Melbourne Uni professor sacked over ‘mawkish' romantic messages wins his job back
'It is our very own private conversation ... and yes, we have the pleasure of getting a glimpse of this together and it is really beautiful reawakening. We share this on a deep intuitive level,' he wrote to the woman.
He described their communication as an 'expedition into uncharted territory', saying it was exciting 'more than gambling is', and that a FaceTime with her was a 'moment of bliss'.
Matthai sent her a photo of himself in his boxer shorts, saying it was to demonstrate he had an ectomorph body type, to which she responded: 'Can I love you German professor?' He replied: 'You do not need my permission, do you?'
He later revealed to an external investigator he'd sent the photo because he had been feeling 'unworthy and abandoned' and needed some 'positive feedback'. Matthai added that the student had sought to strip during a FaceTime conversation, but he stopped her.
Matthai wrote to the student, saying they'd both been missing so much in their lives.
'We are like the dry soil soaking up the autumn rain after a long hot summer. It is very beautiful and caresses our souls, but it should not give you pain. You know that I am barely coping with the separation from [omitted],' he said.
'We are like the dry soil soaking up the autumn rain after a long hot summer. It is very beautiful and caresses our souls, but it should not give you pain. You know that I am barely coping with the separation from [omitted],' he said.
Colman said Matthai should have ensured all his interactions with the student remained work-related, 'scrupulously avoiding any word or gesture that could have been suggestive of intimacy'.
Loading
'Matthai put his own emotional needs before those of [the student]. And he continued to use mawkish, romantic language and to discuss intimate topics. This was highly inappropriate.'
Matthai argued that during this time, he was struggling with a difficult break-up, which impacted his judgment. He said he tried to manage the student's expectations after realising she had developed feelings for him.
Colman said he did so 'ineptly', especially to a student with English as a second language.
On July 3, 2017, Matthai was called into a meeting with the department head, who said the student had made a complaint about him and asked to change her supervisor.
Matthai said he was not provided details of the complaint, but agreed to the swap.
In 2018, the student told the university's HR department that Matthai did not have appropriate boundaries and that some of his comments made her feel uncomfortable, but she did not want to make a formal complaint as she was worried it could jeopardise her PhD.
Years later, in January 2024, the student made a formal complaint about Matthai to HR. Among other things, she alleged Matthai had 'sexually and mentally abused her' for 14 months.
The university hired an external investigator, who analysed 141 texts and emails, which included declarations of love by the student for Matthai.
Sexual harassment was not part of the investigation, and Matthai denied any abuse.
The investigator found Matthai breached the university's workplace behaviour policy by communicating in an intimate, unprofessional, personal and inappropriate way.
Matthai told the university he had not been romantically interested in the student but did not want to hurt her feelings. Any suggestion he was pursuing a relationship with her was 'simply wrong', he said.
He also argued that communication with the student was out of work hours, but Colman said that didn't matter.
'He agreed that he had acted unprofessionally and said his judgment had been adversely affected by his emotional state at the time,' Colman said.
Loading
In December 2024, Matthai lost his job without notice. The university's external investigator said his termination was constituted by the 'severity of the conduct, the significant power imbalance' and the fact that Matthai had 'engaged in wilful and deliberate contraventions of the AWB policy, which he had explicitly acknowledged'.
But in a decision by the Fair Work Commission this month, Colman said Matthai should get his job back.
Colman said Matthai's behaviour in 2017 would have been a valid reason for dismissal due to breach of his contract; however, the complaint was not made until 2024, and Matthai had been the one to provide the investigation with the messages between him and the student.
Colman said Matthai was effectively given seven years to prove to the university that his misconduct was isolated. He also said he was confident the behaviour would not reoccur.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
2 hours ago
- West Australian
Locals say dramatic rescue effort to retrieve Carolina Wilga's bogged van took more than four days
Wheatbelt residents have revealed it took more than four days to manage to retrieve German backpacker Carolina Wilga's van from the remote area in which it was trapped. The 26-year-old German backpacker miraculously survived 11 nights alone in the remote Wheatbelt bush after crashing her car, hitting her head and wandering off in a state of confusion. She survived by drinking rainwater from puddles and sleeping in a cave before she was spotted by local farmer Tania French near Beacon. Bonnie Rock farmer Andrew Sprigg said he rallied a group of locals together after learning the Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions had been called in to retrieve the van. He said the vehicle was removed by a 20t loader which ploughed through the dense bushland last weekend. 'I heard the DBCA were in charge with the recovery and I knew their resources would be stretched, so I contacted (a mate) in Merredin and we got approval to run a loader out there to clear the track,' he told The West Australian. 'We thought we could do it with an old 4WD but (the bush) was too thick. 'There's no track . . . the police damaged their vehicles extensively getting down the track as it was.' Mr Sprigg said it took four days to retrieve the van, and said it was being stored in a local shed for one of Ms Wilga's friends to collect. Fellow farmer Kim Graham helped with the retrieval and said he was happy to lend a hand, given his extensive knowledge of the land. 'At the end of the day you've got someone from the other side of the world that needs a hand, and it's not the most easiest terrain for the authorities to get to,' he told 6PR on Thursday. 'I suppose being locals, we've got a bit of an idea (about the area) . . . for us guys to be able to help out, it's the least we can do, that's what the community does.' '(We knew) it was going to be tough terrain to retrieve, and probably going to cost more than it's even worth for the authorities to do it, and for us guys to be help out ... that's what the community does.' He said the van was in 'pretty good condition' with some 'minor dents and scratches.' Mr Graham said he was part of the initial search effort to find Ms Wilga and said it was a miracle she was found alive. 'We put our plane up and we had guys on the ground looking around with utes and motorbikes,' he said. 'At the end of the day she's got a story to tell, she may not have made it (because) it was -4C here one morning, (it was) pretty tough conditions, so she's very, very lucky. 'I think it's probably a good lesson if we're to take the positives out of it, and that's to make sure that we're covered with our safety whether it's (taking) EPIRBs or satellites if we're going off grid.' Mr Sprigg urged travellers to educate themselves on WA's harsh climate before venturing into the outback. 'My cousin hires campervans out and he has a lot of issues with European backpackers, they follow Google Maps and it leads them into all sorts of strange places,' he said. 'I think there needs to be better planning and better safety and awareness.' Ms Wilga spent four nights recovering in Fiona Stanley Hospital before being discharged on July 16. She returned her family's home town, Castrop-Rauxe, on July 20.
