticks, generating Rs 217.6 billion in FED revenue in FY 2025–26.
Alternatively, a policy intervention involving a Rs 39 per pack increase in FED could reduce cigarette consumption by an estimated 10.7%, bringing production down to around 34 billion sticks. This policy would also boost FED revenues by 20.9% compared to the current plan, resulting in higher fiscal and public health gains.
Notably, the government has set a revised FED revenue target of only Rs. 147 billion from cigarettes in FY 2024–25—a surprisingly conservative figure, considering actual collections reached Rs 157 billion during the first nine months of the fiscal year. We estimate that total FED revenue for FY 2024–25 will reach approximately Rs. 208.2 billion, nearly Rs. 60 billion more than collected in the first three quarters.
Estimated cigarette FED collection in FY 2024/25. Based on PBS's data, the average annual growth rate of cigarettes production from July 2024 to April 2025 is 12.4% higher when compared to July 2023/April 24. By assuming the same annual growth rate for the next two months, the estimated production of cigarettes for 2024-25 will be around 37 billion sticks.
By applying the above market shares and FED and GST rates, it is important to note that the estimated FED revenue collection for 2024-25 is 208.2 billion Rs. This is much higher than 147.8 billion Rs of the government's revised target for 2024-25.
The total indirect tax collection from cigarettes (FED+GST) in 2024-25 will be around Rs 275.7 billion. To protect both public health and government revenue, Pakistan's tobacco tax policy should be reassessed and strengthened. This includes regular adjustments to the Federal Excise Duty (FED) rates and stricter oversight of industry practices, such as production front loading ahead of the budget and manipulation of brand mixes. However, the current budget proposal for cigarette FED rates does not incorporate these tax policy corrections needed to meet revenue and health objectives.
With this decision, the government and FBR hope to control cigarette illicit manufacturing and smuggling. To address those challenges, however, proper tax administration measures should be implemented, such as effective controls of the distribution movements of tobacco leaves, used cigarette machinery and other key cigarette inputs inside the national territory, WHO added.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Dollar down against euro, sterling
NEW YORK: The dollar hit a three-and-a-half-year low against the euro and sterling on Thursday in a broad selloff as traders priced in the likelihood that the Federal Reserve will cut rates more than previously expected. 'This week it's definitely been about the Fed, the prospect of easing sooner and potentially more rate cuts,' said Eric Theoret, FX strategist at Scotiabank in Toronto. Fed Chair Jerome Powell was interpreted as being more dovish this week in testimony to US Congress, saying that, if it were not for expectations for higher inflation as a result of the Trump administration's tariffs, the US central bank would have likely continued to cut interest rates. He nonetheless maintained that the Fed should stand pat as it anticipates an increase in price pressures this summer. US President Donald Trump will nominate a new Fed Chair next year who is expected to be more dovish than Powell, whose term will end in May. Trump on Wednesday called Powell 'terrible' and said he has three or four people in mind as contenders for the top Fed job. The Wall Street Journal reported on Wednesday that Trump has toyed with the idea of selecting and announcing Powell's replacement by September or October. Analysts say that person could operate as a shadow Fed chair, undermining Powell's influence. Fed policymakers Christopher Waller and Michelle Bowman have also both said in the past week that the Fed should cut rates soon, as inflation continues to ease and due to rising concerns about a weakening labor market. Data on Thursday showed that the number of Americans filing new applications for jobless benefits fell last week, though continuing claims rose to the highest level since November 2021. Fed funds futures traders are pricing in 65 basis points of cuts by year-end, up from 46 basis points on Friday, with the first cut expected in September. The euro was last up 0.39% at $1.1705 and reached $1.1744, the highest since September 2021. Sterling rose 0.45% at $1.3728 and got as high as $1.3764, its highest since October 2021. The Swiss franc hit a 10-1/2-year high at 0.80 per dollar. The dollar fell 0.61% to 144.38 Japanese yen. Falling interest rates would reduce the interest rate advantage of the dollar versus peers. It also comes as investors worry that tariffs will slow US growth. The Trump administration has set a July 9 deadline to negotiate deals that avoid reciprocal tariffs with trading partners. The dollar is also under pressure as international investors reallocate away from US assets on concerns about the outlook for the economy and the US currency. In cryptocurrencies, bitcoin fell 0.65% to $107,144.
