Watercare charges Auckland woman $800 bill due to faulty meter
Photo:
Supplied / Watercare
Watercare has issued a public apology - via RNZ's
Checkpoint
- to a user facing an estimated $800 water bill, due to a faulty meter.
The water provider now admits up to 16,000 of its 40,000 EDMI smart meters around Auckland are faulty, generating zero bills and leading to substantial catch-up bills.
Two weeks ago, Lizzie from the North Shore told
Checkpoint
about a $410 bill that she refused to pay, until it was "based in fact and not just plucked out of the air".
She subsequently received another, even bigger bill that equated to using 4342 litres of water a day. The Browns Bay couple now face a combined bill of about $1200.
"This has gone beyond being mildly irritating," Lizzie said. "I can't figure out where this has come from.
"I went back through our previous bills - our monthly water usage is somewhere between $65-75. The most it's ever been was $85 over a Christmas/New Year period.
"I can't figure out why they're saying we must pay our overdue accounts immediately to avoid further action, when they were the ones that agreed we should cancel our direct debit, because the previous bill was over the time.
"I don't know what's going on. I can't figure out how anyone could use this amount of water.
"They don't value their customers, do they?"
Checkpoint
host Lisa Owens was able to pass on a message from Watercare.
"They say they have made a mistake, and they'll get in touch with you directly to apologise and sort this," she said. "They said they sincerely apologise for the inconvenience to you, and they will get you a new water meter and sort out that large bill, which is an estimation."
Lizzie responded emotionally: "I want to say thank you to you, but it shouldn't have come to this, should it?
"Could you imagine a small business trying to operate this way - they wouldn't survive.
"I'm really grateful for what you've done for me ... really, really grateful."
Watercare admitted to
Checkpoint
it had made a mistake with the estimation, blaming a processing error by the service agent. It said it would re-assess the charge in line with past water consumption at that address.
Of the 16,000 fault meters, 13,672 have been shifted to manual reading and the balance are scheduled to move to manual reading.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
16 minutes ago
- RNZ News
New season avocados: Good prices, good quality for NZ, as sector prepares for export
Photo: 123RF Industry group New Zealand Avocados says the new season (2025/2026) has started with solid harvest forecasts, since picking starting last month and will run into summer. Chief executive Brad Siebert said New Zealand shoppers will be able to enjoy good quality fruit at good prices. "Consumers will be seeing some pretty good avocados on the shelf at the moment," he said. Siebert said harvest started in July to first service the local market, ahead of exports which will get into full swing in the coming months. This new season, 6.5 million trays of fruit were expected from the 1400 orchards that were part of the industry group, more than half of which would be exported. Last year's 2024/2025 season was a bumper, with 7.6 million trays reaching $163m. Siebert said last year was a relief for growers. Photo: "As far as last year, that we've concluded now, that was a pretty good relief for many in the industry with substantial gains in export volumes and export value and just an increasing value seen in the local market." It followed a horror season in 2023 due to adverse weather which impacted export-grade fruit earning just $20m from international markets. Siebert said last season, exports rose 170 percent on that terrible season prior, to 3.8m trays sent abroad. However, he said fortunately weather conditions this year have improved. "The weather has been better. The last two years it had some real impact on growers' returns, as the export volume of fruit has been dramatically down and the pack out rate or the class one available for export has been reduced, but we're seeing diversification creates opportunities to send to a diverse set of countries." Siebert said avocado exporters had diversified their markets in recent years, beyond key market Australia, which was bearing fruit for them. Australia was traditionally the largest export market, but he said internal competition there was growing. Photo: Wikicommons "One of the exciting parts of that is the diversification the industry's seen and the export markets, with Asia historically seen around 8 percent of their volumes is now representing 37 percent of our export revenue. "Historically sometimes up to 85 percent of the export crop went to Australia and the Eastern seaboard where the seasonal competitor there being Western Australia. "Consumption continues to grow in Australia, thankfully, but so does the production out of Western Australia." But he said diversification helped spread the risk. "We, like many nations, have diversified, so we've got the ability in the season ahead to export to more countries than any other origin, and so we're headed to North America, Canada, the US and a whole lot more to Asia as well as servicing the important Australian market as well." Avocados into the United States will also face the 15 percent import tariff, which Siebert said was being discussed by government trade officials. Siebert said there was good demand for avocados in New Zealand, as Kiwis consumed the fruit at quite a high rate per capita. But he said harnessing retail opportunities and educating consumers would be key to capitalising on that demand. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