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
Next move in German backpacker saga
Weeks after a lost German backpacker was rescued from the remote Western Australian outback, her abandoned van has been recovered by local farmers. Carolina Wilga had seemingly vanished after she left the tiny township of Beacon, about 300km northeast of Perth, in her black and silver Mitsubishi camper van on June 29. Her van was located almost 150km from Beacon, bogged in a thick patch of isolated scrub on the Karroun Hill reserve, and Ms Wilga herself was rescued a short time later. Several weeks later, a group of determined locals have recovered Ms Wilga's abandoned vehicle. Ms Wilga was found 'ravaged by mosquitoes' and severely disoriented according to WA Police. 7News Credit: Channel 7 A video posted to the community-run Wheatbelt Way Facebook page documents the Sprigg family's efforts to remove the vehicle from the bush. 'Thank you to the Sprigg family for retrieving missing backpacker Carolina Wilga's van,' the post said. 'The community spirit in the Wheatbelt Way is unmatched.' Fred Sprigg, a member of the family who recovered the camper van, posted a comment on the video describing the recovery effort as an 'expensive exercise'. 'Was a community effort. Don't like leaving rubbish in the bush,' he said. It is understood the recovery operation took three days to complete, and Ms Wilga's friends in WA are expected to collect the vehicle so it can be returned to its owners. Ms Wilga's van had remained stranded in the bush since her rescue. 7 NEWS Credit: Channel 7 Ms Wilga was missing for 12 days, with her disappearance sparking an enormous search effort and capturing national attention. After almost two weeks of searching, the 26-year-old was found walking along the road about 24km away from her van by local Tania Henley, who described it as a 'miracle'. In a statement after her rescue, Ms Wilga explained she had got lost after losing control of her van and getting a knock to her head that left her confused. She said: 'First and foremost, I want to express a huge thank you from the bottom of my heart - a thank you that truly comes from the depths of my soul!' Ms Wilga was transported to Perth for treatment before returning to Germany.
Perth Now
20 hours ago
- Perth Now
Fed-up locals retrieve German backpacker's abandoned van
Locals in WA's Wheatbelt region have taken matters into their own hands and retrieved the van abandoned by German backpacker Carolina Wilga after she went missing for 12 days in remote bushland. The now-famous traveller survived almost two weeks alone after her van became stuck in soft sand and she abandoned it, wandering off to try and get help. She was miraculously found by Wheatbelt resident Tania French, who Wilga described as her 'angel.' The 26-year-old spent the next several days recovering in a Perth hospital, revealing she had lost 12kg during the ordeal. If you'd like to view this content, please adjust your . To find out more about how we use cookies, please see our Cookie Guide. Despite Wilga being safely back home in Germany, her van remained abandoned in the outback. Wheatbelt Way posted a video on Facebook on Wednesday, explaining that a WA family had travelled deep into the bush to recover Wilga's van. Carolina Wilga: Backpacker's van recovered by Sprigg family in the Wheatbelt Credit: wheatbeltway/instagram / supplied 'She was found by a local, rescued and flown to Perth but her van remained. But then this happened. Locals from The Wheatbelt Way, the Sprigg family, stepped up, driving deep into the bush to recover Carolina's van. This is what community looks like,' the video says. The post was flooded with comments, including from Fred Sprigg who seemed to be part of the community group that retrieved the van, but was left questioning his actions. 'Was a community effort. Don't like leaving rubbish in the bush. (It) was an expensive exercise to retrieve, would not have been worth it. Was questioning my life choices in the effort,' he wrote. 'Certainly more questions than answers. Is service on top of the rock. Van ran out of fuel on the way out. What would you do if it was your daughter on the other side of the world? I hope she found herself.' Other commenters were quick to side with Sprigg, saying that Wilga's actions were reckless. 'Absolutely vandalism of the bush her driving like a nut case out there! Could of started fires too with exhaust on scrub. Ploughing down the scrub with recklessly dangerous choices,' one person said. 'Still can't understand how she ended up that far into the bush,' another person commented. Backpacker Carolina Wilga recovered in Fiona Stanley hospital in Perth after the ordeal. Credit: Unknown / Instagram 'Well done everyone, and to a few wingers out there, the bush will you be upset if it was a search patrol looking for you or a family member? This lady was blessed by folk who didn't give up,' one person wrote. 'Well done 'The Sprigg Family,' the family are Salt of the Earth who have a wonderful heart and community minded,' another said. The Sprigg family has been contacted for comment.