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
The smokescreen over Pakistan's cigarette taxes: a case for urgent fiscal scrutiny
As Pakistan continues to navigate persistent fiscal challenges, the recent budget documents for FY 2025-26, presented this month, contain an astonishing anomaly that demands immediate attention. It concerns the Federal Excise Duty (FED) on cigarettes – a seemingly mundane line item that, upon closer inspection, reveals a perplexing discrepancy between official production figures and actual tax collection, hinting at either profound systemic failure or, more troublingly, a strategic manipulation of numbers. Let's dissect the figures that raise eyebrows for any economist, or indeed, any discerning citizen. For the fiscal year 2023-24, the FBR successfully collected PKR 237.1 billion from cigarette FED. Building on this, the FBR initially set an ambitious target of PKR 323.7 billion for the current fiscal year, FY 2024-25, which concludes on June 30th. This optimism seemed plausible, especially considering data from the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS), which reported a robust 13.1 percent growth in cigarette production during July-March of FY 2024-25 compared to the previous year. However, the revised estimates in the FY 2025–26 budget documents present a stark and perplexing contrast. The FBR now anticipates collecting a mere PKR 147 billion for the entire FY 2024-25. This isn't just a shortfall; it's a colossal 54.6% reduction from their own initial target, and a staggering 38% less than what was collected last year, despite reported production growth. A closer look at the data deepens the concern. The first six months of FY 2024-25 saw a FED collection of PKR 102.895 billion from 17,627 million sticks, indicating an effective tax rate of PKR 5.837 per stick. This rate implies that around 93 percent of the market comprises economy brands, and 7 percent premium — a plausible split. When we extend this calculation using PBS's reported production for the next three months (Jan-Mar 2025) — 8,746 million sticks — it projects an additional PKR 51.1 billion in revenue. Adding these figures, the estimated FED collection for the first nine months (July-March 2025) stands at approximately PKR 153.95 billion. Here is the crux of the conundrum: This PKR 153.95 billion, reflecting nine months of estimated revenue based on official production, already exceeds the FBR's own revised full-year estimate of PKR 147 billion. For the FBR's revised estimate to hold true, it would imply that for the entire April-June 2025 quarter, the government expects not just zero, but a statistically impossible negative collection of nearly PKR 7 billion. Alternatively, to meet the PKR 147 billion revised estimate, and given the first six months' collection, the FBR must assume virtually no premium brand production in the January-March quarter (as the numbers align perfectly with only the minimum tax rate), and absolutely zero cigarette production and zero tax collection in the final three months of the fiscal year. Such a scenario is economically untenable. So, what explains this extraordinary discrepancy? The plausible explanations are deeply concerning for Pakistan's fiscal health: Firstly, this could be a deliberate attempt to under-report revenue to build a narrative for lowering tax rates. The argument, often peddled by the industry, is that high taxes fuel illicit trade, and therefore, lower taxes are needed to bring the market into the formal net. However, if PBS's reported production is indeed growing, the problem isn't just illicit trade; it's that legal, declared production isn't translating into tax revenue. This points to a massive, systemic leakage within the formal tax net, potentially through widespread under-declaration or other evasive tactics post-production. Lowering tax rates in such a scenario would simply legitimize current tax avoidance, short-changing the national exchequer. Secondly, even if not deliberate manipulation, it signals a profound and alarming disconnect between declared economic activity and the FBR's ability to collect taxes. It suggests that a significant volume of legally produced cigarettes is somehow escaping the tax system, whether through a broken track-and-trace mechanism, ineffective enforcement, or fundamental flaws in revenue assessment. The fact that the FBR's own internal projections are so far off from what simple arithmetic of reported production suggests, is a damning indictment of forecasting and collection capabilities. The implications for Pakistan are severe. At least PKR 50 billion in lost tax revenue from a segment known for its high consumption directly translates into less funding for critical public services and poverty alleviation programs. It erodes public trust in the integrity of our financial data and sets a dangerous precedent for other sectors. As Pakistan embarks on a new fiscal year, this issue must not be dismissed as a mere accounting error. It is a matter of transparency, accountability, and the credibility of the nation's tax system. Moreover, the stakes extend beyond fiscal integrity – cigarette taxation is also a critical public health tool. Weak enforcement and revenue leakage not only deprive the state of much-needed funds but also undermine efforts to curb tobacco consumption, which remains a leading cause of preventable illness and death in Pakistan. A thorough, independent investigation is essential, along with urgent reforms to restore integrity to the taxation of one of the country's most heavily consumed and harmful products. Without decisive action, the smokescreen surrounding cigarette taxation will continue to obscure a harsh reality: Pakistan is haemorrhaging billions in revenue, and its citizens deserve to know why. (The writer is Principal Economist, SPDC) Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Punjab PA approves Rs5,335bn budget
