logo
Greenpeace hails Italy court ruling allowing climate lawsuit against energy company ENI to go ahead

Greenpeace hails Italy court ruling allowing climate lawsuit against energy company ENI to go ahead

Independent3 days ago
Italy's highest court has ruled that a lawsuit brought by climate activists against Italian energy company ENI and its government shareholders can go ahead, in what Greenpeace said on Tuesday was a victory for efforts to pursue climate justice in Italy.
In an ordinance released on Monday, the Court of Cassation rejected ENI's motions to dismiss the lawsuit on jurisdictional grounds and ordered the case to be heard on its merits by a Rome tribunal.
ENI, for its part, said that it was greatly satisfied with the decision, and it expected that the Rome court would ultimately 'dismantle' the climate activists' claims of responsibility.
Greenpeace, environmental group ReCommon and a dozen Italian citizens had sued ENI and its two main government shareholders, the Italian finance ministry and development bank, in 2023 seeking damages for what they said were the effects of climate change.
The plaintiffs cited their fundamental rights enshrined in the European Convention of Human Rights, as well as Italy's ratification of various international climate accords and ENI's stated commitment to reaching climate reduction targets.
ENI and the government sought to dismiss the suit on jurisdictional and other grounds, but the Cassation court ruled that the case could go ahead.
For more than a century, scientists have known that large quantities of greenhouse gases, released from the burning of fossil fuels, go up into the atmosphere and heat the planet, leading to higher temperatures, rising sea levels and extreme weather events that are both more frequent and more intense.
Around the world in recent years, individuals, climate activist groups and local governments have sued energy companies and governments to try to force them to take concrete action to curb greenhouse gas emissions and compensate for losses associated with climate change.
Greenpeace and ReCommon called the ruling historic, saying it would impact current and future climate-related litigation in Italy. They say it brings Italian courts in line with other European countries that have recognized the rights of people to try to hold fossil fuel companies accountable for global warming through lawsuits, and called the ruling itself one of the most significant in climate change litigation internationally.
'No one, not even a colossus like ENI, can escape its responsibilities anymore,' the two groups said in a statement. 'Judges will finally be able to examine the merits of our case: those who pollute and contribute to the climate crisis must answer for their actions.'
ENI said that it welcomed the ruling.
'The proceedings can finally resume before the Court of Rome, where the unfounded theories put forward by Greenpeace and ReCommon regarding the alleged responsibility of Eni for climate change-related damages will be dismantled, in a context that is rigorous and respectful of the law, rather than driven by the instrumental, unfounded, and often misleading slogans of the two associations,' ENI said in a statement.
While the ruling doesn't enter into the merits of the case, Greenpeace and Recommon highlighted the judges' determination that Italian courts can have jurisdiction over claims about emissions by ENI subsidiaries in foreign countries, since in this case, harm allegedly occurred in Italy and decisions were made by the Italy-based parent company.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Eoin Hayes readmitted to Social Democrats after eight-month suspension
Eoin Hayes readmitted to Social Democrats after eight-month suspension

BreakingNews.ie

time25 minutes ago

  • BreakingNews.ie

Eoin Hayes readmitted to Social Democrats after eight-month suspension

Eoin Hayes has been readmitted to the Social Democrats after an eight-month suspension over incorrect statements about shares he held in a company linked to the Israeli military. Mr Hayes said he should have not held the shares as long as he did and has donated the equivalent of €43,443 to three aid organisations working in Gaza. Advertisement He said the amount reflected the increase in the value of the shares he held over the course of Israel's military offensive in Gaza. The Social Democrats won 11 seats in November's election but Mr Hayes was indefinitely suspended from the parliamentary party in December – just a month after being elected. He had initially told the media and his party colleagues that he divested shares in his former employer, Palantir Technologies, prior to being elected to Dublin City Council last June. The company supplies technology to Israel's military. Advertisement But he later revealed that he sold the shares last July – after taking office – for a pre-tax figure of €199,000. The Social Democrats had been calling for economic sanctions against Israel months before Mr Hayes' election to the council. The Dublin Bay South TD's suspension was reviewed by the national executive of the party before being considered further by the parliamentary party. Just after 6:30pm on Friday, the Social Democrats said his suspension had been lifted. Advertisement It said in a statement the decision was made by acting leader Cian O'Callaghan in line with the party's constitution. 'Eoin has been suspended from the parliamentary party for nearly eight months and I believe he should be given a second chance,' Mr O'Callaghan said. 'Eoin has a lot to offer as a Social Democrats TD and I look forward to working with him.' Mr Hayes said: 'At the outset, I want to give a full and unequivocal apology for giving the incorrect information to the media about when I divested from Palantir. Advertisement 'I also want to be clear that I should not have held the shares for as long as I did. Ireland Committee urges Government to include services in... Read More 'For that reason, I have donated 51,000 dollars to three humanitarian organisations active in Gaza – split between UNRWA, Unicef and Doctors without Borders. 'This figure represents the uplift in share price, less applicable taxes, from October 7th 2023 to July 26th, 2024, when I sold the shares. 'I know I have let people down and I am determined to work hard and earn back people's trust.' Advertisement

Turnberry turned into ‘American prison' for Trump's arrival
Turnberry turned into ‘American prison' for Trump's arrival

Telegraph

time25 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Turnberry turned into ‘American prison' for Trump's arrival