16 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Another major bank cuts its one-year fixed home loan rate to 4.79 percent
There could be room for rates to fall even more. (File photo) Photo: RNZ Another bank is cutting its one-year fixed home loan rate to 4.79 percent - and one economist says there might more room for rates to fall. ANZ and BNZ earlier this week cut their one-year special rates to that level, and they have now been joined by Kiwibank. Kiwibank also cut its two-year rate to 4.89 percent, the same as ANZ, and its six-month rate to 5.09 percent. Infometrics chief forecaster Gareth Kiernan said markets had already priced in two more cuts to the official cash rate. "So moves by the Reserve Bank along those lines are unlikely to have much effect on fixed mortgage rates. Infometrics chief forecaster Gareth Kiernan. (File photo) Photo: RNZ / Rebekah Parsons-King "Perhaps when the second cut is all but locked in, it could knock the one-year rate down by another five or 10 basis points - reflecting market certainty around the cut, as opposed to the high probability currently expected for the cut." He said if the bank came out with a more "dovish" statement and a lower OCR track at next week's Monetary Policy Statement, pointing towards the possibility of the OCR going down to 2.5 percent this could be reflected in swap rates and fixed mortgage rates in coming weeks." Kiwibank was also reducing its term deposit rates by between 10 and 15 basis points. At the interest rate peak, the average new one-year special rate was 7.3 percent. On a $500,000 30-year mortgage, at that interest rate payments would have been $791 a week. At 4.79 percent, they drop to $605 a week. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
'It doesn't cost the government anything' - Wayne Brown calls for bed tax rethink
Auckland mayor Wayne Brown is at odds with the government over a bed night levy. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi Auckland's mayor Wayne Brown is renewing his call for a bed levy for the supercity , as it deals with some serious economic troubles . Its unemployment rate of 6.1 percent is the highest of any region. National Minister and Auckland-based MP Paul Goldsmith told Morning Report on Wednesday there's been a long Covid hangover. "The economy's flat, everybody's feeling it. Of course there's two speeds, down in the south and in rural New Zealand we're getting some growth and some upbeat economic news from the regions but of course it's a real struggle in Auckland so that's what our real focus is on." Brown agreed the government would be focused on the city because it was where the election in a year's time would be decided. He was adamant that what he was advocating for was a bed levy - not a tax - and it wouldn't go to the government. "They [the government] use the word tax so they can say no more taxes. It's just dumb, it's not a tax any more than it would be a targeted rate. The people who've asked for it are the industry it would be collected from." He wanted it to be set at 2.5 percent which would raise $27 million which would be enough to attract the likes of a Taylor Swift concert or a State of Origin match. Cities need around $3 million to $4m to attract concerts by artists such as Taylor Swift, the Auckland mayor says. Photo: AFP Cities needed to pay upfront around $3m-4m to bring in each major event. It would enable Auckland to compete against the likes of Sydney which has a bed night levy, he said. "It doesn't cost the government anything. ... It doesn't make sense ..." When Auckland held large events and the hotels filled up, another $100 could be added to the cost of a hotel room "so noone's gonna miss it". It was also "bollocks" for the government to blame the cost of living crisis, Brown said. Those most affected couldn't afford $500 Taylor Swift concert tickets or to stay at the top hotels. He said the government was focused on tourism but had raised the international tourist levy so it was "cheeky" to deny Auckland a bed levy. Brown believed the government would "cave" on the issue, in part because Auckland was the region that decided the fate of the government at elections. He had built a good working relationship with some of the ministers, such as Chris Bishop and Shane Reti. "We have had a number of wins." He believed it was ACT that was the main handbrake on the government agreeing to the bed levy. Councillor Kerrin Leoni, who is standing against Brown in the city's upcoming mayoral election, said she also supported a bed tax. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