LAHORE: The Punjab Assembly on Thursday approved a tax-free budget of Rs 5,335 billion for the fiscal year 2025-26, maintaining the current tax structure without imposing any new taxes. The Finance Bill 2025-26 was also passed, ensuring no changes in provincial taxes, property tax, or transport tax, with no additional levies on industries, agriculture, health, or education sectors. During the session, the House approved 41 demands for grants worth Rs4,306.9792 billion, while rejecting eight cut motions presented by the opposition. The newly passed budget and finance bill will take effect from July 1, 2025. Key allocations in the budget includes; Rs120 billion for construction of roads and bridges, Rs462 billion for pensions, Rs258 billion for healthcare facilities, Rs137 billion for education reforms, Rs200 billion for police to maintain law and order, Rs27 billion for jail administration, Rs1 billion for civil defence, Rs26 billion for farmers welfare, Rs66 billion for agricultural loans, Rs18.22 billion for industrial development and Rs37.96 billion for irrigation projects. Moreover, the assembly approved Rs910 billion for various development projects, Rs161 billion for government buildings, Rs26.5 billion for agriculture, Rs19 billion for veterinary services and Rs1.6 billion for fisheries. Grants for registration, stamps, motor vehicle acts, and excise were also approved. Four significant bills were presented by Mian Mujtaba Shujaur Rehman which include Punjab Autism School and Resource Centre Bill 2025, Urban Immovable Property Tax (Amendment) Bill 2025, Essential Commodities Price Control (Amendment) Bill 2025 and Punjab Labour Courts Bill 2025 These bills were referred to relevant standing committees, with the Speaker seeking reports within two months. During the session, government member Saeed Akbar Nawani raised objections over duplicate serial numbers (35 and 41) in the demands for grants, suggesting they should be merged for clarity. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Mian Mujtaba Shujaur Rehman responded that the practice was longstanding but assured a review to determine if a technical merger was feasible. The Punjab Assembly session was commenced under the chairmanship of Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan after a delay of 4 hours and 6 minutes. The proceedings began with heated exchanges over a point of order, as government member Munawar Ghous lashed out at the alleged illegal actions of the Counter-Cybercrime Department (CCD). Ghous claimed that a former councillor from his constituency was unlawfully arrested by a CCD DSP, handcuffed, paraded in public, and humiliated. He further alleged that the officer slapped the detainee, recorded videos, and encouraged bystanders to film the incident, saying, 'Look at him and make videos.' Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan termed the act unconstitutional and illegal, stating, 'If a video was indeed made, it violates both the law and a High Court order.' He directed the Provincial Minister for Parliamentary Affairs to investigate the matter, calling it a 'bad practice.' In response, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Mujtaba Shujaur Rehman assured the assembly that he would look into the issue immediately. The Speaker also emphasized the need for the government to disarm the public, stating, 'I will consider this government successful only when it retrieves weapons from people's hands.' He expressed concern over personal vendettas leading to entire villages living in fear, urging the minister to take the matter to the cabinet. 'Armed civilians spread terror, and murders are occurring in broad daylight,' he added. Minister Shujaur Rehman responded that Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz was already working on a campaign to eliminate weapons from society and eradicate such a culture. He recalled that the cabinet had previously discussed reopening arms licences in Punjab. Meanwhile, Speaker Punjab Assembly Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan read the ruling regarding his decision on June 16th incident in which the Speaker suspend opposition member Hassan Malik for his misconduct during the budget session. The Speaker stated that opposition members attempted to disrupt the budget speech, with Hassan Malik allegedly throwing the budget book at the Finance Minister. 'After reviewing the video footage, it became clear that this behaviour was repeated, forcing the Finance Minister to halt his speech,' the Speaker said. While acknowledging that protest is a constitutional right, he emphasized, 'I will not allow the assembly to be taken over. I have the authority to suspend members for misconduct. Attempts to obstruct House proceedings will not be tolerated.' The Speaker warned that strict action would be taken against any member trying to disrupt the assembly's functioning. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