Turnberry resort has been transformed into an 'American prison', complete with high fencing and 'sniper towers', for Donald Trump's visit. The US president touched down in Scotland on Friday evening for a few days of golf at his resort in Ayrshire ahead of a trip to Aberdeen next week. Campaign groups have vowed to welcome Mr Trump with a 'festival of resistance', aiming to make their voice heard on issues from climate change to the plight of Palestinians. Gavin Scott, an independent councillor for Girvan and South Carrick, said police had gone above and beyond to deter potential disruption. He told The Telegraph: 'A local resident likened the high fencing and sniper tower surrounding the golf course to an American prison, finding the view quite disturbing and intimidating with a large armed police presence.' Trump Turnberry has become a lightning rod for protest groups targeting the president this year. Palestine Action daubed the resort's white buildings in red paint in March and Greenpeace created a sand portrait of Mr Trump on the beach by the course beside a message reading: 'Time to fight the billionaire takeover'. Earlier this week, protesters sabotaged a sign at Mr Trump's golf course in Aberdeenshire with a placard that claimed the luxury resort was 'twinned with Epstein Island'. The stunt was staged by the political campaign group Everyone Hates Elon as the US president faces renewed scrutiny over his past links to Jeffrey Epstein, the financier and sex offender who died in 2024. On Monday, White House communications director Stephen Cheung said Trump once kicked Epstein out of his club for being a 'creep' and called allegations about him 'recycled, old fake news'. Mr Trump's visit to the UK will include hosting Sir Keir Starmer for dinner before travelling to the 'oil capital of Europe' Aberdeen for 'lunches' and opening the new golf course at his resort at Menie. Mr Trump told reporters at the White House that 'Turnberry is rated the number one golf course in the world'. 'I'm going to see it for the first time in years,' he said, adding: 'It's the best resort in the world, I think. It's one of the greatest courses.' Mr Scott said there had been murmurs of discontent around the villages over 'who's footing the bill' for the extra security. 'To ask Police Scotland or our own government to pay for an already undermanned police force is quite ridiculous and grossly unfair,' he said. Cllr Alec Clark, deputy leader of South Ayrshire Council, said there would always be 'associated costs for any world leaders visit'. 'This is a democracy and people are entitled to make their feelings known,' he told The Telegraph. Emma Bond, Asst Chief Constable, encouraged protest groups to discuss their plans with police. She said: 'As you can imagine, it is a large-scale, complex operation, but actually that's something that Police Scotland is immensely experienced at doing.' The policing plan involves local, national and specialist officers from Police Scotland as well as other forces. She said: 'The key very much is to make sure the president of the United States can come, enjoy a peaceful and safe visit to Scotland and ensure Police Scotland is able to maintain delivery of services to the rest of the community within Scotland over the period of his visit.' Despite the protests, Mr Scott said most residents were supportive of Mr Trump. 'The feeling on the ground here in Girvan and surrounding villages is mainly of excitement and quite happy about President Trump's visit,' he said, pointing out that Mr Trump had refurbished the hotel and tended to the world famous course. 'Something tells me he is using his round to help persuade the R&A to return 'The Open' to Turnberry, we all wish him well on that one, what an achievement that would be!' The Ailsa course at Turnberry, sporting views of the granite craig in the Firth of Clyde and across to the Isle of Arran and the Mull of Kintyre, has hosted the Open championship four times. The course last hosted the British golf tournament in 2009 and Mr Trump is thought to be eyeing up one of the next free slots from 2028 onwards. 'No friend of Scotland' Campaign groups will gather by the William Wallace Statue at Union Terrace in Aberdeen, as well as outside the US consulate in Edinburgh on Saturday. Speaking ahead of the protests, Alena Ivanova, a campaigner with the Stop Trump Coalition said: 'Donald Trump may shake hands with our leaders, but he's no friend of Scotland. 'We, the people of Scotland, see the damage he has done – to democracy and working people in the US, to the global efforts to tackle the climate crisis, to the very principles of justice and humanity.' She added: 'As he dreams of rivieras built on the bones of Palestinians, we demand an end to the genocide. 'Trump is not welcome because he represents all that Scottish people reject.' Liz Murray, head of Scottish campaigns at Global Justice Now who are a part of the Stop Trump Coalition added: 'Trump is bullying his way around the world, slapping tariffs on countries, or threatening to – and that includes us here. 'He's using these threats to impose the interests of his oligarch friends on us – and in particular the Big Tech barons who have his ear – when actually governments should be taxing them and reining in their power. 'It's vital that both Keir Starmer and John Swinney stand up to him – because if they give him an inch on this or anything else he'll take a mile.'

Sir Keir must make the most of Trump's visit
Sir Keir must make the most of Trump's visit

Telegraph

time25 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Sir Keir must make the most of Trump's visit

Donald Trump arrives in Britain this weekend on what is ostensibly a five-day private trip to his two Scottish golfing establishments. The President will be met by ritual protests, but in fact this visit is a golden opportunity for the United Kingdom. The Irish knew how to make a fuss of Joe Biden. Whatever the British may privately think of Donald Trump, we need his goodwill. The Prime Minister should make the most of the President's Scottish heritage and his fondness for all things Caledonian. Mr Trump's links to Scotland are rather closer than those of Mr Biden to Ireland. On Monday Sir Keir Starmer will be meeting Mr Trump for talks and lunch at one of his golf clubs, Turnberry, and later accompanying him to the other presidential course at Menie. Sir Keir will be hoping to steer the conversation on to trade: he needs to persuade the President to strike a deal on steel and to exempt UK pharmaceuticals from a threatened 200 per cent tariff. The PM may also seek to discover first-hand whether Mr Trump really has turned against Vladimir Putin's Russia and will now stay the course with Ukraine. These are legitimate matters for a British PM to raise with an American president. Mr Trump, however, is no ordinary Potus: he is quite likely to offer his opinion about issues here that have caught his attention, such as migration or free speech. He may also give Sir Keir a piece of his mind about Emmanuel Macron's gesture politics on Palestine, or indeed anything under the sun. If something like this happens, the Prime Minister will just have to grin and bear it. Sir Keir must play a long game.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store